Preview

Implications of Day Care in Young Children

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
557 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Implications of Day Care in Young Children
Assignment 4.

Within this assignment I will be discussing the implications of day care for young children and giving both the positive and the negative aspects of this.
A study was done in the united states by Kagen (1978), the study was done on children whose mothers worked, in which case the children were put into day care centres compared to home –reared children. Kagen found little difference between the children placed in day care centres and those raised at home either in the amount of protest or seeking closeness to their mothers when upset. From the findings it appears that it doesn’t matter if a child is in day-care or raised at home or the amount of hours spent with its mothers, there is a special bond between mother and child. Bee (1974) Concluded that there are no negative effects when a child is cared for in a day care centre, provided these are run by trained professionals and only a small number of children. However, Bee (1997) also suggests “The crucial issue is the discrepancy between the level of stimulation that the child would receive at home and the quality of day care. When the day care setting for the child provides more enrichment than the child would normally receive at home, we see some beneficial cognitive effects. When day care is less stimulating than the child’s home care would have been, it has negative effects.”
Psychologists disagree about the developmental effects of day care on young children. Some agree with Bowlby’s prediction that long to medium term separation from the mother could have far-reaching consequences. Others claim that, provided day care is high quality day care has no adverse effects on intellectual development and does not disrupt the child’s attachments. Some psychologists believe that it might even make a positive contribution to the child’s development. The type and quality of care can influence many aspects of development—including memory, language development, school readiness, math and reading

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    - Olds, A. (1982). Planning a developmentally optimal day care center. Day Care and Early Education. Summer.…

    • 7115 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    module threee

    • 393 Words
    • 1 Page

    it is usually the most expensive form of day care. Pros to day care centers is…

    • 393 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are two main studies showing the effect of day-care on attachment, cognitive and social development. Belksy and Rovine (USA 1988) investigated the effects of non-maternal care on attachment types whereas Andersson (1992) investigated whether day-care has a significant effect on the cognitive and social development of middle-class children. A strength of these studies is that both of them are likely to have accurate results due to their large samples; Belksy and Rovine 90 male and 59 female; Andersson 119 children and this is a similarity between the two. However a strong difference comes from the results Andersson’s study shows a beneficial effect of day-care on the social and cognitive development of middle-class children whereas Belksy and Rovine showed a negative effect with 47% of the infants showing insecure attachment when spending more than 20 hours in day-care a week. A large similarity between these two studies would be that neither can be generalised to other cultures due to the ethnocentrism of the samples, in Andersson’s study it is noted that Sweden have a very high developed social welfare system and other cultures may be different (USA showed different results). Also Belksy and Rovine’s study couldn’t be generalised for similar reasons as it was carried out in the USA on US citizens and other cultures welfare system may be entirely different. A final similarity between the two is that both of these studies have confounding variables that may have affected the results/findings; in Andersson’s study the wealthiest children showed better results therefore the background of the child may have been an effecting variable, in Belksy and Rovine’s study, whether or not the infant is used to experiencing new places and environments may have effected how much the strange situation affected the child.…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To identify the difference between deprivation (or separation), privation and institutionalisation Explain the effects of each on experiences a child might have. Define what day care is and explain the different types of daycare available Explain using evidence the impact of daycare on social development Explain using evidence the impact of daycare on aggressive behaviour Apply understanding of how research into attachment has influenced childcare practices Describe and explain using research characteristics of good quality day care Research Methods Completed Outline the main features of a lab experiment Evaluate lab experiments as a research method Outline a clear aim for a piece of…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The sample included a range of ethnic groups and social disadvantages. Some of the results from this project also showed that day care could improve peer relations only if it was of high quality, in which case children showed a reduced level of antisocial behaviour and a higher level of sociability with other children. However, results also showed day care was able to increase aggressive behaviour when children spent more than 20 or 40 hours in day care per week. This further increased in children whose carers were constantly changed.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Full time carer Margaret McCall talks about her day-to-day struggles with caring for her disabled son.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Non Working Mothers Essay

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Top child developmental researchers were used to study the effects of full time, part time, and non working mothers. They would study over the next couple years to get their results. They followed a multitude of families very closely in order to insue accuracy. The results were as follows; the scientists found that in a middle class family that when the mother stayed home with the child, then the results were more positive as the child did well in school, and their temperate was better. In the middle Class family where the mother worked, the child was found to be worse off not performing well in school, as well as having behavior problems. The interesting find that threw the study off was the results of the single parent household where the mother worked, tended to have no effect on the child what so ever. The child was actually was found to be happier since the child would not be at home dealing with the financial situation of a single parent. It was also found that the substitute child care whether it be a grandparent, tutor, or babysitter was found to have a huge impact on the child as well. When grandparents were around the child tended to perform…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Choosing the Best Daycare

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages

    John and Sue, having to return back to work, are having trouble making a decision on which of the two childcare facilities they want to enroll their 8 month-old little girl, Tyree, in. Tyree 's development needs much support, not only in forming a secure attachment, but also in developing her personality later in life. Early care influences the child 's path of psychological, social, and physical growth. Early childhood occurrences, mainly in the first three years of life, are very crucial. Environmental factors affect the brain 's development, which can promote or discourage the ability to learn from adolescence through adulthood. A safe and healthy early childhood setting can also prevent cognitive and behavioral disorders later in life, in which some cannot be reversed.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many parents, having quality child care is a challenge, so a company that offers an on-site daycare would be a great benefit for them. As a result, an on-site daycare would help with recruitment and retention of employee’s, which is an advantage for the employer (McIntyre, 2000). It is believed that an on-site daycare helps resolve difficulties an employee may have with juggling family and work, and with the resolution of these difficulties, employee productivity would increase, and absences and turnover would decrease (Brandon & Temple, 2007). With an on-site daycare, the employee knows that…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Research has found that children that had spent the most time in day care had slightly advanced thinking and language skills. However they had an increased rate of aggressiveness and defiance. Some risk when spending a lot of time in day care can be bad. Daycare can be good for cognitive development and daycare can be bad by making kids more aggressive and impulsive. Children in higher quality daycare develop slightly better cognitive and language skills than being in lower quality daycares.…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Institutional Daycare

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For this first week of class we have to read the first issue in the book Taking Sides. This issue stated the question “Is Institutional Child Care Beneficial to Children?” The big argument is if parents should put their child into institutional care (day care) or stay at home and not make a steady income while having a child. Nowadays people wants careers and their family times to match up, which always doesn’t work out. Parents always want the best for their children. So, if they want their child in a day-care of some sort, they want to make sure their child gets the best experience out of it that they can. Another argument throughout this issue besides the quality of day-care the children could be recieving is how much quality time…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Care and education cannot be thought of as separate entities in dealing with young children (Eager to learn: Educating Our Preschoolers, 2000). For a child’s development to satisfactory, the care should provide quality cognitive stimulation, rich language environments, and the facilitation of social, emotional, and motor development. These qualities are sufficient for a child’s development and the earlier a child develops these characteristic the better it will be for a child’s learning process. Research also says adequate education for young children can occur only in the context of good physical care and of warm affective relationships (Eager to learn: Educating Our Preschoolers, 2000). Moreover, research suggests that secure attachment improves social and intellectual competence and the ability to exploit learning opportunities (Eager to learn: Educating Our Preschoolers, 2000). Learning is not about absorbing facts, but using new information and relating it to what children already know; also known as fostering prior knowledge. To accomplish all of these suggestions, children should be placed in a setting that supports the needed development.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    We have many rules and have many pieces of training to attend to make us more aware of things that we need to be polished on. I go to trainings every other weekend, because we are supposed to have twenty-six hours, and we have to be certified in CPR and First Aid. There are many steps that we have to follow to keep the daycare clean and manageable for anyone around. Some rules are more important than the others, because if we do not follow them the state will give us a deficiency for not doing things like we are supposed to. There is a website that can help you search for a daycare, and it will show you how many deficiencies they have, or if they have been closed down. We have a lot of child protection that will keep the kids from getting hurt…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Daycare Today

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages

    According to the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development’s Study of Early Child Care found that children at the age of four spending more than 30 hours a week in a daycare center became demanding and aggressive. Throughout this study as they tracked the children they found that by the time these same children reached third grade they scored higher in math and reading and the aggressive behavior had dissipated. They also mentioned that the aggressive behavior reported was still in normal range for the age of four, and it should not be cause for alarm. Sociologist at Stanford and the University of California found that cognitive skills in math and reading were strongest when a child entered a center-based program between the ages of two and three (Lewin). These studies show evidence that there are many beneficial…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As I walked through the doors of Pathway Connections, I did not know what to expect. When you are a twenty-two year old female, you are simply supposed to love kids. If you do not then you would be quite blatantly frowned upon by the ever-judging eyes of society. I say this because I have been judged in the past as soon as I say that I do not particularly like kids. It is not that if I saw a little child coming towards me, I would turn my back on him. I think children are adorable, little bundles of joy and nothing short of small miracles. As the youngest child in my family with an unmarried older sister, I have never had a chance to interact with kids and eventually get to love them. They have been children of acquaintances I have had very little time to spend with them and the interaction would generally be contained to some gushing as to how so very cute they were. The moment they were uncomfortable or so much as whimpered, I could just hand them back to their parents before they got difficult. At this point in my life, as harsh as that sounds, I cannot remotely imagine ever raising my own. I would say this is also very typical for a 22 year old to say. We are so busy making our own mistakes, picking ourselves up and living in our self-made bubble that we often forget to step back, take a deep breath and wonder how we got there. And so, when I got to the daycare, I was both excited and nervous to be spending two hours with a bunch of two-year olds.…

    • 3030 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays