Preview

Novel: Of Mice and Men; "Was George justified when he killed Lenny?"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
566 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Novel: Of Mice and Men; "Was George justified when he killed Lenny?"
Of Mice and Men

In the book Of Mice and Men, there are two main characters. George and Lennie, they at first seem like close friends and through the book, they really are friends. From what George does, he doesn't want Lennie's money or anything else. At the end of the book, George only had one option. George did the right thing.

When we first meet George and Lennie, they were running away from Weed, CA for something that Lenny did. A few pages later, Lennie is found with a dead mouse. Towards the end of the book George crushes Curly's hand, kills a dog, and kills Curly's wife. This immediately tells us that Lennie can't control his strength. To me, this was a sign that Lennie wouldn't last very long. Throughout the book, George isn't the greatest friend to Lennie; he never tries to help him but yells at him. If George would have sat down with Lennie and taught him right from wrong, George wouldn't have done what he did and everything would be going just great. Another bad thing about Lennie is that if something bad happens, he tries to hide it, just like kids, if something bad happens they will avoid telling anyone about it. If Lennie told George what had happened, there would probably be a different outcome than what happened.

Many things show that George was the best of friends to Lennie. George did everything that he could to help Lennie; the only problem was that Lennie was a retarded Psycho. Lennie shouldn't have been allowed to work or be around other people without close supervision. George supervised him as much as possible but it just wasn't enough. If George didn't help out Lenny, he wouldn't have had the opportunity to have done as much as he did. George did everything that he could have done for Lennie. If George wasn't a true friend to Lenny, He wouldn't have helped him in Weed. George helped Lennie through many things and it's not his fault that Lennie doesn't know how to control himself; George helped him out a few times such as when Curly was

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Of Mice and Men After reading the story Of Mice and Men, I agreed with George's decision however unethical it may seem. I do not fully condone the death sentence but my opinion still stands. As I will explain, it seems George had no other decision but to take the actions he did to ensure Lenny wouldn't be killed by strangers cruelly and painfully. In a way it was his responsibility. I will explain my reasoning for this line of thought.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    George has Lennie's back in every situation no matter what. George only wants what's best for Lennie. If George didn't care for Lennie he probably would've been dead sooner. When they were in Weeds George helped Lennie escape from the mob that had been sent to kill him, he also took Lennie's work card so he wouldn't lose it. George killed Lennie because he was looking out for him.”I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. I shouldn't oughtta of let no stranger shoot my dog”(61). Candys words came to mind to George and realized that he was the only one Lennie had. He was the only one who got frustrated with him but cared oh so much about him. Lennie had more than just a gunshot coming to him but George instead shortened his suffering by pulling the trigger…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One reason george should not have killed Lennie is because Lennie did not realize how strong he really was. As steinbeck writes, “He shook her then, and he was angry with her. And then she was still, for Lennie had broken her neck”(91) this shows that Lennie was trying to get her to stop screaming, but instead accidentally broke her neck. Also Lennie says, “I’d pet ‘em, and pretty soon they bit my fingers and I pinched their heads a little and they they was dead because they was so little”(Steinbeck 10).…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To further explain, George’s actions couldn’t have been changed due to the fact that Lennie would just do it again, Curly didn’t allow George to stay behind, jail wouldn’t be pleasant for Lennie, George doesn’t kill Lennie out of hate for what he did. To begin, Lennie would unwillingly just keep making the same mistakes over and over again. For example, Lennie touched the girl’s dress in Weed and now he killed Curley’s wife. In the book it states, “Dumb bastard like he is, he wants to touch ever’thing he likes.”(Steinbeck 41) This quotation shows that no matter how many times they run away to another job Lennie will just keep making mistakes. This also shows that he won’t learn that touching nice things…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is clear from the beginning that Lennie cannot tell what's right and wrong. It starts out with Lennie killing small animals such as his pet mice. He then progresses to getting into trouble in Weed because he wanted to feel her soft dress giving them no other choice but to run.When they finally find a new place to stay Lennie gets into more trouble when he kills his puppy and then killing Curley’s wife. At this point he knew that George would be mad but he doesn’t know exactly why so he grabs the puppy's corpse and goes to hide. In Lennie's mind it's better to have one dead thing rather than two. To him taking the puppy and hiding it will mean he will be in less trouble. This is obviously not the case he had killed a woman and didn’t realize how bad of a thing he had done. Some people might say that George did not have to kill Lennie he could have just locked him up or ran. However George had warned him not to do this stuff but Lennie just couldn’t learn from his past mistakes causing him to take someone's…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the beginning of the book we can see that Lennie is an interesting character due to his mental disability. He is a huge, powerful character but he is also very innocent. He seems to have grown up physically but not mentally. In the book George says Lennie is ‘just like a kid’. This is very true because he takes orders from George, he asks George a lot of questions and he is very stupid. George, his best and only friend, even says, “Sure. He’s as dumb as hell.”…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though Lennie doesn't always obey George, he is willing to give up what he wants to do in order for George and him to stay together. Lennie does this because he truly cares about George.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    aggressiveness to compensate for his small stature by picking fights with bigger men. Lennie was a brobdingnagian man. If Curly got a hold of Lennie and killed him, this situation would have been a lot worse than it is right now. There was no other choice for George but to kill Lennie. If George and Lennie kept on running because of this and never looked back, George would have regretted this decision for his whole life. No matter what he did, there…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is clear that Lennie has no sense at all and George has to watch over him constantly. The very first time the men are described it tells us that there is a clear leader ‘they had walked single file down the path, and even in the open’ this shows us that Lennie follows George and sees him as a good example. Lennie is constantly always looking out for George ‘aw, Lennie! I ain’t taking it away jus for meanness, that mouse ain’t fresh’. George always does what he…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lennie is mentally disabled and so always ‘does bad things’, because of this, he constantly depends on George to protect him and get him out of trouble. For example, in Weed, Lennie constantly ‘wants to touch ever’thing he sees’ and this causes him to rip a girl’s dress. Soon, Lennie is accused of rape and only with the help of George is he able to escape imprisonment or maybe even death. Lennie also requires George for simple day to day needs. George helps to keep Lennie in good health, making sure that what he eats and drinks are safe and clean, ‘Lennie for God’ sakes don’t drink so much, I ain’t sure tha’s clean water’. In their relationship, George does almost all the talking to other people as Lennie never really understands what is going on and is not very smart. This is shown when George and Lennie are talking to the boss and George tells Lennie to ‘not say a word’. Without George, Lennie would never have any employment and would not live long. Lastly, George is there for Lennie as a friend and companion. George begins to spend time with him because of a promise to Aunt Clara but a friendship soon grows from that. We know that George really does care for Lennie as in the conclusion of the novel, George confesses that ‘I ain’t angry, I never been angry’ which tells the readers that George didn’t look after him out of guilt or a promise, but that he actually did like him.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One reason george was justified in the decision he made of killing Lennie was the fact that George was the one who vowed to Lennie’s Aunt Clara to take care of him and watch over him and make sure he doesn't get into trouble. This is obvious when George says “ I told his old lady I’d take care him” ( Steinbeck 22 ). Lennie could not function alone, even though he was a grown man. At one time he relied…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lennie may have looked burly and mean, but he was a kind-hearted soul who never meant any harm to Curley's wife. It was a total accident that he did kill her, because of Lennie's mental state. People would have been able to see his condition very easily, in the way he talked, the way he acted around people, and his child-like behavior. These are reasons as to why he would not have been executed or jailed for his crime, well at least not jailed forever. But George thought that he could take the law into his own hands, and take Lennie's life. George must have been thinking that the authorities were either going to kill him, lock him up, or that Curley would seek out revenge. This is where George did wrong. He is worse than Lennie for killing him. Even though they were so close and such good friends, for what reason does he have to kill him? George was scared and Lennie was confused, and George should have taken Lennie into the authorities and plead his case.…

    • 383 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the beginning of the story, George escaped with Lennie from Weed to prevent Lennie from getting lynched. George did absolutely nothing, he had nothing to hide from. Also George warned Lennie about Curley, he told him that he has seen people like that before and demanded Lennie to stay away from Curley (Steinbeck 29). In addition, in order to make sure Lennie got the job, George talked for him (Steinbeck 21). George is like a parent to Lennie, from the beginning we see how he told Lennie that the water he was drinking from didn’t seem potable. He told Lennie to throw the mice away, not to be mean but because it was already dead, it wasn’t fresh. Lennie acted acted like a child and George acted like a parent, he said and did stuff similar to what a parent would. He did all that because he cared for…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George understands Lennie's mental disabilities and was wrong in leaving him alone, regardless of what he told him to do. Also, Curley's wife was aware Lennie was not "right in the head" and basically provoked him into her own death. Of course, Curley's wife did not know that this would escalate to the degree it did but knowing his disabilities should not have allowed him to touch her air, or even hang out with him.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George and Lennie had faced a great deal of injustice throughout the novel. Lennie being one of the main characters in the book also suffers from one of the heaviest examples of injustice. Lennie is big, strong, and mentally ill. He does not realize his own physical strength, and therefore he constantly becomes a victim of it throughout the book. When he starts being picked on by Curley, he doesn't know what to…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays