Mall culture is nothing but an exploitative phenomenon mastermind by materialistic sharks of a blind imitation of the wild west for personal gains – and even at the cost of small traders and entrepreneurs who provide spot service to the community while these huge magnet like sophisticated centralized retail chains attract the gullible customer through media and advertisement blitz craze. Where? Of course, not in villages and in towns but in metropolis like Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Banglore, Kolkatta etc.
Don’t you all present here think that at best we can name it an elite culture to which ordinary person with meager means have no access. Sometimes even if they try and attempt they do it on their own peril. The glitter, the display, the temptation, the marketing gimmicks compel the ordinary man to gulp more than they can chew and pushing them into debt traps.
I feel very strongly that men with means and substantial means can only afford the luxury of mall because they are meant for elites and affluents.
My next point against the topic is this mall culture is simply widening the chasm between the haves and have-nots. It is creating disparity between the rich and the poor. The rich grow richer and the poor poorer – a stage finally reaches when the society will be left with few Birlas, Ambanis and Tatas and the rest grovel in misery and unemployment. What a miserable society it will be!
Now I would like to remind you all that the rural community is not a fraction or part of India, it is India itself, almost the whole of it. Keep in your mind the fact that the rural community makes more than 80% of India’s population. They live in villages where these money leagues feel shy of venturing into. Why should they? Obviously not much of money there. Hence this is the culture which can not become the culture of whole nation. So I think we can call the mall culture as mal culture.
I just fail to understand why we prefer malls than traditional markets just to stuff ourselves with high-priced articles and eatables like pizzas, burgers and giving green vegetables a go by. Think over again and again that fast food and fitness do not go together.
Though India is all set to be a Mecca for shoppers but guard against shop holism, warn experts. Malls give us chance to shop but isn’t it turning us into shopaholics? Beware shop holism is a disorder and needs attention.
Before proceeding on to the topic I would like to ask you a question - would you like to go for shopping in crowded place, in alleys of city’s markets full of paan stains , dirt, spitting, litter or foul odour or a comfortable environment that provide shoppertainment a combination of shopping and entertainment. Yes, I know your answer.
Good morning to all. Honourable chairperson members of jury and the distinguished gathering present here. Today I am standing before you to support the motion i.e. shopping mall culture in India.
The answer to that question which I asked earlier was that we all like to go for shopping in air-conditioned complexes rather than traditionally-high streets. Don’t you all present here think shopping malls have changed the way India does shopping. Shopping has never been so easier earlier. Shopping malls have changed shopping from an ordeal to an outing.
I want to tell you that this year at the peak of puja season in Kolkatta the alleys of city’s iconic new markets were far from crowded. There was not a single queue to be found. Now malls have become a community hubs where people congregate, entertain themselves and also buy things. I very strongly say that today people take air-conditioning and parking facilities as basic. Value for money has changed value to time.
As my honourable opponents has submitted that malls are for affluent and elites. I would like to tell them by example of a lady Vandana Patel, the wife of a farmer who drives from her home from Kelol to Ahmedabad’s big bazaar just for shopping. Do you know what she says ,” despite the distance it makes sense for us to go to a mall because we get everything for everyone under one single roof.
My next argument in favour of the topic is that malls are the prime drivers of an organized retail revolution in the country. At the new rate new ones are coming up. It is virtually a mall a minute. According to recent KSA Technopac researvh of Indian retail industry there were just 3 shopping malls operating in India by 2000 and by 2007 that figure is expected to reach 343 with 54 malls coming up in Delhi only and here I would like to tell them that significant number of malls are coming up in small towns also and they will represent new temples of retail worship.
I firmly reject the opinion shared by my friends that when a mall opens most of the visitors are window shoppers. Do you know what ways NeetA Chopra head of marketing Westside “ we feel the growth will be in malls as shopping as now a form of entertainment and the cost of functioning a mall will be much lower than traditional streets where rents are astronomical and and footfall is unpredictable.
My last argument in the favour of the topic is that people do not miss bargaining in the mall rather they feel quite confident that the store owner is not cheating them. Even if then also some of my friends want to do bargaining then let me tell them that there are kiosks in the basement of some of the malls. They can go there and do the bargaining as much as they want.
Not only this events, promotions, and competitions are regularly held and competitions like DJ wars, product launches contests beauty competitions are held in the atrium.
At last I want to say that mall boom has created its own economy its own brands. The future may include both the large mega malls and smaller malls. At the focus of this churning is the Indian consumer and shopping experience for him to buy from title of rock album become bigger, better, faster and more …..
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The following assignment allows you to analyze the Mall of America. You will have the opportunity to develop strategies designed to assist…
- 371 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
David Guterson’s narrative about the Mall of America delves into several facets that are embedded throughout the mall both physically and mentally. A vivid description about the mall’s interior design makes the audience feel like they have visited the mall. Guterson also writes about how people, individually and as a society, are effected psychologically by this pseudo-metropolis. The grandeur of the mall is, without question, second to none. Shoppers are drawn to visit because of all the modern frills contained within. A theme park, arcade, hundreds of shops, and eateries are the staples of the mall, but the gardens, flowers, and trees define the mall as being “the best of the best.” The atmosphere created by combining “Mother Earth” with…
- 358 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Veblen’s concept of conspicuous consumption (Veblen, 1899) began to outline how the leisure classes demonstrated status through possessions. However, with increasing affluence and mass consumption, Bauman (Bauman, 1988) later suggests that consumers have become identified by what they have, as opposed to what they do, and have become further differentiated between the ‘seduced’ and the ‘repressed’; the seduced having the means to engage fully in society, but that the repressed are not in a position to become effective consumers and so, by definition, are at best marginalised.…
- 1284 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The luxury industry can also be looked at as a status symbol. Conspicuous consumption leads to increasing demands for luxury good items and it is a growing industry with the global luxury goods market growing 9% per year (Business Wire, 2007). Advertising has a lot to do with it, especially Americans who are being constantly bombarded with advertisements on a daily basis. While finding exactly how many advertisements American see a day is nearly impossible, some studies have shown the number to be between 150 and 3,000 (Mortar, 2006). This leads to more consumers being exposed to or being told which items or brands are luxury goods, but unlike the definition for luxury goods, these conspicuous consumers buy their products for satisfy their self-esteem issues rather than for ease or comfort. Although an argument can be made is…
- 3924 Words
- 16 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Mall of America is the largest mall to date in the United States. In my paper today I will be talking about the two primary target markets that Mall of America has and what marketing strategies they should be using to reach those markets. We will also be talking about the types of market research the Mall should be using to decide how to grow. Finally we will also be talking about how the Mall should use Social media to grow.…
- 472 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
William Kowinski has written the article “Kids in the mall: Growing up controlled”, to highlight the ignorance of parents that exposes children to artificial environment of shopping malls. Kowinski argues that this exposure converts children into “pre-programmed consumers” and leads them to a premature adulthood, which affects their emotional development. To prove his argument, the writer relies upon several studies which reveal the importance of the role parents play in nurturing their children with “warmth” and “old-fashioned mothering”. Furthermore, Kowinski defines the mall as a “high school without the impertinence of classes” where children can learn some skills by doing odd jobs. However these jobs might not be helpful in the future since they do not teach them anything new. By adopting a casual tone and specific choice of words, Kowinski succeeds in discussing his arguments and giving his point of view.…
- 756 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The mall and its materialistic image have become a major highlight of American society. By allowing mall goers to share their experiences, this is fairly evident. Two women Guterson meets at a restaurant explain how they “have shopping addictions and live at the mall” (105). These women explain how they feel sorry for other malls because they are so “small and boring”, as if nothing can compare to the Mall of America. These women are right because the mall is so vast and extravagant nothing else can compare to it; and again they are right because what other malls can say that they have and indoor amusement park?! He later goes to say how the mall is not just a…
- 1090 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In Alan Brinkley’s essay The Mall he explores the history of shopping complexes in the United States and gives us insight on the different kinds of complexes. The mall started off as a shopping center. The first shopping center was the Country Club Plaza, opened in Kansas City in 1924. The shopping center soon increased in size and became small “strips.” In 1956, the first enclosed, climate controlled shopping opened in Minneapolis and was called South Dale Shopping Center many cities. The malls spread and began to have similar aspects of the downtowns that they were rapidly displacing, but they were safer. Soon after that malls started being built in many cities. The malls were still increasing in size and they were begging to add movie theaters, video arcades, bowling alleys, restaurants, and hotels. “In cities and towns in every part of America, malls became not just a place for shopping, but often centers of a much-altered community life as well” (Brinkley 115). Malls became like little cities with their own police that were private security forces. For the most part they were able to keep undesirable customers off the premises. Mall evolved into self-contained imitations of cities, minus many of the troubling abrasive features of downtowns. Malls set out to be perfect urban spaces mostly having white middle class women in mind. Many teenagers began to cling to the malls instead of other hang out spots such as street corners, parks and downtown. The mall became a universal shopping center that attracted everyone.…
- 289 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The main reason for the success of the Mall of America is its unique retail-entrainment mix. This mall offers more than the regional malls. Because of the uniqueness of this mall it attract 40 million visitors each year. Visiting the one-stop complex offering retail shopping, guest service, convenience, and a huge variety of entertainment and fun for all. The location was the focus of the mall along with the size and the shopping experience, which make life easier to visit with out being confuse. This mall has something to offer everyone.…
- 281 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I could not help but to think that the purpose of a shopping mall was for everyone to have one convenient place to buy anything they desired. But, the viewpoints expressed though "Community through Exclusion and Illusion" by George Lewis and "Shopping for American Culture," by James J. Farrell, have led me to believe that the shopping mall also serves as a community center. Another article which captured my attention was Ira Zepp's, "The Shopping Mall as Sacred Place." They each express their ideas of how the shopping mall is not just a place to shop due to it's constantly availability, which has created an ideal environment for social interaction for people of all ages. Farrell…
- 918 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
During his stay there he pondered the question: How is the Mall of America part of America? The first thing that Guterson notices is the vast, expansive nature of the mall. After having observed some of the shoppers, Guterson concluded that despite the malls expansiveness, it elicited claustrophobia, sensory deprivation, and an unnerving disorientation, (Guterson p. 452). According to Guterson, these feelings lead to a sense of isolation, away from any kind of community that encourages socialization. Guterson believes that the desire to fulfill these communal requirements is intrinsic to human nature and the shopping mall is only a hindrance to this…
- 973 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Conspicuous consumption is the backbone to our current credit card crisis. The thought process which is explained so eloquently by Veblen when it comes to the ways and means of people’s spending habits along with how corporation use these behaviors to market their wares. Why would a company sell you an economy class when they can convince you that you need and deserve to sport yourself in the luxury class? “A $17,000 car provides transportation as easily as a $100,000 vehicle, but the luxury car makes a social statement that the less expensive car can’t live up to”(Little et al., 2014, p. 288). Additionally, you can see how certain class/type of people now find particular task beneath them as explained through the terms of Conspicuous leisure. So many people used to cut their own lawns and clean their own homes, but now they choose to employ what is usually referred to as the hired help to perform these manual…
- 359 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the social hierarchy of America, the people with the most stuff are considered “the lucky ones.” Who wouldn’t want to be at the top of the food chain? That is why people are so drawn to shopping malls. It’s all about who has the nicest clothes and the fattest wallets. Society will never lose that competitive instinct to be the best, it’s the way we’re wired, and it’s the way we’ll stay.…
- 1872 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Veblen called this “conspicuous consumption-the desire to demonstrate one’s prestige and status based on one’s material acquisitions”. By the consumer trying to keep up with the Jones this leads to needless spending on items and services that the consumer doesn’t really need. This covers all aspects of the general public’s life they are told what to drive, what to wear, what to eat, and where to live. With all these ideas being forced down the consumer’s throat it makes it hard for some consumers to remain true to their self and live within their means. This can result in bankruptcies, maxed credit cards, poor credit, and overdue bills.…
- 711 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One can argue that excessive materialism only affects those who can afford their expenses. They claim that small groups of people, usually being “the 1%”, have a problem with spending money on items that they don’t require. They figure if they have enough money to support their useless purchases, it should not be a problem. And although this may be true in some cases, such as very wealthy rappers or celebrities in entertainment, the rise of excessive materialism is growing among young teenagers and adults that can’t afford the items they are purchasing. Young teenagers will go to the extent of stealing their own parents’ cash to buy high-end fashion clothes, accessories, games, and anything one can imagine. A story of a young girl named Dee in Champagne Taste, Beer Budget explains an incident where she withdrew $1,600 out of her mother’s saving account she had set up for her just to satisfy her fix of buying materialistic fashion items. Her mother says, “Delia, you’re turning into a lunatic, giving all your hard-earned money to multimillionaires!” (Cleveland 279). And she simply responds, “Mama, you’re behind the times.” I was looking fly, and that was all that mattered.” (Cleveland 279). The amount of people in America that can’t support their purchases outweigh those who can, which is most likely the main reason America is currently 59…
- 634 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays