Similarities:
1). Both sculptures represent the same popular subject matter who is the biblical David during the battle with Goliath.
2). Both sculptures use marble as the material.
3). Both sculptures show the strength, confidence, beauty and concentration in the hero David during a combat.
Differences:
1). Michelangelo’s David is completed by 1504 and Bernini’s David is completed in 1623 which is more than a century later.
1). Michelangelo’s David comes from High Renaissance and Antiquated background. Bernini’s David comes from Italian Baroque background.
2). Michelangelo’s David is nude and about 17’ in height and Bernini’s David is life size with a robe on.
3). Michelangelo’s David presents a moment before the battle. His facial expression shows intense focus of the future event that he would be engaged into. He is thinking about his strategy against Goliath. Michelangelo’s work represents an intellectual David.
Bernini’s David presents the second before he launches the stone from his sling, which kills Goliath. His facial expression is full of energy and determination. His body twists to one side and is ready to launch the stone at Goliath. This is a more mature David with a body full of strong muscles that is completely engaged in the action. The sculpture broke new ground in its implied movement and its psychological intensity. Bernini’s work represents a more physical David.
4). Michelangelo created his David with a perfect human form which attracted viewers to follow the lines and texture from the head to his legs. Viewers enjoy observing the sculpture for its fine tone details in David’s intense face, tilted head, flexing arms and strong legs.
Bernini created David to draw viewer’s attention to the movement. The lines and texture are not as detailed and smooth as Michelangelo’s David is, but he utilized the surrounding space to draw viewers’ eyes to the movement of the arms, hands, legs and make viewers feel as if they are at the scene of the battle.
Michelangelo and Bernini are both extraordinary artists who created the same David with dramatically different sculptures, which represented their eras and set standards throughout history.
References and Works Cited “Gian Lorenzo Bernini”. Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica Online. Encyclopedia Britannica Inc. 2014. Web. 15 Jan. 2014
References: and Works Cited “Gian Lorenzo Bernini”. Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica Online. Encyclopedia Britannica Inc. 2014. Web. 15 Jan. 2014
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Silver plate of the Battle of David and Goliath is from the Byzantine art period. The Byzantine plate was created in 629 to 630. Within the Byzantine Empire, it shared Roman legal and political traditions, customary Greek culture, and Christianity. This stunning plate is the major plate of the set of nine; it displays the scene of the King David’s life in the Old Testament. The artist interpretation will be examined. This study of plate will trace the subject matter of iconography, function and composition of the work and style.…
- 878 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Humanism, during the Renaissance period not only involved the study of ancient culture, but it also instilled a sense of respect towards human beings. Many artists at the time focused on the beauty and elegance of the human body. One of these artists was Michelangelo, a sculptor and painter. One of his most famous pieces of work was “David”, a 17 foot tall statue of a man. Michelangelo focused on making the statue as realistic as possible, in order to capture said elegance and beauty. Also, due to the context of the statue being directly after David had slain the goliath, Michelangelo chose “David” to be in a victorious pose. This…
- 457 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
If we add into the comparison the sculpture of David done by Donatello we see some similarities to both Michelangelo’s version and to Bernini’s version and we also notice differences from both other sculptures, as well. The first and foremost major difference of Donatello’s David as…
- 520 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Michelangelo and Verrocchio both have incredible artistic talents and show it in each of their David sculptures, yet they both convey a different meaning of David in their own ideal and using their own medium. Michelangelo and Verrocchio both represent David in different ways through the meaning they convey, the skills and techniques they use, and the beauty that they each portray . Michelangelo and Verrocchio are both artists from the city of Florence, Italy. In this piece both artists were trying to portray the biblical scene of David fighting Goliath, and winning. Their backgrounds have a major influence on the way they…
- 1044 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Christ is shown only wearing cloth around his waist. Both of the sculptures feature Mary and Christ with smooth skin, a remarkable touch considering the materials used and the techniques used to make the works. Although the pieces are very similar, there are differences between them in terms of material, style and degree of realism. Pieta created by Tilman Riemenschneider was made out of wood while Pieta made by Michelangelo was created out of marble stone.…
- 550 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The expression on the faces of each character in this painting drew me in even more. I wanted to know more: Why? Who? What was about to happen? At first glance, it seemed as though the woman in the background, Clytemnestra the mother, is being disturbed. King Agamemnon, the man portrayed in the foreground, appears to be directing the soldier, Achilles, as he is about to strike. After reading the history behind the painting, I better understand the expressions shown and see how they enhance the story that David is portraying.…
- 956 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
I am comparing Bernini’s David of the Baroque era and Michelangelo’s David from the Italian Renaissance. Michelangelo was considered the greatest living artist in his lifetime, and ever since then he has been held to be one of the greatest artists of all time. He was an Italian sculptor, painter, architect, poet, and engineer of the High Renaissance. Michelangelo’s David was a masterpiece sculpture, created between 1501 – 1504 that is a marble statue, of a standing male nude. The 17 foot statue was placed in Galleria dell’Accademia, Florence. The statue represents a Biblical hero named David, after he made his decision to fight Goliath but before the battle has actually taken place. A moment between conscious choice and action. Gian Lorenzo Bernini was an Italian artist and a prominent architect who worked principally in Rome. He was the leading sculptor of his age, credited with creating the Baroque style of sculpture. Bernini’s David is a life-size marble sculpture, created between 1623-24, located in Galleria Borghese, Rome. This statue represents the biblical David, about to throw a stone at Goliath, which will allow David to behead him. The biggest difference in the two sculptures is the moment represented. Michelangelo chose the moment before the fight while Bernini chose the split second when David is launching the stone from his sling. Bernini’s body is violently twisting bursting with energy while Michelangelo had stored in his figure. Bernini has literally created an event frozen in time during the fight and Michelangelo’s was before the fight. The statues are similar because they both were innovative with respect of the ancient tradition that created works that were perfectly balanced, but not as perfectly evocative. The statues represent the same character, the David who beats Goliath, and they both embody the ideal of male form in a natural setting rather than posed.…
- 496 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Michael Angelo’s David was reminiscent of Greek classical sculpture. His David has a look of contemplation, almost like he was in deep though about to contemplate his near future. Michael Angelo’s sculpture was probably meant to depict David before he killed goliath and the fear he felt before he fought the giant. His David is Reminiscent of Greek sculpture and their practice of idealism. Idealism was the expression of what the artist thought to be perfection of human the human form. David stands in the Greek contropostal standing position in which his weight is shifted opposite of his shoulder, this makes sculpture look more naturalistic.…
- 574 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Therefore, “David,” is a fit symbol of courage and civic duty to guard the city. Standing 13’5″ tall, the double life-sized David is depicted patiently waiting for battle, prepped with slingshot in one hand and stone in the other. Michelangelo, in his mid twenties, carved the David after he had already carved the Pieta in Rome. He carved this sculpture from a huge block of marble that had been abandoned decades earlier by another sculptor: Michelangelo took on the challenge of living up to Donatello and other precursors who had sculpted the same heroic figure. Instead of creating David to look relaxed and confident after his victory, Michelangelo's David looks tense and ready for combat. His brow is furrowed, the tendons in his neck are taut, as are the muscles in his nose and lips, and his eyes are focused on something in the distance. Despite this mental concentration, he stands in a relaxed “contrapposto” position, with his sling casually thrown over his left shoulder. This combination of intense expression and calm pose is intended to capture the short period between the decision to fight and the fight itself. The statues hands and head appear to be disproportionally large for his body, possibly because they were deemed more visually important for viewers who would see the statue high up…
- 1347 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Donatello’s and Michelangelo’s David are similar in many ways. Both sculptures being from the Renaissance, they share some characteristics in form. Each artist positioned the body of David in the contrapposto position. Their bodies are curved, relaxed and shown in the nude. This reflects the popular style of sculpture of the culture and relates the ideas about the human form. Donatello’s David is different from Michelangelo’s most in the physical attributes of the body. Michelangelo’s David has more of the sculpted bodies of the Greek gods. The sculpture is muscular, mature and his physical beauty is not to be overlooked at. Donatello’s David has the body of a young man still developing into his body. Instead of appearing strong and confident, David appears to have a young boy facing a task much harder and larger than him.…
- 363 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
What is regarded as definite step in Renaissance taste is Donatello's statue David. The statue is the first freestanding nude since Roman antiquity. According to an analysis by Professors Lawrence Cunningham and John Reich, Donatello wanted to show the beauty of David's adolescent form wearing only greaves and a shepherd's hat (Cunningham 12).…
- 833 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
At first glance, I instantly recognized this work to be a depiction of David and Goliath. Since we had previously discussed similar works in class, this particular scene was very interesting to me.…
- 312 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Michelangelo choose one of the most famous story of David, facing a nine foot, bronze…
- 1250 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Donatello rapidly matured his art and soon began creating his own style. In 1408 he finished the life-size sculpture of David. The figure was made out of marble. The figure follows a Gothic style, popular at the time, with long graceful lines and an expressionless face. The work reflects the influences of sculptors of the time. It's very well executed, but it lacks the emotional style and innovative technique that would mark Donatello’s later work. Originally, the sculpture was intended for placement in the cathedral. It was set up in the town hall as a symbol of defiance of authority to Florentines. Michelangelo’s admiration for Donatello is documented for the time of the marble David by a sketch after Donatello’s David. The statue of David would become the most famous body of work by Donatello. He developed his own style of relief known as schiacciato. This technique involved extremely shallow carving and utilized light and shadow to create the full pictorial scene(web). Observations were made that Donatello refrained from giving his works a high finish ,even at the risk of making them seem less attractive at close range ,in order to preserve the vividness of his “artistic handwriting” (Janson 20; vol.2). The harmony of his work melts as in a “fiery glow”, and his personality grows demon-like into his gigantic proportions out of the sturdy workshop tradition of the middle…
- 1695 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Michelangelo had studied anatomy early in his life. He worked on corpses to learn how the body worked. This was important in the creation of David because of the intricate details in David's muscles and overall body appearance. The dedication to his creation is admirable. To study cadavers to perfect your craft to me is beautiful. Though David isn't perfectly anatomically correct (The upper part of his body is larger in scale than his lower) it was believe that this statue was intended to be place on a high pedestal in a church. So when one looks up, the body will seem perfectly proportional.…
- 779 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays