Preview

Margaret Changes Nusrat's Under The Persimmon Tree

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1190 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Margaret Changes Nusrat's Under The Persimmon Tree
(AGG) Elizabeth Kubler-Ross once said, “The reality is that you will grieve forever. You will not ‘get over’ the loss of a loved one; you will learn to live with it. You will heal and rebuild yourself around the loss you have suffered. You will be whole again but, you will never be the same. Nor should you be the same, nor would you want to (“A Quote”).” (BS-1) In the book, Under the Persimmon Tree, the loss of Margaret gives her a new outlook on life. (BS-2) Later on, when she meets Faiz, he showed her a new way of living. (BS-3) At the end, acceptance heals her pain from the people she’s lost. (TS) Clearly, Nusrat is strongly affected, in both good and bad ways by the loss of her loved ones.

(MIP-1) Losing Margaret changes Nusrat’s view
…show more content…
(SIP-A) She makes the decision to change her religion. (STEWE-1) She decides this for herself, not for Faiz, “Nusrat converted to Islam before she and Faiz even discussed marriage...The idea struck her the first time she entered Faiz’s apartment…” (Staples 134). Meeting Faiz changes her because she wanted what she saw in Faiz. (STEWE-2) Also, Nusrat wanted to know why God would take Margaret away from her, “After her sister's death Elaine began a quest for meaning" (Staples 134). She is lost, angry, and confused. She doesn't understand why the one and only God she trusted, took one of the most important people in her life away from her. However, it has also helped her to learn faith and combine faith with science and math. (SIP-B) After meeting Faiz, she looks at life in a new way and begins to find out more about herself. (STEWE-1) She begins to know what she wants in life: “What she longed for was the kind of peace and assurance that radiated from Faiz" (Staples 136). The loss of Margaret caused her to feel detached from her society, family, and friends. When she stepped into Faiz’s apartment, she felt that peace that she had been longing for. (STEWE-2) She wanted a religion that would be compatible with her own lifestyle, “‘I am a mathematician,’ she said. ‘I need a religion that’s compatible with science and mathematics… ‘Islam is the cradle of modern mathematics and astronomy,’ the imam said” (Staples 137). She …show more content…
(SIP-A) With Faiz gone, she doesn’t feel stable inside, and once again, she feels alone. (STEWE-1) She wonders and worries about Faiz everyday, “She asks her servant, Husna, to check the mailbox every afternoon…” (Staples 43). She is scared she will lose him, and she does not want to go through the same experience from when she lost Margaret. (STEWE-2) She has finally found someone who understands her and he has become a big part in her life: “With Faiz gone, she feels as if one of her main parts are missing…” (Staples 141). He is a piece of her life (BUILD OFF) . There is no longer any liveliness or excitement in her life, but she still must learn to swim. She does not have a reason to maintain her soul to be ‘alive’ nor stayed hopeful (SIP-B) Later on, Nusrat learned to accept the loss and pain.(STEWE-1) She begins to accept the loss of her loved ones, “When she awakens, Nusrat feels peace settling over the raw center of pain in her chest” (Staples 231). The pain subsides when she stops fooling herself and she learns to accept. She now understands that both Margaret and Faiz are in a better place among the stars, and one day she will see them again. (STEWE-2) After she accepts the losses she’s had, she decides to go back to America and make amends with her family, “‘For them my converting to Islam was a little as if I'd died. They felt they'd lost me. They're getting older now, and I think I

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The death of Leslie Lucas’s mother made her more mature, but negative and full of loneliness. “When all of a sudden you feel something reach inside your chest, grab your heart, and squeeze ‘til you can barely breathe (Grimes 51-52)”. Leslie was so emotionally hurt and distraught but it only made her stronger because she also said “A year ago I might have written about something silly, like ghosts, which I don’t even believe in, and even if I did, ghosts would not be at the top of my list. The scariest thing I can think of now is being all alone in this world (Grimes 54)”. After her mom’s death, she snapped into reality and realized how cruel it can be. Having to transfer schools and move away from all of her…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    (BS-3) Najmah has decided not to go with Nusrat, and to stay to try and keep her family’s farmland. (BS-2) Najmah’s life will change drastically after the losses that she has gone through especially after Baba-jan and Habib dying. (BS-1) Najmah’s life will become harder from now on because she has to become more mature and take care of Mada-jan. (R) Najmah has to use what's within her to keep her going and not give up, as a famous author once said, “What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us” -Ralph Waldo…

    • 1907 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Especially when she met her real mother, she was able to self-reflect on how it has been for her and the family she grew up with. Yet, there are still moments in her life when she unexpectedly becomes silent, but her response are different. She comes into realization and deeper understanding of what she has been through. In this case, when her and her mother when to shop, and ended up at a cake store, Silence came again, “It was the fat Buddha… A map of his body in golden dough relief. Before I knew it my mother had ordered and paid for one.” (Nguyen, 233) essentially implying that even in her comfort in food, she was silenced her once again simply because her mother was there. She was left in silenced, that she forgot to ask her mother questions that she has been longing to ask for years, she says, “In the end, I left my questions unanswered, I couldn’t comprehend the loss… the silence…” (Nguyen 237) regretting the feeling of being a stranger and a ghost in which she felt regretful that she never really fantasize about meeting her real mother. However, despite the silenced she faced again, she was able to realize something important in her life. She realized how her stepmother had been a great support for her. “I’m very thankful…for the fact that they raised me and Anh.”(Nguyen, 234) essentially realizing the moments that she thought were repressive…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    How would it feel waking up to bombings and screams? imagine a world where you wake up hoping the previous day was just a nightmare and realizing it wasn't. This is how the Taliban is portrayed in the book Under the Persimmon Tree by, Susan Fisher Staples. One of the main characters, Najmah, is greatly impacted by the Taliban. These horrible people have destroyed her family by separating them and even killing some of them. The way the Taliban is portrayed in the book is similar to how it is in real life, the presentations showed that the Taliban is a group of people who are extremists.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Loss Of Najmah Quotes

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Everyone changes when loved ones are lost, but for Najmah, It affected her heavily, and shaped her actions. Loss effects Najmah heavily in the beginning of the book and builds her character. Loss takes Najmah out of shock and is a driving force for her. Loss also shapes the life changing decisions she makes at the end of the book. Najmah has been affected and shaped by loss many times throughout the book.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine the experience of living under the rule of a violent group of terrorists, with no freedom whatsoever. This is what it is like to Najmah in the book Under the Persimmon Tree, by Suzanne Fisher Staples. In this realistic setting, Najmah, the main character, loses most of her family due to the brutality and imposition of the Taliban. The novel depicted the Taliban as dangerous and strict, which is interchangeable for what the Taliban is like in reality. Staples used the Taliban conflict to deepen the reader's understanding of the impact of conflict on people's lives.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Exposition – we are introduced to Leah. Her thoughts are revealed which illustrate the mind of a woman well on in her years, who has accepted (and is welcome to) the concept of death, and as such is reminiscing on her life – the death of her husband, her wrong-doings (her lying throughout her daily life)…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    (AGG) The author of “Under The Persimmon Tree” often uses symbolism throughout the book. (BS-1) The author of UTPT uses the stars to give Najmah a superstitious belief, and give her hope and guidance to drive her towards her goals. (BS-2) The stars are used to help Nusrat accept loss, she looks to them for hope and guidance, and they have a religious meaning to her. (BS-3) The author uses changes in the stars to convey events and changes in Najmah’s life. (TS) The stars are used to portray changes in the characters lives, and the author uses them to give the characters hope, guidance, and an important meaning, as well as the ability to deal with loss.…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Pipers Son

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Grief and loss are vital elements in this novel. Not only is Tom’s family grieving the loss of a loved one, Tom’s uncle Joe who died in the London underground bombings 2 years earlier, but there are other forms of grief portrayed within the text. Tom grieves the absence of his family. After the death of his Uncle, his father turned to drink, his mother left, his father left. Tom closed himself off from the world; his friends, family and the girl he loved.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Incendies Worksheet

    • 501 Words
    • 2 Pages

    She does this through forgiveness; forgiveness for herself and forgiveness for her son. She allows her children to bury her with a gravestone and hoped for a reassured sense of peace for Nihad.…

    • 501 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death of her father in a sense to her was abandonment, because he dies leaving her to fend for herself. She was left in a world that she really didn’t fully understand. He kept her sheltered from everyone. When he died, she didn’t want to accept the fact that he was dead. It took the townspeople three days to convince to give up his body. They felt very sorry for her. But did nothing to consoled her. They were glad because now she would know like other people, what it felt like to count pennies.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom Brenna Speech

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout the book ‘The Story of Tom Brennan’, each character deals with the tragedy in many different ways. Tom becomes depressed and begins to blame himself, he rejects that Dan, his older brother, has committed a crime and is sent to jail, ‘didn’t they realise we weren’t like everyone else here?’ (Page 134). Kylie, Tom’s younger sister, become rebellious and felt that everyone in their new town, Coghill, would have found out their secret eventually and it wasn’t fair to keep it hidden. ‘That was the thing about my sister, she’d become tough, like I didn’t know her anymore.’ (Page 29). ‘In many ways she’d released me, pushing me into my own fear.’ (Page 190). ‘In some ways, part of me almost admired her guts’ (Page 185). Tess, Tom’s mum, is affected by it the most; she refuses to accept that it’s happened and feels that her son has been ripped away from her. ‘“Well Tess,’ Kath started, “I’m sorry about that, but my son can’t even turn his neck to see his back.”’ (Page 155). She begins to live in denial and won’t talk about it. ‘Come on girlie, don’t be so self indulgent. Life goes on.’ (Page 4). Daniel becomes depressed and realises the consequences of his actions. “He’d been absolutely ripped to shreds. He didn’t sleep, eat, hardly spoke, never smiled. The only thing he did was cry. He cried buckets.” (Page 121).…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    English Essay

    • 1896 Words
    • 8 Pages

    deaths within her life. As she remembers these moments she is drawn back to her old life mentally and eventually physically as well.…

    • 1896 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    loss and grief

    • 2960 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Almost everyone in the world experiences an event which can be considered as a loss. It is the disappearance of something or someone important to an individual, grief is the natural response to the loss, people feel a range of emotions when they suffer a loss such as shock, panic, denial, anger and guilt. Death is one of the major events associated with loss but there are many others that occur which can also have a negative effect on someone’s life by impacting in various ways.…

    • 2960 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    loss and grief

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The death of a loved one can be the most common form of grief; throughout life most people will experience this type of loss. The loss of a loved one can trigger grief such as depression, anger and fear. The person lost could have been a big influence in the life of the bereaved offering them love and security but now that the person has gone they may feel a sense of insecurity like how will I pay the bill or who’s going to cook tea as the person who has gone may have been the main source of financial income for the family and who would do most of the cooking and household chores, and loneliness having the suffered the loss of a companion or a lifelong friend that you would talk to and see almost every day.…

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays