Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Outline and assess the reasons why women might not commit as much crime as men.

Powerful Essays
1134 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Outline and assess the reasons why women might not commit as much crime as men.
Outline and assess the reasons why women might not commit as much crime as men. (50 marks)
The term ‘crime’ means behaviour that breaks the law. For example, someone who commits a crime such as drug offences or theft is considered a criminal. Feminists accept that women commit less crime than men because they are more likely to conform to rules and social controls than men. Based on the evidence in the ‘Official Crime Statistics’ (OCS) of 2009 and 2010 in England and Wales, men are five times more likely to commit crime than women. Surprisingly, ‘violence’ is the second highest of offences done by both genders and the majority of the crime is ‘theft and handling’ for both genders. However, the stats might be socially constructed because the police officers sometimes don’t choose to report crime committed by women.
The statistics are true to some extent; women commit less crime than men. Women conform to the social controls. According Heidensohn, women are generally more conformist because patriarchal society imposes greater control over their behaviour. Also, Smart notes that girls are more strictly supervised by their parents, especially outside the home. For example, girls might get a curfew like not staying out after dark because it can be dangerous for them to stay out that late. Feminists such as Lees state that girls are more likely to be controlled, in that they may fear acquiring a ‘bad’ reputation. She notes that boys in schools often use verbalised sexual labels. For example, they use the label ‘slag’ to control girls. This can lead to girls avoiding any behaviour that is deemed ‘deviant’ in order to avoid these labels which is why women commit less crime than men. However, this view has been criticised because society has changed and social control is balanced.
Male crime might be shaped by masculinity. Men, according to Smart and Oakley, are socialised into ‘aggressive’, self-seeking and individualistic behaviour that may make them more disposed to taking risks and committing criminal acts. For example, some men might assault other men in order to keep their tough exterior and gain respect from other men which is why violence is unavoidable sometimes in most cases. On the other hand, women are socialised into potentially less criminal set of values and norms that stress cooperation, tenderness and caring for others. However, this view has been criticised because society is changing and becoming less patriarchal. Men are becoming less hegemonic because they are in the house taking care of their families which means fewer men become breadwinners.
There are other reasons for why both genders commit crime. According to Croall, teenage girls are usually motivated to commit crime by 3 factors: a drug habit, which often leads to prostitution and shoplifting, excitement or thrill that comes with committing a crime and the conspicuous consumption of goods, for example, designer label clothing, which are often the target of shoplifting. Katz statement is quite similar to Croall’s; young males commit crime for the pleasure or thrill that is derived from the risk of being caught or having power over others. Katz refers to these thrills as ‘transgressions’. Katz argues that men use violence to exercise power over others so that they achieve goals of hegemonic masculinity.
Even though women commit crime, it is because of the lack of education or to care for their family. According Walklate, women do shoplifting and prostitution because they are often motivated by economic necessity. For example, to provide children with food, toys and clothes. Carlen argues that women may commit crimes because they have often failed to gain qualifications and find legitimate work, which is why they usually live in poverty and are dependent on benefits. Another reason might be that their attachment to family life may be weak because they have been abused which is why they run away from home and/or spent time in care. A criticism of this is that Carlen does not explain why majority of women in poverty choose not to commit crime. Also, Carlen conducted unstructured interviews, which has some problems such as, it lack reliability since it can’t be repeated but, it can be quite valid as it shows real-life extension of interview.
However, crime happens due to society becoming less patriarchal. Adler agrees that as society is becoming less patriarchal, women’s crime rates will rise. In other words, women’s liberation from patriarchy will lead to a new type of female criminal because they will have greater opportunity and confidence to commit crime. Michele Burman et al. did a questionnaire survey and found that 98.5% of girls have witnessed, first-hand, some form of interpersonal physical violence. Nearly two-thirds knew someone who had been physically hurt or injured by violence. 41% had experienced someone deliberately hitting, punching or kicking them. 10% of the girls described themselves as ‘violent’ and 10% reported having committed seven or more types of physically violent acts such as punching, kicking and hitting with an object. Some of the disadvantages of using a questionnaire is that sociologists can’t get enough information since the respondents don’t explain and the questionnaire sometimes don’t give the truth. There is also a contradiction to Adler’s statement because less patriarchy only benefits middle-class women.
The statistics on crime is flawed because they are socially constructed. The justice system favours women. Interactionalists such as Pollack agree with the feminist criminologist’s statement that the system is biased against women because male officers tend to adopt ‘paternalistic’ attitudes towards female offender, who are less likely to be stopped, arrested and charged. For example, when committing criminal offences, they are more likely to be cautioned than arrested and charged. Pollack calls this the ‘chivalry factor’. However, this view has been criticized because the police ignore crimes that are committed by women against men i.e. domestic violence.
However, the justice does not always favour women. According to Walklate, women have been raped and put on trial because their original claim was not dealt with effectively. For example, at a court hearing, women might be asked what they were wearing at the time of the incident. However, this view has been criticised because the law serves women better than men, for example, divorce.
The trend of women committing crimes has increased. According to Fagle, the rise in female offenders can be explained by two factors: increase in the number of girls compared to boys and the greater willingness of the public to report crime by girls, the greater willingness to persecute. Thus the crime statistics do not represent the reality of crime for men and women.
In conclusion, Marxists criticise feminists because they state that crime and deviance is all down to social class. They say that deprivation, poverty and inequality are the causes of crime.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are gender differences in criminal behavior solely based up genetic makeup. Gottfedson and Hirschi’s theory provides two facts that make me believe that males are more criminogenic than females. First, as stated in the theory, females are less likely to commit crime because they have higher levels of self control. Second, parents tend to be more vigilant in monitoring girls than boys parents are likely to be more consistent in the application of parental management with girls than boys. Both of these factors I find to be extremely true, especially when dealing with self control. In general, males have more testosterone than females and are more likely to let their emotions get the best of them. When talking about crime I could see how…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A variety of evidence suggests that there is considerable overlap in the “causes” of male and female crime, and that both traditional and more recent theoretical perspectives can help explain both female offending patterns and gender differences for less serious crime. The explanation of serious female crime and of gender differences in serious crime is more problematic. The social backgrounds of female offenders tend to be quite similar to those of male offenders like male offenders; female offenders (especially the more serious ones) are typically of low socioeconomic status, poorly educated, under- or unemployed, and disproportionately from minority groups. The main difference in their social profile is the greater presence of dependent children among female offenders. Female levels of offending are lower than for males. These approaches are less enlightening when differences in female and male offending patterns. For example: Why are serious crimes against property and against persons so much less a feature of female offending? Male criminal participation in serious crime greatly exceeds female involvement,…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Radical feminists such as Heidensohn claim that women’s lower crime rates can be explained in terms of patriarchy. She claims that both in the family and at work men exert power and social control over women. Women who challenge the traditional roles of women within the family run the risk of having them imposed by force. In public, women are controlled by the male use of force and violence, by the idea of holding on to a ‘good’ reputation, and by the ‘ideology of separate roles’. Women often choose not to go out into public places because of the fear of being attacked or raped. Heidensohn argues that the consequence of this control is that women have fewer opportunities to commit crime and acts of deviance whereas men have more opportunity.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Bibliography: Chesney-Lind M. & Pasko L. (2004), the Female Offender: Girls, Women and Crime, (2nd Edition), London: Sage.…

    • 3029 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Smart, C., (1978). Women, crime and criminology; a feminist critique. 1st ed. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender Patterns in Crime- This means that most of the crimes that are being committed are higher by males rather than females. Most of the serious violent crimes that are being committed are higher by males rather than females. This is…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The aim of this essay is to compare, contrast and evaluate two sociological theories of crime causation and two psychological theories of crime causation.…

    • 1985 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The involvement of females in crime and as the committers of crime was once a rare phenomenon but in recent years a dramatic increase has been seen all over the world. In England and Wales statistics have shown between 1994 and 2006 female crimes have steadily increased and have since continued to do so (MOJ 2009). Many sociological explanations and interpretations have arisen to coincide this surge in female offending as to understand its recent development in society. This assignment will look at different feminist explanations and critically evaluate them and their value in understanding female crime.…

    • 2514 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hines & Kimberly (2006) observed that women are also likely to be less aggressive in committing offence as compared to men. They observed that women mostly express verbal abuse and aggression as compared to men who are likely to express it with their…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In terms of age, both sexes, criminal activity appears to peak in adolescence and early adulthood. C.Coleman & J.Moynihan suggests that the Official Statistics are biased in such a way as to over-represent young offenders and under-represent the older offender. In terms of sex criminal statistics in all countries have consistently shown that more males than females appear before the courts and are convicted for criminal activities. Official statistics suggest that women tend to commit a relatively narrow band of offences in comparison to men. The difference can be in part explained by differing socialisation and social expectations. There is the difference of opportunities as men are more likely to occupy public spaces as against the private spaces. However Pollak has suggested that women may not feature so highly in the statistics as they may meet more lenient policing or sentencing with a greater likelihood of a caution or a non-custodial sentence. In terms of ethnicity black people seem to be disproportionately among the known offender population, at least for certain…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Home Office provides details of the known offending behaviours of men and women. For example, a third of men born in 1953 were convicted of an offence before age 45, whereas only 9% of women were convicted before this age (Home Office 2001 as cited…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Feminist Theory Of Crime

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The feminist criminological theory aims to understand minorities in race, gender socioeconomic status and many more and their intersection with one another and their relation to crime. In relation to interpersonal violence and gender, females are greatly underrepresented in studies- particularly regarding those who commit offences. As mentioned above this places a pressure on the legal system that does not know how to properly respond to these women. Feminist theories aim to bridge the gap between males and females in the criminal justice system and provide gender appropriate crime responses for all. Furthermore, breakthroughs discovered in feminist criminology regarding female crime and victimisation may assist in explaining male crime to some extent. Since feminist theory looks at all female crime and victimisation- including crimes involving males- reasons as to why males become victims of female assault and why they assault females are…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women are targeted in the criminal system…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Violence against women (VAW) is an issue that, for many years, was widely unrecognized. However, the rise of the feminist movement in the 1970’s brought this issue back to the forefront of public policy. While the first wave of feminism focused on topics such as women’s suffrage and the right to vote, this second wave expanded to topics concerning sexuality, legal inequalities, and reproductive rights. Women were openly discussing their life experiences and bringing attention to these barriers (Mallicoat, 2015).One of the most important roles this feminist movement played was establishing violence against women as a social problem that concerned not only public health but also the criminal justice system. Having an accurate measure of VAW is…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As I was doing my research I came upon this book titled “The Gender of Crime” by Dana M. Britton. In this book it describes all different crimes and how men and women are punish in the criminal justice system. It states that women convicts are usually more violent, have been given several more chances, and that’s just the way we were raised as society was raised. We were raised to respect women; women shouldn’t be taken away from their children. It also states that men are usually arrested more because they commit more crimes.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics