Preview

Human Cloning: Moral Arguments

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
5693 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Human Cloning: Moral Arguments
Moral Arguments Against Human Cloning
A. Would the Use of Human Cloning Violate Important Moral Rights?
Many of the immediate condemnations of any possible human cloning following Wilmut’s cloning of an adult sheep claimed that it would violate moral or human rights, but it was usually not specified precisely, or often even at all, what the rights were that would be violated. I shall consider two possible candidates for such a right: a right to have a unique identity and a right to ignorance about one’s future or to an “open future.” The former right is cited by many commentators, but I believe even if any such a right exists, it is not violated by human cloning.
The latter right has only been explicitly defended to my knowledge by two commentators, and in the context of human cloning, only by Hans Jonas; it supports a more promising, even if in my view ultimately unsuccessful, argument that human cloning would violate an important moral or human right.
Is there a moral or human right to a unique identity, and if so, would it be violated by human cloning? For human cloning to violate a right to a unique identity, the relevant sense of identity would have to be genetic identity, that, is a right to a unique unrepeated genome. This would be violated by human cloning, but is there any such right? It might be thought there could not be such a right, because it would be violated in all cases of identical twins, yet no one claims in such cases that the moral or human rights of each of the twins have been violated. Even the use of fertility drugs, which increases the probability of having twins, is not intended to produce
E-12
twins. However, this consideration is not conclusive (Kass 1985; NABER 1994). It is commonly held that only deliberate human actions can violate others’ rights, but outcomes that would constitute a rights violation if those outcomes if done by human action are not a rights violation if those outcomes result from natural



References: Adams, M., ed., The Well-Born Science, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990. Brock, D.W., The non-identity problem and genetic harm, Bioethics, 9:269-275, 1995. Callahan, D., Perspective on cloning: A threat to individual uniqueness, Los Angeles Times, November 12, 1993, B7. Chadwick, R.F., Cloning. Philosophy, 57:201-209, 1982. Eisenberg, L., The outcome as cause: Predestination and human cloning. J Med Philos, 1:318- 331, 1976. Huxley, A., Brave New World, London: Chalto and Winders, 1932. Jonas, H., Philosophical Essays: From Ancient Creed to Technological Man, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1974. Kass, L., Toward a More Natural Science, New York: The Free Press, 1985. LaBar, M., The pros and cons of human cloning, Thought, 57:318-333, 1984. Levin, I., Boys from Brazil, New York: Random House, 1976. Macklin, R., Splitting embryos on the slippery slope: Ethics and public policy, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 4:209-226, 1994. McCormick, R., Should we clone humans?, Christian Century, 1148-1149, 1993. — — — , Notes on Moral Theology: 1965 Through 1980, Washington, DC: University Press of America, 1981. NABER (National Advisory Board on Ethics in Reproduction), Report on human cloning through embryo splitting: An amber light, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 4:251-282, 1994. Pollack, R., Beyond cloning, New York Times, Nov. 17, 1993, A27. Rainer, J.D. Commentary, Man and Medicine: The Journal of Values and Ethics in Health Care, 3:115-117, 1978. Turner, P.O., Love’s labor lost: Legal and ethical implications in artificial human procreation, University of Detriot Journal of Urban Law, 58:459-487, 1981. Verhey, A.D., Cloning: Revisiting an old debate, Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 4:227-234, 1994. Weiss, R., Cloning suddenly has government’s attention, International Herald Tribune, March 7, 1997, 2, 1997. Studdard, A. The lone clone, Man and Medicine: The Journal of Values and Ethics in Health Care, 3:109-114, 1978.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Best Essays

    References: Andrews, L.B. 1997. Is there a right to clone? Constitutional challenges to bans on human cloning. Harvard Journal of Law and Technology. 11(3): 647-676.…

    • 1944 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    J. (2015). Cloning humans? Biological, ethical, and social considerations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112(29), 8879-8886. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1501798112…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the years, science and technology have expanded to make it possible to create identical creatures. While new cloning technology is a great advancement, it raises a plethora of moral and ethical questions. Cloning may bring about new ways to find cures for babies, according to Philip M. Boffey, but cloning also “could usher in a new eugenics”. The problems produced from the prospect of cloning greatly outweigh the benefits.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leon Kass’s provides a compelling article on why the world should ban cloning. Kass’ article, “Preventing a Brave New World”, provides Kass’ theories of if society progresses on its current path, society would start to turn to cloning as an alternative to typical reproduction. Cloning offers a way to design an offspring rather than the typical experience of child raising. Kass believes if cloning is not banned, society will be more dependent upon technology and be at technologies whim.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Lita, A (2005, November 4) though difficult a humanistic approach to cloning is imperative. International Humanistic and Ethical Union; the world union of Humanistic organizations. Retrieved March 17, 2008 from http://www.iheu.org/node/1827…

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Satire On Cloning

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Cloning is a very important part of genetics and science. It will be able to make livestock faster and improve crops. It can produce stem cells that we can use to repair damaged organs and maybe even form a whole new organ. However, the use of human embryonic stem cells and cross-species hybrid pose ethical…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Harris, J. “Goodbye Dolly? The Ethics of Human Cloning.” Journal of Medical Ethics (1997): n.…

    • 86 Words
    • 1 Page
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Journal Review

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages

    According to Stewart, identity is defined as being made up of interlocking features that mark how persons behave and respond to others. (Stewart 2012) I found the lectures on identity to be very interesting and coordinating with last weeks lecture on behavioral blend. I believe that identity is something that is constantly changing, hopefully for the better and I truly believe that people have the ability to change. As a Christian, we believe that all people…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    More Human Than Human

    • 2325 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In Cure or Quest for Perfection? Goodman brings her audience into the ongoing bioethical debate on human cloning. She states the benefits of therapeutic cloning for the treatment of diseases like cystic fibrosis and Parkinson’s disease. On the other hand, she condemns the practice of reproductive cloning for any reason. Stating, “There’s no compelling reason that justifies the risk or the results” (Goodman pg. 499). She also poses the question of the moral status of an embryo by weighing it against the suffering of an adult.…

    • 2325 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cloning Persuasive Essay

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages

    What was once thought to be the content of fiction novels and comic books is now being fully explored and realized in the cutting edge world of modern science. Scientists now possess the necessary capabilities and technology to make the process of human cloning a reality. While this is a controversial and rather sensitive topic, cloning is an innovative practice that has the potential to vastly improve the lives of unlimited amounts of people. Although cloning may prove to be a useful remedy for many of today’s issues, there are those in the scientific and medical fields who remain vehemently opposed to its practice. It is for this reason that lawmakers, scientists, and doctors around the world are currently locked in a fierce standoff that will determine what if any, impact that cloning will have upon our ever-changing society. Each side has compiled substantial evidence against the other as to why cloning should or should not be legalized and practiced. It is my strong belief that the curative effects that could be reaped by practicing cloning far outweigh the arguments of anti-cloning advocates; the practice of human cloning should be legalized and practiced. Countless individuals could benefit from its various applications and the future of medicine would be drastically enhanced.…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Encarta Dictionary: English (North America) defines identity as “the name or essential character that identifies somebody or something” (def.1). We all have sets of characteristics that we recognize as belonging uniquely to ourselves. This constitutes his or her individual personality for life. Finding out what makes our identity.…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis: “Those who support human cloning make several claims of fact, value and policy to argue their case for human cloning.”…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Human Cloning Controversy

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Since the dawn of civilization, mankind has been plagued by innumerable ethical quandaries. From the subjugation of those whose pigment doesn’t match our own to the creation of weapons of mass destruction, history has repeatedly shown us that as the human race progresses, there are always ethical dilemmas that make us question our every step. As our technological capabilities continue to grow at an exponential rate, these predicaments have continued to crop up alarmingly fast. Among the most recent ethical questions to plague our society is the one pertaining to human cloning. Supporters of this potential technological breakthrough cite it as one of the greatest achievement of the human race, while its detractors bemoan the ethics of…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis Statement: Although human cloning is a scientific discovery of great significance which is the creation of a genetically identical copy of a human it has some medical advantages; however, it raises high debates because of its religious, ethical, and scientific disadvantages.…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should Cloning Be Banned

    • 604 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The subject of human cloning is a very controversial topic. The cloning of Dolly the sheep in 1997 by scientist Ian Wilmut generated a very unexpected reaction around the world. However these reactions were not all positive. Cloning refers to the development of offspring that are identical to their parents genetically. While it is referred to as an unnatural process, it can occur quite often in nature. Identical twins, for example, are clones. However, human cloning is very new and very complex. In this essay I will examine both sides of the argument into the banning of cloning starting with reasons why cloning should not be banned.…

    • 604 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics