Preview

In the context of the years 1485 to 1603 to what extent was the government of England dysfunctional in the mid-Tudor period?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3558 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
In the context of the years 1485 to 1603 to what extent was the government of England dysfunctional in the mid-Tudor period?
In the context of the years 1485 to 1603 to what extent was the government of England dysfunctional in the mid-Tudor period?
During the Tudor Dynasty it is easily thought that the years between 1547 and 1558 were ones of crisis. With the succession of a child and the first woman within England, people have assumed that the years between Henry VIII and Elizabeth I were an unproductive interlude. The mid Tudor period is seen as negative years within the Tudor Dynasty. It is regarded that Henry VIII and Elizabeth I’s reputations were a factor in why historians such as A.F Pollard and S T Bindoff supported the ‘Mid Tudor Crisis’ . The ‘two little Tudors’, referring to Edward and Mary, seemed colourless in comparison to their surrounding successors, so much so that A Pollard says “Edward was portrayed as a sickly boy who, throughout his reign, was the pawn of two ‘regents’” while Mary was seen as an ‘intolerant, dogmatic and neurotic woman who failed to produce an heir’ . Therefore it could be seen that people believed the years of crisis were at their most dysfunctional between the years 1547-1558. W R D Jones argued that Edward and Mary’s reigns were a period of religious disruption, large scale disorder and rebellion alongside the inefficiency and sterility in government and administration, social and economic problems and disastrous foreign policy. This supports the description of the mid-Tudor period being dysfunctional. However there could be influence from the 16th Century writers such as John Foxe who was author to ‘Book of Martyrs’, which was written just after Marys death and depicted her as a monster . Foxe was responsible for a lasting picture of Mary as it fitted prejudices of a confident. Under these circumstances it was not surprising that the period 1547 – 1558 were marked by disasters. However historians such as David Loades, Jennifer Loach and Robert Tittler stress that there was much creativity in the period. Government under Duke of Northumberland



Bibliography: 1. ‘England 1485-1603’, Flagship History- (Collins Educational of Harper Collins Publishers) 2002 2. A.F Pollard, The History of England - a Study in Political Evolution (New York, H Holt, 1912) 3. J. Foxe, the Book of Martyrs, 1563 4. A.G.R Smith, the Emergence of a Nation State (London 1984) 5. M Hutchings, History Review: “Mary Tudor re-assessed”. March 1999 6. J. Guy, Tudor England (Oxford 1988) 7. D. Starkey, ‘Edward and Mary: The Unknown Tudors”, BBC Television, 2002. 8. D .Loades, The Reign of Mary Tudor: Politics, Government and Religion in England, 1553-58, (2nd Ed), (1995)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    HOW FAR WAS HENRY VII’S CONTROL OF THE NOBILITY 1485 TO 1509 DUE TO HIS FINANCIAL POLICIES? (24 marks)…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I believe that Henry VIII was ultimately unsuccessful in his aims from 1509-1514. He had three mains aims during this time and these were to secure the dynasty that Henry VII had created, assert his authority over his new kingdom and Foreign Policy, which Henry was planning to completely change. Various factors and traits contributed to this lack of success, which will be explored in this essay.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tudor governments were relatively successful in dealing with the problem of rebellion, although this was more effective towards the end of the period than at the beginning shown through the decline in rebellion after 1549: only 5 English rebellions occurred as opposed to 10 before 1549. Over the course of the Tudor period the main aims of rebellions were only fully achieved in the rebellions of 1525, the Amicable Grant and 1553. In addition to this the reforms made to local government, policies directly implemented by central government and the effects of trials and retribution, such as Henry VII’s concessions made to the late 15th century pretenders, Lambert Simnell and Perkin Warbeck and later in the period during Elizabeth’s reign, who recognised rebel Shane O’Neil as Earl of Tyrone, all contributed to the reduction in the frequency and scale of English rebellions. Pre-emptive strikes implemented by Tudor governments were also instrumental, especially during the start of the period in Henry’s reign and later in Elizabeth’s reign, in preventing rebellion or stopping riots from becoming dangerous rebellions. In some areas these strategies and tactics worked better in some areas than others; Irish rebellions were generally more costly and more difficult to suppress.…

    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Explain why there were fewer rebellions in England during Elizabeth’s reign than in the years between 1485 and 1558…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Tudor is the first queen regnant in the history of England, who reigned from 1553 until her demise in 1558. She is greatly recognized for her religious persecutions and execution of over 300 Protestant subjects (Loades 54). Mary Tudor, Queen of England, was given birth on the 18th of February 1516, at the Palace of Placentia in Greenwich. She became the only surviving baby of Henry VIII and his first wife, Catherine of Aragon. Mary was known as Mary 1, Queen of England and Ireland. After Edward's death, Mary challenged and fruitfully deposed the new queen, Lady Jane Grey, who was given the throne in a secret arrangement by Edward and his advisors (Loades 46). At first, she recognized the religious coexistence in her country, but she…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mid Tudor Crisis Essay

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There has been some debate as to whether it is true to say that during the reigns of the ‘mid-Tudor’ monarchs there was a crisis. For both Edward and Mary there were various factors that did pose problematic for them such as the threats to the Tudor dynasty through rebellions and neither having a strong heir to the throne after their deaths. Moreover, there were also factors such as finance and foreign policy that also made the crown slightly unstable as inflation continued to rise and England lost possession over French towns. However, although there is evidence to show that there was a mid-Tudor crisis, the stronger argument is that there was, in fact no crisis but a time where…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Queen Elizabeth Dbq

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Queen Elizabeth I of England, who ruled for 45 years from 1558-1603, had an uneasy reign. Since she was a female monarch and not male, which was rare in England, people believed that she wouldn’t be a competent monarch. The people who were not favorable for female monarchs or even females in general, believed very strongly abut the issue. John Knox, a Scottish religious reformer, declared in First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women, that a women ruler is “against all nature” (D1). However, there are some who are favorable to Queen Elizabeth’s rule as a female. Marcus Gheeraerts, an English court painter, depicts Queen Elizabeth as a person who is rich and in control by dressing her in extravagant clothes and putting the world underneath her (D8). During Queen Elizabeth’s reign, there were those who were not favorable to her rule and those who were, but apart from what others said, she herself thought that she was a competent ruler.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The majority of rebellions during Tudor England – 1485-1603 – did not carry out their principal objectives and reasons of this can be harshly classified by category in consequence of the weakness in the rebellion, or of the force of the reigning monarch. For example the poor control of a revolt beside the purely localised complaints would not have probably led to a successful rebellion and can be seen like defect of the rebels. On the one hand the stability and the force of the government would also lead to an easy defeat of risings. However, it would not be right to declare that all the rebellions not were successful; friendly Grant of 1525 is an example of retirement of government like direct consequence of revolt. Moreover, it would be simplistic to allege that the military defeat of a rebellion constitutes the revolt like failure automatically.…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To better understand the life of England’s King Henry VIII, one of the most famous and infamous of monarchs in history, the times into which he was born must be understood. Like his father, Henry VII, Henry VIII reigned during the transition from Medieval England to Renaissance England. The advent of the printing press, the rise of skepticism, and the move toward secularism were responsible for rapidly changing ideas. They were also the cause of some of the greatest conflicts of the sixteenth century. The 16th century was a confusing mass of changing…

    • 2027 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Haigh, Cristopher (1993). English Reformations: Religion, Politics and Society under the Tudors. Oxford University Press…

    • 1946 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the 16th century, female rule become dominant within England and Scotland. The paper first describes the strong belief that people held about a women’s subordination to men. It then examines the difficulty of having a female monarch, with this belief system. The position and authority of Mary Tudor and Elizabeth are discussed, including their treatment of the people of England. Furthermore, questions pertaining to marriage, children, and legitimacy are discussed within the paper. The article also examines each queens’ response and actions towards external voices questioning their authority, as a monarch. Additionally, the paper also provides accounts were women’s right to rule was defended during the 16th century and at its end. The…

    • 150 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    History has not been kind to Mary Tudor. Compared to what followed, her reign seems like a brief but misguided attempt to hold back England's inevitable transformation to Protestantism. Compared to what came before, her regime looks like the regressive episode of a hysterical woman. Considered on its own terms, however, the regime appears much more complex, leading contributors to this volume of essays to reach far different conclusions about her reign: reestablishing traditional religion in England was an enormous undertaking that required rebuilding the Marian Church from the bottom up. Moreover, given more time it might have succeeded. Finally, as these essays continually remind us, concepts differentiating Catholicism from Protestantism…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Tudors Notes

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages

    3. Theology – Majority still believed in traditional beliefs, only small numbers of reformers and church itself did not change that much after the reformation so can’t have been that bad.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One obvious continuity was that the Tudor bloodline had been passed along, keeping the same family ruling England. Which eliminated quite a lot of threat from keen opposition. Henry the eighth was young and healthy which was a promising thought at the time for the public. The position of men and women didn’t change either, women still had barely any rights and could night speak their thoughts or argue with men’s views. They were expected to do feminine activities and produce children who were possible heirs to the throne. As Henry the eighth needed to produce at least one heir, he decided to marry Catherine of Aragon, (a Spanish princess) after many years of weighing out other options. He used Catherine just like his father did to stabilise and secure a sturdy relationship with Spain and improving foreign relations. Another factor that was kept the same were the bonds and recognisances between the crown and the nobility, which threatened a fine to the aristocracy if they weren’t to remain loyal to the king and break his trust. These were very unpopular with the nobility, but controlled factions being formed, eliminating threat yet again. A common characteristic with both Henry the eighth and seventh was their irrational behaviour with money as they didn’t control or use it very…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays