Preview

Michael Karkoc's Milgram Experiment: Socially Formed

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1077 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Michael Karkoc's Milgram Experiment: Socially Formed
A 98 year old Minnesota man was accused of committing war crimes during WWII. He could face arrest and extradition to Poland because of his actions. Michael Karkoc was accused of deaths of 44 people in 1944. His son has denied the allegations and claimed it was fake history. Polish investigators had been working since 2013 to find the Ukraine commander. The commander was supposedly part of an organization who ordered soldiers to burn buildings and kill residents in nearby villages. Evidence was found leading to Karkoc, and his handwriting was compared with a list of salaries signed by commanders. US authorities still need to decide on whether to extradite Karkoc, but Polish authorities have said his age will not be a problem. This however, …show more content…
The Milgram experiment demonstrated that people have been socially conditioned to follow instructions by an authoritarian figure. The participants in the Milgram experiment are pressured and almost verbally forced into continuing to deliver shocks to other participants for giving false answers. They had falsely been told the experiment was to determine the influence of punishment on memory. The results showed that 65% of the participants delivering the shocks delivered a fatal amount of voltage even knowing the destruction of it. It is hard for people to disobey because they have been socially conditioned to follow orders. It has been taught from a very young age and throughout school and multiple activities. Karkoc was put into situations where a looming authoritarian figure may have dominated his mindset, and pressured his actions. He was put into an area where it first may have seen like an “experiment”, but gradually became more real. The area became very hostile and made people start to go to extremes because the environment became extreme. It is very difficult for one person to act against the teachings and brainwash they may have experienced from the Holocaust. They were taught in their schools at a young age that they should persecute the Jews and they were socially conditioned to dislike them. In boot camp, soldiers are conditioned into following orders precisely and …show more content…
Forgiveness is given to many people who have acted in self defensive of their families. This was war time, and he was protecting his family from the advancing troops by helping his country win. He was providing food and shelter to his family through his loyal service to his country and orders he was given. If seen from his point of view, it may not seem he is so guilty. He was instructed from his commanders to destroy these villages or else he would die, his troops may die, or even his family would die. He could have been put into a life or death situation involving more than just himself and felt he was protecting the lives of the love ones around him. Karkoc may have been protecting more people than he killed by following direct orders and this is not an inhumane act that many believe it to be. The influence wartime situations had on Karkoc may have caused him to not think of the actions he was doing in a humane sense. It taught him to think of it as wartime, just like the fake prison became a prison, and follow the orders given by his commander similar to the results of the Milgram’s experiment and our socially conditioned selves. Compare the devastation that the United States caused from the atomic bombs. The US is not as guiltless as many believe, and Karkoc is not as guilty as he seems. Karkoc was psychologically pressured and forced into following orders instantly and trying to defend his troop and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The reason is, as Weschler states, “Such interethnic violence usually gets stoked by specific individuals’ intent on immediate political or material advantage, who then calls forth the legacies of earlier and previously unaddressed grievances. (Weschler 784)” The author emphasizes that violence is often fueled by few individuals’ greed of political power and material gains. Hence, when we judge the immoral crimes of war criminals, it would be too rash for us to simplify or generalize that each individual of the criminal group bears the guilt and the responsibility of the war crimes. However, we cannot ignore the fact that the actions of individuals are often influenced by the pressure and the expectations of…

    • 1901 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Fact, former Helicopter pilot Lawrence Colburn had said he saw captain Earnest Medina kick and shoot an innocent Vietnamese woman.(3) “Captain approached the women looked down at her kicked her with his foot, stepped back and just blew her away.”(3) From this statement alone you can see Lt. Calley isn’t the only guilty one. Another helicopter pilot Hugh C. Thompson also stated that a soldier said “yeah we will help them out of their misery.”(3) The Geneva Convention clearly prohibits violence to a life and person in particular murder of all kinds.(4) These were supposed to be the good guys but their actions say otherwise.…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andersonville Prison

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After the war, Wirz was charged for personally murdering 13 of the Union soldiers held captive at the prison camp. It was alleged that Wirz had murdered thirteen Union prisoners of war at Andersonville by shooting, stomping, subjecting such prisoners to the mauling of bloodhounds, and various other mistreatment. However, this is controversial. There were 160 witnesses called to the stand to testify, who all were prisoners. 145 of the witnesses claimed that they had no knowledge that Wirz had murdered anyone at all, and claimed that if he had actually committed these crimes, they most certainly would’ve heard about it. Talking was all that the prisoners could do at the camp, and if these crimes had happened, they would’ve discussed it while in Andersonville. Also, the 13 people who were claimed to be “murdered” were never identified. James Madison Page, an inmate at Andersonville said, “Fictitious men do not need names (Wirz Trial)”. Wirz however, was found guilty on 11 of the 13 charges of murder and for conspiring with high officials. He was sentenced to death and executed on November 10, 1865. Henry Wirz was the only person executed for war crimes during the Civil War.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nearly half a century after they were conducted, Milgram’s (1963, 1965, 1974) obedience studies remain among psychology’s most widely known and most often discussed experiments. Briefly, under the guise of a learning study, an experimenter instructed participants to administer increasingly powerful electric shocks to a ‘‘learner’’ when the learner made mistakes on a memory task. Although in reality no shocks were delivered, participants were instructed to start with a 15-volt shock for the learner’s first mistake and to increase the voltage in 15-volt increments for each successive mistake. In the basic procedure (Experiment 5), participants could hear the learner’s vocal protests and demands to be set free through the wall that separated…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the experiment, the subject is told by the experimenter to give shocks from a scale of low to dangerously high to the person in the electric chair (who was an actor) when they give a wrong answer. The shocks were not real, but prior to the experiment, the subjects were given a small shock to influence them that the shocks in the experiment were true. After the experiment, Milgram assesses that “between the command and the outcome, there is a paramount force, which is the subject’s capacity for choosing their own behaviour” (p. 851). Although there were people who acted in immoral ways and increased the shock levels, there were also those who chose to renounce the unjust commands of authority, “providing affirmation of human morals and ideals” (p. 851). Therefore, people do have a choice in refusing to abide by authority’s rules and demands, but they choose not to because they do not want to suffer the…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Several minutes later Lieutenant Calley returns and says “How come they aren’t dead?” The soldiers then turn to kill them although some seemed apparently uncomfortable and unwilling to do so. The situation in which the soldiers are left alone with prisoners display a similar behavior as witnessed with Why My Lai 1st semester project 46 the subject in the above mentioned experiment. After leaving the soldiers alone with the orders to “take care of them” they show subtle sympathy towards the gathered prisoners in “sparing” their lives rather than shooting them right away. This of course can be interpreted in the individual soldiers’ sense of moral ethics towards his fellow man, but under the circumstances of this specific, somewhat chaotic and brutal event one could just as much assume they are meant to kill the prisoners instead of simply guarding them. Comparing this situation with the experiment we encounter a slight problem when taking the concept of consequence into consideration. For the participant in the experiment there was no immediate consequence in not being obedient to the experimenter and raising the shock level when required. However, for the soldiers in the mentioned situation, they faced an authority figure which during the massacre was known to be life threatening towards the soldiers if they did not do what was ordered. The results of the experiment and the mentioned example differ as we look closer at a situational perspective; nonetheless we see similarities of the two when looking at the result of the given order in the absence of authority. The soldiers involved in My Lai were all part of an institution larger and more powerful than any of those used in the Milgram…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’Brien felt like he had to be at the war because of people in his community and would have felt ashamed if he didn’t go to war. The war in some of the people of the communities eyes felt like the war was a privilege not a right to go to war, so that means that Tim has to think that the war is an immunity granted to him. He says about the man he killed, “He would have been taught to defend the land was man’s highest duty and highest privilege. He had accepted this...He could not picture himself doing the brave things his father had done, or his uncles, or the heroes of the stories.” (119) This shows how Tim O’Brien had the same complications as this young man he had killed. He had felt like he himself and the soldier could have been so much more and followed their dreams. The soldier and him felt the expectations of his community and family. When he said in the text that he had to do the brave things his family and the heroes had done that he had to follow the tradition and put his whole dream to the side just to fit into the communities expectations, which leads to the stereotypical pressure put on them to follow…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stanley Milgram, born a Jew, wonders how he was fortunate enough to be born and raised in the United States, however, he was still impacted by the Holocaust. He felt very passionate about the Holocaust and feels guilty that he hadn’t died in the concentration camps with his fellow Jews in Europe (Miller, 2015). Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University, sought out the reasoning behind why Nazi soldiers blindly obeyed authority, especially after the Nuremberg War Criminal trials in World War II (McLeod, 2007). The Nuremberg War Criminal trials consisted of thirteen trials against the higher ranked “Nazi war criminals.” The Nazi criminals killed innocent Jews but proceeded to do so anyway during the Holocaust (Nuremberg Trials, 2015). Some of the Nazis knew killing Jews was immoral, but claim they were “just following orders.” The fact that Milgram was a Jew (Miller, 2015) accompanied by the testimonies in…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abu Ghraib Research Paper

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The report further incriminated the 372nd military police company under Karpinski. "Taguba found that between October and December 2003, there were numerous instances of sadistic, blatant, and wanton criminal abuses of prisoners." (43)…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1968 during the Vietnam War, the Charlie Company led an attack on the small village of My Lai 4. The settlement was inhabited by Vietnamese civilians and harbored no military-aged men. One of the platoon leaders, Lt. William Calley, directed the murders of many defenseless civilian women, children, and the elderly. About five hundred civilians were found in mass graves after the massacre. The buildings of the settlement were also destroyed. This is similar to the killings of the surrendering Indians of Sand Creek and subsequent burning of the village. Calley and Chivington both also fabricated military reports in an attempt to cover-up the truth. Despite the nature of both massacres being exposed for the public, no significant punishments were ever enforced on either Calley or Chivington. No criminal charges were ever filed against Chivington, and the criminal charges filed and convicted against Calley ultimately resulted in no punishment due to public and presidential support of him. Ultimately, these massacres have shown that our military has many times acted inhumanely towards other ethnicities and nationalities only to receive a slap on the wrist in punishment, as well as the significant condoning of these actions by American…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Were suppose to be helping, not killing the innocent. At least fourteen soldiers were tried for court, only one was convicted for life in…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    While propaganda not only led to discriminatory policies and violence, it also had a substantial psychological effect on its victims. On the side of ethnic Germans, propaganda played a pivotal role in reinforcing certain beliefs. For instance, it strengthened the idea of Aryan superiority, which boosted the perpetrator’s sense of entitlement and superiority over others. This feeling was one that was key in allowing an environment of anti-Semitic ideology to flourish. Propaganda was crucial in fostering psychological distance between perpetrators and their victims, making it easier for acts of violence to be carried out against Jews without empathy or guilt.…

    • 1685 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust, the annihilation of millions of Jews and other minorities directed by Adolf Hitler, was a tragedy that overwhelmed Europe during World War II. The Holocaust is still a popular topic in the modern-day classroom and the discussion of hatred, negative stereotypes, and genocide remains as relevant as ever. This horrific historical event continues to teach the world lessons on the importance of respect, the influence of discrimination, prejudice, and obedience, and how, despite World War II appearing as the distant past, the messages and importance of the Holocaust still resonate through the population today. The Holocaust is seen as the pivotal moment of hatred in human history.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Just like soldiers coming home in the (moral logic of survivor guilt by nancy sherman). The narrator feels responsible for ks death just like all the other soldiers…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milgram experiment tells us about human and obedience. Humans are socially adapted to the society they live in and obedience is when a group humans follows the rule no matter wrong or right. Humans are usually obedient in most situations. That is due to teachings they receive. For example, when Hitler was killing groups of people, it was wrong; but the group of authority just listen to him and followed the rules. This situation was wrong and harmful but it was something that they just followed because it was the law of the society. Also, punishment tells humans they can do better in society. Punishment is a tool used to make the person or group obey to the rights of the society. Humans have a tendency to follow demands that are no right. For…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays