Tyrell Dunn
University of Maryland University College
MODERN TECHNOLOGY AND THE USE OF ELECTRONICS
Modern technology and the use of electronics, especially computers have changed drastically over the last century. While many feel that there is a major advantage for the frequent use of computers, especially for the youth; there are some who oppose the constant use of them and feel as though they can be a bit of a downfall to the learning process overall. While we may all have our personal opinions on how computers impact the youth on writing and also reading. Clive Thompson and David Gelernter, who are both authors have strong opinions on how computers effect students. While Clive feels as though the use of computers encourage the youth to read and write more; David does not agree with the constant use of technology. Both authors have made very strong and valid points on the topic.
Clive Thompson, who is a science and technology writer for the New York Times Magazine feels that since computers, text messaging and different social sites have come available to everyone, it offers kids the opportunity to write more. In this generation kids are constantly texting one another and engaging in various social networks, compared to older generations who only wrote when it was required for them to do so. He makes points by explaining that social media and status updates encourages kids to write more to their audience explaining their daily tweets and online blogs. On this topic, Thompson discusses a lot of research by Professor Andrea Lunsford and finds himself agreeing with her studies; stating that, “ I think we’re in midst of a literacy revolution the likes of which we haven’t seen since Greek civilization,” she says. A lot of socializing starts online and sometimes involves texting, status updates and blogging. It’s giving the young people the ability to express themselves more through their writing, where they effortlessly communicate back and forth with their peers. Clive Thompson makes a great point by explaining how computers effect the young generation into writing to their peers and not just their professor for an assignment. In conclusion, he agrees with Lunsford, stating that,” Technology isn’t killing our ability to write. It’s reviving it and pushing our literacy in bold new directions.” David Gelernter, who received his undergraduate degree from Yale University in classical Hebrew literature and is a professor of computer science at Yale; feels exactly the opposite. Unlike Thompson, he feels that computers should be in the schools and could help accomplish great things in subjects that he feel are being neglected as art and music. The difference is that Gelernter feels as though, “Computers make our worst educational nightmares come true,” he says. He makes a point on how the software on computers computes auto-spelling and also arithmetic. He explains that multimedia blinded students from the fundamentals of actually reading a book, and understanding what the author is conveying to the audience. David explains his theory on his conditions on how a computer should be used. First he states that there should be a new software for children that ignites the child’s imagination to get them to become more involved. Second, he wants to limit the use of computers for only recess and relaxation periods, for the purpose of kids not becoming dependent on it. Most important, he feels like educators should learn what parents and teachers already know: you cannot teach a child anything unless you look him in the face. “The computer’s potential to do good is modestly greater than a book’s in some areas. It’s potential to do harm is vastly greater, across the board.”
The two authors have stated strong opinions about their beliefs on computers, and how they affect the younger generation. The similarities the share, is that computers do offer different opportunities to help them both academically and socially, but we should not ignore that the basics is what students need to be successful and not a short cut.
References
Thompson, Clive. (2002-2003). The New Literacy.
Gelernter, David. (1994). Computers cannot teach Children Basic Skills. New Republic.
Kennedy,X.J., Kennedy, D.M., Muth, M.F. (2011). The Beford Guide For College Writers
References: Thompson, Clive. (2002-2003). The New Literacy. Gelernter, David. (1994). Computers cannot teach Children Basic Skills. New Republic. Kennedy,X.J., Kennedy, D.M., Muth, M.F. (2011). The Beford Guide For College Writers
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Amy Goldwasser discusses about how young people of today do not read and write like people in the past have done. She uses various types of evidence to support her argument such as statistics, personal statements from other people and descriptions of the past along with examples of books and speeches. In particular, she notes what Doris Lemming describes the new generation as “a fragmenting culture" in which "young men and women … have read nothing, knowing only some specialty or other, for instance, computers” (qtd. In Goldwasser). Computers is mostly all this generation knows,…
- 364 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In Andrea Lunsford’s essay “Our Semi-Literate Youth? Not so Fast.” tells the reader that when college-age students or students in general abuse technology, they are prone to become semi-literate. As of matter of fact, Lunsford demonstrated a survey research and came to a conclusion that technology benefits the writing skills of the youth. Lunsford states, “So yes, these students did plenty of emailing and texting……
- 211 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
There are several claims made in Professor Susan D. Blum’s and Marques Camp’s article and essay respectively debating the use of technology and its effect on everyday reading and writing, as well as its influence on education. Both Blum and Camp present their arguments in a negative manner indicating their disapproval of the use of electronics in the school environment. Blum’s article ‘The United States of (Non) Reading: the end of civilization or a New Era?’ displays the argument in an assertive manner that students are not reading enough to the extent that some students don’t view reading as an essential, mandatory deed, but view reading as no more than a mere suggestion, or a recommended activity. This is conveyed by Blum’s astonishment “Sometimes students don’t buy the textbooks” even though their Professors would consider that to be a mandatory requirement to their respective courses.…
- 588 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
For example, Thompson cites Lunsford findings as, “of all writings that the Stanford students did, stunning 38 percent of it took place outside the classroom.” Lunsford is a credible person as she is a professing of writing and rhetoric, and this shows that the evidence that Thompson uses to support his arguments are reliable as they come from a credible person. Thompson also writes says “Facebook encourages narcissistic blabbering, video and power point have replaced carefully crafted essay, and texting has dehydrated language into “bleak, bald, sad shorthand.” This is the position held by those who oppose the internet as a source of the new literacy and instead see it as the cause of the problem experienced by students when…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In addition, not everyone agrees that technology has a positive impact on writing. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” (2008), Nicholas Carr argues that the easy accessibility of information on the Internet doesn’t benefit people much. Carr believes this because the information provided on the Internet does not require much effort to look up, which affects the ways we read, think, and write on certain subjects (Carr) It is not always true. In the article “Studies Explore Whether the Internet Makes Students Better Writers” (2009), he reports on findings to determine whether or not technology has a positive effect on student writing. He quotes Stanford student, Mr. Otuteye and his belief on the effect of technology on student writing.…
- 204 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Clive Thompson, in his chapter excerpt “Public Thinking,” from the book Smarter Than You Think: How Technology Is Changing Our Minds For the Better published by Penguin Group, argues that the development of technology of mass communication improves the user’s writing and their ability to collaborate. To support his argument, he incorporates statistics to show the enormity of the production of writing, anecdotes to connect with the reader’s emotions, experiments to support the claim that people perform better in front of an audience, Stanford Study of Writing to support the claim that students are writing more than before and history to debate how the scientific progress would have been furthered with the current ability to collaborate. His purpose is to explain how technology improved the users’ thinking and writing in order to convince his audience that it has made people more intelligent. Thompson adopts an informal tone for his audience of students and parents by using simple language and pronouns.…
- 1671 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Some might have said that Google invent new innovative ways to learn. In “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr’s that the internet is a threat to our brains, but there is no evidence of such cause. I found that the internet is a tool when it comes to reading, studying, and anything that I am able to find on the internet. We are in a world that enable us to learn much than in a book could which might lead to believe that technology can improve teaching and learning, but there still some continue to insist in traditional reading or writing. For example, the baby Boomer generation might be more resistant to rapid technology changes and prefer to pick a book instead figuring out how or what technology could improve one reading or writing which a lot generation X prefer to do. We have to integrate both generations to find median ground to understand digital application can improve teaching and learning due to why literacy matter. We need to able to guide the…
- 538 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The advances in technology that focus on communication have completely transformed over the years leading to all new types of ways to connect with someone like through text messages and virtual apps. These advances affect numerous people ranging from students to possibly a boyfriend miles away but what affect do these advances actually have? Michaela Cullington’s “Does Texting Affect Writing?” and Jenna Wortham’s “I Had a Nice Time with You Tonight. On the App.” each address this topic through similar arguments. Cullington bases her argument on the idea that texting does not have an effect on writing. She focuses on research and opinions of others as well as gaining a closer insight through her own research. Cullington’s intends to reach out…
- 1201 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In the article “The New Literacy” by Clive Thompson, he argues alongside with Stanford University professor Andrea Lunsford that technology, specifically social media, is improving students’ writing ability. There is a great deal of debate when judging social media and how it has affected this generation for the better or worse. According to Thompson, Lunsford indicates that technology is motivating and improving the writing capability of our peers today. Personally, I disagree with Thompson’s positive outlook on the effect social media has on students’ writing capability and believe that social media has destroyed and continues to destroy students’ proper writing technique.…
- 1013 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Lenhart, A., Specialist, S. R., Smith, A., Specialist, R., Macgill, A. R., Manager, P., et al. Writing, Technology and Teens - Pew Research Center. Index of /. Retrieved July 16, 2012, from http://pewresearch.org/pubs/808/writing-technology-and-teens…
- 1695 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Secondly, people should moderately use technology because an over-use of technology, such as in the use of social media sites, causes a vulnerability in real-life social skills. In “What’s the Matter with Kids Today?,” Amy Goldwasser incorrectly points out that children should use their form of reading and writing in their social lives and apply it to education. Goldwasser refutes against the claims of the older generation in that the Internet has negative consequences on children and instead, argues that the Internet beneficially impacts children because it is a form of communication that is composed of a generation of writers, activists, and storytellers. She believes that the internet has encouraged teenagers to “read and write for fun;…
- 1036 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Frequent text message users, social media advocates, and opinionated bloggers all write about various topics, but how does that compare to classic writing? Clive Thompson, author of Smarter Than You Think, continuously supports his mark that the Internet, regardless of its credibility, is progressively transforming today’s way of writing, allowing society to write more effectively and for longer lengths. Based on Thompson’s claims he makes in “Public Thinking”, it is apparent that appeals to logos, collaboration, and audience have helped immensely to express his argument of how technology is impacting modern writing and our society as a whole.…
- 905 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Nicholas Carr believes that the internet is having a negative impact on the way we read and write. In this article he states, “I’m not the only one. When I mention my troubles with reading to friends and acquaintances—literary types, most of them—many say they’re having similar experiences. The more they use the Web, the more they have to fight to stay focused on long pieces of writing.” Here he describes how the internet serves as a distraction to him while reading. I can relate to this statement because I also feel a sense of distraction while reading and having the internet to my access. Just like Carr, I too find myself not being able to sit down and enjoy a book like I would eight years ago. The main for this may be because of technology. Whether it’s coming from a phone, computer, or tablet social networking also plays a big role in many lives today. With the list of social networking sites rising, you can also expect the users to increase as well.…
- 1014 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
One implication to the university students as a whole are that students are ineffectively taught, leading them to have unrealistic views of their writing skills. The article mentions this briefly, in that students are rushed through the education system without learning proper writing skills (Simkin, Crews, & Groves, 2012). Because teachers in high schools do not take the time to critically evaluate the writing skills of students, they are often given good grades which then builds up an ego. This ego is what allowed them to have such confidence in saying that they were at least average or above. The study proves this by showing that students that had enough knowledge to get into the business program are below average when it comes to writing skills, which would not be the case if they were critically evaluated during high school. This article is implying that an English mark of “B” or average in high school is really below average. Another implication of the article is that of technology. Technology is often blamed as being one of the reasons of falling literacy rates among the youth. The article states that text messaging is degrading the language skills of university students, technology may also be the reason for the reduction in the reading of literature by adults and kids alike. The drop in the population that reads literature from 57% to 47% from ages 18-34 could also be due to technology becoming a distraction. Reading is often an activity people derive pleasure out of, but in today’s fast moving society, young adults would rather spend hours on social media then reading novels, which in turn boosts ones writing and grammar skills. Although the article does not specifically comment on this, it is implied via the statistics of the dropping literacy rates in America. The last general implication also has to do with word…
- 977 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many notable advances made in technology that took place during the twentieth century. The world gradually moved from the industrial age into the technology age during this era. Once technology took hold nothing could hold back the flood of its advancement and the innovation that grew from it. Of all of the important advancements three standouts that are intimately connected are the inventions of the radio, computers, and the internet. The radio could be said as the beginning of the information age and the sharing of information worldwide.…
- 748 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays