Toby Walsh National ICT Australia and UNSW, Sydney http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~tw
How to write a good paper
Toby Walsh National ICT Australia and UNSW, Sydney http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~tw
How to write a good enough paper
Toby Walsh National ICT Australia and UNSW, Sydney http://www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~tw
Why me?
•
I’m not sure
•
Many other researchers who consistently get their papers published Peter van Beek, Pascal van Hentenryck, ... Often win best paper awards
• •
Why me?
•
My papers get rejected too!
• •
“This should be sent to a journal” “Very good work, but I’m not sure why Alan Bundy hasn’t written this?” Anonymous review: “Clearly the author fails to understands Walsh’s previous work on this topic”
•
1st Lesson
•
Don’t lose heart
•
Even if you do everything right, reviewing is imperfect Good papers will be rejected But try to learn from your knock-backs!
• •
Why you?
•
Academic career
•
Publish or perish
•
Have an impact
• •
Communicate your results Many have not had the impact they deserve for being bad writers
•
Writing is fun!
Outline
•
How to get your paper rejected
•
There are many traps even experienced researchers make Myself very much included
• •
Hints about how to write a paper
•
Writing is a craft not a science!
How to be rejected
•
Submit over-length
•
Blind man: send in 7 pages even though the instructions clearly say 5 Once they see quality of work, they’ll be pleased you sent in more material
•
How to be rejected
Submit over-length
•
•
Diplomatic immunity: put extra 2 pages in appendix Appendices clearly don’t count Similarly, bibliography doesn’t count
• •
How to be rejected
•
Submit over-length
•
LaTeX hacker:
• • •
change from 11 to 9 point font squeeze inter-line space ...
•
No one will ever notice
How to be rejected
•
Submit late
• • •
Deadlines