In Anton Chekov’s “The Lady with the Dog”, Chekov uses direct language along with slight descriptions to dictate the setting. However, the main purpose for the settings of Yalta and Moscow are to influence Gurov’s motives and feelings. The atmosphere that Gurov is open to is infectious. The locations of Yalta and Moscow represent two different ideologies in Gurov’s life. Yalta expands on the mischievousness and romantic aspects of Gurov while in Moscow the boring and mundane life of Gurov is exhibited. The location called S. is brief, but also entails a rebellious attitude. The plot overall is pushed forward by the chronological change in venue.…
This article was published in The Explicator. In the article, Levitt from the University of Colorado in Boulder, examines the similarities between Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby and Anton Chekhov’s novel The Lady with A Dog. The author of the article supposes that Fitzgerald, who was intricately familiar with Chekhov’s work, may have used The Lady with A Dog as a template for his novel. The Explicator is a journal for literary criticism. It has been in publication since 1942 by Routledge, an academic publisher based in the United Kingdom. Today, Routledge is considered to be one of the world's leading publishers in the field of humanities. While the main subject of the article, the comparison between the two novels, is not a part of my chosen…
Dmitri ventures to the city of S- and ends up in the theater, watching a performance called “The Geisha.” “The theater was full. As in all provincial theaters, there was a fog above the chandelier, the gallery was noisy and restless;” (Chekhov 174). This setting was busy and dramatic. There is lots of people coming in, it’s hard to keep track of everyone. In this big theater the mood is mysterious, giving Dmitri an opportunity to get a moment alone with Anna.…
This brings us back to the incident with Anatole. Anatole first meets Natasha at the opera and soon a “courtship” of sorts begins. Regardless of her engagement to Prince Andrei, Natasha begins to fall in love with Anatole Kuragin. She tries to reassure herself by saying, “So she knows I’m betrothed, so she and her husband, Pierre, the upright Pierre, have talked and laughed about it. So it’s nothing at all” (Tolstoy 571). But, she begins to feel that she is even more in love with Anatole Kuragin than she ever was with Boris, Denisov, or even Andrei. “Natasha feels a ‘sensation she had not experienced for a long time’ that eventually leads to a ‘state of intoxication’” (Lattin). Together, the two plan an elopement. Despite the fact that Anatole is already married, he…
“Still I say that a man who stakes his whole life on a woman’s love and, when that one card gets beaten, turns sour and sinks to the point where he’s incapable of doing anything at all, then that person is no longer a man, not even a male of the species.” (Turgenev 27). Bazarov makes his view of love very clear in this scene and also seems to foreshadow his demise. He says that someone who gives up everything after failing in the game of love, is weak. This would be an obvious notion from Bazarov since a nihilist has no respect for anyone or anything. Ironically, Bazarov clearly explains exactly what ends up happening to him in the story. He is the card that is beaten by Anna Sergeevna when she does not tell him whether or not she shares the same feelings as him, when he expresses his love for her. He tries to hide his sadness and frustration by engaging in a romantic manner with Fenichka Nikolayevna, the servant who becomes Nikolai Petrovich Kirsanov’s wife at the end. When this fails as well, Bazarov knows he can no longer hide his feelings and need to love and appears to be a changed…
Marya eventually meets and falls in love with Nikolai. At a key moment in their relationship, Marya perceives his inner struggles and directly addresses them. Doing so jolts Nikolai out of his cynical stupor, and “For a few seconds they looked silently into each other’s eyes, and the distant and impossible suddenly became near, possible, and inevitable” (1144). In all of this, we see how Tolstoy develops Marya into a strong and capable woman. Her relationship to her father, does not define her development as a woman and as her own person.…
In Colonel Chabert, author Honore de Balzac describes the twisted marriage between the Colonel and his ex-wife; despite the fact that she married Chabert, his wife never actually loved him. After the Colonel goes to war and is pronounced dead, his wife moves on to marry another man even though she knows he is still alive. On page 33 the Colonel says, “She knows that I am alive; since my return she has received two letters written in my own hand. She does not love me anymore” (Balzac 33). Another statement made by Chabert, “Monsieur, the Countess Ferraud is my wife! She posses 30,000 pounds that belongs to me, and she won’t give me a sou” (Balzac 26) is further evidence that his wife never loved the Colonel but rather married him for his money and military status. If she actually did love him she would have given him enough money to live comfortably after she found out he actually survived the war. Nobody enjoys seeing somebody whom they truly love suffer, and if the love is strong enough they will do whatever is necessary to help that person. However, the…
“The Lady with the Pet Dog “, written by Joyce Carol Oates, is the story that I personally liked better then Anton Chekhov’s interpretation more because it presents a more modern the theme of the love affair between two people. The story presents a unique account contrast to the other version and the secret relationship between a man and a woman who are trapped by marriage that they feel unhappy about. I reason like this one more is because I like the way Oates shows the forbidden love in the eyes of a female protagonist since they show a different side of love that I am not use to seeing since I am a male. This story grabbed my attention due to the more modern type since it was easier to understand her actions and emotions which I like…
Throughout his life, Ivan was convinced that a successful life was measured by adapting to, and meeting, the expectations of the bourgeois society in which he lived. Tolstoy described the standards that the society expected one to adhere to as “proper” and “decorous”. Ivan pursued those standards with blind ignorance much “as a moth is to light” (44). Rather than looking to his inner self, developing his own set of values and living a moral life according to those values, Ivan lived a hollow life detached from emotional ties, always doing what he thought others would accept as being the right conduct. His interpersonal relationships, including his marriage, were perfunctory and served merely to advance his social status or promote his own agenda. As a result, the relationships were superficial, self-serving, and materialistic and towards the end of his life, resulted in Ivan being isolated, terrified and in great despair at a time when he needed compassion and true friendship the most. Ivan did not realize until his death was imminent that in order to live a fulfilled and right life, he should have shunned material things and superficial relationships, and instead, he should have embraced love, compassion, and spirituality throughout his…
In these two stories the account of what takes place is told from opposing sides of the relationship. In Chekov 's version of "The Lady with the Pet Dog," the story is told from the perspective of the male side of the couple. Dmitry Dmitrich Gurov is a forty-year-old banker who lives in Moscow along with his wife, daughter and two sons. His major internal conflict in this tale is that he has never been able to make a legitimate connection with someone of the opposite sex and considers women " the inferior race" (Chekhov 102). He cannot find any emotional worth in his interactions with other people, and most specifically in this story, women.…
Another way that Oates's version of the story differs for Chekhov's version is the subtext from “Anna’s” perspective is completely different. While Chekhov's character discovers real love for another human being for the first time in his life, and experiences the ultimate sacrifice that involves it, Oates's protagonist begins to love herself for the first time. Gurov's love is about his partner, but Oates's "Anna" takes her back to self.…
The way Katerina Ivanovna reacts to her husband’s death enlightens her persona; she cares deeply for him or at the very least holds a caring heart when she does not refuse him in her home. Although she alleged she was glad he died her actions betray her because she forces everyone to leave her husband alone so that his death may be respected. Moreover Katerina sends Polia to search for Sonia so that her husband can see her one last time. She cares about her husband but also cannot forget that he has hurt her and her family.…
The author used description to reveal a general picture about Gurov. Referring women as "the inferior race" but "he could not have lived without "the inferior rate"" (Yarmolinsky, 776) either. Women are essential to his life but it is wonder that he has ever loved any of them. These details suggest that he might not be a suitable man for marriage. As mentioned, Gurov was a dynamic character; indeed, his change was a major fact for the story. Gurov's feeling toward Anna changed before and after she left. Although not many descriptions depicted how he felt about the relationship, a very important detail reveals his thinking. " Gurov cut himself a slice and began eating it without haste" while Anna was so anxious. In this, the characters' gesture or attitude enabled the readers to learn about them. Gurov was so "cold" and neglectful toward Anna and thus to him she was not different from the other women he had met. However, his feeling started changing when he got back to Moscow. Using description and dialogue the author reveal the change in Gurov. "And only from time to time he would dream of her with her touching smile as he dreamed of others" (Yarmolinsky, 782). The way the author described Gurov show the readers how deep he was fascinated about Anna; "Already he was tormented by a strong desire to share his memories with…
Many people have an excuse that people believe justifies those actions. As stated in the survey above men and women often cheated because they were emotionally invested in another. Dmitry’s unhappiness, which leads to him cheating, is justified in the sense that his wife has drove him away, which he describes “She read a great deal, used simplified spelling in her letters, called her husband, not Dmitry, but Dimitry, while he privately considered her of limited intelligence, narrow-minded, dowdy, was afraid of her, and did not like to be at home” (Chekhov 235). Not only did Chekhov justify Dmitry’s reasons for cheating, but he also gives Anna reason to cheat as she describes her husband in a boring manner. As the audience we then feel bad for Anna and Gurov and see it as something good, since they are happy together, although it is still very…
In Chekhov's short story, "The Lady with a Dog," components of the setting, such as location, nature, time, and season, encourages the characters Anna and Dmitri to entertain their affair with a unattainable relationship and charming illusion. In the beginning of the story, the character Dmitri Gurov had been on vacation in Yalta when he hears of the arrival of a mysterious lady with a dog. Within the first paragraph, readers are presented a location contributes to setting up the theme dreamy self delusion. Yalta, a resort…