One of these five ways is observational learning and imitation which is linked to the social learning theory that Bandura put forward. Huesmann suggests that children will observe the behaviour of certain role models they may identify with within the media, and then recreate this behaviour later on. Children tend to imitate behaviour that is successful in gaining the models objectives on TV, which means that vicarious reinforcement may also have to take place in order for the media to have an effect on aggression.
Research to support the social learning theory is the bobo doll study conducted by Bandura, Ross & Ross (1961). 72 male and female participants were placed randomly in two groups; the aggressive and non-aggressive condition. Children in each of the conditions were presented with either a same-sex or different-sex model behaving a certain way towards the dolls. The aggressive role models would use physical and verbal violence on the dolls whereas the non-aggressive models would behave respectfully. Findings show that the children that observed the aggressive condition acted more violently than those observing the non-aggressive condition. Boys also showed generally more aggression than girls, especially if the model they were observing was also male, suggesting that individuals must first identify with a same-sex model in order for the behaviour to be replicated.
However, this study may not fully explain the social learning theory explanation for the influence of media on anti-social behaviour. The bobo dolls are not real and therefore do not retaliate, which questions how valid the study is. Perhaps, if the violence was towards human beings, the children may not imitate. The study also only involves children, which makes it harder to generalise to the wider population; Smith et al (2004) said that children’s behaviour is more likely to be rough and tumble play rather than serious acts of violence suggesting that they may not interpret the models behaviour seriously. Demand characteristics were also present in the study as Noble (1975) found that a four-year-old said “Mummy, look! There’s the doll we have to hit!” before the study was even started, meaning that there are methodological issues with the study and that it lacks ecological validity because it was a laboratory experiment. Another criticism of Bandura’s study is that it can be seen as artificial because it looked at behaviours children do not regularly display. However, Johnston et al (1977) questioned teachers and peers of children who observed an adult behaving aggressively, and found that they generally behaved more violently, suggesting that observation and imitation has an effect on an individual’s behaviour.
Desensitisation is another way that exposure to media violence may lead to anti-social behaviour. Desensitisation is when recurring exposure to violence in the media reduces someone’s intensity of physiological reactions. The brain gets used to the violence and reacts less and less, reducing HR and BP and galvanic-skin responses (GSK). People that are desensitised are therefore less likely to intervene when they see violence and more likely to act violent and aggressive themselves.
Support for desensitisation comes from Carnagey et al (2007) who studied the effects of playing violent computer games on response to real-life violence. Participants were placed into two conditions – one condition was to play a violent game for 20 minutes and the other was to play a non-violent game for 20 minutes. Then, all the participants were shown videos of real-life violence and had their GSR measured. Findings showed that the participants that played the violent game had reduced HRs and BPs, suggesting that increased exposure to violence in the media does result in desensitisation.
However, Cumberbatch argues that this desensitisation is only towards violence in the media; i.e. people aren’t as shocked if they see violence in the media more often. It doesn’t, however, account for violence in real-life. Hagell & Newburn (1994) also found that young offenders watched roughly the same amount of violent TV as non-offenders which suggests that violence in the media does not always result in desensitisation, therefore other factors may be involved. Belson (1978) studied 1565 teenage boys and didn’t find any evidence that exposure to TV violence leads to desensitisation. However, this is a study conducted on teenage boys so therefore it is gender biased and does not account for adults or young children. However, Schamm et al (1961) found that individuals with access to a television showed more anxiety about using aggression than those who did not have access to television.
Although there is a lot of supporting research which shows the effects of media influences on antisocial behaviour, most of the studies and research conducted is done in Western cultures, meaning that the studies are culturally biased. The studies are also conducted on the younger individuals in the population which can therefore not explain how media influences antisocial behaviour in adults; therefore the research has sample bias. Also, none of the studies show the long-term effects of media on antisocial behaviour; they are all short-term. The research therefore is not conclusive; it only shows a positive correlation between media and antisocial behaviour, therefore it does not show cause and effect. The effects of media on antisocial behaviour are likely to be influenced by a variety of other factors.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
One social psychological theory of aggression is Bandura’s social learning theory, in which he combines both social and cognitive psychology in his social cognitive perspective of human behaviour. Bandura believed that behaviour was not only motivated by psychological factors but also by more socio-environmental factors. He argued that the individual and the environment were linked, something which he called reciprocal determinism. Bandura believed that the presence of a role model from whom behaviour could be imitated was the key part of the social learning theory, and that this role model would either be similar to the person imitating the behaviour (e.g. same age or gender) or is in a position of power (e.g. celebrities or parents). Despite this the individual imitating the behaviour still needs to have a level of self confidence in order to imitate, which Bandura referred to as self-efficacy.…
- 731 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
A researcher named Bandura proposed that children could learn just from observation – a statement that was contradictory to previous researchers’ theories. To prove that he was right, he set up an experiment where preschool children would watch films of associates beating up a Bobo doll. After their altercation with the Bobo doll, the associates in the films were either rewarded, spanked and scolded, or had no attention at all. Researchers showed one film to each group of children. Then, the children were observed in a room with a Bobo doll to see if they had imitated the heinous acts toward the Bobo doll.…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Social learning theory was developed by Bandura and is linked to vicarious learning. Bandura found that we observe other people and imitate their behaviours. A prime example of this was Bandura’s Bobo doll experiment. Children observed when a person was fighting a Bobo doll, and then as each child spent time with the doll they then copied this behaviour by hitting and kicking out at the Bobo doll too, just like they had previously seen.…
- 550 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Bandura, Ross and Ross- variation of the Bobo doll study- they compared the effects of real-life, filmed, and televised aggressive role models. They found that children were more likely to display aggressive behaviour when they observed a cartoon or filmed model, in comparison to real-life models.…
- 1288 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The social learning theory can especially be seen in the behaviour of children, who look to others, models, to see how they should behave. Bandura proved this theory in his Bobo doll experiment, in which children watched an adult display unique, violent ways of playing with the Bobo doll (this covered both the attention and motivation steps, as the children were not distracted from observing the aggressive actions and could have been motivated to imitate them due to the older model behaving in such a way). When left alone in a room full of the same toys, the children, observed through a one way mirror, would display similar behaviours to that of the models, even repeating some of the phrases used by the adults in the demonstration, such as ‘Sock him in the nose’. As this was a fairly unique phrase, unlikely to have been heard by the children before, this shows us that the children learnt these phrases directly from the models, whose behaviour they had merely observed, which proves the social learning theory, it also shows that Bandura managed to operationalise how much the children learnt from the models. As well as this, there was no gender bias in Bandura’s research as the models were both male and female, although it was found that children were more likely to imitate the male. This could however be due to the role of ‘the…
- 1022 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
One social psychological theory of aggression is social learning theory. SLT argues that like all behaviour, aggression is learned through both direct and indirect reinforcement. Behaviour which is reinforced, be that positively or negatively – positive reinforcement occurs when the behaviour causes desired outcomes, negative reinforcement occurs when the behaviour causes undesirable outcomes - is more likely to be learned and repeated. Operant conditioning states that learning the behaviour occurs through direct reinforcement, for example if a child cleans their room and is given some sweets (positive reinforcement) or when a child cleans their room so their parent stops telling them off (negative reinforcement). SLT unlike operant conditioning, believes that behaviour can also be learned and repeated through indirect reinforcement or vicarious reinforcement. This theory was developed by Bandura and claimed that the majority of behaviour is learned through watching others. It states that if people observe another person’s behaviour reinforced – positively or negatively – they are more likely to repeat that behaviour. Bandura named these observed people models and said that people are more likely to imitate the behaviour if the model they are observing is similar to them, powerful, admirable or nurturing, for instance a child’s parents would be their most probable model. One of the main differences between traditional behaviourism and Bandura’s view in social learning theory is that Bandura believes that observation alone is enough for learning to take place unlike Skinner who argues that learning is a consequence of reinforcement.…
- 1615 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Bandura's social cognitive theory suggests that children learn through observation, so it would seem to mean that children would learn aggressive behavior through observation of violence in media. But this also means that if children observe positive behaviors in media, they should demonstrate those behaviors as well. The theory states that when children see certain behavior being modeled, they will accept it and use it (Denler, Wolters, & Benzon, 2013). This is why there needs to be an emphasis put on positive media for children and young adults. The Foundation for a Better Life creates public service campaigns demonstrating acts of kindness, loyalty, honestly, courtesy, devotion, and dozens of other values on billboards and commercials. “We believe that people are basically good and often benefit from a simple reminder. We offer these messages in an effort to promote good values, good role models and a better life,” is a statement made by the foundation when asked why the campaign is being done. I believe all messages in the media, good or bad, violent or gentle, affect those who view them- whether that’s the intention or…
- 1243 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
575-582. This study, famously known as the “Bobo doll experiment” set out to examine four main hypotheses: 1) that children who observed an adult model acting aggressively would imitate these aggressive acts even in the absence of the model, 2) observation of a non-aggressive adult model would inhibit aggressive behaviours, 3) that children would be more likely to imitate the behavior of a same-sex model and 4) that boys would act more aggressively than girls (Hock, R.R. 2005, p.86). The study took place in the Stanford…
- 2471 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Social Learning Theory (Bandura) suggests that behaviour is learned from our environment, for example we observe behaviours through a role model, we perform the behaviour (copy) then this mode of behaviour becomes accepted through reinforcement. For example, young footballer copies Wayne Rooney and kicks out at an opposition player, then gets praise from team-mates, this behaviour is reinforced, then…
- 491 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I- Introduction: the influence of media in the crime commission, as an act of Aggression.…
- 2762 Words
- 12 Pages
Best Essays -
How research by Bandura and colleagues on social learning and aggression has contributed to our understanding of children’s behaviour.…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The experiments results did not fully prove Bandura's prediction but did prove some of his predictions. Children exposed to an aggressive adult model were more likely to imitate the aggressive behavior. The experiment also concluded that boys were nearly three times more likely to imitate physical violence than girls. The children exposed to the passive role model showed less aggression than those who…
- 452 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The findings seem to show that when the children were exposed to any form of violent behaviour from the models they became more imitatively and non-imitatively aggressive as a result.…
- 1046 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Children learn social behavior such as aggression through the process of observation learning, i.e. watching the behavior of another person. During the "experiment" the children exposed to the violent model tended to imitate the exact behavior they had observed when the adult left the room. The children in the non-aggressive group behave less aggressively than those in the control group, and boys behaved more aggressively than girls. The study also showed that boys who observed an adult male behaving violently were more influenced than those who had observed a female model aggressive behavior. Boys were more likely to imitate physical acts of violence, while girls were more likely to imitate verbal aggression (McLeod,…
- 1195 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Over time, it has been observed that people have a tendency to learn from the world around them and from the people they interact. The phenomenon of learning within a social context by observation can be termed as social learning. Most individuals tend to observe and replicate the behavior of things with which they come in frequent contact and this is more likely to occur if their feel an emotional attachment with the object they are emulate. Children copy their seniors when they feel a certain amount of respect and admiration for them, and likewise, people emulate figures in popular media because they feel a psychological connection and they elevate these figures to a status of power within their lives. When people choose, consciously or subconsciously to imitate characters that display violent or criminal tendencies, the likelihood that crime levels will increase.…
- 430 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays