Letters and Science 121
T-Th 2:00-3:30, 2040 VLSB
Spring 2013
This course explores the concepts of origins in science and religion and their cultural contexts and entanglements, from antiquity to the present. Popular culture tends to emphasize the conflict between science and religion on such issues, particularly, in recent times, with respect to the origin of life and its evolution (including human evolution). We hold that science must acknowledge history, both the history of the natural world and the history of concepts about it, and that religion must deal with the changing knowledge of science, including issues of origins, causation, and teleology. Our guiding questions include: What are origins, and why do we want to know about them? How does this desire manifest itself in different ways of constructing and analyzing knowledge? What sorts of intellectual processes, standards, and tests can be applied to different concepts of origins? What happens when different notions of origins clash? How do we negotiate these clashes in today’s world?
Instructors
Professor Kevin Padian Professor Ronald Hendel
Department of Integrative Biology Department of Near Eastern Studies
5099 VLSB, kpadian@berkeley.edu 276 Barrows, hendel@berkeley.edu office hours: W 11-12 and by appt. office hours: Tu 11-12 and by appt.
GSIs
Dale Loepp, dalel@berkeley.edu office hours: Th 3:30-4:30 and by appt.
Nick Matzke, matzke@berkeley.edu office hours: Tu 3:30-4:30 and by appt.
Yosefa Raz, yosefaraz@berkeley.edu office hours: Th 1-2 and by appt.
Course requirements
Participation (sections), 20%; two short papers (5 pgs), 20% each; Midterm exam, 20%;
Final exam, 20%
Required texts
Ronald Hendel, The Book of Genesis: A Biography (Princeton University Press, 2012) Charles Darwin, The Annotated Origin: A Facsimile of the First Edition of the First Edition, ed. James T. Costa (Harvard University Press, 2011) (paperback)
Other readings posted on class bSpace site
Schedule and readings
Part I. Science, Religion, and Origins
Jan. 22 (T) Introduction: What do origins mean, and how should we study them?
Note: discussion sections will not meet in this first week
Jan. 24 (Th) Science and religion: Contradiction or complement? Read: Gould, “Non-overlapping Magisteria,” at http://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_noma.html ; Coyne, “Seeing and Believing”; Miller, Finding Darwin’s God (excerpt); Collins, “Faith and the Human Genome”
Jan. 29 (T) The structure of science Read: Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, ch. 2-3 (pp. 10-34); and “How Science Works,” at http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/howscienceworks_01 and be sure that you read all 21 webpages in this section.
Jan. 31 (Th) The structure of religion Read: Geertz, “Religion as a Cultural System”
Feb. 5 (T) The structure of secularism (Dale) Read: Taylor, A Secular Age (excerpt)
Feb. 7 (Th) Atheism, agnosticism, theism: What’s the difference and the difference it makes Read: Onfray, The Atheist Manifesto (excerpt); Dawkins, The God Delusion (excerpt); Hitchens, God is Not Great (excerpt); Rosenbaum, “An Agnostic Manifesto;” Haught, “Evolution and Faith”
Feb. 12 (T) Origins of the universe (Eliot Quataert) Read: Bryson, A Short History of Nearly Everything (excerpt)
Feb. 14 (Th) Origins of life (Nick) Read: Pross, What is Life? (excerpt)
Part II. History of the Present
Feb. 19 (T) Creation myths: How and what they mean Read: Enuma Elish; Hesiod’s Theogony, lines 104-233, 535-615, 807-885; Hopi creation myth; and Chinese creation myth (bSpace). Web texts at: http://www.etana.org/node/581; https://www.msu.edu/~tyrrell/theogon.pdf; http://www.indianlegend.com/hopi/hopi_001.htm
Feb. 22 (Th) Cosmology in the Bible and the ancient Near East Read: Genesis 1-3; Hendel, Genesis, pp. 15-44
Feb. 26 (T) Theodicy: God and the problem of evil Read: Job 1-11, 38-42; Ecclesiastes 1-12; and Babylonian Theodicy at http://www.etana.org/node/582
Feb. 28 (Th) From myth to philosophy in ancient Greece Read: Vernant, The Origins of Greek Thought (excerpt)
Mar. 5 (T) Science and religion in the middle ages Read: Hendel, Genesis, pp. 83-90, 146-156; Dallal, Islam, Science, and the Challenge of History (excerpt); Overbye, “How Islam Won, and Lost, the Lead in Science;”
Hannam, “Magic and Medicine”
Mar. 7 (Th) The heresy of Galileo Hendel, Genesis, pp. 156-166; Galileo, “Starry Messenger,” pp. 1-5, 12-15; and “Letter to Duchess Christina,” pp. 1-6. Web texts at http://people.rit.edu/wlrgsh/Galileo.pdf http://www.disf.org/en/documentation/03-Galileo_Cristina.asp
Mar. 12 (T) New worlds and deep time Read: Hendel, Genesis, pp. 176-182; Cutler, The Seashell on the Mountaintop (excerpt) and the reading guide to Cutler. SHORT PAPER DUE
Mar. 14 (Th) The rise of the Cultural Bible (Yosefa) Hendel, Genesis, pp. 166-176; Sheehan, The Enlightenment Bible (excerpt)
Mar. 19 (T) Midterm exam
Part III. Darwin’s Shadow
Mar 22 (Th) Narrative in science Read: Landau, “Narratives of Human Evolution” and the reading guide to Landau, plus “How to read a scientific paper” and skim the paper on Tiktaalik
Apr. 2 (T) The origin of species: What Darwin said and didn’t say Read: Darwin, Origin of Species, chs. 1-4, and particularly the reading guide to Darwin; Padian, “Darwin’s Enduring Legacy” and “Ten Myths about Darwin”
Apr. 4 (Th) Origins of humans and sexual selection Read: Darwin, Descent of Man, Vol. II, Chapter 21, beginning on page 385 at http://darwin-online.org.uk/contents.html#descent
Apr. 9 (T) The descent of humans: Race, slavery, power Read: Genesis 6-11; Hendel, Genesis, pp. 197-208
Apr. 11 (Th) Origins of sex and gender Read: Genesis 1-4, 18-19; Hendel, Kronfeld, and Pardes, “Gender and Sexuality”
Apr. 16 (T) Ethics in evolution Read: Darwin, Descent of Man, pp. 84-104; at http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?pageseq=171&itemID=F937.1&viewtype=side
Apr. 18 (Th) The rise of fundamentalism Read: Hendel, Genesis, pp. 182-95; Bryan, “The Menace of Evolution” at http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/scopes/bryanonevol.html
Apr. 23 (T) Intelligent design and “intelligent design” Read: Padian and Matzke, “Darwin, Dover, ‘Intelligent Design’ and textbooks”
Apr. 25 (Th) The missing link: How we know about evolutionary transitions Read: Lebo, The Devil in Dover (excerpt)
Apr. 30 (T) How we know about evolutionary transitions (part II) Read: Padian Dover trial testimony at www.sciohost.org/ncse/kvd/Padian/Padian_transcript.html (begin reading after the first recess in the transcript)
May 2 (Th) The end of the world: Apocalypse, extinction, or entropy? Read: Hendel, Genesis, 63-82; SHORT PAPER DUE
FINAL EXAM: Monday, May 13, 11:30-1:00
--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Be sure to get this exact version; other editions will be useless.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
[ 8 ]. Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man: 1871, in Sources of the Making of the West: Peoples and Cultures, A Concise History. Volume II: Since 1340, ed. Katharine J.Lualdi (Boston, New York: Bedford St Martin’s, 2007), 131.…
- 4347 Words
- 18 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This course is intended to give students an understanding of the fundamentals of financial and managerial accounting. This knowledge is a valuable asset for any business career.…
- 1113 Words
- 10 Pages
Good Essays -
Darwin, Charles. "The Origin of Species." The Online Literature Library. Knowledge Matters Ltd., n.d. Web. 30 Nov. 2012.…
- 1186 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
•Discuss the ways in which developments in scientific knowledge may conflict with the ideas about the origins of life developed by different cultures:Different cultures and religious in the world have their own ideas about life, it maybe quite different to the scientific evidenceIn biblical creationism different organisms were made for specialised environments at the same time, the organisms that were created have not changed nor are they related.…
- 515 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Trew Chimenti Professor Ellis Cosmic Views and Humanity 30 August 2014 Babylon and the Enuma Elish vs. The Old Testament Throughout the fabric of time, the human race has defined itself on the basis of cosmology. Religion had provided a way for people to accept their very importance in the natural order of the universe, to reflect and understand that creation itself was not random but specified toward the human population. Without an inkling for the beginning, the human mind had developed the multitude of ideas for the creation of the universe, metaphors that allowed a complicated idea to become accessible. Looking at the different religious mythologies, it is easy to see the similarities between them; how the idea of creation had been adapted…
- 901 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This assignment really allowed me to examine those around me and their varying beliefs about creation. I was shocked to discover that people so close to me actually believe in evolution and the big bang theory. I consider it a privilege to have opened up this door to conversation with people I never even considered. The course has prepared me to apologetically defend and explain the creation account and the gospel. Please be in prayer with me as the Lord wants to use me to speak truth to my neighbor. Through the course of this paper I will detail the answers of my interviewees from a survey with many vital framework questions concerning origin. For the survey I interviewed my mother, father, and next door neighbor.…
- 1111 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Offers a comparative approach to religious world views in relation to such questions as the origin of all…
- 6057 Words
- 65 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
References: Darwin CR. (1859)On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. London: John Murray.…
- 750 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Johns, Michael. “Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life.” Rev. of Rock of Ages, by Stephen Jay Gould. Emory Report. 27 Sept. 1999: Print.…
- 795 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Darwin, C., "The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle For Life", London, John Murrary, (1859) :490…
- 2485 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Assess the view that science has replaced religion as the main ideological influence in society today? (33 marks)…
- 823 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Thus, a problem arises if we first allow arguments saying the world is old and then try to make the Word of God fit. Each of us must choose which we will vest with ultimate authority: God’s Word or incomplete human knowledge. Many will argue that science and religion are different realms that do not relate to each other. But this way of dividing or compartmentalizing truth contradicts Scripture. There is one God who created all of reality, and His Word is equally authoritative in all that it reveals to us. If we treat evolutionary ideas as authoritative about the history of the world, this leads us to a distorted view of truth and a distorted view of God’s Word.” (Spencer, 2009)…
- 1393 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history, every society has had some form of myths that have significance or reasoning behind why they have been shared with society. Whether it is myth designed to teach a valuable lesson or a myth that explains something as simple as why the seasons change the way that they do, to these societies they all have played some sort of purpose in explaining why life is the way that it is for them. But while these myths cover that wide range of topics, there is only one myth that can hold distinction of explaining where life itself came from: the creation myth. These are myths that are unique to every culture, society, and religion known to mankind because without them people would not have understood where they and all the living things in the world came from. Two examples of these myths are the Mesopotamian creation myth and the Hebrew creation…
- 1548 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Genesis, a Greek word meaning “origin” or “beginning,” is the title given to the first book of the Christian Old Testament. It is an extremely important book, especially in regards to some of philosophy’s most important questions, such as, “How did the universe come into being?” “Does life have any meaning at all?” and “How do we decide what is moral or immoral?” If fact, the teachings of this section of Scripture, is where the Christian worldview finds its beginning. In this essay, we will look at what the first eleven chapters of the book of Genesis have to say in regards to the natural world, human identity, human relationships and civilization.…
- 1210 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
• Elliott, Paul 'Erasmus Darwin, Herbert Spencer and the origins of the evolutionary worldview in British provincial scientific culture ', Isis 94 (2003), 1-29…
- 13135 Words
- 53 Pages
Powerful Essays