Preview

Ivan Illich's View Of Over Medicalization

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1544 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ivan Illich's View Of Over Medicalization
Conrad, as above detailed - bought forward the base understanding that medicalization is the medical manipulation of deviant behaviors and daily life events. Irving Zola elaborates further, claiming that these manipulations are used to benefit individuals or groups of individuals in more than just physiological ways by aiding wider social or political agendas and expectations into what is deemed acceptable [Zola, 1972]. This concept can be used to explain the surge in the number of different diagnosed medical conditions over the last couple of decades. Behavioral patterns that have been otherwise been noted as sinful or criminal now diagnosed as medical by nature, transitioning them from undesirable to ill. This can be highlighted with children …show more content…
The idea that medical experts – those accredited with the role of improving the health of individuals; are intentionally conceptualizing issues that don’t concern medical or health related thinking - as deep-rooted into an individual’s health and well-being. Exploitation of society’s otherwise non-medical issues have lead some sociologists to believing that Medicalization is the worst thing that can happen to an individuals health [illich, 1976]. Ivan Illich’s argument views medicalization from the perspective of the public and the patients diagnosed. Good health isn’t just the absence of disease, instead it is considered complete Mental, physical and social soundness [WHO, 1984]. Illich makes the point that health as concept should be managed by individuals, with the process of medicalization growing to be more prevalent in society this becomes more difficult. Increases in the number of issues that weren’t previously approached as medical in nature such as: Menopause, Sleeping Disorders and obesity to name a few [Blackburn, 2009], mean individuals must allow medical experts to interlude with their personal, physical selves. Addressing earlier societies as private and accommodated with interaction occurring between just a single expert and patients over-issues that were deemed medically serious. Illich however, did acknowledge that this newly medicalized …show more content…
This can be put to the social trends of society; health is becoming and has become a productized, an entire marketplace has been generated around treatments and diagnostics [Turner, 2004]. The new healthcare reform is no-longer considered an issue of public-policy instead it is seen as a matter concerning public-finance, for which a business plan must be followed. To help accommodate the increase in medicalized issues in a socio-economic context for its consumers, who are becoming more educated in medical terminology for analysis and improvement of their own personal health by modems such as TV and the internet [Clovin, 2012] [Barker, 2008]. One example of this would be the projection of conceptually medicalized ideas in media outposts, encouraging people to consider their health in ways they would have otherwise overlooked. Medicalizations prevalence in today’s society can also be explained by ever advancing technologies; new tools are made available, increasing the number of new diagnostics, providing empirical evidence that conditions that may not have been deemed medical, have medical aspects. The issue advancing technologies bring to the medical society is the myth that medicine can heal everything, delaying death – given the sufficient time and funding. Consequently leading individuals to believe that medicine has completely overcome disease, forgetting

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Well-known philosopher Michel Foucault wrote a book called ‘The Birth of the Clinic (1973)’, the main idea behind the book is that Foucault trails how medical knowledge was transferred by scientific methods in the eighteenth century. He recorded that the doctors based their treatments on observation of the patients symptoms rather than referencing books to analyse the type of disease the patient may have. Through observation, Foucault was able to develop the concept of ‘surveillance’ whereby, patients would go for regular check-ups to get analysed and find out if they were healthy or diseased. Keeping in mind back in the old days, they created a false ideological truth about people who were abnormal. These people were seen to be possessed by the devil because…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emily Parks Alexander AP Language 11 March 2024 Medical Ethics Synthesis Science and medicine is the most rapidly advancing facet of human knowledge, and has been since the Scientific Revolution. Germ theory, anesthesia, and chemotherapy, among many other advancements in the medical practice, have improved the lives of many in a way that is difficult to quantify. Now that mankind has reached such a point in healthcare, where pain and illness can be more successfully mitigated than ever before, it is ever so important that ethical and humane treatment is prioritized. Informed consent, humanization of patients, and proper compensation of individuals who influence medical advancement, are the most crucial aspects of medical ethics regulations in today's world. Comparatively, informed consent and similar…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    We are living in a era in which technological advances have made many things possible in different areas of science. Medicine is a huge area of research due to the constant struggle for more effective ways of staying healthy all the time. People need to be instantly gratified, and the technology makes it possible. However, people’s need for instant gratification often overlooks the harmful effects of medicine. Not only are health effects overlooked, people are naturally inclined to conform to what they feel is normal. In Ayn Rand’s novel, “Anthem”, people are living in darkness blindly following what everyone else is doing. This goes to show that people have and always will be pressured by conformity and social norms. Pharmaceutical…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Historically, people have sought to understand the world around them and how they as people exist within that world. Through the desire for understanding of ourselves and our bodies we as people seek to label and quantify bodily functions, behaviors, and illness. People first tried to explain illness in terms of a Biblical context – good verses evil. Therefore, illness was seen as a punishment for some overt or covert evil within the person. Slowly theological explanations gave way to value judgments on those in lower socioeconomic classes and a choice of unhealthy living (Weitz, 101-102). As scientific progress moved forward two models of illness became more apparent: the medical model and the sociological model. This gave way to understanding…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purpose of Freidson’s article was to analyze the social organization of the medical profession and its members. In his study, he explored how the medical profession has gained a monopoly in its field, which grants it complete jurisdiction over determining what illness is therefore how people must act in order to be treated as ill (Freidson 1970:205). Because medicine has the ability to label one person’s grievance an illness and another one not, Freidson believes that medicine creates the social role of illness. Illness is thought of as a deviance from a set of norms that represent normal or healthy behavior. “Human, and therefore social evaluation of what is normal, proper, or…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ehrenreich proclaims, “Health is almost universally recognized as a kind of virtue” (Ehrenreich, 2015, p. 338). Based on the decisions a person chooses, society may not consider him or her morally “good”. Ehrenreich explains that society redefines virtue as health and argues that society has made health a moral issue (Ehrenreich, 2015, p.337). The redefinition of virtue puts health choices as the main reason whether an individual is “good or bad” instead of the individual’s actions and character. Consequently, health has become a moral issue due to its judgmental state. Ehrenreich declares, “To say we want to be healthy is to gravely understate the case. We want to be good” (Ehrenreich, 2015, p. 337). Society’s standards base if an individual has moral standards because he or she has physical…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What we can think of as the current era of health care is one in which economic and financial considerations will dominate the delivery system, complementary and alternative medical practices will continue to rise, an aging population will present many dilemmas, efforts will be made to keep patients out of institutions, patient safety and health quality will become of increasing concern for hospitals and other health care providers, managed care has been shown to not be effective and will be supplanted by other types of products, and the use of electronic and digital media will play an increasingly important role in health…

    • 231 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Medicine has come a long way in curing and treating its patients, but it has also brought new threats onto humanity. It seems to be revenge from death, since medicines main focus is prolonging death. Emanuel stresses throughout his article that as people grow older, it is harder for them to function fluently after acquiring any illnesses. He talked about strokes and medicines achievement in reducing morality of strokes, but “Americans who have survived a stroke suffer from paralysis or an inability to speak. And … suffer from more-subtle brain dysfunction” (Emanuel 77). Although medicine treats strokes with more ease, the effects that come after have not been dealt with. Emanuel has come to the conclusion that diseases and illnesses older people acquire will further disable them through the ways medicine works. This is an example of medicine’s “repair and adaption” method, which has made the “revenge effects of medicine” even stronger. The stroke will be treated and the patient must adapt, only to be hit by medicine’s revenge with mental dysfunction. As a matter of fact, Tenner mainly discusses this method in his excerpt; “theorists believe that lasting tissue damage may make the body less resistant to future stress by shifting resources to ‘repair and adaptation’” (Tenner 56). Doctors aim to repair the tissue damage dealt by a disease and then make patients adapt to them in some type of way, but adapting means changing to fit into the new circumstances given. If adapting occurs, then the person will now be dealing with whatever new challenges arose from the illness acquired or tissue damage, like strokes leading to mental dysfunctions if treated. It is a method that leads to the patient having more health issues after already being treated by medicine. This is all a way to cheat death, but embracing death in…

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Author Atul Gawande is a surgeon, staff writer for The New Yorker and a professor at the Harvard Medical School. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End was an inspiring book that unwrap people’s mind for discussion and question our current practice of medicine and care. It is easy for audiences of all ages to relate to this book even if the young do not think about the process of death. It has a comprehensive coverage of medical sociology, where it deliberates on the evolution, controversial conversation of medicine and issues after medicine becomes impotent to people’s health. Gawande uses recounts of people (patients) and his own reflections on the stories to illustrate the dilemmas of the two facet of medicine: to attempt…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As we travel with time our health conditions take a leap at the same time. There are some illnesses that can be treated with common medicines; and some conditions are given enough attention to be treated. Physicians are too keen on their field, promoting different kinds of remedies just to alleviate or heal a disorder.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sociology and Social Care

    • 2824 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Sociologists argue that health and illness have two aspects to them. The first of these is biological, and there…

    • 2824 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Prescriptions for psychiatric drugs to children and adolescents have skyrocketed in the past 10 years. This article presents evidence that the superior effectiveness of stimulants and antidepressants is largely a presumption based on an empirical house of cards, driven by an industry that has no conscience about the implications of its ever growing, and disturbingly younger, list of consumers. Recognizing that most mental health professionals do not have the time, and sometimes feel ill-equipped to explore the controversy regarding pharmacological treatment of children, this article discusses the four fatal flaws of drug studies to enable a critical examination of research addressing the drugging of children. The four flaws are illustrated by the Emslie studies of Prozac and children, which offer not only a strident example of marketing masquerading as science, but also, given the recent FDA approval of Prozac for children, a brutal reminder of the danger inherent in not knowing how to distinguish science from science fiction. The authors argue that an ethical path requires the challenge of the automatic medical response to medicate children, with an accompanying demand for untainted science and balanced information to inform critical decisions by child caretakers.…

    • 8471 Words
    • 34 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assisted Suicide Essay

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rapid and dramatic developments in medicine and technology have completely given us the power to save more lives than was ever possible in the past. Medicines have put at our disposal the means to cure or to reduce the fatal suffering of people afflicted with diseases that were once fatal or painful. At the same time, medical technologies have given us the power to sustain the lifes (or, some would say, prolong the deaths) of patients whose physical and mental sustainability cannot be restored, whose horrible degenerating conditions cannot be reversed, and whose fatal pain cannot be eliminated. As medicines struggle to pull more and more people away from the hand of death, the plea that tortured, deteriorated lives be mercifully…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Society experiences health and wellness in many different perspectives. Sociologically speaking, there are two major theoretical aspects to healthcare. Functionalism demonstrates illness as an inhibitor on society’s functions. Conflict theory describes issues within the healthcare system, rather than focusing on individual illness affecting society. All in all, both approaches share the same ideology on the source of overall health. These two perspectives illustrate a sociological root for issues within health and medicine.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Irving Zola, and Joseph Schneider (Overgaard, et al., 2014, p. 743). Published studies primarily focus on medical interventions of deviant behaviors, mental health, personality differences, aging, and the role that medical intervention has played in society. Additionally, studies also examine the increase of pharmaceutical advertising that robustly stimulates the invention of illness and targets consumers to self-diagnose through check-lists of symptoms (Maturo, 2012, p. 124). Ultimately, most theorists agree that by describing certain aspects of life and human differences as pathologies, the institution of medicine has metamorphosed into an institution of social control, therefore dictating what is normal and acceptable within society, and what should be classified as a medical condition in order to correct or control undesirable and deviant behaviors. (Conrad,…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays