Preview

Juveniles Vs Adult Offenders

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
615 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Juveniles Vs Adult Offenders
In contemporary society, there is a debate over whether a separate justice system should exist for juveniles and adults. While some juveniles have demonstrated the need for a separate justice system for juveniles, others have proven otherwise. There are separate justice systems for juvenile and adult offenders because of the belief that the mind of juveniles can be reformed unlike adult offenders. However, the juvenile justice system is similar to the adult justice system in many ways. In terms of the rights of the offenders, both juvenile and adult offenders have the right to an attorney, the right to confront and cross-examine witnesses, the right to protection against self-incrimination, the right to notice of charges, and prosecution needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt …show more content…
Additionally, in both the juvenile and adult justice system, sentencing utilizes offense history and the severity of the crime. The juvenile justice system is distinct than the adult justice system in terms of their purpose, the role of the court, the pre-adjudication programs available, the trial procedures, and the sentencing process used. Unlike the adult justice system whose goal is to punish, the priority of the juvenile justice system is to rehabilitate and reform juvenile offenders. Additionally, the court or state has the right and responsibility to act like the parent for a child if the family is unable to do so through the Parens Patriae doctrine. In the juvenile justice system, juvenile offenders are given a hearing, whereas in the adult justice system, adult offenders are given a trial. Juveniles are prosecuted for committing delinquent acts. Adults are prosecuted for committing crimes. In other words, juveniles can be found to be delinquents while adults can be found innocent or guilty. During a hearing,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    "Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults" is an essay by Laurence Steinberg, which expresses his views of if, when, and why youth offenders should be tried as adults. He compares the juvenile system to the adult system and point out hat the two differ in their respective forms of decision making for treatment or discipline. In the recent past, society has redefined the judicial system for juveniles and is striving to get more youth offenders trued and disciplined in adult jail systems (632). According to Steinberg, "[this] represents a fundamental challenge to the very premise that the juvenile court was founded on - that adolescents and adults are different (632)", and these forms of discipline are detrimental to the rehabilitation of young criminals. The author poses the question of how effective the judicial system is at determining when a child is to be tried as an adult and points out three very distinct characteristics of an adolescent individual between the ages of 12 and 17. First, he states that "there are dramatic changes in individuals' physical, intellectual, emotional, and social capabilities" between these ages (632). Secondly, he claims that between theses ages, individuals that have broken laws are still open to many positive influences that may help them abandon their criminal instincts and tendencies (632). Lastly, he points out that youth offenders who are sentenced to harsh punishments as adolescents often do not recover from the mental harm it causes because it is an important developmental time and these experiences may have lasting and disadvantageous effects on their adult behaviors (632). In a second argument, Steinberg explains that he doesn't believe that the age of a young defendant should be overlooked and, as seen earlier in the essay, uses three main points to illustrate this idea. First, he expresses that the legal system has a set of regulations and customs which differs from the individualistic and informal setting of a juvenile court…

    • 606 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Many in the criminal justice field view deterrence at the juvenile level, from future criminal ideations, as the answer to much of the crime problem. If this tenet is followed then it makes sense to try to deter the unlawful behavior in juveniles before they turn into the next population of adult convicts. Many say that the answer is to give juvenile offenders harsher penalties including the use of adult sanctioning and more punitive practices. Others advocate for treatment and protection from the adversarial nature of the adult system in the spirit of the, not so long ago history of our juvenile…

    • 3319 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the justice system juveniles is quite different from the adults criminal. In the justice system their main objective is to rehabilitate the juvenile while as for adults their objectives are to deter crime and punish the offender. When it comes to juveniles in the justice system issues are developed and questions are raised whether or not juveniles should be adjudicated to the adult court system. When juveniles are adjudicated to the adult court system, there are many issues introduced to the justice system, such as at what age should juveniles be adjudicated to adult court and for which crimes.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Not too long ago the House of Representatives approved “The Juvenile Crime Control Act of 1997” which would greatly increase the number of juveniles convicted and incarcerated in adult facilities. When I was made aware of this I took it upon myself to research juveniles tried as which in turn caused me to question whether juveniles should be tried as adult. Many claim that the age of the juvenile does not matter, if the child is old enough to do the crime they must do the time. On the contrary, I came to find that not only age but mental development in terms of cognitive development, the development of mental maturity and, formulation of personal identity have a lot to do with how the…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Persuasive Paper Part 1

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    From the 1980s to the 1990s there has been a surge in minors who commit violent crimes as shown in a research study conducted by the Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch Currently. The information was based on federal and state correctional data related to race, history and nature of crimes committed by minors. The study showed inmates under the age of 18 in state prisons has more than doubled from 1985-1997. The study also shows that 61% of those minors admitted were convicted of violent offenses1. The Juvenile Court Act was founded in 18992 when the idea of reforming minors took place and the majority of crimes committed by minors were of minor misconduct. The justice systems were separated because adults were treated as criminals and minors were treated for rehabilitation. , created to rehabilitate and protect minors. The courts intended the system to be more informal and treat the juveniles rather than punish them. This system was not developed to undertake the current rise of…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Young, M. C., & Gainsborough, J. (2000). Prosecuting juveniles in adult court: an assessment of trends and consequences. The Sentencing Project, 1-10.…

    • 1525 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trying Juveniles

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Trying juveniles has been a topic to the public we hear about in the judustrial system. It contains a lot of arguments which has its pros and cons. Considering being a juvenile delinquent you must commit a crime that is under the age of 18. Prosecutors can charge juveniles as adults when they are suspected of violent offenses or crime. Back in time when this happened, this treatment involved the death penalty. As of today it involves being prosecuted through adult courts and incarcerated in the adult jails and prisons. Addressing this topic is important because society is not aware what happened or what is happening to juveniles being tried as adults. After reading this paper, you will learn different offenses juveniles commit and why it leads to being tried as adults. You will know how the death penalty came in effect, ended, and the different cases that happened between times. I will talk about juveniles being prosecuted through adult courts and the benefit of it. Also juveniles being incarcerated with adults and the risks they face. My intention of writing this paper is to get you to know the research I gained from it, and hoping it interest you to do more research on it too. Do convicting a juvenile as adults helps stop crime.…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our current criminal justice system frequently places juveniles into adult prisons and until just recently had mandatory life sentences for some juvenile crimes. The much divided Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences were unconstitutional and as a result has sparked vigorous debate as many have joined the conversation regarding how juveniles are treated in prison and if our current system is working. Despite the fierce debate, current science and statistics seems to favor one side over the other. The current United States legal system is clearly flawed as alternative systems are superior, the current system adversely affects juveniles and their chance at rehabilitation, and recent findings on juvenile brain…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Juveniles in Adult Prisons

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The juvenile justice system was conceptualized about a hundred years ago in order to safeguard children from the abuses they were previously subjected to in adult prisons (Schiraldi and Zeidenberg, 1997). Trends indicated that in the traditional system, the children were often returned to society as hardened criminals. A juvenile system was therefore devised for juveniles in order to ensure that they would be housed in centers different from adult offenders…

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Juvenile Justice Reform

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Controversies dealing with juveniles’ age in which they can be charged as adults, giving them life sentences in prison without parole, the application of neuroscience, and the roles both the federal and state governments have played in shaping the policies towards justice reform have been discussed at length for the better half of United States (U.S.) History (755). Dating as far back as 1825, the United States of America has delved into the topic of juvenile justice (755). Today, advocates of the youth and victims’ rights still provide strong interest in criminal justice reform. From lobbying for light sentencing standards for the youth, to making them accountable for their actions, the controversies and arguments towards reforming juvenile…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Juvenile vs. adult criminal system differ in many significant ways and similarities in others. Some of the differences between the two is juveniles are not prosecuted for committing crimes, but rather delinquent acts. When a delinquent offender commits a very serious crime, they maybe tried as an adult. Another significant difference is juveniles do not have a right to a public trial. If a juvenile offender is charged with a crime the trial portion involves the judges hearing the evidence and the ruling. Yes, having a separate system for juvenile and adults is necessary because the main aim for juveniles is to rehabilitate and reform the juvenile offender so they can resume functioning normally society.…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first juvenile court was established in Chicago, Illinois in 1899 when the question presented itself whether or not juvenile offenders should be tried and sentenced differently then adult offenders. (Anderson, 1998) This is one of the reasons that the juvenile system was developed. Legislatures felt that’s the offenders age and maturity level be taken into consideration and that rehabilitation be the main focus of juvenile offenders. Physiatrist offered the facts that during adolescence, the prefrontal cortex, which governs the “executive functions” of reasoning, advanced thought and impulse control is the final area of the human brain to mature. (Beatrice Luna, Ph.D., 2005) The explanation offers the reasoning on why poor decision are made by adolescent, simply because their brain is not fully formed and able to understand to the effect of an adult the acts that they are committing. Mike Brommel, a well-known psychiatrist, stated, “The theory is that as a juvenile, a youth lacks the mental capacity to be guilty of a crime in the same manner as an adult”. It was often said by many social activists, lawmakers, and other officials during the late 1800’s that children institutionalized with adults were learning adult criminal behaviors and were exiting those institutions ready for life careers in criminality. (2004) Although the crimes that a juvenile and adult commit may be the same, the question becomes as to whether or not the crimes were committed to the same caliber.…

    • 701 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, they both try to achieve this goal using different methods. In 2013, Ethan Couch, an American minor who was 16 years old at that year, killed 4 people because he was driving under the influence of alcohol. Ethan was tried in the juvenile court and he was only sentenced ten years’ probation and with no time in jail. The victims’ family members were so frustrated because they said that the justice was not received but other members of society thought that this was a good decision because the main goal of the juvenile court is to rehabilitate not to punish. One year earlier, seventeen-year-old minor named Takunda Mavima was under the influence of alcohol and he crashed his car and killed two passengers and injured two others. He was tried as an adult and he was sentenced to between thirty months to fifteen years in jail despite the fact that he was a role model student in high school [Weston,B. (2016).]. These two examples clearly show the different ways both the criminal justice system and the juvenile justice system try to achieve their goal. Criminal justice system’s main concern is to punish the person who breaks the law and to make sure that he or she gets the right retribution so they don’t come back again in prison. On the other hand, the juvenile justice system was established to treat the lawbreakers rather than punish…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juvenile Crime Paper

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There are some important differences in the juvenile and adult courts, which protect the offenders. When dealing with cases in the juvenile courts the age of the juvenile is taken into consideration, along with the nature of the offense. This protects the juvenile from being tried as an adult if the age, nature of the crime and even the mentality doesn’t warrant that the juvenile be tried as an adult. For example, if a 13 year old juvenile stole a car and went joy riding. They wouldn’t be tried as an adult because they would determine if this was a first offense, and also evaluate the severity of the crime. It would most likely be dealt with in the juvenile courts. Another big difference in the juvenile and adult courts is the terminology, which is used. For juveniles who are brought into court, the terminology refers to the situation as an "act of delinquency". In the adult court the term "crime" is used. The juvenile offender's background is taken into consideration. For instance, the juvenile's academic record and family background are taken into consideration for a case. This doesn’t apply to adults who are presented in front of a judge. This happens that way because we tend to try and protect the children regardless of their actions. Often we as a society feel that putting kids in jail will not make things better, but will then start a long history of criminal actions to come. When dealing with juvenile offenders they are not arrested like adults; instead they are taken into custody. While an adult would be indicted the juvenile has a petition filed against them. In the juvenile court they agree to a finding or deny the petition. Adult offenders must plea, either guilty, not guilty or no contest. In the juvenile court the case can have an adjustment made to it; from that point, the juvenile court will decide if the juvenile offender will remain in a detention facility or childcare shelter. There is a…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fhydy

    • 2476 Words
    • 10 Pages

    • Explain the differences between the adult criminal justice system and the juvenile justice system…

    • 2476 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays