English II
May 25, 2012
Privileges vs. Rights
Throughout history, people have always wanted what they can't have. Since the 1970's, this is the attitude most Americans have taken with respect to underage drinking. It was at this time that many states changed the legal drinking age from 18 to 21. The theory behind this was, if you rise the drinking age, people will drink more responsibly, because with age comes responsibility. Unfortunately, the people who made these laws did not consider that fact that so many individuals would not adhere to it. If America lets our young people today and our future leaders drink at a younger age, we would be risking a higher chance of our adult population abusing alcohol.
Critics argue that turning 18 is the age of which adulthood begins and in which people should be allowed to consume alcohol legally. According to Opposing Viewpoints, “at age 18 you become legally responsible for your actions.” This being said, you are given the privileges to buy cigarettes, enlist in the military, vote, serve on a jury, as well as multiple other constitutional rights. People who support lowering the legal drinking age believe that once an individual turns 18 years of age, they should be permitted to purchase alcohol and consume it in a legal manner. Therefore, people who oppose changing the legal drinking age believe it should remain the same for the safety of the society.
One of the most significant reasons for the not lowering the legal drinking age from 21 to 18 is to help ensure the safety of young adults. “Underage drinking is a leading contributor to death from injuries, which are the main cause of death for people under the age of 21 (The National Institutes of Health). Driving under the influence is considered to be the main cause of motor vehicle crashes among drivers ages 16 to 20. Young people's lack of driving experience renders them less likely to cope successfully with hazardous situations that that of a driver who isn’t under the influence of alcohol. This, combined with a desire for risk-taking driving behavior such as speeding--along with a tendency both to underestimate the dangerous consequences of such behaviors and to overestimate their driving skill--contributes to the high fatalities of young adults from alcohol related accidents. In addition to ensuring the safety of young adults, deciding to not lower the drinking age would also prevent the negative effects on the development of the brain.
Another vital reason for not lowering the drinking age would be to avoid the risk of damage on an adolescent’s brain. According to ProCon.org, “the brain's frontal lobes, essential for functions such as emotional regulation, planning, and organization, continue to develop through adolescence and young adulthood.” If the legal drinking age were lowered, it could potentially expose the brain’s development to be interrupted as well as its’ key processes to be damaged. If keeping the legal drinking age at 21 has a chance at saving a single life or preventing damage to an adolescents body, then at 21 it should stay.
As young adults, we may think that we are capable of making conscious and responsible decisions when it comes to our consumption of alcohol but as history has proven, as a whole, we are not. The generations before us may have started this fatal trend, but we have to pay for it. As punishing as this sentence seems, considering that the statistics indicate a decrease of deaths per year, it seems a small price to pay for general well-being and the cost of lives.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
There are many dangers and potential problems with lowering the drinking age. The states of Massachusetts, Michigan and Maine lowered the drinking age, and then experienced a slight increase in alcohol related crashes among the 18 to 20 year old age range. Desired results? Hardly. What about insurance companies? The law may recognize the age being lowered, but insurance might not. The rates of drivers 21 years old and younger would skyrocket which seems really unfair, especially when the unemployment rate is so high right now. Most teenagers who have not had a drink yet might engage in binge drinking, causing legal issues, and using lack of judgment. The crime rate would be outrageous.…
- 294 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In 1987 the United States passed a law mandating all states to have a twenty-one year old alcohol purchase age. This means over half of college students are not legal to buy alcohol. College kids are college kids though, and one way or another they are going to get their alcohol. Many people, myself included, believe that the legal drinking age should be changed from twenty-one to eighteen. “An 18-year-old is afforded, among other things, the right to vote, the right to marry, and the ability to serve in the military” (Engs, Heath, Levine, Smith). In the United States an eighteen year old is considered an adult, yet eighteen year olds are not completely treated like adults. They should be able to make their own choices at this age, and buying and consuming alcohol is one of these choices. Even with all the arguments, the legal…
- 877 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the U.S. the age of adulthood is 18. And with that comes many responsibilities and decisions that can now be made without consents. But there is still one thing a now young adult can’t decide on their own and that is if they will consume alcohol. The legal drinking age is not until you are 21 years of age. People argue that it should be lowered for it is an individual decision and 18 is old enough to make that decision. The legal drinking age should remain as is because the brain of a young adult is not fully developed till the age of 21.…
- 483 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
A lot of people believe that having the drinking age at 21 helps prevent teenagers from making thoughtless decisions. Teenagers that want to drink, do it anyways before they are of legal age. No matter what the drinking age is, there will always be some people that are going to drink before that specific age. A lot of people start drinking because they know it is illegal and they just want to break the rules. So if the drinking age was lowered, it could possibly lower the amount of people drinking because they won't feel obligated to drink since they can drink whenever they want. Also once teenagers reach a certain age they realize that they have a lot more responsibility and they think that the drinking age is overrated. Since the privilege of drinking is far from any other privileges that one obtains at a much earlier age, they don’t want to wait for just one privilege. By lowering the drinking age some people might wait a few years till they are legal and therefore there would be less teenagers making thoughtless mistakes.…
- 764 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
According to Fabian Grund, in Why the Legal Drinking Age Should Be Lowered, lowering the drinking age comes with many pros, including less binge drinking, less illegal substance use, and if consumed properly, it could even be good for your health (Grund 5-8). In the article, Fabian Grund says it best: “You can take responsibility to buy a gun, get killed in combat or vote for your president, but you can’t even buy a damn beer.” (2) In other countries, you are able to legally buy and consume beer and wine at the age of 16, and at the age of 18, you can legally purchase liquor. The U.S. also has the highest legal drinking age, which is 21. If alcohol was available at a younger age, it would cut down…
- 922 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many pros and cons to lowering the national drinking age from 21 years of age to 19 years of age. I believe the drinking age should stay at 21 even though many of my peers feel otherwise. People under the age of 21 are drinking whether it is legal or not. They may have a fake identification or have someone purchase alcohol for them, the fact is they are drinking. When I talk with others about this topic, comments are always made such as: when a person turns 12, they can get a hunting license and carry a gun, at 16, they can get a driver’s license and quit school, at 18 they have the right to vote, serve in the military and are considered an adult. They can have a baby and get married but can’t have a glass of champagne to celebrate. I understand these thoughts and sometimes wish it was 19 but when you look at the research, it is better for everyone that every state to set the legal drinking age 21.…
- 1251 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Teenagers are not mature enough for the drinking age to be lowered to eighteen years old. Being able to drink at an early age can lead to alcoholism at more quickly. When teenagers consume alcohol it is more easily for them to drink and drive because they believe nothing can or will happen to them. All fifty states minimum age to drink is twenty-one, but in some states it is okay for people under that age to drink under adult supervision. Having to drink in front of adults brings…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
All fifty states set their minimum drinking age back to twenty one in the 1980’s because they felt that eighteen wasn’t the appropriate age. Some people did not agree with this change because at the age of eighteen people can vote, drive cars, fly planes, pay taxes, marry, become a legal guardian, own a gun, risk their lives a member of the U.S. armed forces. Honestly, today the drinking age doesn’t matter, whatever the age a person will always try and find a way to drink. Even though some believe the drinking age should be lowered because that way students and young teens won't binge drink and will know how to handle their alcohol better, lowering the drinking age is not a good idea and can cause harm to others. Teens will end up taking advantage of this and it’s a health risk.…
- 1004 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
There has been a question looming for years on whether or not the drinking age should be dropped down from 21 to 18. Many people have views or opinions on what the legal drinking age should or should not be. Right now the legal drinking age is 21, and many people, especially a younger crowd, are working extremely hard to change that to 18. All over the world, different countries have a different standard which leads to a different drinking age. There is a reason why the United States has put the legal drinking age at 21. This was to ensure that there will be no underage drinking, which today has clearly not been the best idea because underage drinking happens more and more frequently.…
- 777 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Another source decided to look into what the results were in New Zealand when they decided to lower their country’s drinking age to 18 in 1999. NPR.org says in the article, “The review also looked at drinking habits in other countries, paying special attention to New Zealand, which lowered its drinking age from 20 to 18 in 1999. Several studies found a spike in alcohol-related car crashes and increased drinking there among still under age 16 and 17 year-olds.”(1) It truly doesn’t matter if a lower drinking age will stop people from drinking underage and driving with the law being 21. People who choose to drink underage get a ride instead of driving while intoxicated. This is also important to show you because once again it didn’t change for the good in those countries it crashes of kids who were even underage which is why it should stay 21 because it is saving…
- 842 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There is a giant debate on what the legal minimum drinking age should be in the United States. Many people think that it should remain at 21 years old and others believe that it should be lowered to 18. While both have their own various reasons, this has been an important topic in our country for a long time. President Ronald Reagan signed and passed the National Minimum Drinking Age Law in 1984 which obligated states to raise their legal drinking age to 21 or suffer reductions in Federal highway funds. The highway funds and drinking age was linked together by the young lives lost on our highways. Even though this was a satisfactory reason to raise the drinking age there are still more reasons to why it should be 18. Despite what most people…
- 1237 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In 1984, the Uniform Drinking Age Act, a law which would severely penalize states who failed to restrict the drinking age to 21 or higher, was signed into law (Hoover). It is odd to think, in today’s day and age, that 35 years ago the drinking age was below 21 in over 70% of US states (“Minimum Legal Drinking Age…”), however, this all changed when the federal government took away highway funds and dangled them in front of these states like a carrot, waiting for them all to raise their legal age for consumption of alcohol. For a law that is broken by over 70% of those to whom it is applicable (Muhlenfeld), this age has been given relatively little debate, mostly because it has been so engrained in our culture that underage alcohol is wrong. The national de facto drinking age of…
- 2084 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
One of the reasons why the legal drinking age should be lowered is because it would diminish the thrill of breaking the law to get a drink. According to Ruth C. Engs, Pofessor, Applied Health Sciences, “Although the legal purchase age is 21 years of age, a majority of college students under this age consume alcohol but in an irresponsible manner. This is because drinking by these youth is seen as an enticing "forbidden fruit," a "badge of rebellion against authority" and a symbol of adulthood." This implies, students and people under the age of 21 will drink in an irresponsible manner because of peer pressure or just wanting to show adults that they don’t have to listen to them anymore. This also shows, if legal drinking age was lowered then most students and people under the age of 21 would learn that they don’t need to rebel to get a drink or break laws and since 18 year olds get a lot of responsibility like voting, this would add to it and show that they can be trusted with not over drinking.…
- 307 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the United States at the age of eighteen you receive the rights and responsibilities of adulthood. As an adult you should be able to make your own decisions on drinking alcohol. You can vote, smoke cigarettes, serve on juries, get married, sign contracts, be prosecuted as adults, and join the military. It is known that alcohol consumption can interfere with development of the young adult brain's…
- 706 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Alcohol in the hands of an irresponsible under aged person, can be deadly. Furthermore, for anyone to consider lowering the legal drinking age from 21, to 18, in my opinion is simply ludicrous. John Bowersox reports, “Since Colonial times, drinking alcohol has been part of American culture and its use by young people has been accepted by many as part of growing up. In fact, during the late 1960s and early 1970s, many States lowered the legal drinking age from 21 to 18. Following this change, the number of alcohol-related traffic fatalities among young people increased. In response to these acute consequences, beginning in the early 1980s individual States increased the drinking age to 21. In 1984, Congress passed legislation that would…
- 927 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays