Investing in TUFS
The case refers to a company called Northern Insurance and their huge investment on TUFS (Technical Underwriting Financial System). That system was the largest investment ever made on IT by Northern Insurance and it was supposed to assist the company by “streamlining the underwriting process and providing strategic e-business capabilities”. Yet, after a couple months, TUFS became the cost-center of the company, spending almost $4 million, and therefore the CIO, Martin Drysdale’s job was on the line. He had a meeting with the CFO, Melissa Freeman, to discuss the reasons why the system was not providing the benefits it was supposed to and whether to keep investing on it.
Discussion Questions: 1. TUFS was a great idea that would help the company a lot. It was supposed to help streamlining the underwriting process and therefore with cost savings. However, the technicians did not get any participation from the underwriters. Also, the departments were not in the same page in the creation of the system, and the result was a lot of money had to be spent on fixing underwriting errors that kept appearing over and over again. Additionally the senior underwriting managers still insisted on old reports instead of just looking it online, one of the benefits of TUFS. And lastly, there was a lack of business involvement in decisions, which contributed to the disappointment of the system. In conclusion, most of the resource of the company was spent on addressing underwriting issues that could have been prevented from the beginning if the underwriters and technicians had worked together (or did not lack in communication). 2. The IT people from the TUFS and the underwriter managers must get together and change the system so the whole situation with fixing one mistake and finding many others is prevented. Also, the system needs to be created (or changed) in such a way that it is easy and comfortable for the underwriters to use. To help with the transition to using the TUFS, a training program for the underwriting department would be perfect. Furthermore, the company needs to prioritize all the projects and apply deadlines to them so they have a clear list of what and by when to do it. 3. The benefits can be measured by comparing the amount of time spent using the old system and the new one (including training). And also, the company could have some kind of cost savings scorecard, and again compare the old system with the new one.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The case highlights the need to review and reassess the audit committee’s duties, especially considering its existing workload. Plaintiffs also claimed the transfer did not cover all the risk responsibilities from the prior risk committee. In addition, it reveals the need to have in place a process to receive information that may have a significant impact on financial reporting – in this case arising from a defective product. Finally, the case raises the question of corporate culture and the role it plays in the effectiveness of a complaint process in a large multifaceted…
- 1598 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The first impression when reading into the Eileen Foster case was that she was not wrongfully dismissed because it appeared that her actions were slightly overboard for an organization that was already aware of potential issues and who did discontinue operations of numerous locations based on assessments performed by the Fraud Risk division. When companies realize turmoil, it is typical and reasonable for the organization to push back on the…
- 422 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
You have been the CEO of Middlefield Hospital for 2 1/2 years and finally resolved the workforce challenges that plagued the hospital when you first arrived. In a recent meeting, the chief financial officer (CFO) indicated that the financial performance of the hospital has been deteriorating over the last 6 months. The hospital is not meeting its budget and he is concerned about the future. The new facility across town has continued to cut into Middlefield 's market share by admitting more patients. The number of admissions to Middlefield Hospital is declining each month, and more uninsured patients are seeking services at your facility. You convene the Middlefield Hospital management team and discover a few interesting facts, which are identified below.…
- 2491 Words
- 10 Pages
Good Essays -
Facts of the Case: Micro Enhancement International (MEI) was a software development company that was on the about to have an IPO. They hired Coopers and Lybrand as the auditor. The IPO for MEI was delayed because Coopers and Lybrand were resisting some of MEI’s recognized revenue and were threating to add a “going concern” to the audit. In the end Coopers and Lybrand allowed MEI to recognize the revenue and took away the “going concern” qualification. By the time the issue was settled MEI had lost the underwriter for the IPO and then went bankrupt shortly after. MEI sued Coopers and Lybrand for multiple things, but then wanted to add a breach of fiduciary duty. MEI’s CEO Staples said that, “he trusted Coopers and that Coopers had agreed to do the audit to do the Audit and to serve as MEI’s business advisor…” The judge denied this request and MEI appealed.…
- 481 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The details within the case description give us the main points, but our remedy for the company’s problems rely on some facts that are derived intuitively. These facts are in regards to the organization’s structure, employees, and management. As for the structure of management, we assume that Denver Department Stores is governed by…
- 3150 Words
- 13 Pages
Good Essays -
Mr. Terry Reed, the CFO of Excello Telecommunication learned of an elaborate opportunity or transaction that could possibly save the company, this consisted of selling some of their products to another company. Then on December 20, 2010 Excello sold $1.2 million of products to Data Equipment Systems. With this type of sales transaction it could only be recorded when the shipment occurred. Then Data Equipment through Excello a curve ball on this transaction. Data Equipment System wanted Excello Telecommunication to hold the product til January 11, 2011, because Date Equipment did not have the warehouse space to hold the shipment of the product at that time.…
- 1722 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
RBC Bank experienced a system application issue that was expected to last a full business day. Due to the technical difficulties at hand, Senior Underwriter Stephie Duguid, and the Underwriting Team were not able to work on client requests. Unsure what to do, Stephie reached out to her Canadian partners in the Advice Center…
- 260 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In order to correct some of the problems at the Fruitvale branch, the workload on each of the underwriting teams should be balanced as some of the teams may be handling more policies than the other teams. It appears that some of the tasks accomplished in the Rating Department and the Policy Writing could be eliminated with upgraded computer systems. Additionally, a strict policy for handling all policies should be implemented. If the first in-first out (FIFO) method is to be used, it must be used uniformly by each department. Lastly, the method to calculate SCT and the resulting TAT may be flawed resulting in inflated and unrealistic expectations.…
- 2198 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Claims Outlay Recovery for XXXXXXXXXXXXX Ltd – An analysis of a recently undertaken process redesign and commentary on its effectiveness…
- 4378 Words
- 18 Pages
Best Essays -
The company president meet with seven employees and told them that the company was in no position to give any wage increase; however, steps were already underway to establish a medical insurance plan by the end of the year. The seven employees met outside of the plant and decided the company’s position was unacceptable.…
- 792 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The case begins with Jim McIntoch the vice president of finance of Amalgamated Forest Products...…
- 264 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
What went wrong with the TUFS investment and what can be done to prevent these problems in the future?…
- 406 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Russell Smith knew why he had been summoned to the office of A. Walter Rognlien, the 74-year-old chairman of the board and chief executive officer (CEO) of Smith’s employer, Cardillo Travel Systems, Inc. Just two days earlier, Cardillo’s in-house attorney, Raymond Riley, had requested that Smith, the company’s controller, sign an affidavit regarding the nature of a transaction Rognlien had negotiated with the United Airlines. The affidavit stated that the transaction involves $203,000 payment by United Airlines to Cardillo but failed to disclose why the payment was being made or for what specific purpose the funds would be used. The affidavit included a statement indicating that Cardillo’s stockholders’ equity exceeded $3 million, a statement that Smith knew to be incorrect. Smith also knew that Cardillo was involved in a lawsuit and that court injunction issued in the case required the company to maintain stockholders’ equity of at least $3 million. Because of the blatant misrepresentation in the affidavit concerning Cardillo’s stockholders’ equity and a sense of uneasiness regarding United Airlines’ payment to Cardillo, Smith had refused to sign the affidavit.…
- 1808 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
no benefit to the company, acting in own interests, therefore, breach of fiduciary duty; consequently , acting oppressively…
- 397 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The case is about the changes brought by a newly appointed C.E.O. and the shift it brought in the much cherished culture of HP.…
- 1770 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays