Preview

Mariah Burton Nelson: Standing Tall for Women's Rights

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
739 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Mariah Burton Nelson: Standing Tall for Women's Rights
In Mariah Burton Nelson’s article I Won, I’m Sorry, the relationship between women and athleticism is put into perspective. Athletes fight to dominate while a feminine woman fights to appear nonthreatening and beautiful. Female athletes must battle to display a balance between these two different worlds. Nelson reveals the struggles of a woman attempting to establish herself as a fearsome competitor while maintaining a feminine grace in order to gain the acceptance of the public and more importantly, the opposite sex. As a former professional basketball player, Nelson is all too familiar with the female athlete’s battle to earn respect as a force to be reckoned with, without betraying the qualities of an elegant lady. She traces her claims as far back in history as the forties and fifties, discussing the commonness of dress codes being enforced on female athletes, even going as far as following championships with beauty competitions. From Nelson’s perspective, it seems to be a way of demonstrating vulnerability so as to accommodate male superiority, an everlasting tradition that shows no signs of fading away.
As if it is not enough for women to avoid wearing heels to prevent being taller than their husbands, Nelson provides evidence that female athletes will sometimes go as far as expressing apologetic behavior for their “‘masculine’ strivings” in order to preserve acceptance as a genuine feminine woman (Nelson 572). The athletes cannot display their desire to go out and win without appearing aggressive and unladylike, so they might compensate by being featured in the media modeling for makeup ads or squeezing into revealing swimsuits and posing in vulnerable positions to depict themselves as the weaker sex.
Nelson expresses her distaste for the division between femininity and athleticism throughout the article, arguing that if men can retain their respect even after displaying recklessness during competition, women should not be discredited for showing the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article titled”Face off on the Playfield”, by Judith B. Stamper explores the issues of female athletes competing on traditional boy’s sport team. First, Stamper explain how opponent agree that girl are not aggressive enough. But supporters argue that girl don’t have good equipment like boy. The author also report that some male athletes get uncomfortable having physical contact with girls. Second, girl are too weak to compete. In Addition she emphasised that supporters say Title IX has benefitted girl’s health and how society view girls. Now, more girl are playing sports. Finally Stamper concludes that as the debate over ow Title IX continue, boy are now asking to compete on girl’s team.…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The general argument made by author Susan K. Cahn, is that in" today's' society there are women athletes who are media celebrities and a source of inspiration for many. But not long ago, being serious about sports was considered appropriate only for men and boys". Throughout the 20th century, women's increasing participation in sports has challenged our conception of womanhood. Some celebrated the female athlete as the embodiment of modern womanhood, but others branded her "mannish" which was liked to being a lesbian. Ultimately, she altered the perception of sport as an exclusively male domain. More specifically, Cahn focuses on the decades between 1920 and 1960, Cahn argues that at the beginning of the century, the debate centered on the…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Research Paper Final Draft

    • 1562 Words
    • 3 Pages

    held against them ("Masculinity and Gender Roles in Sports"). As the role of women has progressed, a…

    • 1562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    “I won. I am sorry” by Mariah Burton Nelson pointing out the real differences of men and women based on athletes. The differences occur when the media barely gives attention to female athletes. Media play an important role to promote images, positive and realistic messages, opinion to the public. However, it is disappointing when media play an opposite role and show no interest toward female athletes.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An issue that I have always been concerned with is how much attention male sports get, while female sports get pushed aside. Males and females put forth the same amount of effort and the same amount of hard work towards the sports they play, and in return males dominate the limelight. Arguments opposing this show that males are obviously better athletes than females. According to Mariah Burton Nelson, controversial activist and author, football, baseball and other manly sports in the United States are not games, but a culture which offer a pre-civil rights world where white men, as owners, coaches and umpires, still rule. In the manly sports, men learn to think about and talk about women in contempt. It is common practice for boys to be belittled as "wusses" or worse if they are not tough or brutal enough or willing to deny their own pain or the pain of others.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tough Break: Response

    • 505 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Rogers touches on gender issues and stereotypes related to gender in the essay. He makes that clear by discussing the differences in behavior exhibited by male and female participants in the sport. He points out how the two genders are perceived by fans of the industry as well as the significant difference in the way the athletes view the sport. The females are more sportsmen like and accommodating as they see that the sport is “for fun.” The men on the other hand, are more aggressive and mean-spirited toward one another as they see the sport as one in which they must compete for dominance and prove their superior abilities.…

    • 505 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a result of the immense sexual objectification of women in sports in modern times, ''Playing the Field:Sports and sex in America”' examines the evolution of women's sports from a time when sweating was taboo, as was wearing shorts, to temporarily, when the muscular physiques of Venus and Serena Williams reflect new paradigms of beauty. Ironically, when many women first began to play sports, they were shunned and covered up, unable to play in venues with men in attendance because it would be unladylike for men to see women sweat. Therefore, how we as Americans react contemporarily to women's sports (glorification, hypersexualization), represents a stark contrast. Therefore, a downside of hypermasculinity, is the burden that it puts on male and female athletes who don’t meet its standards. From requiring women to be fully covered in a full body veil to having women play tackle…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Success in sports is, arguably, the determining factor of overall success and public admiration of a man today. We find that many men look to the athletic world as a means of escape, liberation, or fulfillment of their lives. While all this may be true, there are many costs associated with the game, both health and relational, and just about everyone who aspires to this type of success falls victim to these costs. However, despite the fact that many are fully aware, they seem to have little weight in people’s decision to pursue a professional athletic career. On the other hand, this ignorance is justified as some see the costs as just part of the job, and as Michael A. Messner suggests in his essay, “Sport and Gender Relations: Continuity,…

    • 1972 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Title IX

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A fundamental factor in American culture and the development of many crucial life skills, sports have historically excluded women, pushing them to watch from the sidelines rather than partake in them. It is not only important for women to experience the sports lifestyle, but also for society as a whole to have its entire population participating in a common activity, thus breaking away from the archaic norm.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    68% of girls play sports, between the ages of 9-11 years, or the “finding your identity period”. (Click) So when mini netball skirts that fly up with every move, are their uniform, what messaging are they getting? (click) Young girls nowadays are bombarded with pictures that only highlight ‘sexiness’ of sports women. (click) Women’s beach volleyball is more popular than most mainstream sports such as cycling, hockey and basketball. In 1999 the International Volleyball Federation regulated uniforms standards, but they were accused of selling the player’s looks rather than their talents. Hence the FIVB, allowed anything as long as it looks clean and professional. Yet, still women's sports are covering nothing except their capabilities. The first image is from a 1980’s professional volleyball team, and the second from the 2012 Olympics, and certainly the bikinis drew the crowd. In fact 90% of the audience were men between the ages of 16- 54, hence proving the impact that the appalling mistreatment of women’s bodies, has on men’s perception of us as pleasure objects. The degrading of women can also be blamed on the media’s repulsive…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women Sports Report

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Page

    I am interesting to look at Women Sport Report webpage because I understand more about their success. According to article “I Won, I’m Sorry” Mariah Burton Nelson has portrayed the images of female athletes in a way as what people looks at these athletes. Female athletes feel more pressure than male athletes. People expect them look femininity at all the time in competition .For instance, they have to be smart and industrious, but in addition they have to be act like women such as kind, nurturing, accommodating, nonthreatening, placating, pretty, and small. They have to smile even they feel hurt after an accident. They cannot get angry with anything. They should make up when present in front of audiences because they are woman. In my opinion,…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To be a Black Woman in America is a peculiar experience; it is both masterfully beautiful and painfully destructive. In the wake of the 2016 Olympics, one could see Black Women dominating in a multitude of competitive arenas including track and field, gymnastics, swimming, basketball, tennis, boxing, and fencing. Powerful athletes like Simone Biles, Allyson Felix, Clarissa Shields, and Ibtihaj Muhammad broke world records and stereotypes through their amazing feats of perseverance, athleticism, and endurance. Despite their triumphs, these athletes were publicly chastised for seemingly trivial issues of their hair, facial expressions, and perceived unpatriotic attitudes. Even in the world’s arena of athleticism and human spirit where social constructs such as race should be a non-factor, these women were vilified, subjugated, and disrespected by virtue of their marginal status of woman and black. Headlines of their accomplishments were filled with language steeped and smothered in sexism, misogyny, and racism. BBC reporter, John Inverdale, remarked that Andy Murray was the first athlete to win two gold medals in tennis.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are two worlds created for athletes: one for the men and one for the women. The two realms are created because of the socially constructed characteristics of gender. If a man participates in a woman’s sport or visa versa, controversy is created. In addition, the question of an athlete’s sexuality comes into play. Randy Boyd, a black gay columnist at Outsports.com stated, "You’re black, you’re an athlete, you’re a Man with a capital M, and this is what you do, follow the script that has been given to you.” Many individuals also assume that all female athletes are lesbian. In today’s society an athlete playing a non-traditional sport for his or her gender takes on a large amount of criticism from both players and spectators. Sports have been built on the skill of the athlete. Now athletes have to maintain skill, public admiration, and a low key profile about their sexuality. Today’s representation of black sexuality does not suggest different from Hooks and West but is portrayed negatively in sports through examples of the black athletes.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are several impacts on female athletes and women’s sports of being sexualized and hyper-feminized in the sport media. First, “Sports Illustrated lack of respectful coverage of female athletes tends to “minimize the opposition that strong women represent” by only including very little coverage of women” (lecture, p.6) This is kind of disrespectful for women, and will mislead women. They might think that strong women are not able to play and get attention. Second, “women are being objectified and viewed as a potential object for sexual gratification.” (lecture, p.7) This will mislead women to value their appearance rather than their abilities as an athlete. Ultimately, fewer and fewer women will think their body as an object of another…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    ad essay

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Femininity is about appearing beautiful, vulnerable, small and winning male approval.” Women want to be tall and attractive to feel elegant and worthy. But know nowadays, women are redefining femininity as strong, independent, and athletic. In the article “I Won. I’m Sorry” by Mariah Burton Nelson she argues that, “Athletic competition, when you come right down to it, is about winning, which is no problem for men, whose gender codes tell them that aggression and domination are admirable male traits. “But how can you win if you’re a female?” This quote is trying to say that, for men its always right to win because they are always being competitive about everything, but if you’re a girl should you be able to win? Why should it not be feminine for girls to win and be competitive? To get back to the point, most female athletes dedicate a lot of attention to portraying a feminine appearance. For this reason, they join modeling. For instance, in Nelson’s article she states that Basketball Star Lisa Leslie has received more attention for being a model than for leading the Americans to an Olympic victory. That’s ridiculous because there are more models than women athletes; she should have more attention on her big accomplishment rather than her posing in her swimsuit. Why do women…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics