Preview

Physis vs. Nomos in Sophocles' Antigone

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1459 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Physis vs. Nomos in Sophocles' Antigone
Known today as the "Nature versus Nurture" debate, the question of human social conduct and character development has remained a topic of interest for many philosophical discussions. Centered around the natural and socially constructed, ancient Greeks referred to this debate as physis versus nomos – is individual behavior a primary product of custom and convention or absolute natural fact? Greek mythology addresses this dichotomy of mankind through scenarios of interaction between man and the supernatural. The juxtaposition and/or separation of physis and nomos in this way is found in many myths, an overt strategy that is used to convey Greek ideas of inherent moral responsibility. Sophocles addresses the question of physis versus nomos – in essence, right versus wrong – in his rebellion-inspiring tragedy Antigone. Among others, his main characters, Antigone and Creon, are representative of the two ideologies in contrast. In regards to the burial, or rather, non-burial, of Antigone's slain brother Polyneices, they are constantly battling over polar positions: state against individual citizen, law against conscience, and human nature against divine nature. Ultimately, in following her conscience and sacrificing her life in defiance of nomos, Antigone is validated as a martyr and hero, while Creon is left alone in sorrow and despair.
Given the fates of these two characters, is the fate of man subjective to acting solely on what is morally righteous, essentially upholding physis over nomos? In Antigone's very famous choral ode, the Chorus tributes man's accomplishments and mastery over sea and sky but also emphasizes human inferiority to divine powers: "only against Death shall he call for aid in vain; but from baffling maladies he hath devised escapes." The physis-nomos dichotomy, however, is not addressed in any part of the ode; instead, it is grouped together, leaving fate at the hands of obedience of both land's law and "that justice which he hath sworn by

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The most significant theme in Sophocles’ Antigone is whether or not the law of man conquers divine law. Amidst the play, the newly crowned king Creon proclaims that the body of Polyneices will not receive a proper burial, but instead will be publicly shamed and left to be preyed upon by wild animals. Upset with Creon’s mandate, Antigone mourns the death of both of her brothers, Polyneices and Eteocles, and gives Polyneices a proper burial so he can move on to the afterlife.…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Creon's Laws In Antigone

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Creon’s opinion was that Eteocles went about obtaining for the throne in a more honorable way than his brother did, so Creon believed that Eteocles deserved a lavish burial and the Polyneices did not deserve to be buried at all. Creon proclaimed that the gods supported this, although his opinion on the brothers was very subjective and was not necessarily in accordance with what the gods wanted, especially since there was no way of knowing exactly what the gods wanted. Sophocles has Creon’s stubbornness and pride be his downfall as he faces tragedy throughout the…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Antigone believed that not burying her brother Polyneices and burying her other brother Eteocles due to the command of her uncle Creon was a very wrong thing to do and being the loyal person she was she did not accept this law carried by her Uncle and disobeyed him with the mindset knowing burying her brother Polyneices was the right thing to do know the consequences that came with it.…

    • 70 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    QUOTE The Burial at Thebes: A Version of Sophocles’ Antigone translated by Seamus Heaney. There is a war between brothers over power and the two are clashing over the crown in Thebes. Over a ferocious battle, they both perish in the mighty battle, Eteocles and Polyneices. After the Battle, Creon comes to Thebes and is pronounced the current king. Creon decides to give Eteocles a proper burial since he fault in favor of Thebes, but denies Polyneices any type of burial and this is a big shock since it is a rule of the Gods that everu recieves a burial of some sort. Creon makes one order declaring if anyone atempts o bury polyneices, they are sentenced to death, and Antigone, the little sister of the two brothers, decided to defy this order and…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So haimon leaves and says to the king, “Not here, no; she will not die here, king, and you will never see my face again. Go on raving as long as you’ve a friend to endure you.” (Ode 2 scene 3, lines141-143). After that, haimon is gone and Antigone is escorted into the wilderness where she will be locked in a vault of stone. Although he does not want to leave Antigone to die. The only thing that she has with her is the food that they provide for her. That is what leads to her death. The only god she has is the gods of hell, and they could show her an escape to death. While Oedipus and Creon share traits of effective rulers in a crisis, confidence, decisiveness and a desire to save their city, ironically they bring tragic consequences upon Thebes due to their own actions and fall, ignorance, causes suicides and no belief in gods. Well first of all, we should blame Creons pride, his actions and fall. Secondly, Creon does not believe in any gods, or believe his son and Antigone. Haimon leaves Antigone and Creon. Antigone gets brought to a vault of stone for her punishment and death. If this was to happen to one of my family members I would furious. My family comes before me in any situation. I think of my family before me when it comes to something like being killed or if I get stuck in a bad situation. Family comes…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antigone Sophacles

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    11.) Sophocles does not take a stand in favor of either side. In death Antigone was praised and remembered for her bold and noble deed in burying her brother despite disobeying the king and although Creon lost both his sons and his wife due to his stubborn and ignorant nature.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The concept of justice is a tricky one and thus it comes as no surprise that the differing views on what is morally right between Antigone and Creon result in the tragedies of Antigone. In Antigone, Antigone and her sister Ismene return to Thebes after they discover that their brothers were waging war against one another to determine who would rule Thebes after the death of their father, Oedipus. When Antigone returns, she discovers that her brothers, Polyneices and Eteocles, already killed each other. These deaths result in Creon becoming the king of Thebes. Upon his rise to the throne, Creon declares a law which holds that those who oppose the state cannot receive a proper burial with formal rites. King Creon specifically notes the importance of keeping the city honorable and thus enforcing this new law, “Such are the rulers by which I will guard this city’s greatness; and in keeping with them is the edict I have published touching the sons of Oedipus.…

    • 1685 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Sophocles’ Antigone, Antigone, on the other hand, believes her act of civil disobedience to bury Polyneices was justified due to her belief that the laws of the gods should be carried out above any man made law, including those declared by Kreon and that those who have passed away before her must be honored. In the beginning of the play, Antigone tries to convince her sister, Ismene, to bury the body of her brother. Ismene, at first, was skeptical, for she knew it was Kreon’s decree that no one shall bury Polyneices for he was a traitor to the state. However, Antigone thought otherwise. Antigone states, “I’ll lie there, dear to him, with my dear friend, when I’ve performed this crime of piety; for I must please those down below a longer time than those up here, since I shall lie there always. You, though, if you think it best, dishonor what is honored by the gods” (Sophocles 22-23). Antigone believes burying her brother is of higher standards than to follow the laws of Kreon, for the gods must be worshiped above all else and she follows her principles to the very end. A king may rule the land, but the gods rule all and it is this mindset that Antigone possesses that allows her to fulfill the gods’ wishes. Later in the play, when Antigone is questioned by Kreon himself, she denies nothing and bluntly states that his mortal laws are no match to the laws of the gods. She claims, “It was not Zeus who made this proclamation; nor was it Justice dwelling with the gods below who set in place such laws as these for humankind; nor did I think your proclamations had such strength that, mortal as you are, you could outrun those laws that are the gods’, unwritten and unshakable. Their laws are not for now or yesterday, but live forever…” (Sophocles 38). Antigone followed through her decision to bury her brother because the gods’ laws are eternal. It was Antigone’s strength to stand by her…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Not only is the Antigone an incredible work of drama and tragedy, it encompasses a great moral argument that has two sides; Antigone or Creon. It can also be said that the argument being made in either case is larger than the prerogatives of just these two people and more an argument between obeying the will of man or the will of the gods. Creon’s argument is for the former because of his motivation to let Polynices’s body sit in the sun and rot without giving the body a proper burial. The burial would also allow the soul of Polynices pass into the underworld in the eyes of the Greeks. Not only does this act go against the traditions of the Greek…

    • 1598 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ismene and Antigone differ in their opinions for burying their brother. After attacking Thebes against his brother, Polyneices died, his body left to the birds and bugs in the middle of the woods. Creon then declared whoever buries Polyneices, will die by stoning in front of the public. Antigone goes to her sister with concern for her brother and says, “Ismene, I am going to bury him. Will you come?” (Sophocles 693). Ismene then got upset and responded, “I must yield to those in authority. And I think it is dangerous business to always be meddling.” (Sophocles…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the ancient Greek tragedy, Antigone, Sophocles’ character, King Creon will issue a law that no one will perform the burial rites over a dead traitor of the state. In advocating his law, he will deem Polynices a traitor. Antigone will unapologetically revolt against Creon’s law citing the rite's for the dead are the concern of the gods. Creon, believing himself to be omniscient in all matters of state and church ignores the coherent warnings given to him by his family and friend. Ironically, when he judges Antigone as a traitor to the state, Creon has committed the most grievous offense himself: treason against the laws of the gods,…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, Antigone says to Creon “But if I’d allowed my own mother’s dead son to just lie there, an unburied corpse,then I’d feel distress.” (227-229). This quote shows how Antigone is doing the right thing by burying her brother and what Creon is doing to her brother Polyneices an act of injustice. This also shows how Antigone and Creon are different because she is being driven by the love she has towards Polyneices and Creon is being driven by the hate he has towards him. Second, Antigone says to Creon “But where could I gain greater glory than setting my own brother in his grave?” (570-571). This quote shows how Antigone is willing to disobey the law to give her brother a proper burial because of how much she loves him. This quote also shows how Antigone is determine to do what she thinks is right which is bury her brother Polyneices even though she would be disobeying orders. He doesn’t think women are the same as men because they disobey men’s…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Morality is concerned with the theory of right and wrong characteristics or good and bad behaviors; its role can shape an individual’s personality which can affect his or her call of action. It is only natural that we should have some kind of moral laws since our experiences are dwelled from our sense of duty and physical forces. It’s an aspect in humanity which helps them make rational decisions and it also serves as guidance for mere goodness. Our existence defines who we are as an individual because of our values that help us see past our wrongdoing and helps improve our future. This can be seen in Sophocles’ story of “Antigone,” Antigone’s character portrays a strong individual who is loyal and values her family more than the society. This tragic heroic story demonstrates the…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disobedience In Antigone

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The play “Antigone,” by Sophocles displays an interesting storyline in which the main characters Antigone and Creon undergo various obstacles due to their actions. Throughout the play, Antigone attempts to secure a respectable burial for her brother Polyneices. By choosing to protest and defy Creon’s rule, Antigone unquestionably breaks the law. However, her defiance does not seem like an act of civil disobedience against injustice because Antigone was acting in her own self-interest when considering dying for her brother.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antigone, by Sophocles, is a story about the struggle between Antigone, who represents the laws of the gods and Creon, who represents the laws of the state. The play takes place circa 442 B.C. in the city-state of Thebes. The story revolves around the burial of Polyneices. Polyneices led an army against his brother, Etocles, the King of Thebes. They killed each other in battle and the new king, Creon, made a decree that only Etocles was to be buried because Polyneices was his rival. Antigone, sister of Polyneices and Etocles, feels that she needs to bury Polyneices in accordance to Zeus ' law, but this went against Creon 's decree. Also, Antigone has to bury Polyneices without the help of her sister Ismene. Since Antigone decided to follow Zeus ' law, which states that all bodies must be buried, she defied Creon 's decree and buried Polyneices anyway. Caught by the guards, while burying her brother, Antigone was sent to a rocky chamber as punishment by Creon. Creon 's son, Haemon, was engaged to marry Antigone, but he along with the rest of the city thought Antigone 's death was unjust. Even after Teirsias, the blind prophet, warned Creon to release Antigone and bury Polyneices, Creon remained reluctant. Finally, Teirsias told Creon that the gods were going to punish him and Creon became worried. By the time he got to the rocky chamber, it was too late: Antigone already hung herself. Creon found his son sobbing next to her and when he told Haemon to come back with him, Haemon spat in his face and pulled out his sword. In the struggle to save Haemon, Creon opened the way for Haemon to impale himself. After Creon 's wife, Eurydice, found out her son was dead, she stabbed herself to death.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays