Preview

Limitations Of Libertarianism

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1424 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Limitations Of Libertarianism
One of the most debated topics by philosophers in history is the meaning and limitations of free will. After analyzing through a number of philosopher’s position, I believe the most plausible explanation of free will would be the following: there are events in life that we could control, but there are always some limitations on how far our free will can take us. In essence, I believe that there is “free will” in this world, but with an asterisk. This adjusted free will theorem is something that could be seen in Saint Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologica and in Roderick M. Chisholm’s Human Freedom and the Self. Both of these philosophers build upon each other when it comes to the topic of free will. This could be seen with Aquinas, where he would …show more content…
Chisholm in Human Freedom and the Self makes the most sense out of the three major ideas of free will, which are Libertarianism, Hard Determinism, and Compatibilism. The basis of libertarianism is as follows: determinism is proven to be false and human possess the freedom required for moral responsibility. This could be seen with the following excerpt from the respective article: “…at least one of the events that are involved in the that is caused, not by any other events, but by something else instead…and this something else can only be the agent—the man.” (Chisholm 421) Based on this insight that Chisholm is making, he makes it such that there is responsibility present for human being. This is based on the two types of causation found in his article, transient and immanent causation. Transient causation is created “when one event or state or affair (or set of events or states or affairs) causes some other event or state or affair”. In contrast, immanent causation is “when an agent, as distinguished from an event, causes an event or state of affairs…” (Chisholm, 421) Combining these findings, Chisholm is trying to say that humans only have moral responsibility in the events that are caused by themselves rather than all events in a chain. For examining Chisholm’s ideas, we will consider this situation: person A opens the window to let in some “fresh air” and the “fresh air” outside blows some tree leaves into the room that person A is currently in. In this situation, the immanent causation would be the “fresh air” blowing in the tree leaves and the window letting in the “fresh air” because these are all some type of event that causes another event. On the other side, person A opening the window would be the transient causation because the opening of the window occurred because of person A. In essence, the moral responsibility of creating this series of event would

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Essentially, free will is the ability to act without constraint; however, Tierney asserts that there’s…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Free will, by definition, is having the ability or power to act without regard to limitations and at the individuals own discretion.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stan Lee, creator of many of the Marvel movies, once said, “With great power there must also come… great responsibility.” Free will is like a great power that has been given to us. It can be used for good and evil. As humans, we believe that we have a choice in everything. Thus the idea of free will. But because of that choice there will always be a downside to free will.…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In “Thought Experiments” from Scientific America in November 2011, Joshua Knobe evaluates a number of scientific experiments on the nature of free will conducted by experimental philosophers. Knobe analyses studies of how a person feels and thinks, a very insightful question in philosophy, to get a better understanding of peoples beliefs in free will and how people views can be relative or…if a person can be morally responsible under circumstances.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Frankfurt, H. G. (1971, January 14). Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person. The Journal of Philosophy, 5-20.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once again, the passage that resonated with me was Wheelan's discussion of behavioral economics. At the end of the chapter, Wheelan explains the notion of "libertarian paternalism," which generally means that although you may make mistakes, society won't force you to adapt your behavior to fit their ideals, but will instead point you in the right direction. I found this discussion interesting because it described the passive acceptance of decisions that is becoming more and more common when enacting change requires proactive effort. Some of Wheelman's examples included insurance coverage, retirement savings, and presumed consent for organ donations. When I feel that I don't grasp a situation or concept completely I'm prone to fall into this…

    • 193 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The debate between freewill and determinism stems from the apparent conflict between the universal rule of causality that is deeply rooted in nature, and between the apparent ability of human beings to choose between multiple courses of action in order to lead to the most desirable outcome. The universal rule of causality simply claims that inorganic matter such as tables, chairs and rocks are acted upon by whatever forces affect it, however, human beings seem to be an exception to this rule by their unique ability to ponder about how to go about making decisions in their life and which…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gary Gutting, the author of the article, What Makes Free Will Free? deliberates that we do not have free choice as we assumed which a researcher confirmed. By free choice, this means the conviction that our conduct is dictated by our own unrestrained choice and that we have complete power over our activities. Also, Gary Gutting examined various thoughts on determinism as the researchers suggested. Determinism refers to the conviction that all human conduct or any other occurrences have a cause. This is opposed to a person's will to accomplish an action. Gary Gutting discussed what David Hume, a philosopher, believed and the belief of David Hume is that both determinism and free choice are possible, they are compatible with each…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This essay will discuss if freewill is compatible with determinism. The concepts surrounding free will and determinism will be examined. The concepts are: incompatibalism, compatibalism, moral responsibility and libertarianism. Each concept has sub categories falling under the titles of hard or soft depending on the views. I will argue that freewill is compatible with determinism as there are certain things that are determined by physical process’s stemming from the formation of the universe resulting in the formation of the “laws of nature.”…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The political scope of the 1910s also defined the growth of German nationalism and military power, which began to become realized in potential invasions of Belgium and the Austria-Hungary territorial disputes. Of course, the rise of German industrialization had allowed the formation of a world-class naval fleet, and the continued threat of military power in Germany throughout Europe. By this time, Wilhelm II was able to act as a more aggressive political figure in the quest to gain territorial expansion into Hungary and Belgium. This type of political hostility defined the underlying fears of British and France concerns about an invasion. The military might of Germany was not a major part of the political tensions surrounding the assassination…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Free will: the philosophical assumption that individuals can dictate their own lives free of any social constraint or external factors.…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I would lean more towards the compatibilist view stating, unless I am the cause of my actions I am not responsible for them. As compatibilist holds that free will and determinism are compatible, we can properly understand what it means for our actions to be free so we see that a free action is doing what one wants. Believing in compatibilism doesn't mean the determinist view is false, but if it is true, we can still have free will. I believe that we make decisions based on our own desires and beliefs. It is said that compatibilists attempt to revise and weaken the commonsense notion of free will. Thomas Hobbes was the first person to articulate a compatibilist position believing that although the person is free to act on their motive, the motive is determined. In other words, he says “Everything we choose to do is strictly determined by the need to relieve the physical pressures of our bodies. Humans…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I personally believe that we as human beings are given free will. For instance, lets say there is an all omniscient God and lets say he knows what we will do and what our destiny is but he sends you a problem to over come such as,…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arguments about free will are mostly semantic arguments about definitions. Most experts who deny free will are arguing against peculiar, unscientific versions of the idea, such as that free will means that causality is not involved. These arguments leave untouched the meaning of free will that most people understand which is consciously making choices about what to do in the absence of external coercion, and accepting responsibility for one’s actions. Hardly anyone denies that people engage in logical reasoning and self-control to make…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Society is built off of the system “you get what you work for “, which is what Libertarian theory: Theory of both Access and Allocation represents. When you choose to start rationing healthcare resources you start to take away people’s liberty and freedom. Liberty and Freedom is what America is built on and if we start to ration healthcare resources people will no longer have a say in what they get no matter how much they are contributing like Capabilities theory: Theory of Allocation states.…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics