Is Caliban A Success Or Failure Essay

The actions portrayed by Caliban in Shakespeare's work, The Tempest, shows his failure in an attempt to murder his master. The overall failure of his plan appears to be an effect of poor judgement in many ways. This includes a lack of discernment when trusting others to help with executing the murder, as well as ill contrived planning. If Descartes rules were followed, he may have been more successful in achieving his main objective. Caliban does not succeed at killing Prospero due to irrational decision making and an effort to work with others, conflicting with Part Four in the novel Discourse on Method by Rene Descartes. Calibans enslavement to Prospero is what had ultimately caused his change of character. He becomes enslaved to the same man who enters his territory and disrupts his peace, therefore causing tension and discomfort in the land that Caliban had once lived in tranquility. Due to this sudden intrusion of his privacy and contentment, Caliban becomes unruly and leads a dissolute lifestyle. Prospero sees him to be disobedient to the lifestyle imposed on him; however, Caliban had no rules to follow before the arrival Prospero and his daughter. He details this in the beginning of the
There are a few aspects that cause the failure to complete the task. While observing Descartes’ methods, there is a strong correlation between Part 2 of the methods described in his work to the concept of arranging for Prospero’s death. This specifically describes how an individual's work is typically more successful than a committee or group effort. This could have been helpful in Caliban creating his own plan rather than having the input of Stephano and Trinculo, who became equal parts in the plot. Without the contribution from the two, Caliban would have devised his own plan. According to Descartes’ rules, creating his own design would have led to a more successful