Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

How Far Do You Agree That Family Is at the Centre of Jerusalem and Death of a Salesman

Powerful Essays
1520 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Far Do You Agree That Family Is at the Centre of Jerusalem and Death of a Salesman
How far do you agree that family is at the centre of Jerusalem and Death of a Salesman? Compare and contrast the presentation of familial responsibility in both plays.

The concept of family has changed since the 1950’s, compared to the present day. Back then, the old fashioned family value system was seen as the norm – the wife typically stays at home taking care of the domestic side of the household including looking after the children, cleaning and cooking. While the husband goes out and does what was viewed as the ‘hard labour’ work to provide for the family. Family can be seen to uphold an important role throughout both plays. However, we see more of this conservative view in Death of a Salesman rather than Jerusalem. Miller presents Willy and his family’s outward appearance as what is seen as the ‘ideal’, but to us this could be a disguise as the audience gradually discovers the issues going on within his family. However Butterworth explores how much the traditional family role has changed over the years and how the liberal family is evolving, particularly through Johnny and Dawn’s relationship and him as a surrogate father to teenagers searching for identity.

Butterworth and Miller both present very diverse ideas of family in their plays. This could at first be seen through the settings at the start of each play. Butterworth presents Johnny as a forty-year-old man who lives in a “mobile home” by himself. The description of his home that stands in a “fairly permanent state” and his surroundings may be seen as a reflection of him and his personality. This description could mean, like his home, Johnny is “fairly permanent”, mainly towards his responsibility as regards to his son. In the play, Dawn confronts Johnny about not being a good father figure, whilst in other moments we notice Johnny’s maturity as he tries to protect Phaedra. Another way that Johnny is seen as “fairly permanent” is through his incapability to provide a decent phone for Dawn which within “two weeks” of purchase becomes “cut off” because he forgot to “pay-as-you-go”. This could indicate, like the phone, Johnny is there and working for a short amount of time and before realisation he is back to his old, irresponsible, disconnected ways. In Death of a Salesman, the setting also reflects the Loman family and how perfect their “home” appears to be on the surface. The description that Miller gives is that of a normal home, as it contains a kitchen, the parents’ bedroom, the boys’ bedroom which is located “above the unseen living-room”. Although the portrayal of their home seems ordinary, Linda lists that they need “sixteen dollars on the refrigerator... nine-sixty for the washing machine” and “three and a half” for the “vacuum cleaner”. All of these faults within their home reflect their family. Everything may seem ideal on the surface but as time goes on, like the possessions, the people within their family begin to wear out and break down, which is mainly aimed towards Willy and his growing illness. Both sets then symbolise the effect that the surrounding of each play had on Willy and Johnny

In both plays, Johnny and Willy seem to both had absent fathers in their life. Johnny’s lack of a father figure in his past may be a result of him being what some people interpret as a bad role-model for his son and having a fragile relationship with him. One of Johnny’s many exaggerated stories includes him describing how he was born from a “bullet”. As bullets are known to cause quick damage it may be interpreted that Johnny’s father has damaged him by leaving him and his life as fast as a “bullet”. From psychologist Bowlby’s study, he suggested that if a “child does not form an attachment before the age of 2½ years, it would not be possible after”. This theory could explain why Johnny has difficulties having a normal relationship with Marky. We see Marky’s incapability of expressing emotional feelings towards Johnny in the stage directions, which may make the audience feel sympathetic towards him as he “doesn’t want to” give Johnny a kiss. Personally, I agree with Bowlby’s theory of attachment because of Marky’s behaviour to Johnny. It seems that Johnny is a stranger to Marky and he communicates with him as if communicating to one of Johnny ‘friends’, which presents that there is not a very strong bind between them. A flute at the start of Death of a Salesman represents the single faint link Willy has to his father and his faint, delicate appearance, whilst a drum is used in Jerusalem to represent Johnny calling for his son. The music that drifts through the play from the flute remains in the distance which represents the almost non-existent position that Willy’s father had during his childhood which could be an explanation to the way Willy has turned out. As a grown man, Willy pampers his sons with excessive love to disguise in a way for what he never experienced as a child. While doing this, he also oppresses them in an effort to grow into the kind people and characters that he desires.

Johnny and Willy’s sons can be seen as contrasts of each other, essentially between Marky and Biff. Willy’s son Biff, seems energetic, strong and at first respected amongst his friends as Linda comments on how George, Sam and Frank “obey him” when he gives a command. As the verb “obey” is used towards someone with authority, for instance a King or a God, this provides a glimpse of how Biff’s friends may possibly view him. This ability that Biff seems to possess may have stemmed from the way Willy has brought him up. Willy is glad about the fact that his sons are “built like Adonises” as an Adonis is the God of desire. This displays that Biff is ultimately “well liked” as his father wishes him to be. On the other hand, Johnny’s son Marky is perceived as the opposite; quiet, fragile and tormented by his school peers as Dawn notifies Johnny that “Marky comes home every day in floods. Scratches. Bruises.”. Which reveals that unlike Biff, Marky cannot be helped from being un-liked, as people are not fond of his father the “gyppo”, this reflects onto him and the lack of responsibility that he has provided for Marky. Alternatively, Biff can be viewed as a character that cannot live up to his father’s expectations, resulting in him failing in his future life.

A traditional quality of fathers is that they pass on advice to their children. In both plays the advice passed on by the play’s paternal figures show their inadequate ability to be responsible for themselves which leads them to fail in their duty to bring up their sons. However, it can be seen that towards the end of the play, Johnny actually tries to mend what he has broken in his son by giving his heartfelt advice about the worth of “Byron blood”. By making Marky aware of how much this “blood” is worth and how the doctors “need” him is Johnny’s way of reassuring Marky that despite what happens, he will always have value and although it does not show on the outside, it is within him. However, the audience is left uncertain whether to believe Johnny’s storytelling at this point and whether it is just another one of his stories that he uses to distract himself and others from his sticky situations. On the contrary, Willy uses myth and fantasies as a means of bringing up his sons. He is a firm believer in the myth of any man who obtains “personal attractiveness” can achieve their dream. Although, we see his belief plunge through the outcome of Biff and Happy’s life as at the very start of the play, we discover that both boys are back in their parents’ home after “ten years now” seeing as Biff in particular has not yet found a sturdy job and “has yet to make thirty-five dollars a week”. We see Willy ignore the love that his family has to offer him through his obsession of money and being liked. Overall, I agree that family is at the centre of both plays and Johnny and Willy fail in their responsibilities to uphold their roles as responsible fathers. However in my view, Willy is a bigger failure than Johnny. Although Johnny’s failure to be a dependable father and untrustworthy partner leads him to have an unfulfilling relationship with Dawn and Marky, it can be seen that this side that he lacks is redeemed through his attempt to hide and protect Phaedra from her abusive step-dad Troy. Whilst Willy, even though he ends his life to financially support his family, he leaves without mending the damaged relationship between Biff and Happy and forces his wife Linda out of conventional role as a housewife, to be the head of the household, resulting in Willy failing to achieve his “American Dream”.

Word count: 1,507

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    R/G Questions Gg

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As you watch the movie and after you have read the play, think about and respond to the following questions. Type your responses on this document (a copy is on my teacherweb page).…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arthur Miller creates an exciting and engaging story by depicting a family dealing with a tragedy, characters with impressive depth, and an interesting plotline. Linda’s role in “Death of a Salesman” by Arthur Miller plays an important role in keeping the family together. First, Linda worries about Willy, asking him questions to dig into his mind. She has clues to her husband’s suicidal tendencies, but still supports him in his actions, even to the point of sheltering him from the real world to uphold his mental state. Finally, Linda tries to keep her family glued together, despite the effect it has on herself.…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this literary analysis piece I will be breaking down the popular play by Arthur Miller, Death of a Salesman. Death of a Salesman, is a very riveting story that follows Willy Loman, a retiree-aged working class business man living in New York. Who deals with troublesome denial, and uses the events of the past to deal with his problems of the present, this begins to create more problems for Willy as he becomes unable to separate past events with current events. Along with intense financial strain as an ageing business man in a new era of business. Willy feels pressured to be very financially successful and well liked person by himself, and the people around him like his brother, Ben, and his neighbor, Charley, who has a very successful son who is a lawyer. Willy, along with many people in the real world, suffers…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In conclusion, “The Death of a Salesman” by Arthur Miller greatly examined the famous American Dream, theme of betrayal, as well as abandonment. In trying to achieve the American Dream, Willy took his life. The Dream consumed his world until he was no more. However, within the mindset of the American Dream, it did indeed have one positive aspect. Part of the Dream is to wish that your children amount to more in life than yourself and this is what Willy tries to do in the play. Though Willy and Biff have feelings of betrayal towards each other, both intended good will upon each other. The play has proven to be riddled with many human emotions.…

    • 116 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Linda Loman

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Arthur Miller’s play, Death of a Salesman, through his character, Linda Loman, the author alludes to the idea that everyone, whether they are famous or not, deserves support when they are at their lowest in life. For instance, when Linda is talking about Willy to her sons she says, “He works for a company thirty-six years this March, opens up unheard-of territories to their trademark, and now in his old age they take his salary away” (40). Here, Miller presents how Willy has worked at his company for a long time and use to do a great job when he was younger, but now that he is older he is not as popular. Therefore, he does not make as much money anymore, which caused the company to take his salary away. This illuminates to the idea that…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death of a Salesman

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages

    An excellent father will make every effort to constantly do what is best for his family. He will put his needs last, ensuring that his family is well cared for and not lacking for any necessities. And, most significantly, a first-class father will make his family his main concern, coming before his job, his friends, or even himself. In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman is a prime example of a horrific father in every way mentioned previously. Not only is Willy Loman not a good father and spouse, but he furthers his failure by being a typical anti-hero and by failing to accomplish the American Dream. There for I believe the play is not necessarily what Miller and Kazan perceive it to be. Here I will be discussing Willy Lomans discraceful actions towards his family and finally expose the actual theme of the play.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arthur Miller is recognized as an important and influential playwright, not to mention essayist and novelist. Although he has had plenty of luck in his writing career, his fame is the product of his ingenious ability to control what he wants his readers to picture or feel. As one of his critics states, "Miller writes ingeniously, conveying the message that ‘if the proper study of mankind is man, man's inescapable problem is himself (Brown, 306).'" Miller accurately puts into words what every person thinks, feels, or worries about, but often has trouble expressing. By the use of symbolism, Arthur Miller portrays Willy's (along with the other Lowmans') problems with family life, the society, and himself in Death of a Salesman.…

    • 2059 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is often said that society, family and your inner self is very judgemental. Arthur Miller's play Death of a Salesman tells the story of Willy Loman, a salesman living in Brooklyn, New York and his family. Willy knows deep down what his capabilities and problems are which is why he exiles himself socially. Biff Loman, Willy's eldest son, is misunderstood but it is known that Willy has affected his life since Biff was a young man causing him to be isolated from his father and family. Happy Loman, younger son of Willy, is the most successful of his brother and father however he is isolated from society and his co-workers. Alienation is displayed in many ways throughout the play where Willy, Biff and Happy are isolated from themselves, from society and from their families.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death of a Salesman

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Being a father is one of the most significant roles in a family; they are influential and they stand as their family’s pillars. Children, especially sons, consider their fathers’ legacy as a legend and dream to follow fathers’ footsteps. A son’s future depends on the role of the father, and it is so important that their family’s faith depend on their relationship. Arthur Miller’s “Death of a Salesman” consists of endless father-son conflicts due to the fact that Willy, an oppressive father, has high, unattainable expectations for his son Biff; while he appears to have virtually no relationship with his youngest son, Happy. Willy refuses to admit that his actions and his teachings have led to the destruction of his relationships with his sons.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Death of a Salesman

    • 8993 Words
    • 36 Pages

    Miller, Arthur. Death of a Salesman: Certain Private Conversations in Two Acts and a Requiem. New York, NY: Penguin Books, 1999. Print.…

    • 8993 Words
    • 36 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    B. “All literature shows us the power of emotion. It is emotion, not reason that motivates characters in literature.” – Duff Brenna. Using TWO characters we studied this semester (they may NOT be from the same play) discuss whether it is indeed emotion that motivates them in action and in thought.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Based on the works of Karl Marx and his reversal of Hegelian philosophy, Marxism has developed into a political direction and a social theory. The social aspect contains two social classes, the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. This type of capitalist society is relevant in the play by Arthur Miller, Death of a Salesman. In the play, a dedicated salesman Willy Loman struggles to aid his family near his retirement. Inevitably, Willy is part of Marx’s proletariat classes and lies to cheat himself into believing he is of higher class. The influence of Willy’s lies is apparent in his oldest son Biff, who is able to analyze his father’s dream and attempts to gain more in life than that of the proletariat. By accepting the materialistic ideals of Marxism, Willy Loman and his son Biff, both struggle to make…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nong, Amy Prof. Buscher Eng. 1B Essay 3 Death Of A Salesman by Arthur Miller, is a drama about the American dream,where we were lead to believe that the underdogs had a chance to become something bigger in the future, but that is not the case in this drama. In this drama, we witness Willy losing himself because of the American dream, and we also see how the dream gives off false hopes. The theme of the drama is abandonment, Willy Loman life was full of abandonment since the prelude , in the tragic form, his father casting him off at a young age, followed by his brother’s expedition to Africa, Willy has been omitted many times by the one he cherished .…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the heart of Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman, the central conflict occurs through the relationship of Willy Loman and his eldest son, Biff. Throughout the play, Miller uses the continuously building relationships to reveal the true themes of the play, as well as to create a character of hope and a tragic character. Through Willy Loman unrealistic expectations and unrealistic view of life, Miller is able to create a tragic character whom with the help of conflict results in the formation of a character of hope, Willy’s son Biff. The use of conflict between two characters, one the parental figure over the other, can be used to contribute to the works’ themes.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Arthur Miller's play, "Death of a Salesman", Miller uses many different characters to contrast the difference between the successes and failures of the American system. Willy is the long time salesman who has little sales ability but his imagination makes up for it. Linda, Willy's wife, has always been with him even through the deterioration of his practicality. Biff and Happy are the two sons who follow in their father's fallacy of life, while Ben is the only member of the Loman family with that special something needed to achieve. Charlie and his son Bernard, on the other hand, enjoy better success in life compared to the Loman family.…

    • 1199 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics