Paper

The Booklet

Case Analysis Using the
Stakeholder Impact Analysis
Chapter 5

Case:
To Qualify or Not to Qualify
(PageS 418-420)

Jane’s Dilemma

Name 1

Name 2

Name 3
An Overview:

Worksheet for the Ethical Decision Making: using the SIA Framework

How to go about doing the SIA: Just follow the instructions in this booklet

What is SIA Framework: This is a framework involving how a proposed action/decision would impact upon stakeholders.

Why use this Framework: When a person is faced with a problem (ethical problem), he needs some kind of ethical principles to arrive at a defensible ethical decision & this framework would help him arrive at that decision (in a systematic way).

How: By using this 3-in-1 questioning package

5 Questions Approach (created by Graham Tucker the 5 types of question vary from the short term to long term & from a quantitative to a qualitative aspect)

Moral Standard Approach (created by Velasquez to test for the morality of the action)

Pastin Approach (created by Pastin to test differing ethics approaches)

Background of case:

Issues from the case

STEP 1: PROTECT THE FUNDAMENTAL INTEREST OF STAKEHOLDERS

Identify all the stakeholders in the case
1
2
3
4
5
6
(Add more if necessary)

Bear this in mind when making the decision:

Fundamental Interest

When I make the decision I must ensure that:
Well offness

The decision should give more b_______ than c____/ b_____ to the stakeholders

Fairness
The distribution of benefits and C____/ b____ should be f_____ to all stakeholders

Rights

The decision should not of_______ the rights of st__________ & the deci_______ maker Step 2
Describe the proposed decision in the case:
To add back $150,000 to the inventory …..

Step 3: THE 5-Questions by Graham Tucker
Challenge the proposed decision described in Step