Immigration Proposals
Old Patterns: Immigration Proposals
The issue of immigration has been a topic of great debate since people can recall. In spite of this, Immigration did not always hold the negative connotation it transmits at the present time. Migration was used as a way to better ones lifestyle and America granted many that opportunity; however, history validates the idea that immigrants have become political scapegoats for financial recessions, unemployment, violence, diseases and the overall failure of America. As a result of these accusations, many fear the idea of immigration and are the basis for why it possesses a disapproving stigma. Throughout the last decade many laws and proposals have been designed to deal with the immigration status, but none have ascended without causing a great dispute. For example, In November of 1994 California voters enacted proposition 187 also given the name “Save Our State”(SOS), a measure that banned illegal immigrants from public services, such as non-emergency health care, and public education. Additionally, State workers would have been required to report anyone suspected of being an illegal immigrant. While illegal immigration is a problem that needs to be solved, Proposition 187 was not the solution. Denying illegal immigrants basic services prevented children from attending school, and those in need of attention from getting professional medical assistance. What is more extreme is that state employees would have had to report anyone who was suspect of being illegal, the source for such suspicion proclaims racial discrimination. Proposition 187 is racist and discriminatory and therefore impermissible.
The argument behind proposition 187 was that if the undocumented individuals were prohibited from using state resources and consequently deported, then California’s financial problems would disappear. Although in reality the proposition would cause much more harm to California than saving it. For instance, they would have had to use
The issue of immigration has been a topic of great debate since people can recall. In spite of this, Immigration did not always hold the negative connotation it transmits at the present time. Migration was used as a way to better ones lifestyle and America granted many that opportunity; however, history validates the idea that immigrants have become political scapegoats for financial recessions, unemployment, violence, diseases and the overall failure of America. As a result of these accusations, many fear the idea of immigration and are the basis for why it possesses a disapproving stigma. Throughout the last decade many laws and proposals have been designed to deal with the immigration status, but none have ascended without causing a great dispute. For example, In November of 1994 California voters enacted proposition 187 also given the name “Save Our State”(SOS), a measure that banned illegal immigrants from public services, such as non-emergency health care, and public education. Additionally, State workers would have been required to report anyone suspected of being an illegal immigrant. While illegal immigration is a problem that needs to be solved, Proposition 187 was not the solution. Denying illegal immigrants basic services prevented children from attending school, and those in need of attention from getting professional medical assistance. What is more extreme is that state employees would have had to report anyone who was suspect of being illegal, the source for such suspicion proclaims racial discrimination. Proposition 187 is racist and discriminatory and therefore impermissible.
The argument behind proposition 187 was that if the undocumented individuals were prohibited from using state resources and consequently deported, then California’s financial problems would disappear. Although in reality the proposition would cause much more harm to California than saving it. For instance, they would have had to use