Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Japanese monetary policy

Powerful Essays
1270 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Japanese monetary policy
The rather poor economic performance of Japan since the early 1990s provided inspiration to US and UK policy makers in how they addressed the 2007 financial crisis. How did US and UK policy makers respond to the 2007 financial crisis in a way that was different to the response in Japan? This part of the question would benefit from quantitative evidence.

There are several similarities between the Japanese financial crisis of the 1990s and the global financial crisis that started in 2008. Countries like the US and the UK realized this and have studied the measures that were taken by the Japanese central bank (Bank of Japan) at the time in order to learn from it. Measures that proved to be effective have been taken into account and are currently being applied in adapted forms by the Federal Reserve (the US central bank) and the Bank of England (the British central bank). In order to understand these measures, a brief recapitulation of Japan’s crisis will be given first in this paper. Subsequently, a comparison will be made with US and UK policies in order to analyze the differences and similarities.

In the three decades following 1960 Japan achieved a rapid economic growth. Euphoria about the economic prospects started to break out due to the long period of excellent economic growth rates, which is referred to as the Japanese post-war economic miracle. In the 1980s overconfident institutions, firms and citizens started massive borrowing and aggressive speculation, which caused the economy to overheat. A bubble was created in the stock exchange and in the real estate market, which came to burst at the beginning of the 1990s. The resulting negative wealth effect caused the Japanese people to cut their expenditure and increase savings. People had no trust anymore in the banks, which had turned into zombie banks due to the large amount of non-performing assets on their balance sheets (toxic debt), and therefore they kept their savings outside the banking system. Dropping sales (due to increased saving) resulted in job losses, which in turn led to even more saving and less spending. By this way the Japan provisionally “saved” itself into a recession.

The Bank of Japan first reacted to the recession with conventional monetary policy. They reduced interest rates in order to stimulate the economy. However, due to the collapse of asset prices, the insolvency of banks and firms and the refusal of Japanese consumers to spend their income, the Japanese economy slipped into deflation from 1998. The deflation worked as an incentive for the Japanese people to save even more and spend even less, since saving yields a positive return when there is deflation. The Bank of Japan responded by further lowering the interest rate to (close to) 0%. Because of the deflation however, the real interest rate was still positive and people continued to save. Since the interest rate could not be dropped below 0% the Bank of Japan reached a state of monetary policy impotence, see figure 4.
FIGURE 4
Janese Interest Rate(Benchmark Interest Rate)

Source from: http://www.tradingeconomics.com

Japan also suffered from fiscal policy impotence. Neither significantly increasing government expenditure nor dropping taxes was possible to stimulate the economy. The first because Japan did not have the funds (they were in debt) and the latter because the conservative and risk averse Japanese citizens were very likely to save tax cuts instead of spending them.

For a long time, the Bank of Japan believed that economic growth and recovery of asset prices would bring things back to normal over time. Their efforts were focused on prevention of bank failures and collapse of the financial system and not on active recovery. The zombie banks, which were for a large part responsible for all the misery, were implicitly protected. Accounting rules were relaxed, so that banks got the opportunity to conceal their financial trouble. There was no public support for any form of financial bailout that would solve problems on a more structural basis and throughout the 90s the financial institutions continued to muddle along. This period is known as the lost decade (Vollmer & Bebenroth,2012).

In the early 2000’s the Bank of Japan tried a different approach. They came with an important policy innovation, called quantitative easing. Under the quantitative easing program the Bank of Japan started to increase the monetary base, in order to flood the banks with liquidity. The idea was that the banks could lend this newly created money to households and firms and that this would lead to an increase in consumption expenditure and investments.

In addition to the quantitative easing, the bank of Japan also broke with their previous policy of regulatory forbearance. They implemented a series of accounting reforms that made it more difficult for banks to conceal their bad loans. By making the financial sector balance sheets more transparent the bad debt problem was emphasized and it became clear that the accumulation of non-performing loans had to be curbed. A certain degree of public support for recapitalization was secured, which made it politically possible to inject public money in the financial sector (Lipscy & Takinami, 2013).

These unconventional policy measures seemed to assort effect. After a long period of trial and error and policy experimentation, the Japanese managed to turn the tide and modest economic growth was recorded until the global financial crisis kicked in in 2008. Although the growth figures had not been fantastic, the Japanese gain and loss during anti-crisis were noticed by UK and US policymakers. In their view, the Japanese experience had highlighted what policy actions should be taken or avoided to deal with a financial crisis.

Basically, the reaction that followed from the UK and the US to the 2008 financial crisis is fourfold: interest rate cuts, quantitative easing, bank bailouts and change of regulations (Parkin, Powell & Matthews, 2012c). Due to lessons learnt they executed these actions much faster and more determined than Japan however. For the interest rate cuts and the quantitative easing, this is greatly illustrated in the figures below(See figure 5 and 6).

FIGURE 5
United States Interest Rate 2007-2012(Benchmark Interest Rate)

Source from: http://www.tradingeconomics.com

FIGURE 6
United Kingdom Interest Rate (Benchmark Interest Rate)

Source from: http://www.tradingeconomics.com

Where Japan had reduced interest rates gradually, the US and the UK took relative much sharper cuts. Also, they introduced quantitative easing on a much larger scale. As can be seen from the expansion in outstanding balances at the central bank, the monetary base was increased to a much larger extent (See Figure 7).

FIGURE 7
Central Bank Balance Sheets (US, UK AND JAPAN)

Source from: (Philips, 2013 )

Another lesson learnt from Japan was that you should not let toxic debt create zombie banks. Both the US and the UK immediately injected massive amounts of public funds into large commercial banks when they ran the risk to fail. To justify these bail outs to the public, great transparency of the financial sector balance sheets was sought after, for instance by doing stress tests. Also, the Japanese case was frequently referenced to in order to secure public support.

The public resentment against the irresponsible and risky behavior of financial institutions that caused the financial crisis, has contributed to a change in regulations. These will continue to change, since the debate about acceptable risks, supervisory authorities and banks that are ‘too big to fail’ is still ongoing. If the evolving regulations, combined with the measures that were first introduced in Japan’s financial crisis of the 1990s, will be the way out of the crisis remains to be seen (See Figure 8).

FIGURE 8 Monetary policy in Japan and the United States

Source from: (Lipscy & Takinami, 2013)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The purpose of this assignment is to prepare a paper U.S. Federal Reserve monetary policy that characterizes the state of the economy. This paper will describe the primary concern in which the Federal Reserve currently has in regard to the economy. In addition, this paper will provide the stated direction of recent policy as it affects the economy. Finally, an explanation of the current actions by the Federal Reserve that confirms the…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    mother, Ruth, brought him to live with her at a sailor's hotel and bar that she…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    This report will discuss the causes and effects of quantitative easing monetary policy in US, UK and Japan on the basis of some relevant economic data. A brief introduction will discuss the nature of quantitative easing policy. In the US part, the global financial crisis will be analysed firstly, which is the cause of QE policy in US. Then, the influences of this policy, especially for banking industry will be addressed. In 2009, the Bank of England decided to implement the QE in UK as well. In this part, a brief comparison of consequences between US and UK will be addressed. The third part is relevant with Japan, which is the first country that applied QE policy in the world, to solve the asset bubble collapse in 2001. Finally, a brief comparison of US and Japan will be put forward and some summing-up will be argued in the conclusion.…

    • 5282 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Closing Case Japan

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. In the 1980s Japan was viewed as one of the world’s most dynamic economies, today it is viewed as one of the most stagnant. According to Hill, The Japanese economy has stagnated because in quick succession their stock market collapsed and property prices rapidly followed. Japanese banks found their balance sheets loaded with bad debt and they reduced lending. As the stock market plunged and property prices imploded, individuals saw their net worth shrink. Japanese consumers responded by sharply reducing spending, depressing domestic demand and sending the economy into a recession.…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Stack and Build wooden blocks are blocks that are made of natural wooden blocks. The building blocks come in a set of 50 pieces that include a variety of shapes. Children build all sorts of different things with the blocks and play with them in infinite ways.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    International Business

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. The Japanese has stagnated due to Japanese banks, which had financed much of the boom in asset prices with easy money, now found their balance sheets loaded with bad debt, and they sharply contracted lending and deflation. The Nikkei average plunged from nearly 39,000 points in December 1989 to about 14,300 points in August 1992, thereby losing about 60% of its value. As a result, investors lost the equivalent of (U.S.) $2 trillion and property values plummeted by about $10 trillion. Property values in certain parts of the country declined by 70% and plunged Japan into a deep recession for 10-years.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Monetary policy is the key tool used by Federal Reserve to monitor and control US economy. According to Vance Roley and Gordon H. Selon, in their article “Monetary Policy Actions and Long-Term Interest Rates”:…

    • 2958 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    What started as an American ‘prime-mortgage’ lending crisis spread to Europe and the emerging markets of Asia, South East Asia and Latin America, affecting a wide range of financial and economic activities and institutions, which includes, the tightening of credit with financial institutions making both corporate and consumer credit harder to get, devaluation of the assets underpinning insurance contracts and pension funds leading to concerns about the ability of the instruments to meet future obligation, devaluation of some currencies /increased currency volatility and liquidity problems in equity funds and hedge funds.(Francis Ikome 2008 - The Social and Economic Consequences of the Global…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Identify at least three problems facing the FED in achieving its goals of monetary policy and give your recommendations on how to deal with each of the problems you list.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to the removal of barrier between Banking and commerce and volatility in the interest rate, the savings and loans institutions crashed and went…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Now, as the United States moves towards a globally interdependent marketplace, the stakes are much higher than they were when Congress established the Federal Reserve in the early 1900’s. A country’s debt can now become the world’s debt, and the role of the U.S. federal banking system is now considerably more under pressure and scrutiny than ever before. As we have been seeing with the current liquidity crisis in the U.S., and how it has affected U.K. and Asian markets, strong, comprehensive policy-making is now crucial to sustaining long-term economic viability.…

    • 5540 Words
    • 23 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the iconic poem of The Raven by Edgar Allan Poe, he expresses deep feelings of sorrow, love, madness, and loneliness. Due to the foul of the air that has came and visited Poe one dark and dreary night in the middle of December. The raven itself forces its way into the room, as a standing reminder of an untimely death Poe can yet to get over. Poe sits in his own loathing self pity for a lost cause with the name of Lenore. Poe feels so grieved over the loss of his loved one that he lets his imagination transform a bird into a prophet bringing the agonising news that the two will “nevermore” be reunited, not even in heaven.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The global economic downturn, the sub-prime mortgage fiasco, investment bank collapses, falling shares and home prices, and tight credit pushed the United States into a recession by end 2007.In response to which the Federal Reserve, Treasury, and Securities and Exchange Commission responded with unprecedented , monetary policy expansion, fiscal stimulus and financial institutional bailouts intended to create employment, promote investments and combat slumping consumer spending. However these policies have had useful as well as contradictory results in their outcomes. The following report discusses various monetary and fiscal policies, reasons for the contradictory consequences ,impact of these policies on the banking sector for e.g. how banks started hoarding and investing money in securities instead of lending out to businesses, and how Citibank in particular has been impacted. The report concludes with a number of recommendations to address the challenges of debt management, dismal unemployment rate and the crisis of the banking sector.…

    • 2545 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Japan, a relatively small nation in size, located in Eastern Asia between the North Pacific Ocean and the Sea of Japan boasts a population of about 127,368,088 people; 10th most populated nation. It is quite hard to imagine how a country about the size of the state of California could have been positioned and was predicted to become the largest, most powerful economy in the world. Japan’s economy, in the years following World War II can be described as nothing short of a miracle. For three decades, the real GDP of the country grew at an unperceived rate: a 10% average in the 1960’s, a 5% average in the 1970’s, and a 4% average in the 1980’s (CIA World fact book, 2012). This tremendous success was due to a strong work-ethic, cooperation in the government industry, efficient and innovative high technology sector, and a comparatively small defense allocation (1 % of GDP) (CIA World Fact book, 2012). In the 1990’s, however, growth slowed down to 1.7 % which was due largely in part to inefficient investment. In 2007, Japan’s 69 year economic expansion came to a screeching halt; as a matter of fact, they entered an economic recession as of 2008. The global demand for Japanese exports decreased significantly; as a result, the recession worsened and has brought rise to a new challenge: deflation. In March 2011, Japan's strongest-ever earthquake, and an accompanying tsunami, devastated the northeast part of Honshu island, killing thousands and damaging several nuclear power plants. The catastrophe hobbled the country's economy and its energy infrastructure, and tested e country’s ability to deal with crippling natural disasters. As if matters could not get any worse, Japan’s massive government debt which totals over 200% of the total GDP; in addition to the aging population, pose two additional long-run problems for the country itself and foreign investors alike. Despite the past decade of…

    • 3868 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    2007-2008 Financial Crisis

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Economists and scholars spend years dissecting financial markets and evaluating the causes of booms and busts. Throughout United States history there have been multiple economic booms that were underestimated and followed by recessions. In the situation of the 2007-2008 global financial crisis many culprits have been identified as causes, such as loose monetary policy, credit booms, deregulation, over complexity, and greed. Since the economic boom was solely dependent on weak policies and misconceptions, this leads me to believe prevention was possible with adequate regulatory policy, risk assessment and clarifications for commercial banks.…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays