In saying the above, PK deliberately picks on Joe specifically, and by McCabe putting the word ‘creative’ in italics, it shows that PK does not expect Joe to know what it means, when in fact, it is ironic, as PK is his teacher, who is meant to teach him the things he does not understand, Also, Joe uses slang in his poorly worded sentence, to emphasise the contrast between his education in PK’s perfectly formed sentence, playing up to PK’s expectations. Later on in the story, PK makes his attitude towards Joe even clearer, when he says: “‘Empty your mind. In your case Joe, […] that shouldn’t be too difficult.’”
By PK targeting Joe and insulting Joe’s intelligence, it increases the conflict between them. By having Joe as the narrator, we see the situation from his point of view and we see PK as a villain. PK’s attitude towards Joe shows that PK thinks Joe is uneducated and beneath him. It is also quite ironic that PK asks the class to be quiet repeatedly, and then picks on Joe, almost granting him permission to answer back, making the class noisy once again. Further on in the story, while PK is ‘teaching’ the class about ‘creative writing,’ and how to get inspiration, he reveals the cultural divisions in the class in this conversation: “‘Is it ‘The Clash?’’ ‘[…] It is none of that Clash trash.’”
In McCabe writing PK’s response to Joe’s sensible question in a nasty ways, it shows PK’s snobbish attitude towards Joe and that PK does not consider Joe’s music taste appropriate, its portrays PK as a posh man, who looks down his nose at anyone who does not agree with him and his musical preferences. Towards the end of the story, PK makes his plans for the lesson that day clear. “‘Now I’ve got a pile of prelims to mark, so I want you to keep quiet and get on with it.’”
When PK says ‘keep quiet and get on with it,’ it makes it clear he cannot be bothered talking to them anymore; or teaching them. McCabe’s word choice shows that PK has given up with the class, and when he mentions the prelims, it is clear he is more focussed on the other class, who are obviously bright, if they are allowed to do prelims. In Joe’s essay that he writes in class, McCabe uses typography and structure to get across Joe’s message. In the paragraph, Joe uses only capital letters, giving the idea that he does not understand how to write sentences, or that he does not want to conform to the basic rules of writing. He is also playing up to PK’s expectations and more by making his entire essay grammatically incorrect. Sentence structure is well used when Joe tops-and-tails his essay with the phrase: ‘I AM SHEER MENTAL SO WATCH OUT.’
This reveals how he wants people to view him, when in fact, in the middle of the essay, Joe reveals his emotional side when he says: ‘I LOVE HER [his mum],” this is the antithesis of him being ‘sheer mental’. McCabe uses repetition and characterisation in the paragraph, to show how Joe really is as a person. When Joe repeatedly uses the phrase: “‘I HAVE GOT NO […],’” it reveals that Joe realises his poverty and he is terrified at how is life is going to turn out. It shows he knows his situation very well, and he has accepted the fact that he is in a completely different social class to PK. His word choice with this quote shows how little Joe thinks of himself and his possessions, and it reveals how tough Joe’s exterior is, in spite of his situation, which makes the reader pity Joe. In this short story, ‘Kreativ Riting’, Brian McCabe shows conflict between a rebel student and his snobbish teacher PK. This essay discussed how McCabe reveals the educational, cultural and social class divisions in the class using characterisation, word choice, and typography.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
When the author gives insight on Scouts school life, It makes sense to me because she is rather wealthy and been around intelligence. So yeah, that’s probably why her teacher is mad because she cant teach this kid because she probably already knew it.…
- 163 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Melissa Duffy’s essay titled, “Inspiration” is an excellent example of how an individual’s attitude toward a certain subject, in this case, writing, influences the way the preform. As I read, it dawned on me that the approach our teacher take in teaching us have an immense impact on our attitude towards it. Duffy tells her story of “Inspiration” in a periodical format to lay out the moments in time that shaped her as a writer.…
- 398 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
It shows how the teachers interact with students, and how students react with the teachers. In that meager setting at Oakcity High School with Mr. Bartlett, he doesn’t cater to students needs. He does things in a strict basic formatted setting because “...on any job they get outside of school, there’s going to be a certain formats they must follow to be successful on the job. McDonald’s, there’s a certain way of frying French fries. There’s a certain was of customer service. They have to learn that format”.(pg. 661) He feels as though his students are unable to comprehend those in depth discussions. He teaches basic ideals and principals, then tests students on them. He also feels that all of his students are “somewhat on the same level”(pg. 661). His basic teaching format of “read a section, complete the section handout, take section quiz, repeat daily for five days, take chapter test Friday”(pg. 662) is completely unacceptable and demoralizes students. One student, Monique says “I want to go to college, but... if this is boring here I’m going to be bored in college”. This apathy towards students highly affects them…
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Blue made sure to see that the students were receiving positive feedback. When each of the students entered the room, they retrieved their binders and all sat down quietly. Each of the students were very respectful to each other in that whenever someone raised their hand to speak, they were the only ones who spoke. There was no character development program or a posted set of rules displayed in her classroom. In her classroom she did the majority of the talking while the students listened and answered her questions. In the high school classroom, there was quite a bit of talking and disruption among the students in the beginning. There were many students who were up and walking around while he was discussing the homework. There was no character development in the classroom. Mr. G didn’t seem tell really be listening to his students, one student had to repeat his question three times. Each teacher provided a way to show respect and understanding to their students, and then the other showed a class room that didn’t have much respect for each…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
While the class was writing a paper, Howe was enjoying an idly moment at his desk, when suddenly a boy at the door way interrupts the class. The boy wanted to know if he had the right room for the English 1A class. Howe nodded to him and the boy stopped before Howe and said, “I am Tertan, Ferdinand R., reporting at the direction of head of Department Vincent” (273). The introduction brought fourth a mocking cheer from the class, and “Howe looked at the class with a sternness he could not really feel, for there was indeed something ridiculous about this boy” (273). Here Howe is irritated at the…
- 958 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The first few weeks were focused on learning about each class mate as well as learning about different audiences for different situations. An assignment that was assigned to the class was that everyone needed to get on the internet and research about people that were affected by different horrible situations, such as drugs, alcohol, women that worked “the corner” for money and many other reasons. While looking through the pictures of each person, we were to right a short summary about a person that was interesting. One person that stood out is “Takeesha 3- is a prostitute and is a mother and she is happy with the way things are she says it is what it is” (DeShazo #10) This woman stated that she knew what she had done and was really okay with the way it was. Also, another assignment completely opposite of this assignment was “Fish Cheeks.” This is a story written by Amy Tan about a girl that is Chinese and has a crush on an American boy and is ashamed of her culture. An example is “Because she is the opposite of him and does not know what he will think of her family.” (DeShazo #1 Fish Cheeks) This girl was ashamed of her culture and soon realized after the dinner was over that her mother was trying to make things better for her by cooking…
- 937 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Sherman Alexie constructed a short fiction story related to the “telling stories” section in the Norton Eleventh edition. In his story, a main theme presents itself. The main theme presented in the story is that of general stereotyping. General stereotyping clearly identifies itself when William, the taxi rider, states “No, not jewel-on-the-forehead Indian” (Alexie 62). Constructing an essay related to the most obvious theme would defeat the purpose of experiencing literature differently. Every reader experiences a piece of literature differently. What a reader takes during or before reading a piece of literature directly relates to the culture they experienced growing up. Everybody is engrained with a unique thinking process. Every reader will perceive a piece of literature differently due to the unique engrained thinking process. A major aspect that causes each person to perceive things differently directly relates to the culture one experiences while growing up. The theme I perceived, the challenges of cross-culturing, provides another way of…
- 1566 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
When Joe is first introduced to the readers on page 8, he is perceived immediately as having a calm, easy going attitude. Even though they are not related by blood, Joe treats Pip as part of his own family. It’s fortunate that Pip was able to have Joe in his life as he grew up and not just his sister. Joe’s calm demeanor is the exact opposite of Mrs. Joe’s short tempered nature and because of this Pip was able to have somebody to converse with and tell secrets to. In the novel, whenever Pip has an issue, he knows that he can talk to Joe about it. Joe will not…
- 388 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Arnold’s relationship with Mr. P started violently, but as they opened up to each other, Mr. P was able to give Arnold hope; this makes Mr. P arguably the most important mentor. Remarkably, Mr. P was able to become a mentor because of this. In the beginning of the book, Arnold finds his mother's name written in his geometry textbook. Infuriated that the school has books from when his mother was a kid, Arnold throws the textbook at Mr. P. As a result, Arnold is suspended from school and Mr. P comes to visit Arnold at his home. Out of the blue, Mr. P confesses to Arnold that he should be the one apologizing because he has hurt so many Indian kids over his years of teaching; he can’t apologize to them so he apologizes to Arnold. Mr. P tells…
- 1022 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The Lesson is a short story written by the writer Toni Cade Bambara in the late 1970’s. Sylvia, the narrator of the story is a young African-American female who receives a lesson in class inequality. The setting story of begin the slums of Harlem, New York and is dated as “back in the days” which is described in the opening of the story. Throughout the story Sylvia, realizes its world outside of her neighborhood, not as similar has she once thought. I chose the article, “Sylvia and The Struggle against Class Consciousness in Toni Cade Bambara's "The Lesson” this article analyzes the Sarah Wiktorski writes the article and she analyzes the struggle against class-consciousness and sets the mind of the reader to think about some of the consequences of class-consciousness. It contributes to the study of literature because it helps us understand the book, “The consciousness” by Toni Bambara changes the way the reader thinks and attempts to re-conceptualize his or her understanding of representation of class-consciousness. The writer hopes to present to the world a real picture of disadvantaged minorities and shows how on should change the world and…
- 1199 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
A writer is an artist who communicates particular ideas through text.(Wikipedia) Sometimes, there is more behind the text rather than the text itself. Behind every piece of writing there is some sort of inspiration or reasoning as to why a writer wants to express a particular topic. There are many different reasons as to why writers decide to pick up their pen, typewriter, or computer and write. Some may have a specific assignment they need to complete and others may just write just to express their thoughts and theories. Throughout this course, we have read and analyzed numerous articles and essays describing different out looks on race, gender, and class. What…
- 1865 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
The next three years of middle school could bring nothing but positivity and joy to my reading and writing career. I was indulging myself in interesting books, like Animal Farm and The Stranger and Maniac Magee. I did nothing less than expected, I succeeded in my English language art and writing classes. I felt great. I loved to read and write so, I decided to take my love for the arts to a different height- I joined a creative writing club. My middle school creative writing club was so fresh and new. It was headed by two creative writing majors from Howard University. They were interning for class credit and they were something like my new heroes. They introduced us to free write poetry and shared their own. They weren’t just creative in writing but the arts and other fanciful things that made me interested in not only writing arts but other arts as well. I was intrigued with the different forms of writing they exposed us to. The club in all taught me about poetry and free writes and scripts and dialogue too. As a group we wrote plays, long verse poems and just stories to express how we felt. Sometimes we even acted out our writings.…
- 474 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The school was a dull, conservative place where tradition, education and reputation were put before creativity and dreams. Mr Keating, a new English teacher came to the school and changed that. He taught the students to express themselves, suck the marrow out of life and to seize the day. Mr Keating did not force his students to do anything, he left their choices up to them and let them do what they wanted. Keating's only wish was for his students to live fun, enjoyable incredible lives.…
- 707 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There is a scene in The Horse and His Boy, one of C. S. Lewis’ Narnia chronicles, in which the fugitive, Aravis, explains why she fled her homeland. As she begins, she switches to a style of speaking that is florid, poetic and quite captivating – for in her country, children are taught how to tell stories, just like English children are taught how to write essays. “The difference”, Lewis tells us, “is that people want to hear the stories, whereas I never heard of anyone who wanted to read the essays.”It is hard to disagree with Lewis that, as a medium for communicating ideas, the traditional student essay is fundamentally unexciting. One issue is the requirement for “formal” language at all times – even though academic writers who succeed in engaging with their readers often do so by writing texts that are lively, enthusiastic and frequently irreverent, encompassing the odd anecdote, colloquialism and venture into the personal.…
- 664 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Principle Higgins slowly guides me to Mrs. Lewis's classroom. I come in the classroom noticing everyone’s staring at me, Principle Higgins says with a booming voice ”6th graders today you're going to being taught by Mr. Johnson!”, I see principle higgins walking out of the classroom as if he wasn’t leaving to someone else's job.…
- 286 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays