Preview

Jay Gatsby v. Tom Buchanan

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
542 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jay Gatsby v. Tom Buchanan
Jillian Lydon
Mrs. Dolan
Literature 2
17 October 2014
Jay Gatsby vs. Tom Buchanan
Throughout the novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, the characters Jay Gatsby and Tom Buchanan are compared and contrasted quite frequently. Gatsby and Tom are alike in that they are both extremely wealthy and flaunt it, both men also are in love with Daisy Buchanan and both Tom and Gatsby have secrets that they are hiding from their loved ones. The two men differ in the way they came into their money, the way they treat other people and in the fact that Tom is married to Daisy while Gatsby just has an extreme desire for her.
Both Jay Gatsby and Tom Buchanan are extraordinarily wealthy and have no problem showing it off to others. Gatsby throws lavish parties every weekend in hopes of winning back his true love, Daisy Buchanan, while Tom lives in an extravagant house and makes sure that everyone knows he is above them. Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby are both in love with Tom’s wife, Daisy. Although it may take a while for Tom, while Gatsby knew from the moment he met Daisy, by the end of the novel both men realize Daisy is the most important person in his life. Gatsby and Tom both have major secrets in their life. Tom is cheating on Daisy with Myrtle Wilson, his friend’s wife. While Tom is having an affair and lying to Daisy, Gatsby lies as well. Gatsby lies about his life and how he came into money and doesn’t tell anyone besides his friend and neighbor Nick Carraway. Although both men are similar, they differ even more.
While both the men are exceptionally wealthy they came into money very differently. Gatsby had to lie and cheat for his money in his later years of his life and Tom was born into prosperity. Tom makes it very clear to Gatsby in the novel that wealth is “in his blood,” causing Gatsby to work even harder to win back Daisy. Gatsby is a very friendly and good-hearted person. He treats others with respect and truly only wants his love for Daisy to be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the book, “The Great Gatsby,” the characters Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby are more alike than they appear. They also share the same differences too and they also never loved Daisy. One of their great differences is that Gatsby is more organized and Tom is not.Tom’s great differences is that he is cheater and Gatsby is not. They have two different personalities but can relate to the same secret affairs throughout the book.…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom Buchanan was married to Daisy Buchanan, and Tom was having an affair with Myrtle Wilson- who was married to George Wilson. Jay Gatsby had always loved Daisy Buchanan, and they finally got reconnected one day after years. This reuniting was a result of Nick moving beside Gatsby, because Nick was Daisy’s cousin. Gatsby had an ostentatious house and car. Furthermore, he regularly had large parties at his mansion. Nick stated that “there was music coming from [his] neighbor’s house through the summer nights…. and on weekends his Rolls-Royce became an omnibus bearing parties to and from the city” (39). This quote gives readers the idea that Gatsby had the same parties day in and day out. There was always a crowd at Gatsby’s house, the same crowd over and over, that went to drink their worries away. Gatsby was defined as having “new money”, meaning that he did not grow up in money. That was not the case for Tom and Daisy. They lived in the “old money” side of the bay. Daisy was married to Tom for his money, mostly. In that time period, women could not divorce their husbands so Daisy was stuck with him. Moreover, Gatsby obtained his money in order to impress Daisy. In…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jay Gatsby is a character who is a little sketchy at the beginning. No one really knows who he is, they just know that he is freakishly rich and throws huge elegant party’s that you want to be invited to. As the story goes on he starts to get more sketchy because you’re really not sure if he is lying or not about the war medals or how he’s made so much of his life. But then he just turns into a love sick young man who was not being himself to get a girl. Gatsby is a kind hearted man who always cares about peoples wellbeing but just makes a few bad decisions to try and get the woman he loves. Tom Buchannan on the other hand is a cold hearted man who might have a lot of money and a nice wife but doesn’t understand the American dream. He expects respect that he doesn’t deserve and cheats on his wife. But when he suspects that she is cheating on him he confronts her with rage ‘I suppose the latest thing is to sit back and let Mr. Nobody from Nowhere make love to your wife. Well, if that's the idea you can count me out” (Chapter 7 The Great Gatsby). Tom is a rude man who almost seems happy that he doesn’t care about anyone or try to help anyone. He could have saved Gatsby and Wilson from their deaths but just decided that he didn’t want to and that he didn’t care.…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom and Gatsby’s relationships with Daisy differ. Even though Gatsby has not seen Daisy in five years, he still loved her very much and stayed loyal the whole time. This shows that Gatsby loves Daisy so much that he would stay lonely and hopeful for years just for her. Gatsby never gave up hope during the time that they were apart. Tom has an affair on Daisy with Myrtle. This shows that Tom isn’t loyal to Daisy and he doesn’t put any effort into their relationship. Tom really uses Myrtle to satisfy one of his needs and Daisy to satisfy another. Gatsby was the only one willing to work and put effort towards him and Daisy while Tom took his and Daisy’s relationship for granted.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Imagine the 1920's have been re-enacted, a time of luxurious parties and when things, didn’t seem to matter or mean as much as they do now. The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, gives you a picture of what the time period was like. It was a time known as the "Jazz Age", where the economy was at its peak, and money was easy to be held. Prohibition was in affect, and bootlegging was very gainful for those who took part in it. Jay Gatsby most likely took part in an illegal business scheme, such as bootlegging, to make his fortune. Tom Buchanan, on the other hand though, acquired his wealth through inheritance. The plot of The Great Gatsby seemingly also revolves around a girl, Daisy Buchanan, whom Tom and Gatsby both love in different ways. However, they are similar as they both want to be able to call Daisy “mine.” In The Great Gatsby, although Tom and Gatsby strive to be financially successful and maintain a high social class, and they both love Daisy in a way, they are two completely different people with different personalities and morals.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion Tom Buchanan is an arrogant man. He has a beautiful trophy wife Daisy Buchanan and a child Patty. He cheats on his wife with a woman named Myrtle who is already married. When Gatsby comes back into Daisy’s life he gets angry and wants it to stop. He does not care who he hurts in order to get what he wants.This made him so angry he lied to get Gatsby…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gatsby used his wealth to throw parties so he could try to get Daisy’s attention and impress her. He did end up impressing her. However, because Daisy was married to her husband Tom she could not be with Gatsby. Tom found out about Daisy’s affair and confronted Gatsby. Gatsby insisted that Daisy never loved Tom but Daisy could not deny her love for her husband. It showed that Gatsby was extremely naive to believe that Daisy would love him to a certain extent as to say that she never loved her own husband. Gatsby believed that he could easily win her back simply by showing up with his wealth, but he was wrong.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Set in the 1920’s, F. Scott Fitzgerald’s book, The Great Gatsby, tells the story of social classes and a wealthy man who lost the love of his life. This man, Jay Gatsby, is born poor, but he works his way into becoming rich, and thus being the symbol of new money. Daisy Buchanan, Gatsby’s lover, is born as old money and lives in East Egg with her husband Tom Buchanan, and is a glamorous person. Gatsby always loves Daisy, but was unable to marry her because he was poor and Daisy loves rich men, so Tom marries her. Gatsby attempts to stop time and “repeat the past” because he has lost the girl of his dreams. Fitzgerald…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His very actions identified the morality and values of the 1% as he, and Daisy, showed that romantic infidelity goes both ways, and how easy it was to become a hypocrite. His marriage, which Gatsby points out later in the book, was under circumstance of wealth; Daisy, the unreliable character split between two men, believes it to be love. Tom’s obsession with uncovering Daisy’s past with Gatsby also shows his insecurity of losing Daisy. This possessive attitude could easily be explained away with his obligation to their marriage, but Tom had already been cheating with Myrtle. This breakaway from the idea of the perfect American family unearths the underlying patriarchal dominance of the 20s as Tom declares Daisy’s infidelity as unjust while evading the topic of his own…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the commotion about whether Gatsby is trying to steal Daisy from Tom, Daisy now has the decision to choose between Tom and Gatsby. However, Daisy thinks they are asking too much of her, and instead of choosing she reveals that, “‘[she] did love [Tom] once — but [she] loved [Gatsby] too’” (Fitzgerald 102). Daisy now wants both of them, and no longer has a problem discarding Gatsby because of his lack of wealth. Not only does she toy with Gatsby’s emotions, she also conceals the truth about the murder of Myrtle, which costs Gatsby’s life dearly.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, wealth is the origin of Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy. Gatsby believes he is “the son of God” (Fitzgerald 105) and struggles to civilize himself into a wealthy man. When he is a poor soldier, he meets Daisy, “the first ‘nice’ girl” he has never met (Fitzgerald 158). Throughout the story, it is found that she is…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom and Daisy live in the elite East Egg, populated by established families of old money. Gatsby buys an extravagant mansion across from them, in the garish and flashy West Egg, in an attempt to become closer to Daisy. He is obsessed with deconstructing their lives; near the end of the novel, after a fight between the three, he tries to goad Daisy to confess she never loved Tom. She is unable to commit and makes up with Tom after running over Myrtle. The corruption of the Buchanan’s is internal; even before the Myrtle incident, the Buchanan home is in mild and constant turmoil. Domestic violence is hinted on Tom’s part, and an explicitly violent revealed when he attacks Myrtle during their affair. The multiple affairs Tom has with other women have caused the couple to move many times. However, Tom and Daisy stick together, inconsiderate of the lives they had ruined in the…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Gatsby found out that Daisy married Tom Buchanan, he lost himself. Gatsby was only worried about Daisy and what she wanted, for he needed to win her over to reach his goal. He focused so much on Daisy that he lost comprehension of his possible character collapse that could occur if he went too far with her pampering and temptation to take her from Tom. Gatsby has wasted many years trying to live up to the American dream and gain wealth. However, Jay has failed to realize that the so called “American Dream” doesn’t exist, for the society has become selfish and grouped into classes. Because of this and the fact that he was considered “new money”, Jay was powerless in the task of reaching Daisy’s class and rating. Jay was prepared to take the blame for Daisy, when she accidentally hit and killed Myrtle Wilson, Tom’s mistress. Because everyone believed that Gatsby did the bad deed, Nick told him to flee the town, but he stayed, for he couldn’t leave Daisy. After George Wilson, Myrtle’s husband, shot and killed Gatsby to gain revenge, Daisy left the town and didn’t attend Jay’s funeral, which led to the end of Jay’s character breakdown. Gatsby’s character downfall and ordeal were negatively impacted by his need to achieve the American dream and Daisy’s…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How Is Gatsby Selfish

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Daisy initially fell in love with Gatsby’s newfound riches than Gatsby himself. As soon as she discovered his wealth she falls back in love with him, completely disregarding her own husband. Daisy was too caught up in the wealth and attention she received from Gatsby that she even declared, “why - how could I love him [Tom] - possibly? … ‘I never loved him” (126). Buchanan is so infatuated with Gatsby's lifestyle that she announced she never loved Tom and only married him because Jay was at war. Daisy’s husband had the wealth to support her and gave her some attention, but she detached from him the moment a richer man came along, who gave her the attention she desired. Therefore Daisy’s craving for more riches causes her to cheat on her husband for the man who is supplying superior funds and…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Great Gatsby, the relationship between the different characters eventually disintegrated because of unreal love and the struggle for wealth. The most controversial relationship in the novel is the relationship between Daisy and Tom. Infidelity in their marriage has caused problems not only for themselves, but for other characters also. Tom and Daisys relationship seems to be normal and healthy at the beginning. They are a wealthy couple living in East Egg, one of the most powerful and wealthy communities in New York. Tom is a friend of Nicks from when they went to Yale, and Daisy is Nicks cousin. Nick soon discovers that Tom and Daisys relationship is not all bliss. Tom and Nick go to New York City where they meet Toms…

    • 1503 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics