I agree with the article “Testing times for NAPLAN” that the NAPLAN testing in which a million students in years 3,5,7 and 9 undertake numeracy and literacy tests should be banned . NAPLAN constricts teaching and learning, stifles creativity, pressurises kids and schools ,leads to comparison with other schools and does nothing to improve the students learning . NAPLAN will not improve Australia’s education system, indeed it is making it worse. Teachers do not get the chance to see the test papers of Individual students therefore the teachers cannot discuss results with students i.e. where the student went wrong and how they could improve . Parents, Teachers and students never even get the chance to receive the answers sheet so there is virtually no way telling were the student has gone wrong. Schools don’t know how to improve their learning problems to well after the NAPLAN results have been sent out in late September or October almost six months after these tests have taken place. Many schools spend the weeks prior to the test dates in preparing for the tests, stressing out students and stifling their creativity. This over preparing for the tests wastes the lessons time in which students should be learning other things. Schools and students must take time out of the school day just to complete the tests in which many students finish with plenty of time to spare. This just wastes teachers ,students and parents time .The NAPLAN tests are required to be taken at the same time this could interrupt many schools time frames with students doing the tests during their lunchtimes and before their school is usually meant to start ,and honestly what is the reason for this is it just so one student doesn’t text their friend at another school the answers to question 18 ?
Since the recent creation of the myschools website ,in which the government publishes the schools NAPLAN results online comparing it to other schools. This addition of a website now encourages many schools to cheat by having teachers change the answers or having a large class discussion about the questions or using a calculator in a non-calculator test this all just so the school can perform well. I’m pretty sure that the point of learning is not to be compared to others and just compare yourself to you so why compare a school to other schools?
Another point I would like to raise is that The Australian government says that the environment is important and that we should be sustaining it for future generations when about 12,000 trees are being cut down each year for these pointless tests I am honestly starting to doubt whether our government care about our precious environment after all. These tests cost the government around $100million each year ,this money could be spent on things like disabled people and hospitals. So why would you waste this money on something like pointless tests ?
In conclusion I believe that the NAPLAN tests should be banned because it stresses out students ,compares schools unfairly ,costs too much money and ruins our environment.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Standardized testing has been a controversial subject amongst many people. Many of the Grade 12 Provincials Examinations have been removed from the academic courses; thus, creating a dispute. In the article “B.C. Education: Eroding standards, endless conflict” by Jerry Mussio, the author shows support in standardized testing and discusses how eliminating the testing has had an adverse impact in British Columbia. Mussio claims that eliminating the Provincial Examinations has had a negative effect in British Columbia’s education system.…
- 362 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
During an evaluation performed over the last few weeks for the Kelsey Elementary School Website, Team B has noted that there were many pieces of information that were gathered as to the strengths and weaknesses of the company. We thoroughly examined these strengths and weakness and determined the 5 best possible fixes to update.…
- 959 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Teachers and schools should be held accountable, but not judged by some test that is a blanket test. This act takes away the ability of teachers to actually be able to teach, they just instruct to what is on the test. Students learn at different levels; this test hurts those students that may not learn quick as the others or learn in the same way. The NCLB is an even bigger problem in areas such as Chicago, Atlanta schools with children that come from poorer families and do not get the help they need at home.…
- 468 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Firstly, NAPLAN interferes with the school curriculum. So much importance is being attacted to this test that other subjects in the school course become forgotten as teachers focus more on NAPLAN. In preparation for this ‘so important’ test, teachers centre their teaching around certain topics and other subjects that are just as essential to a students learning seems to be deemed as insignificant. Much time is also put into the preparation for NAPLAN. The national survey conducted by the University of Melbourne found that in four months before NAPLAN, teachers had already started holding practise tests, while some were holding DAILY tests. The time spent being wasted on NAPLAN could have been put to better use, such as focusing on the curriculum, and actually benefitting the students and their learning. Restricting the time means that teachers are trying to force a large amount of content onto students without properly teaching it. The schools curriculum so that students are learning the correct and necessary material, but the interruption caused by NAPLAN means that teachers fail to do this.…
- 374 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Introduced in 2005 to promote transparency and accountability in the public sector. It is retrospective and information can be sought from any time in the past. Any person can request information for a school however this must be done in writing. Schools have a duty to provide assistance and advice to…
- 999 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
The excruciating examination process in which thousands of pressured students who are not fully ready to take an exam, must prove what they have ‘learned’ to aggressive and rapacious examiners, only a minority being selected in the vast marine of shinning students who have just been unchained of the shackles of school work and deadlines? And the rest...? They are left to dry out in the harsh world, to be taunted for doing miserable on that one day, not being given another try. Exams deteriorate us and oppress our very lives making our everyday routine revising and reiterating for an exam that can determine our whole life. The 2 sided pages trap us into our failure, whilst the time ticks at its loudest, making us write nothing but a single letter on a line which finally concludes our end result. Of course if you are to do well, you are fine, but with the ever-changing ruthless mark scheme it’s very difficult to do just well. The pressure put on the fragile mind only gives the tormenter one choice under the stress leading to the examination. To give up! Even the polite and civilised students fall and loose complete confidence in them self’s, feeling like they ruined there only last chance to shine. NO! It’s exhausting having to prepare for an examination when the end result is marked so harshly, it puts the only courage you have down. Masses of tress being removed, the same tress giving us the air we breathe. Papers and papers and pages and pages... all for a single letter on a line, is it truly worth it? Examinations should be banned from the education procedures to avoid any harm it does to the livelihood of a child’s mind.…
- 663 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I am a freshman from Seguin High School in Seguin Texas; I feel that the Texas education system is corrupt that we as students are learning to test and not to actually learn. We as students retain information for short periods of time to take a test then forget which is one of the reasons I feel that the United States of America is falling behind in the education system. However Texas does not have to be like the rest we need to take away a lot of the tests and not learn to test but learn the information we’re being taught. Not by rushing us to hurry and take a test. Now I understand that we are trying to catch up to the rest of the world however by rushing us students we are not learning to learn but learning to retain information in short bursts to take a test. However I am not saying that tests should be taken away we do need check point but at Seguin High School we are taking state CBA ,s every week or every other week .When I feel that we as students feel that we should not be monitored every second of the day. When a new employee is hired are they assigned tests to show their improvement? No. it is based upon their performs however there are teachers who will give students grades that they didn’t earn so yes there should be two checkpoint tests year but not to determine whether the student passes or fails just to determine where everyone stands and how to alter curriculum. Please respond back…
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Schools across government, independent and Catholic sectors were identified as eligible according to 2008 National Assessment Program on Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) results, the school’s ‘suitability and readiness to participate’, the school’s student background characteristics (enrolment size, student language background, student enrolment data, and community (ie. ‘disadvantage of the school’).…
- 1005 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Passing NCBS is a total wasting of federal money. The author of “The death and life of great American school system” tells us that one cannot fix the complex issue like; education s, with the money itself. Instead of introducing strength in the education system, another issued was developed which was, testing. Through NCLB the school reform program “testing” became the back bone of the education system and largely became a waste of federal taxes money.…
- 504 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The No Child Left behind Act is the central issue of debates in the educational arena. In wanting to provide accountability and close the achievement gaps between various sub-groups of the population, the federal government enacted NCLB in 2002.The act focuses on four pillars: stronger accountability, freedom for states and communities, proven educational methods, and more choices for parents. Since its inception, it has been surrounded by controversy. The (NCLB) divided decision makers from local school systems all the way to the federal level.…
- 1204 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Since NCLB in 2002 saw a large rise in the use of standardized testing America’s PISA ranking actually fell from 18th in math to 31st, science and reading also fell similarly(Walker). Sadly America is raising a very unintelligent generation, who is so worried about learning how to take tests well that they forget to actually learn. We can’t really trust these large testing companies to gauge our education system’s effectiveness when they themselves have repeatedly had major issues with faulty scores on tests. Legislators from across the country should come together to not only save our country money, but to protect this country’s future, the next generation’s…
- 766 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Every parent wants to have the best education possible. State and local government have always been responsible for education from kindergarten through 12th grade. The federal; government was more for equality of education. The federal government, state and local authorities have all proposed ways to make education better for everyone. The No Child Left Behind (NCLB) act was proposed just for that reason. Even though it was proposed by the federal government, the states still set the standards for the testing. Since the proposal and enforcement of the act, there has been a great debate about the effectiveness; however there is data that shows the constructiveness of this act outweighs the pessimistic views.…
- 3566 Words
- 15 Pages
Powerful Essays -
believe it is wrong to allow just a single test to decide whether an entire…
- 1352 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
testing should be abolished. NAPLAN stands for the National Assessment Program- Literacy and Numeracy and it is a test designed to assess the academic performance of students. I don’t believe that there is much point to the test. Some students get so stressed and worried about the test it’s unhealthy. While preparing you for NAPLAN it doesn’t make time for other dare I say more important curricular activities. It also does not aid children in their learning. if i had a dollar it wouldnt be enough for tow wnef gnfdksjng dfknbgr gsj rfgk dfgvdfh gg gd fd dfv v v v f f gb fb df b fdb f b fd bv df bfd b df b fd bf b fd b fd b fdb fd b fdb fd b f bf db df b dfb df b fd bd fb f bf b df bfd b fd bf b fd bdf b fd bf b fd bf b d dfb df b b f b fd b df bf mnf knbkjv fdj bjnfd fvhudf vjhuf vjfd fdvn jfdh vj fjd b fj bj fjd b fj vbjf nbv nf bn n bjn j n jn nj bn bj jbk bj b hb hb bh bh hvb hb b b nb bk bjbhhgjhhivghjvbdnf vnfbhkjnv fnvn v cf vcfx v fdvhjdf vfcn vjhxd cvmtesting should be abolished. NAPLAN stands for the National Assessment Program- Literacy and Numeracy and it is a test designed to assess the academic performance of students. I don’t believe that there is much point to the test. Some students get so stressed and worried about the test it’s unhealthy. While preparing you for NAPLAN it doesn’t make time for other dare I say more important curricular activities. It also does not aid children in their learning.testing should be abolished. NAPLAN stands for the National Assessment Program- Literacy and Numeracy and it is a test designed to assess the academic performance of students. I don’t believe that there is much point to the test. Some students get so stressed and worried about the test it’s unhealthy. While preparing you for NAPLAN it doesn’t make time for other dare I say more important curricular activities. It also does not aid children in their learning.testing should be abolished. NAPLAN stands for the National Assessment Program- Literacy and…
- 221200 Words
- 492 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Mooney, John. "Online Assessments Test the Limits of Public School TechnologyHalf of ! ! NJ Districts Lack Adequate Computers, Internet Capacity." NJSpotlight, 25 Sept. 2012. Web. 27 Sept. 2012.…
- 952 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays