Both theorists believe in discovery of learning and acceptance of individual differences. Discovery of learning consists of encouraging children to discover for themselves through unprompted interaction with the environment. The acceptance of individual differences in both theories is the same. Vygotsky and Piaget both believed that all children go through the same stages of development but at different rates. Therefore, children are better off in a classroom in which the teacher plans for activities where children that are at the same stage can work together.
Though a classroom inspired by the Piaget theory can be seen as similar in some aspects to a classroom inspired by the Vygotsky theory, they can also be seen as very different in the same aspects. Piaget believes that children should discover on their own and should not be guided by others, while Vygotsky believes that others when learning should guide children. Another difference in the two theories is that in the Piaget theory teachers do not impose new skills unless children show interest or readiness in that skill. Vygotsky, on the other hand, believes in the "zone of proximal development." The zone of proximal development is a range of tasks and or activities that children cannot handle by themselves yet but can do with the help of more skilled partners.
Overall, the theories of Lev Vygotsky and Jean Piaget are seen as different. However, there are some characteristics of each theory that make these theories similar. Both theories still remain very influential in classrooms today.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
1) One major difference between Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s theories is that Vygotsky emphasized that… Page Ref: 267…
- 644 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Piaget conducted many studies over many years and believed the best way to study children was in their natural environments. Piaget even studied his own children to make detailed observations and gradually developed a theory that was to become very influential. His theory of learning is often referred to as a ‘Constructivist approach’. This is due to his belief that children constructed or built up their thoughts according to their experiences of the world around them. Piaget felt that learning was an ongoing process and children would adapt their original ideas if a new piece of information seemed to contradict their…
- 1960 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In contrasting points between Piaget and Vygotsky, they have very different ideas for how the cognitive development took place and continued. Piaget believed…
- 544 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
like piaget posited children learn from hand on experiences. However unlike piaget he claimed that timely and sensitive invention by adults when children are learning a new task (zone of proximal development) could help children to learn new tasks. Vygotsky also stressed the importance of social interaction he felt other children can guide each other’s development as well as adults. Vygotsky also thought that children needed to be active in their own learning and that play is important for holistic learning.…
- 402 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
To Vygotsky, the child is an apprentice who actively learns by interacting with an adult mentor, who provides the child with knowledge and cognitive tools. Where learning theory saw the child as a passive recipient of training/ conditioning, and Piaget saw the child as a lone scientist, Vygotsky saw the child as a collaborator with adults (M. W. Watson, 2002).…
- 794 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Unlike Piaget's notion that children's' development must necessarily precede their learning, Vygotsky argued, "learning is a necessary and universal aspect of the process of developing culturally organized, specifically human psychological function" .In other words, social learning tends to proceed development.…
- 525 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Vygotsky’s views conflict with Piaget’s on the social and cultural influences as Vygotsky considered that the use of language was the driving force to a child’s cognitive development. Vygotsky also placed more importance on the social influences impacting on cognitive development whereas Piaget was criticised for underestimating this as he stated “much of what child learns begin by accident –The child accidentally performs some action, perceives it, like it and then repeats the action assimilating it into her or his existing schemes” (Hook et al, 2002,…
- 1310 Words
- 6 Pages
Best Essays -
Les Vygotsky believes that children copy what they see their parents doing. He believed in cultural, Vygotsky believes in children construct knowledge. Vygotsky believes social interaction is vital ingredients in learning in development. Vygotsky believes the children should be shown so they can be successful. Piaget, Erikson’s, Skinner and Vygotsky believe that children learn by how and they think they also learn with intelligent and cognitive development.…
- 582 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Smith, L and Dockrel, J and Tomilnson, P (1997) Piaget, Vygotsky and beyond: Future issues for developmental psychology and education, first edition.…
- 2249 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Both Piaget and Estes believed that learning takes place in an all or none sense. Someone cannot learn something if they cannot relate it to something they already have learned. The best classroom setting for this would be if the teacher related the new subject to the subject they had just left off on. The major difference between these two theorists would be that William Estes described his theories through mathematical questions while Jean Piaget had more of a cognitive focus and described his theory through four different stages of…
- 1137 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Vygotsky concerned himself with the social setting around children and how this contributes to the learning of children, Piaget failed to mention this in his theory. Piaget’s data are renound for their unreliability. Firstly he collected the data alone, without any help and the number of children he used in his studies was small. Vygotsky proposed that language and thought develop together, Piaget’s thought were the opposite of this in that he theorized that thought proceeds…
- 1228 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Vygotsky said that “interaction encourages development by creating cognitive conflict that motivated change” (Vygotsky in Woolfolk and Margetts, 2007). This shows that through social interactions between peers (learning), it fosters development to a higher learning level – hence moving into the territory of Piaget’s work. Vygotsky had the theory of “the zone of proximal development” which is “the distance between the actual developmental level as determined by independent problem solving and the level of potential development as determined through problem solving under adult guidance or in collaboration with more capable peers”. He shows that “the key to hearty intellectual growth was for children to be supported in this zone. That way, learning could actually shape development” (Thurber, 2003). For the child to be assisted by a supportive and non-judgemental elder, the potential development is far greater then if the child was left to perform in his or her own capacity. For a child trying to learn un-assisted, cognitive development that is “more adaptive, more organised, more effective and more complex” (Mussen, Conger and Kagan, 1984) would be lesser than learning with an experienced other because, according to Thurber, “physical and sensory exploration boost cognitive development” (Thurber,…
- 952 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Piaget believed that intellectual development only happens when a child interacts of innate capacities with environmental and progresses through series of hierarchical qualitatively different stages. As a child grows his understanding of the world becomes more complex. This frame work is one that all children will pass through in the same sequence. Piaget theory is one that puts the child charge of their learning, he or she is an active participant of their learning rather than a passive receipt of biological or environment input. Therefore they learn from their own experiences.…
- 1955 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
| Which of the following is a similarity between Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s theories of cognitive development? Answer…
- 1967 Words
- 8 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
work, I was never able to read his writings or to meet him in person, and in reading…
- 4430 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays