Preview

Lysistrata and The Importance of Being Ernest comparative essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1012 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Lysistrata and The Importance of Being Ernest comparative essay
Lysistrata is a play that was set in Athens between 410 and 412 BC. At the time the play was set, women were expected to have no rights in society, and were not allowed/expected to discuss their opinions in matters subjective to men only. Women also had to obey their husbands at all time, and accept any demands made by their husband. The Importance of Being Ernest (TIOBE) was set during the Victorian Era, and at this time, the way women were expected to behave was similar to that of Lysistrata. And men were expected to be committed, and had a strict set of rules to follow when trying to address a woman. However, in Lysistrata, the female characters (mainly Lysistrata and Myrrhine) are seen to break all the rules and norms expected of a woman as they rebel against the men by refusing to have sex with them in order to stop the civil war in Greece. In TIOBE, the female characters show glimpse of following the Victorian ideals of womanhood; whilst the male characters are seen to not follow the rules as much. Both the plays involve characters of the upper middle class and upper class; therefore the targeted audience will also be of upper and middle class people.

Firstly, in Lysistrata the male characters do not play a significant role, and rarely appear. But in the scenes that involves the male characters, they are either seen discussing political issues, or desperate for sex. For example: the scene of Myrrhine’s seduction. Cinesias is seen as desperate for sex as he is “stiff with desire”. The word stiff is used to describe Cinesias’s penis, which shows his sexual desires and how desperate he is for sex. This also shows that he is unable to control his sexual temptations, while Myrrhine is able to; further revealing that men were weak. The quote: “won’t you please come?” proves this as Cinesias is shown pleading for sex.

The men in TIOBE play a more dominant role in the play, although they do not fully reflect on the ideals of Victorian manhood. For example,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the play, Lysistrata, the women of Athens learn of Lysistrata’s plan to withhold sex in an effort to bring her husband back from war. The Athenian women decide to unite and implement Lysistrata’s plan in an effort to regain their own husbands and sons. In Aristophanes’ work he demonstrates his view of women as being cunning and resourceful beings yet at the same time comedic without even trying: The women make meeting to conspire plans, the women make themselves luscious to attract the males of the community, and the women work together as one to achieve a common goal. The Athenian women are seen by the males of the Greek society as stay at home mothers: cooking, cleaning, and offering sex. The stay at home mother is not considered to possess the…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    that, instead of showing how men were seen as superior in the 19th century, the play…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A modern day audience would also be surprised about the equality between men and women. Men were seen as dominant leaders who were expected to support the family and respect women. They were expected to sometimes experience drinking/sex but this was to remain chaste. We can see this from the play when Eric’s drinking problem was brought up and Mr Birling said ‘We do not need to know about this.’…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lysistrata's Boycott

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lysistrata’s plan was successful because the men were driven by sex and it eventually caused them to reach an agreement with the women. The hardest objective for Lysistrata was convincing the women to agree to remain abstinence. Lysistrata wants the women to step out of their comfort zone as women to help end the Peloponnesian war in Greece. Lysistrata seems to be the only woman who understands the big picture of her plan.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    An Ideal Husband Analysis

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Different characters in the play have taken different roles that bring out a clear picture of the position of women, for example, the conversation between Sir. Robert and Mrs. Cheveley when the former asks the latter if science can come to grips with the problems of women; this sets the implication that women are very much complex. Despite the fact that the majority of male characters have problems with women, most women as well have issues with men. A number of them have disagreements with their husbands, and they suggest that men need education although they are not sure of the men’s capacity to…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lysistrata Gender Roles

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Kleonike and Lysistrata look at the other women as sex objects. The women look to see how difficult it will be for a man to resist each woman. Lysistrata is ultimately the most masculine woman in the play. She, unlike the other females who attempt to escape the treasury to find their husbands, is able to fully ignore and reject her own attraction to males. In this way, Lysistrata stands outside of the action of the other females of the play and works hardest to reject the fragility and frivolity that characterizes the other women. Lysistrata's dual ability to reject her own sexuality while exploiting others enables her to create peace in Greece by keeping the men home away from war and to end…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Counter examples are used throughout this play, and is a key role in the parody of the play. On both male and female sides of the dynamics in the play the first one is right from the start. “the streets are absolutely clogged with frantic females banging on tambourines. No urging for an orgy!” (727) In the “Classical Age” of Athens upperclass women assumed the role of a housewife, where their duties were to either clean up the house or organize the slaves of the house to do it for them. It was unheard of for women to be out in the streets like this period much less at night. The women of Athens formed together to plot against the men to bring them home from the war. As the women were gathering to plan against the men, Lysistrata said, “I'm on fire right down to the bone. I'm positively ashamed to be a woman—a member of a sex which can't even live up to male slanders! To hear our husbands talk, we're sly: deceitful, always plotting, monsters of intrigue...”(728) this quote makes me laugh, because while she is saying this her and multiple women are plotting a way to get back at the men. This quote plays off the stereotype that a woman is always out to make a mans life miserable in everything they do, but this is exactly the thing they are trying to do. While the women are out in the streets they continue to show how ridiculous they are when they are complaining on how much they do for their men. This quote by Kleonike is a prime example, “They'll be here. You know a woman's way is hard mainly the way out of the house: fuss over hubby, wake the maid up, put the baby down, bathe him, feed him...” (728) Kleonike goes on and on about how much work they have to do, but she mentions that she gets up the maid, which does the work for her. This quote plays of the stereotype that women do a lot of house work, but in the play they have maids so obviously they are not doing too much.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lysistrata

    • 313 Words
    • 1 Page

    In Lysistrata, Aristophanes makes fun of women, but he also makes fun of his own sex: men. Kinesias, Myrrhine`s husband, is one of many targets of the women's sex strike. In the scene between Myrrhine and her husband, Kinesias is fooled and tricked by his wife (Episode, p.199-203). As how many of the women of Greece embody the idealized or stereotypical female, as so Kinesias represents the stereotypical, dimwitted male figure in this play. In Lysistrata, Kinesias proves himself as a foolish, poor father and woman-hater, I think. Kinesias only seeks out his wife because he has a painful erection. And also he is not able to take care of his own children. In that part of the scene where he talks to his wife he says: “Don`t you feel sorry for the baby, unwashed and unsuckled for six days now?” (lines 58-59), by that he makes her to come out for “him”. So, he is even using the little kid, in order to get what he needs. But he gets outwitted by his playful wife anyways; humor that was used here by the author, for both husband and wife, was really on point. However, the part when he shouts out: “It`s not a blanket I want – I want to fuck!” (line 122), made me feel uncomfortable: so straight forward. After, when he can`t get what he wants, he prays to Zeus saying: “…let her fall back down to earth again, and let her point of impact be this dick of mine right here” (lines 171-174). It is funny, but also really sad; all he wants is just to have sex with her. Kinesias's character confirms that Aristophanes meant Lysistrata to be a play mocking the sexual desires and attributes of both sexes.…

    • 313 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lysistrata Research Paper

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages

    To remedy this situation, Lysistrata told the women about her plan. “Well then, we must abstain utterly from the prick,” she tells them (Aristophanes 193, ln.121). In other words, she is telling the women to follow her and have a sex strike because, of how much it would impact the women’s husbands. Lysistrata tells them that she knows that the men will eventually give up when she says, “If we should sit around, rouged with skins well creamed, with nothing on but a transparent negligee, and come up to them with our deltas plucked quite smooth, and, once our men get stiff and want to come to grips, we do not yield to them at all but just hold off, they’ll make a truce in no time. There’s no doubt of that,” (193, ln. 148- 152). This mean that if they weren’t gettin sex, then would surely follow their wives orders in order to have sex again. In addition, the women would also go take over the Acropolis so, these soldiers wouldn’t be receiving any more money to continue fighting. Lysistrata tells Lampito not to worry about the…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lysistrata Gender Roles

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Athens terrible war with Sparta has been going on for years and Lysistrata, a middle-class housewife from Athens, organized a meeting with women from Athens and other cities, including Sparta, that the women should all refuse to have sex with their husbands until their husbands end the ridiculous war. After convincing the women, Lysistrata also explains that she's sent women to occupy the Acropolis, the government center of Athens, therefor hoping to gain control of the treasury, and be able to cut off the money supply for the war. The women swear an oath that they will follow Lysistratas’ plan, and the women join together at the Acropolis. The Chorus of Men met them there from Athenian, chorus referring to “a group” in the play who advise one another, they have come with fire to smoke the women out of the Acropolis; however, the Chorus of Women shows up carrying buckets of water. After the Women's Leader drenches the Men's Leader, the group of men leave embarrassed, showing the first bit of power that the woman obtained over the men. Lysistrata then emerges from the Acropolis to complain that she is worried that the women are all going against the oath, and trying to have sex with their husbands. This is a huge conflict because the women need to stick together, and fight together against the men if they wanted any change. An…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Blackrock Essay

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The theme of masculinity is prominent throughout the play. Physical strength and other male attitudes are revealed The audience are positioned to respond to the theme…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The literature of this sort of masculine society, of which the Iliad and Odyssey are examples, aptly illustrates these social conventions. The themes of these works are subjects which are of interest to men; warfare, hunting, the problems of the warrior and ruler, and so forth. That which would concern women, such as domestic affairs, is not involved in this literature, or is dealt with only casually. Keeping in mind this important attribute of epic poetry, which is the direct result of its social and intellectual environment, one cannot help noting the great difference between the Odyssey and all other epic poems. No other literary work of this period, or of a similar cultural background, gives such a prominent position to women. No reader of the Odyssey can help having vivid memories of the poem’s outstanding female characters. There are many women in the Odyssey and all of them contribute in mean-ingful ways to the development of the action. Furthermore, they are treated seriously and with respect by the poet, as if there were no difference between his attitude toward them and his feelings toward the chieftains for whom his epic was composed. Among the memorable women in the poem are Nausicaa, the innocent young maiden; Arete, the wise and benevolent queen and mother; Circe and Calypso, the sultry and mysterious temptresses; Penelope, the ideal of marital devotion and fidelity; Helen, the respectable middle-class matron…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women have more rights and freedoms in today's society than in previous eras. The lines between social classes are more relaxed, expectations have been lowered, and a woman speaking out has become more accepted. Today, women are allowed to do whatever men are. This, however, was not always the case. Take, for example, William Shakespeare's play Othello. There are two main female characters in the play: Desdemona, Othello's wife; and Emilia, Iago's wife. Both of these women fit into a certain social category from the time, each category with its own specific expectations and requirements. Throughout Othello, whether or not these women take action to break through the societal expectations has a great effect on their ends.…

    • 2956 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    So naturally, in Sophocles’ play, “Antigone,” the main character is a clear example of a courageous, intelligent high-class woman defying her culture’s limits. She didn’t just go against the State, but her superior male relative as well. This in turn intimidates and infuriates the king. The gender roles are very important because they create tension in the story, which helps build up to the climax. It also affects the decisions of some characters because they want to defend their pride.…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Iliad, patriarchy is the only social system. The women of Iliad are typically valued off what is viewed as alluring. Women who are more arete have a higher value placed upon them. They then become a form of a trophy, and a viewed as more of a prize. Although, many women where cared for by the men in this myth as individuals, they were often won as a trophy.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays