Preview

John Stubbs: Love and Role Playing in a Farewell to Arms

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
892 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
John Stubbs: Love and Role Playing in a Farewell to Arms
John Stubbs ' "Love and Role Playing in A Farewell to Arms"

John Stubbs ' essay is an examination of the defense which he believes Henry and Catherine use to protect themselves from the discovery of their insignificance and "powerlessness...in a world indifferent to their well being..." He asserts that "role-playing" by the two main characters, and several others in the book, is a way to escape the realization of human mortality which is unveiled by war. Stubbs thinks that Hemingway utilized role-playing as a way to "explore the strengths and weaknesses of his two characters." Stubbs says that by placing Henry 's ordered life in opposition to Catherine 's topsy-turvy one, and then letting each one assume a role which will bring them closer together, Hemingway shows the pair 's inability to accept "the hard, gratuitous quality of life."

Stubbs begins by showing other examples, notably in In Our Time and The Sun Also Rises, in which Hemingway 's characters revert to role-playing in order to escape or retreat from their lives. The ability to create characters who play roles, he says, either to "maintain self-esteem" or to escape, is one Hemingway exploits extraordinarily well in A Farewell to Arms and therefore it "is his richest and most successful handling of human beings trying to come to terms with their vulnerability."

As far as Stubbs is concerned, Hemingway is quite blatant in letting us know that role-playing is what is occurring. He tells that the role-playing begins during Henry and Catherine 's third encounter, when Catherine directly dictates what is spoken by Henry. After this meeting the two become increasingly comfortable with their roles and easily adopt them whenever the other is nearby. This is apparent also in that they can only successfully play their roles when they are in private and any disturbance causes the "game" to be disrupted. The intrusion of the outside world in any form makes their role-playing impossible, as evidenced at the



Bibliography: Bruccoli, Matthew J. and Clark, C.E. Frazer (ed.), Fitzgerald / Hemingway Annual 1973, pp. 271-284, Microcard Editions Books, Washington, D.C., 1974

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Subordinate characters, whose roles are seemingly unimportant, are thermically critical in Richard Connell’s and Eudora Welty’s short story. A subordinate character often either motivates or challenges the protagonist to do something. The subordinate characters from “The Most Dangerous Game” and “A Worn Path” help the reader understand how the protagonist feels and believes. Both stories are similar since their subordinate characters help express the protagonist’s thoughts, mindset, and characteristics.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Moss, Joyce. Wilson, George. “F. Scott Fitzgerald” Literature and It 's Times, 1997 p. 6…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henry first talks of having no affection towards her, only bothering because it’s easier than going to a brothel (Hemingway 30). He eventually falls in love with her however, and they wind up spending his entire hospital stay together. In The Role of Catherine Barkley, the author reports that Jackson Benson describes Catherine as heroic in the way that she “is the one who taught Henry to love.” This might be the case as Henry never discusses past lovers or even much of his family. Catherine and Henry become so much in love her having a child accidently doesn’t even phase him, as long as it doesn’t get in the way of their love of course (Hemingway 138). While in Switzerland, they would rarely go out of their house, and almost never left each other (Hemingway 290). The book ends with the loss of Catherine and their stillborn baby (Hemingway 331). Henry is terrified of this happening and prays that it doesn’t. When it does he leave the hospital and the book is over. This is the final scene of the book and perhaps the most important, as it is the most life…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To build a relationship, one must talk and interact. Krebs feels like women and relationships are “too complicated,” and he does not want to “have to work” to get a girl (Hemingway 71). Since building a relationship will require discussing the truth about the war and his experiences, Krebs refuses to build relationships, and that forces him to become an outsider. His main focus is that “he [doesn’t] want to tell any more lies” (Hemingway 71). To Krebs, women represent growing up because that would force Krebs to be a man and risk being rejected because of the truth. Lying is complicated and child-like just as women are complicated. Life is much simpler as a child. To build a relationship would mean that Krebs has to become a man. Part of being a man involves sharing his experiences of war and that is complicated as well. By ignoring women and refusing to build relationships, he can remain as a child and not have…

    • 3753 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hemingway interestingly uses the character of Brett to reevaluate the gender roles of men and women in the early twentieth century that manly, alcoholic, and emotionally unstable women can still be loved, but by doing this Hemingway reinforces the gender stereotype that…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many scholars have spoken about American expatriates and alcoholism in their reviews with a pessimistic point of view and with negative comments, like Cowley in his writing saying that “The Sun Also Rises is, in fact, a major example of a drunk narrative, in which alcohol is inseparable from the modernist ethos of despair”. However, I’d like to point out that all these critics have been written in the light of each scholars’ period, and that no one asked himself what Hemingway meant when writing about those themes and that precise moment of the…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The concept of heroism in A Farewell to Arms is contested as Hemingway asserted what he defines as the deeds, goals, and the necessity of a hero. Heroism is defined by Hemingway as a character trait which allows the person to abide by a personal code that not only fights for themself, but for those around him. These actions are called into question as the arrogance of other characters, such as Ettore, Bonello, and the engineers, is compared to Henry who seemingly eschewed glory for the sake of protection. This allowed Hemingway to articulate how a hero should act and determine what a hero should base their decisions upon. The gratification of heroism is also put in context as Hemingway challenges what a hero should fight for. Whether they fight for a sense of personal glory and success, or a far more intangible notion, such as happiness. Indeed, Hemingway does define heroism as the ability to abide by a moral code of honour to achieve survival and defend companions in the hope of achieving some form of happiness, a definition made manifest through the protagonist, Frederic Henry. The nature of heroism is not the only theme Hemingway explores here, with the relevance and necessity of bravery in society also up for examination.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Conflicts” among characters in Hemingway’s “Soldier’s Home” helps the reader to understand the main character’s feelings and physical conditions - depression. The story starts with two different pictures showing Krebs before and after joining the army. The author stages the story of Krebs’s inner conflict to the relationship with his family. Indeed, the author leaves a lot of doubts that make the reader believe Krebs had pain of heart broken while in the war. The author does not directly describe the cruelty of war that Krebs experienced; however, through the conflicts among the characters in the story, readers can assume how the post young soldiers had suffered in the war and understand their trauma by the aftermath.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Social Commentary in The Sun Also Rises Thesis: In the post-war novel The Sun Also Rises, Ernest Hemingway presents the disillusionment and cynical world view of the “Lost Generation” through the travels of American and British expatriates living in Europe after World War I. While money, alcohol, and sex act as the driving…

    • 4322 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hemingway alludes to how racism in the 1920’s was; it made Cohn feel the need to defend himself against others who might feel they were racially superior. Cohn learns to box even though he dislikes it, showing how even though he may have started out as a weak character with a continuing sense of inferiority throughout the book, Hemingway still instills a feeling of strength in his person. Jake and his inner circle of friends seem to display the sort of unabashed, uncaring attitude that modern day men display now towards Robert. Throughout the novel, Hemingway sets aside two main differences between all the men; possessive and controlling (to Brett) and “nice” or innocent (Count Mippipopolous, Pedro). Debatably, the signs of jealousy and possessiveness may be considered typical for men, or a part of the strength stereotype (if strength was not equivalent to being emotionally confident of one’s feelings) all of which can be seen in characters such as Jake (unknowingly being homophobic), Mike (being possessive of Brett and not being comfortable with her sexual promiscuity) and even Cohn (being confident that he can win Brett over and refusing to give…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Authors F. Scott Fitzgerald and Ernest Hemingway are both writers of the mid 1920s and mid 1950s. Both evolved from the same literary time and place, but both created their readings in two very different literary styles. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Outside the Cabinet Maker and Ernest Hemingway’s A Day’s Wait are two perfect examples of how their works differ as well as have some similarities. Two distinct similarities that Hemingway’s A Day’s Wait and Fitzgerald’s Outside the cabinet makers have are the way both were written. Some of the differences are the ideas they used for the story line, as well as their literary styles.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    But the criticism extends beyond the damaging affect these expectations have on men and focuses on the even more impossible position it puts women in. Hemingway allows Macomber to fulfill the expectations and as a result attains power and status but Margot is never able to attain both of these of being a man but Margot is never able to fully attain power or status. When Macomber fulfills his role as a man he attains power and status, but his wife is unable to attain both of these. While Macomber does die, he dies a happy man, his wife is left crying and without an…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moore’s ‘How to be an Other Woman’ is written in the second person narration where the author the reader becomes like the main character. Unlike third and first person narration, second person point of view is rarely used as it ‘remains [in] an idiosyncratic and experimental form’ (Burroway, J. 2011 pg. 304). This perspective works by assigning the reader to become the main character and through the use of the pronoun ‘you’, the story is read similarly to an inner monologue or instruction manual. Contrasting the first and third points of view in Updikes ‘A&P’ and Hemingway’s ‘Hills like white elephants’, the reader can’t draw their own conclusions as they are forced into becoming a pre-designed character. Also this particular point of view…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Role Modle

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the four stories covered by this paper, are examples of boys following role models. Some follow good role models and some choose bad ones. In Old Man and the Sea, there is one boy, Manolin and one role model, the old man. The old man is a good role model and Manolin benefits and learn valuable lessons. In Lord of the Flies, there are several boys and several role models, but the two main role models are Jack and Ralph. The boys learn how to do things the right way from Ralph, the good role model, and how to do things the wrong way from Jack, the bad role model. In Of Mice and Men, George, an intelligent and cynical man is the role model. Lennie, a man of limited abilities, is protected by his role model, George. George and Lenny are friends. Their relationship is beneficial to each of them because George is able to protect his friend, Lennie and, Lennie can avoid being abused by other people because he is protected by his role model. In Hamlet, there is no obvious role model. Hamlet shows that people can make decisions without a role model.…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics