Preview

Macdonald Triad

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
534 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Macdonald Triad
Macdonald Triad

Heather Scourfield

Grantham University

Macdonald Triad

The Macdonald Triad is a theory that a set of three characteristics, when presented together, are associated with violent, specifically homicidal behavior. J. M. Macdonald suggested that cruelty towards animals, fire-setting and excessive bed-wetting during in childhood linked violent behavior in adulthood. This theory has strengths and weaknesses. It provides an explanation, not necessarily a valid one, for a tragic situation. Sometimes that is all anybody is ever looking for in those situation; an explanation. Personally, I do not agree with the Macdonald Triad. Although I would not doubt that all three separately are indicators of troubled behavior that even the combination of the three would be a “red flag”, but not sufficient enough to say that it is a direct link or cause of violent behvior. To me there isn’t enough data to back the theories validity. The studies described in the text consist of research counts of 84, 102, 1200; that is not enough research or statistical data collection to convince me that these behaviors are direct links to the behaviors shown in serial killers. The simple downfall of this theory is the lack of research and study groups. On the flip side the strength of this theory is its potential. With more money, research, studies, and attention I believe this theory’s reputation could improve. The Macdonald Triad does a good job of describing the emotional behind the act of the act. The connection between nature/nurture and a child’s emotional development process is extremely important and often times are direct indicators of how they will act or react as an adult. Now I agree that animal cruelty shows inner aggression and hatred towards themselves or another person, that bed-wetting shows lack of control, stress and signs of fear and that fire-starting is a sign of needing attention, lack of respect for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, Dennis Rader was a man of a normal childhood that started having sexual fantasies and grew obsessed with bondage. The loss of his job made him lose self-esteem and caused him to seek attention. Free time and such a particular obsession lead to the murder of ten innocent individuals. Rader was a psychopath that was no longer in control of his actions. “Some people believe there is a biological predisposition of brain wiring, and others suggest that serial killers fail to bond during early childhood” (Mann).…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kip Kinkel Research Paper

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Looking at the trials and tribulations of an average adolescent’s life, there are many times of stress, trouble, and hopefully growth. If there are compounding instances of setbacks and hardships, this could be very detrimental to the development of a young mind. There are never any definitive answers as to why any of these young individuals who commit terrible acts of violence did what they did. There are multiple instances throughout their upbringing that can give some insight as to what could have led to the execution of a horrendous violent outbreak.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jeffrey Dahmer Persona

    • 2175 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Jeffrey Lionel Dahmer was an American serial killer and sex offender from Milwaukee Wisconsin. He was born on May 21st in 1960. His mother reported having a difficult pregnancy; he was a bubbly happy kid. But he was always sick he had ear infections and throat infections. But then at the age of two his family moved to Iowa and his father got a new job. Jeff and his father had a very good relationship. While he was in Iowa his father was cleaning out their crawl space where there were a lot of dead animal bones and Jeff reported saying that he loved the noise that they made. His interest in the noise of the animal bones is a slight warning of one of the MacDonald triads. He moved to Doylestown Ohio. After that started elementary school and his little brother David was born, his teachers reported that Jeff was starting to feel neglected. At this point his parents began to fight a lot and they were constantly yelling at each other, they each got separate rooms. After something exciting like moving happens, something bad always happens like his parents fighting so he associates good things with bad. Jeff would always leave his house and go into the forest by his backyard and hit the trees and wonder why his family just couldn’t get along. His family not being happy obviously affected him in a strong way and made him feel alone and helpless. Jeffrey suffered from a double hernia and had surgery to correct the problem at the age of 4. He was always sick and in the hospital. After that the Dahmers moved into a new house and he became friends with a little boy named Lee. He went to school one day and took a bowl of tadpoles and gave them to his teacher who gave them to Lee, later Jeff took the tadpoles and killed them with motor oil. This is another example, he tried doing something nice for someone and his teacher just gave them away which hurt his feelings so he killed the good thing. And again the Dahmer family moves to another house in Ohio, and he attends a new…

    • 2175 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Macdonald Triad theory has been around for several years and has been studied and re-studied several over the years. J. M. Macdonald, in his 1963 paper, “The Threat to Kill”, noted that certain behaviors were more prevalent in the violent offenders he was studying (Ramsland, 2012). He found that among the 100 psychotic and non-psychotic patients he interviewed that there was a pattern in their behaviors. One thing to keep in mind is that while Macdonald noted these behaviors he did not see much value in them as a predictor.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking for Alibrandi

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The theme change is explored throughout the novel “Looking for Alibrandi” written in a young teenagers perspective by Melina Marchetta confronts the readers the variety of changes happening in a teenager’s life. The book includes changing in relationships, changing in perspective, and growing up.…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first factor is brain damage. “ … This depends on when the damage occurs, it is a very precise thing. All of the killers and psychopaths had damage to their orbital cortex, right above the eyes.” All of the brains that Mr. Fallon looked at had this in common. The second factor is genetics, there is actually a gene for violence, MAOA. This gene is only on the X chromosome so it is passed from mothers. This is why men tend to be more aggressive because in females this gene is diluted . However this factor leads to the next factor. “In order for boys to show this gene they have to go through something really traumatic usually before puberty.” Fallon goes on to say that “ Either being involved or seeing violence...so, if you have this gene and you see a lot of violence it could be a recipe for disaster.”…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A gene called MAOA is associated with aggressive behaviour, it regulated the metabolism of serotonin, and additionally low levels of serotonin are associated with aggressive and impulsive behaviour. A study from a Dutch family with a history of violence including rape and arson found low levels of MAOA in their blood. It showed that the men had a defect in their MAOA. This study shows that the gene MAOA is associated with aggression, this means that some genes can influence the susceptibility to aggressive behaviour, however it is not certain that one gene can determine aggressive behaviour, however it is likely that many genes can contribute to human behaviour rather than one single gene.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    contribution to their behaviors as an adult. This show that evil is nurtured and not…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Something I have come to question about this theory is the following: if one begins acting out at a young age due to these factors that drive them to deviant behavior, doesn’t that affect them in the future to act out or worse (criminal behavior)? In other words, if a person begins criminal behavior from a young age, won’t that affect them as they continue to progress throughout their lifespan? (which some can argue would make this theory a waste of time!)…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Although this may be, psychologists have come across numerous cases where they were not able to identify source of actions due to the complexity of their behavior. By identifying the root causes, it was determined that serial killers tend to begin their killings due to drastic change or impact in their environment. As stated by Eric W. Hickey “ Cases of serial killing share commonalities and characteristics; anger, low self esteem, fantasy, facilitation, and objectification of the victims are all common denominators in understanding the etiological rules of serial murder” (Hichey, 2010). The lives of Jeffery Dahmer’s, Albert Fish’s and Mary Bell’s lives were carefully assessed; each suspicious activity that occurred within their life that could have led them to commit such heinous crimes. During psycho-analysis of this topic it can be seen that there are similarities when comparing different killers. Even though there are different reasons as to why they commit such gruesome acts; it can be correlated to some factors such as being a social pariah, ill-treatment as a child, or neglectful…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What makes people do inexplicable, terrible, socially unacceptable acts of violence? This question brings to mind the age old psychological theory, Nature vs. Nurture. Are people born predisposed for violence? Is there something genetically different about serial killers and murderers? Can their behavior be explained by a difference in their very make-up? Or are they made violent by seeing violence, having un-supportive and demanding parents, being mentally, sexually, and physically abused? Nature vs. nurture is one of the most sought after answers in the field of psychology and may never be “answered” but can be “understood” I feel study in the minds of serial killers has helped to define exactly what nature vs. nurture really means.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animal Abuse Scandal

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Boone completes J.M. MacDonald’s Triad of Sociopathy, his parents died when he was young and he was sent from one abusive foster home to another, this was the ultimate trigger which leads to his sociopathy. Said Ezra PoVel State Certified Psychiatrist. The Triad of Sociopathy consists of arson, animal cruelty and enuresis (bed wetting), and according to his 3rd foster mother he often wet the bed, sociopathy is believed to be a product of parental neglect, cruelty or trauma and leads to “homicidal proneness” in many…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Female Serial Killers

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Everyone’s childhood plays an extremely important role in determining who they will become and who they grow up to be. Your childhood molds and shapes you in every way. But not everyone’s childhood is happy and picture perfect, as some kids grow up in an environment that can set them up for hate and failure, which can ruin their chances for success. The childhood people have is the base that they build on to form their psychological base in adulthood (Vronsky, 2007). So one extremely interesting factor contributing to the makings of a female serial killer is abuse that is experienced in their childhoods. The FBI study has stated and confirmed that most to all serial killers come from an unstable,…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leaving the Cave

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages

    children. Critics of this theory believe it promotes narcissistic behaviors because its purpose is to…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the past couple of decades, many of those who work in the field of forensic psychology have conducted numerous amounts of research to determine the link between violent offending and those who suffer from a mental illness. However, even though a large amount of research has been tested and it is indicated that there is a relationship between the two, it has been a major challenge to determine whether the results are accurate. Because these two share very similar risk factors to each other, the link remains in doubt. To start this essay, it will first define some key terms that will be used throughout, which include mental health problems, schizophrenia, and violent offending. These terms will be defined so there will be a central understanding to the topic being discussed. The main focus of this essay will try and determine the link between violent offending and people who suffer from a mental health issue. This will involve a very thorough analysis of the risk factors that arise from mental health problems and violent offending. First, this essay will begin by defining the term mental health problems, more specifically the types of illnesses that will be taken into consideration for the purpose of this essay. Second, it will explore theories and how they attempt to explain mental health and violent offending; and third, argue the links between mental health problems and violent offending. Increasingly, it is intended that these areas of discussion are to support the argument that people who suffer from a mental health problem are at an increased risk of violent offending.…

    • 2217 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics