I scene ii, line 48-78.The lines I chose from this scene is when
MacBeth and Banquo first met the 3 weird witches. And they told
Macbeth about his future, where he’s going to become the thane of cawdor, and be the king of scotland thereafter. The idea blew
Macbeth’s mind, but he became very attracted to it very quickly.
However, the witches told Banquo that his son will be the King of
Scotland right after, and that Banquo will not be as powerful as
Macbeth, yet much more powerful.Macbeth kind of went mad after the witches said that, he urged to know more, but the witches just vanished, leaving MacBeth there blankly and worried. I think this scene is one of the most important scene in the whole play. This is the scene that basically brought out the whole storyline- the urge of power, the lies, the murder, and many horrible things. It really plays an essential role in foreshadowing what will happen next.!
!
!
!
The first production I chose is from the production of Royal
Shakespeare, it’s called MacBeth, it is directed by Craig Armstrong.
And the second production I chose is from the theatre production
The Tragedy of MacBeth, directed by Jeremy Sabol. Generally, I prefer the first production better, as the production choices give more impact to the scene, and provide the readers a better understanding of the characters. In both productions, the lighting is very dark, with a thin layer of smoke in the background to build a sense of suspicion when the witches were in the scene, and it also suggests the evilness of this scene. Also, the costumes for the characters in the second production was not as related to the original text. Well, the witches were dressed up quite “appropriately” to show their identity as witches- they had messy and colourful hair, wounds on their face, yellow teeth, etc. Which nicely shows their wickedness as witches. However, for Banquo and MacBeth, they were dressed in nice suit and quite modern shirts. Which I don’t think was very connected to the original play, where they just came back from a battle. But for the first play, I think the costumes and the props nicely demonstrated the characters’ identity. Where the
witches were dressed in filthy clothes, dirty hair, and one of the witches even had a bloody eye. And for MacBeth and Banquo, they had the prop of a horse, and was dressed in armours, which indicates that they just came back from the battle, so the audience could understand the background more. The camera angle of the first production seems to be changing frequently, also to give the viewers different sides and perspectives of the characters, and making the production more attractive. However, in the second production, the camera angle seems to be in front of the characters at all times, which makes the production a bit tedious, and the audience may not feel as involved in the play. The characters of the second production are very static, they tend to stand in one place and talk- the three witches stood in a line and talked for the whole time, while Banquo and MacBeth stood in another line, and it was just a plain conversation rather than an acted out scene, which doesn’t have much impact on expressing the characters’ emotions or feelings. But for the first production, the witches were moving around, standing up or sitting on the ground, different gestures were shown, and Macbeth and Banquo also had many sudden movements. Also, the constant eye contact between the characters really showed the engagement of the characters, which makes the audience more involved into the play. I think these things really make the production more interesting, where movements can show the personality or the feeling of the character, and their gestures can show their identity, etc. The tone of the characters between the two productions were quite different. The witches in the first production really had a evil voice, and it really gives the audience a feeling of wickedness; MacBeth and Banquo constantly raised their voice in the play to express their feelings, and that really engaged the audience. For the second play, the witches spoke in a very soft voice, and it was very hollow, it also gave a feeling of evilness, and it successfully built up suspicion. However, in the second production, Banquo and MacBeth were calm throughout the whole production, there weren’t any dramatic rises or falls that could truly express their feelings. And it gives the audience a sense of that
MacBeth was quite careless of what the witches said, and they seem to be just reading the lines, without putting in much feelings and emotions to make the audience more connected. So overall,
with the above justifications, I think I would prefer the first production more.!
!
The first production really brings the text to life, and makes the story much more interesting, so readers/audience will become more engaged in the plot. It also focuses very much on the darkness of this scene (the production had very dark background), and greatly show the evilness of it. The production also greatly brings out suspicious and the wickedness of the witches, which is quite essential for the audience to feel. In the production, the character for MacBeth showed much eager to see the witches again when they vanished. This expression showed that MacBeth was actually really attracted by what the witches were talking about, and showed a bit of his greed for power.!
!
In the production, nothing major was omitted from the original play.
But I found this small thing when Banquo was talking, the mention in the original text that he turned to the witches and turned back to
MacBeth wasn’t clearly showed, which might not have made the scene as dramatic. But for hyperbole, I think the part where
MacBeth pointed his sword at the witches to warn them was quite exaggerated. In the original text, the words don’t strongly show
MacBeth’s eagerness to understand what the witches are saying, the original text doesn’t even contain an exclamation mark when
MacBeth talked to the witches. So the production greatly shows that
MacBeth was very attracted by the witches’ words, and was urging to know more (about his “bright” future). I think the director brought this hyperbole in order to show the audience about the hidden greed that MacBeth has, which wasn’t clearly mentioned in the beginning of the original text. Though he didn’t show obvious urge to those titles, but the way that he pointed his sword at the witches really showed his eagerness to know more, and how he wants to have possession of those titles.!
!
!
!
In my own creation, I did a quick film script according to this scene, and in my interpretation, I imagined MacBeth in the 21st century,
where he is working in a company. In my script, MacBeth’s greed for power and authority is more obvious, where in the beginning, its shows that he’s working very hard in order to get a promotion.
However, when he overhears his co-workers were talking about that his promotion, he acts violently, and demand for more information, which large shows MacBeth’s urge for power. However, his coworker was upset by his violent behavior and leaves him without a word. !
!
My interpretation has brought out MacBeth’s hidden traits forth to the audience more clearly. It has made it more apparent to the audience that deep inside MacBeth, he has been longing for the
King’s title, and as a result, it will give the audience a deeper understanding of the character.!
!
So think about it, if you connect the original play to my interpretation, you’ll find that though they are in two totally different settings, and characters are different, but the main idea is the same. MacBeth’s urge for a promotion is like he wants to be the king of Scotland. So the value or the purpose of it is really to bring out the true feelings or personality of MacBeth, where is not shown so clearly in the original play.!
!
So after listening to my interpretation, do you think that MacBeth has been longing for the king’s title since the beginning of the play?
Or do you think that though he wanted to know more from the witches, but those are just simply out of curiosity? If you think about it deeply, the situation that MacBeth was in was basically like a career life, he needed to climb up slowly, and reach the peak in the end. So I think my interpretation has modernized the situation of
MacBeth to a surrounding where the issue could be more clearly understood by the audience, and it’s also to show that this is also a current issue, so audience could be more connected to what is going on in the scene. !
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Macbeth was a good solider, a noble solider but it all changed when he had chance to pike at his fate. The first encounter Macbeth had with the witches, he learns that he is destined to receive the kingship of Scotland. Here is the beginning of Macbeth power thirsty journey, although he was unsure of the accuracy behind the prophecy but his desire to be king is seeded. Furthermore, after the witches vanish, part of Macbeth prophecy came true. Now Macbeth is intrigued by the possibility of the remainder of the witches’ prophecy. With part of his destiny already a reality, Macbeth’s urge to receive the kingship is now even stronger than before.…
- 451 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Banquo they foretold Macbeth's and Banquo's future they told Macbeth that he will be a king, and they…
- 624 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the beginning Banquo is thinking well if the first thing the witches came true and made Macbeth king why can't his kids become king later. Then macbeth enters in the kings attire. Macbeth discusses his fear of the kids that left. Macbeth invites Banquo to the feast that night, and Banquo accepts his invitation. Banquo says he will make it, but he is going on a horse ride for the afternoon. Macbeth now is contemplating killing his best friend Banquo. The reason he worries is he doesn't want him or his family taking his power. He decides to hire the best assassins he knows to go kill Banquo will he is far away from the castle. They take off to get Banquo. They end up killing Banquo, then come back to the castle in the beginning of the dinner party. It is odd because Macbeth wants no one to know he was apart of the killing, but they pull him aside in the dinner party to talk about the killing. When he comes back to the dinner party he says where am I supposed to sit. They tell him right there there is a empty seat, and Macbeth sees Banquo’s ghost. They start thinking he is crazy. He then says it is weird Banquo is not here I invited him. Lady macbeth interrupts saying he has seen things he was a little kid, and not to ask questions that…
- 396 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Macbeth starts out powerfully, mixing freeze-frame scenes of Macbeth’s epic battle against what appears to be an entire Norway battalion with the mysterious lines of the macabre, grotesque Weird Sisters. In this way, it gives an assertion of the witches’ power, seeming to claim that they are the source of all this discord and violence, and already beginning to set the play up to portray a sympathetic Macbeth. As the play progresses, it increasingly lends itself…
- 405 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Macbeth (1997) is not that different but there are a few changes. The scene begins with the three witches vision of Macbeth slaying Duncan. The clip switches between the three witches and the war on the battlefield. In the end of the battle Macbeth fulfils his destiny and kills Duncan. After that the three witches starts to tell about Macbeth’s prophecy. The two witches on the left and right side seems really annoying, compared to the one in the middle. The two others seem to silly, and not special witch like, in relation to the witch in the middle with the black hair, and to Polanski’s Macbeth. I like the witch with the black hair because she more serious compared to the two other witches plus she the only one with their hair loose. The two other witches have their hood on, which is both greys. I think that one in the middle with the black hair would fit a lot better in Polanski’s Macbeth. I think the Macbeth (1997) has tried to capture the witch the most people are familiar with. A real witch is a bit wicked, and has a crazy…
- 512 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Snow Patrol - Run Snow Patrol - Run SnowPatrolVEVO SnowPatrolVEVO ·81 videos Subscribe 201,187 13,031,935 Like 53,879 Dislike 945 Like I dislike this About Share Add to Statistics Report…
- 3815 Words
- 41 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The film was a easy way to understand the very difficult playwright, this is especially good for high school and readers who aren't a big reader. Changing the dagger scene was by far the smartest, that scene was well written but confusing in the playwright. Loved how the film changed the order to a less complex and backwards way of doing things. Also having a person holding the dagger instead of the playwright version of a floating dagger, the filmed changed many of the key events to help viewers have a better understanding of the story of Macbeth. The playwright of Macbeth can be confusing and a challenging view of the idea, many would think the playwright version of the dagger scene a bit weird, the film makes it a more modern concept. That's why I relate and agree that the film is a better version and more enjoyable view. The playwright was very hard to read to start off with, it not only was hard to understand but in the playwright I found myself confused on many things which led to a poor understanding of the…
- 1031 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Comparing Traves’s article with Macbeth, I realized that the characters in Shakespeare’s play are based on history and he specifically changed Macbeth’s personality in many ways.…
- 301 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
After hearing of the flop performance of Macbeth at the college I ventured to find another performance to critique that was of good theatrical merit. I found a performance at the Chesapeake Shakespeare Company of Macbeth. It was performed on a thrust stage I got a seat on the right side middle area. I had a good view throughout and the actors seemed to understand their surroundings and their performance was accommodating to all sides of the thrust stage. As I had no prior knowledge of Macbeth or the story line going in for critique purposes I did prior research on the storyline so I could focus in on the elements of production and acting. While I’d like to note they stuck very close to the themes and dialogue as Shakespeare wrote it. Never before have I been to a performance of this at this caliber especially not in a thrust theater it was emotionally involved the scenes really jumped out and were thrusting towards us as the actors voices echoed through the theater.…
- 562 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Blood is a recurring symbol in the Macbeth play. Representing honor, disloyalty, and guilt, Shakespeare uses blood to describe Macbeth’s desire to destroy his king, leading to the eventual downfall of his country.…
- 435 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The portrayal and function of the witches in the original play of MacBeth and the movie have several diffrences. In the play the witches are discribed as ugly things with beards and are outcasts of society that wear black robes. But in the movie the witches are very creepy. They have a more modern day horror film look. The witches are no showed as witches but as nurses with masks and black framed glasses. Not only are they shown as nurses (witches) but they are kitchen staff, serving women and cleaning maids too. Also throughout the movie the witches are roaming around in the background of pretty much every scene. It gives a feeling that they are there constantly to ensure the MacBeth and his wife, Lady MacBeth, fulfill their tasks that needed to be done.…
- 425 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
As we all know movies and plays are really different, for Macbeth the differences were quite extreme. From the witches to the killing we see multiple differences that are not telled in the play. Yet all in all they are both great attributes to Macbeth and for…
- 623 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The passage creates a image that shows the reader two sides of Macbeth. His evil side and his fronting side. When he and his wife or just himself is in front of people, they seem innocent, little to know that he killed his friends. It is a two faced image.…
- 720 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The olny thing Macbeth is concerned with is power. Macbeth is the star of the play, the whole story is focused around his rise and fall from power. He, more than anyone displays the idea that people only do what they do to benefit and further themselves. He doesn't kill king Duncan because he thinks that it is for the better good of Scotland, he does it for his own personal gain. Then when he becomes king, he continues to cause the deaths of those around him in fear of losing his newly acquired power. This shows how the power changed him into somthing that he never wanted to become, consumed by his own greed. “The power of man, for none of woman born shall harm Macbeth” (4.1.91-92) He even goes to the witches looking for ways to preserve the power and when the tell him that he is practically invincible he goes mad with his power. Even when his wife commits suicide he is still set on repelling the attacking forces of Malcolm and MacDuff. When the opposing forces finally do arrive he boasts to all that oppose them and slay them malevolently. He does not defend his castle because he loves his people, he knows that they are not fond of him, he does it because he wants to preserve his power.…
- 799 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Dramatic irony is employed from the beginning of the play. The repetition of the paradox “fair is foul and foul is fair” (Act 1 Sc 1) by the Witches introduces the theme of the disruption of the natural order. Macbeth echoes similar words just before his first encounter with them, “so foul and fair a day I have not seen” (Act 1 Sc lll). This draws to the audience's attention the relationship that will form between Macbeth and the Weird Sisters. Dramatic irony is employed here, since Macbeth is unaware at this stage of the importance of his words. The audience though are able to see the connection, which creates dramatic suspense. His words highlight the contribution of the Witches to the events and outcomes of the play. Foreshadowing is one of the first dramatic techniques to be used in the play. In his meeting with the witches in Act 1 Sc lll, Macbeth learns of the prophecy. It plants the idea of treason in his mind. It is Macbeth's ambition that compels him to commit regicide. Without the deliverance of the prophecy by the Witches, Macbeth would not have considered becoming king. Macbeth at this stage of the action considers the witches insignificant, lowly and evil. He is initially fearful of them and approaches them with…
- 1187 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays