Girls are often shunned away from little league games due to the toughness, manliness, or the possibility of becoming a tomboy. In addition, it is argued that girls would get hurt playing baseball and boys would quit the team. (Ring, 2009, p. 121) The idea that girls and boys don't share the same physical abilities in conjunction with excluding girls for their protection are often used a tools to keep girls from playing boys. Girls are expected to play the feminine version of baseball, which was constructed to limit the physical capacities of women and girls and to prevent them from acting in a manly of masculine manner. It is commonly believed that boys are better suit for playing sports and girls are not regarding their physical capabilities.
There are minimal differences in the physical development of boys and girls. Boys and girls are commonly equal regarding their physical capabilities, except that boys have greater forearm strength and girls have a greater range of flexibility. With the proper training or practice these differences can be reduced. It is also argued that girls are more susceptible to injury than boys and that their bones are not as strong as boys. The claim is just as false as the others that are used to exclude girls or women from baseball. According to Dr. Joseph Trog, "any age disparity in bone strength was negligible between the ages of ages of eight and twelve, and if anything, girl's bones tend to be more resistant to breakage than boys."(Ring, 2009, p. 123) If girls are allowed to begin training at an early age there should not be any reason why girls and women should be prohibited from competing and playing amongst men. There are barely any developmental differences between young boys or girls and if there are they can be easily overcome with proper training. "The real difference in sizes and strength show up by the middle of high school, when boys and girls are fifteen or sixteen years old." (Ring, 2009, p. 149) This refutes the belief that young girls and boys cannot play sports together due the so called differences in their physical capabilities. If individuals who are opposed actually did research instead relying on false claims they would see that there is no legitimate reason to separate boys and girls regarding differences in physicality.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the article titled”Face off on the Playfield”, by Judith B. Stamper explores the issues of female athletes competing on traditional boy’s sport team. First, Stamper explain how opponent agree that girl are not aggressive enough. But supporters argue that girl don’t have good equipment like boy. The author also report that some male athletes get uncomfortable having physical contact with girls. Second, girl are too weak to compete. In Addition she emphasised that supporters say Title IX has benefitted girl’s health and how society view girls. Now, more girl are playing sports. Finally Stamper concludes that as the debate over ow Title IX continue, boy are now asking to compete on girl’s team.…
- 119 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Because of all the attention male sports get and all of the notoriety male professional athletes are awarded, it is clear to me that male sports have casted a shadow over female sports allowing the public to overlook its excitement and potential. Baseball is everywhere. The mainstream media is packed full of merchandising opportunities that every talented athlete only dreams of. The media gives a massive a mount of attention to male sports, allowing female sports to appear not as necessary or worth wild. It is unfair, when each athlete, whether it is baseball or…
- 707 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“‘You play like a girl’” used to be one of baseball’s classic insults. Not anymore. Softball diva Jennie Finch made it cool to not only throw like a girl, but to run, field, and hit like one, too. Not since Babe Ruth has a player dominated so completely from the pitching rubber and the batter’s box. Jennie also accomplished something Ruth never could: she showed the boys it’s okay to be one of the…
- 944 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In regards to the roles of the women and coach with one another, for example, the coach barely cares at first about the team and states "girls can't play baseball", and how he doesn't have a team of ballplayers, but a "team of girls". We however later see a transformation in him that shows his true love of the game, looking past what gender roles were considered back then. Another example is where is Marla, who is a better hitter than most men, yet is almost not allowed in the league because she is considered "ugly". In conclusion, the movie expressed how hard it was for women to be taken seriously outside of "housewife" labels that were bestowed upon them. This film also adds the twist of women struggling to prove themselves as athletes in the 1940s before the Women’s rights movement and Title IX were established, and I believe this movie contributed some insight that way for…
- 363 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The main issues of the memoir genre are that you cannot verify the veracity of the information given in memoirs, as well as a lack of effort in concealing the identities used in the stories. This leads to questions of nonfiction and the writer's integrity, as well as issues between publishers and people who feel victimized by portrayals of them in memoirs. However, memoirs are a captivating type of literature for all who would like to enjoy a story of other’s struggles.…
- 655 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The hot sun was beating down on my neck as I was picking weeds in a field.The humidity is so thick you could cut it with a knife. The smell of grass was in the air. My soft hands were getting blistered. My skin had been browned as it was covered in dirt. I hated my parents for making me do this. A man comes over and asks me to make sure that I don’t miss any. This man was my grandfather. My parents had me dropped me off while they were at my sister's softball game. I was stuck working with my grandfather for the day. He had owned two houses right next to each other, each with a large lot that needed to be maintained. There was a lot of weeds to be picked. This scene happened all too often when I was younger. I did not like this at the time and hated my parents for making me do this work. But working with my grandfather taught me character and work ethic. He himself was a hard worker and wanted me to be like him. I did not understand this at the time and just did not want to be there. In the long run I learned a lot of valuable skills from my grandfather and he became one my most influential role models.…
- 570 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
If you had two teams with the best men and women on each team it would be a great game and people would love it. In fact, if this happened ticket sales would go through the roof and sports would become more popular than they are today. “Sexually-segregated teams perpetuate the belief that female athletes don’t play as well as males”, according to Laura Pappano coauthor of “Playing With the Boys: Why Separate Is Not Equal.” This shows that it doesn’t mean that boys and girls are equal if the boys are playing on boy teams and the girls are playing on girl teams. If professional sports were co-ed it would make for more exciting games.…
- 555 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When I was in the 7th grade I heard an interesting story of life experiences from my friend. She was doing a presentation at my school about her life in Peru. I began to think about it, but I didn’t know that I seriously wanted to become an exchange student until I was in 8th grade.…
- 966 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
With girls on boys’ sports teams, girls can showcase their talent. They can also build a level of comfort with boys and vice versa. Finally, girls can help destroy gender stereotypes by competing with boys. Though critics argue boys and girls on the same team may logistically offer challenges such as coaching and uniform styles, the problems can be easily be surpassed through minor adjustments and innovation. Ultimately, the goal of a sport is to improve mental, social, and social health, and the introduction of a girl on a male team does not harm and even aids the ultimate…
- 624 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many aspects why female and male athletes should not compete together. Although one reason may be because of physiological differences, societal barriers also prevent female athletes from competing with males. What it means to be male or female is one of the hardest things to decipher. This is one of the more bigger struggles between masculinity and femininity. One institution that specifically targets this idea of gender differences is professional sports. Women are challenged because of these gender differences to be accepted into a male dominated institution. Female athletes are encouraged and in many cases forced to under appreciate themselves by the media because of sports. Our society tends to under appreciate women who play…
- 313 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The first baseball game was recorded in 1846 and is credited to Alexander Cartwright’s knickerbockers. The knickerbockers lost to the New York baseball club at the Elysian fields in New Jersey. Then came the establishment of the National association of Base Ball players in 1858 and the world was introduced to the first systematic baseball league. America prides itself on equality, perseverance, and a fair chance for everyone to make it. Baseball today is played by men and women of all ages. even though it has its scandals and woos, it still represents the best that america has to offer. When i was only 10 years old, there was a girl on my little league team. Not only was she one of the best players on the team, but a role model for the other girls that thought baseball was only a guy sport. This represents the american way, that it doesn't matter whether or not you are male or female, you still are able to give it a shot. In football, females are looked as cheerleaders, or people to fill the stands to watch the men play. If a women goes…
- 838 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Six-word Memoir is a scheme originally established by a U.S founded storytelling publication. The publication aimed at presenting a podium for storytelling in all its kinds. For instance, ‘I can’t keep my own secrets’ is a six word memoir that depicts an individual’s tendency to reveal chief secrets or significant past moments in their lives. On the other hand, when I say ‘Alcohol has utterly ruined my life’, then I am simply trying to inform the reader of my continued abuse of alcohol and my bitter…
- 576 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Gender is defined as an ongoing cultural process that socially constructs differences between men and women. This day in age, men still have more privileges than women do. Men have more wealth and power, many role-models are males, and women are seen as child raisers. Dr. Jack C. Watson says that women in sports face such things as “social isolation.” Many women have been put down for sports participation because it is more of a male kind of thing to do and were expected to be more cheerleaders than the actual players. As stated in the Seventh Edition Child Development by Laura E. Berk, “Women is more compassionate than man and has a greater propensity to tears…But the male….is more disposed to give assistance in danger, and is more courageous than the female.” (Aristotle, cited in Miles, 1935)…
- 1230 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
However the popularity of woman's in “men's” sports has risen, and in the majority of our society many girls are pushed to join sports, as much as boys are, such as soccer or basketball, and are placed into leagues where they gain experience for when/if they decide to join their school leagues. As time progresses, I do believe that sports will be seen as vital socialization for men and women, if not in the generation of my generations, children, then in their children. Those of my generation where sports have been a big part of their life, will wish to share that with their children. The joys of being on a team, learning how to cooperate and work with others, no matter how different is vital to human beings regardless of gender. The norm of sports being for 'men' seems to be shifting as more professional athletes are coming out with their sexual orientation. Gay men are often ridiculed and regarded as weak, or 'not real men' the players coming out or demonstrating, “I'm gay, yet I had a successful athletic career in spite of/regardless of my…
- 688 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Girls and boys are scientifically said to have different personalities and ways of thinking for example boys are scientifically said to be a bit more clumsy than girls. Girls are said to think more than boys so that is another reason why girls and boys do not have that bond a girl/boy team may have. Also some sports are just not meant for the other sex for example football yes, a girl may play it, but it is very uncommon that a girl is involved in football for safety reasons same with volleyball boys are not usually involved. So for safety reasons it would not be safe for some…
- 491 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays