Preview

Professional Negligence In Nursing

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1321 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Professional Negligence In Nursing
Professional Negligence

In relation to professional negligence the concept of the reasonable man becomes that of the reasonable professional. The reasonable man will normally lack the skill and expertise acquired by the professional. These professional men and women are not only required to take reasonable care but also to measure up to the standard of competency that can be expected from such professionals-that is the standard of, for example the reasonable nurse or the reasonable solicitor.
The Irish Supreme Court considered the issue of Medical Negligence in The case of Dunne v. The National Maternity Hospital {1989} IR 91 and set out the standard of care in what we call professional negligence. In this case the plaintiff sued the
…show more content…

It was contended that the Health board was negligent in the discharge of the plaintiff’s father who committed suicide following discharge. This man had been admitted to a psychiatric hospital suffering from depression and was discharged after nine days. It was claimed that the discharge procedure was not properly conducted. This procedure in relation to a patient suffering from depression involved consideration of the potential risk of suicidal traits.
An expert witness concluded that the hospital notes did not appear to show a proper assessment of risk had been undertaken prior to discharge. Apart from one note there was no evidence that staff carried out a suicide risk assessment.
Another expert was of the view that it was not sufficient to ask the patient about suicide especially when there were some pointers towards suicidal thoughts. Expert witnesses said that in relation to suicide assessment there were two schools of thought .One school believed that the process of suicide risk assessment must be a formal one consisting of consistent and continuous inquiry into the mental state of the patient .The discharge must be as a result of an informed decision accompanied by the risk
…show more content…

The test applied then was whether the defendant acted with ordinary care of an equally competent practitioner as to the administration of a general practice approved by a substantial amount of practitioners of like skill and specialisation. The principles in the Dunne case state that a difference of opinion is no grounds to establish liability.
Applying these principles to the case the court held:
It was not up to the judge to decide which of two schools of thought –the formal or informal – was to be preferred. It was however inherent in both that the risk of suicide in a patient with depression was assessed prior to discharge. In this the court did not interfere in the professional judgement as to which form that assessment took but it was clear that it was “ general and approved practice” that the risk of suicide was assessed prior to discharge of a patient suffering from depression.
In this instance the court accepted that the procedure was not incorrect but the question arose as to whether it was carried out in a manner that accorded with general and approved practice. The court held that there was no indication that the assessment had been carried out, as was good practice and noted in the patients clinical notes. There was no evidence then that the patient was in firm


You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The care for MR. Ard was below standard of care. Mrs. Ard’s testimony of what happened the night of the 20th collaborates with the nurses logs of when Mr. Ard was checked on. The nurses brought in to speak as expert witness both agree that the care was below standard of care and steps were skipped in assessing Mr. Ard’s care. The nurse was contributory negligent. “A person who is negligent when that person does not exercise reasonable care for his or her safety, thus contributing to any injury sufferer” (Pozgar, 2012, pg. 125). The nurse was aware of Mr. Ard’s issues in the doctor’s notes, she was also made aware through constant calling from the wife of Mr. Ard, and not responding in a timely manner. According to Pozgar, the nurse did not have to be directly aware of the issues that may happen, but aware that something might happen and to keep an eye on the patient in case it did (2012). The Judgment by the court was granted towards Mrs. Ard in wrongful death, and I agree.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The case of Hall versus Hilbun is a case in which an exploratory surgery was conducted to try to locate a possible blockage in the small bowel to alleviate abdominal pain. Mrs. Hall went into the hospital complaining of abdominal pain, upon being seen by doctors she was treated by a general surgeon by the name of Dr. Hilbun who stated he thought the pain was due to a blockage in the small bowel and thought an exploratory surgery was deemed appropriate for treatment. Mrs Hall consented to the surgery and at first things went seemingly well. After surgery Mrs. Hall was awake and communicating, Dr. Hilbun accompanied her back to the private room that she would be staying in and stayed with her for some time. Her vital signs has been consistently within the appropriate range since she awoke after surgery, therefore Dr. Hilbun felt it would be ok if he left the hospital for the night.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contracts I Course Outline

    • 2280 Words
    • 10 Pages

    b. Hawkins v. McGee – an expectation to the idea that most medical promises should be argued in malpractice suit…

    • 2280 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Elements Of Negligence

    • 94 Words
    • 1 Page

    Negligence is a failure to use reasonable care that results in harm to another party.…

    • 94 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the nursing field in recent years has had an increasing concern with legal and ethical dilemmas in clinical decision-making. In nursing there law has major impacts through a wide range of issues. Being healthcare professionals it is highly important for that professional to know the ways the laws regulate their scope. There are issues from clinical negligence to resource allocation. The people that work in healthcare are accountable…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Suicide-related forensic assessment procedures are an important component of a forensic professional’s responsibilities in a correctional setting due to the excessively high occurrence of prison suicide as associated to the general population. Suicide is a major cause of death among prisoners and the assessment of suicide risk should not be viewed as a single opportunity at intake but rather an ongoing process (Weiner & Otto, 2013). An inmate can become suicidal at any point during their confinement therefore suicide-related forensic assessment procedures should begin at the point of transfer to the correctional facility and continue until the offender is released from custody. When conducting suicide-related forensic assessments there are…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John D. Arras looks at a situation which poses a patient suffering from uncontrolled pain by having the physician ignore their decisions amongst life and death. He mentions that physicians may contribute to “suicide and suicidal ideation” (page 478, column 1) which is statistically shown in over fifty percent of cancer patients who suffer from uncontrolled pain that is often brought on by untreated depression. In this situation however, if patient is given control of their own lives and obtain adequate psychiatric and palliative care to treat depression, it is assumed that most would lose interest in PAS/euthanasia. Using a similar example, there will always be a small amount of patients who may have pain that cannot be treated, for these patients J. Arras believes that present law on PAS/euthanasia can represent an impossible barrier to a distinguished and decent…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Negligence Case Analysis

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Legal: The four elements that demonstrate negligence that can lead to a medical malpractice lawsuit includes the following four according to our course note book and our instructor Kristin J. Kjensurd. 1st Clinician owed a legal duty of care to patient, 2nd clinician violated the duty of care, 3rd Duty of care violation caused injury to patient and 4th Patient suffered harm requiring compensation. In the article I read, all four elements that demonstrated negligence were violated by the clinician Cammy Elaine Nye. The 1st element Nye violated was her responsibility as a CNA to provide a professional level of care. As someone who is perusing a carrier in the healthcare field I feel that it’s our responsibility to provide a level of care that we are entrusted with, which I feel Nye failed to do. She put herself before the patient by not mentioning the incident that lead to Mrs.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Drug Induced Suicide

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Bibliography: Quill, Timothy E. “Physicians Should ‘Assist In Suicide’ When It Is Appropriate.” Journal Of…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This paper is being submitted on July 29, 2012 for Carol Taylor’s M230 Medical Law and Ethics course.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    in Coleman 12) This states that most people who are choosing physician- assisted suicide is due to them being depressed and under psychological distress. If the patient is depressed they are not in the right state of mind, and they are more likely to be careless and not think through the consequences of choosing doctor assisted suicide properly. Once a person overcomes their depression and is in the right state of mind they are more likely to change their minds about physician- assisted suicide. Most of the patients have to looked passed their disabilities and illness in order to make the choice that is best for…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Acting lawfully as a nurse within their roles and responsibilities will reduce the risk of negligence. Negligence is the failure to present the level of care considered reasonable under the incident, consequential in an unintentional injury to an alternative party. Patients and associates have the right to seek out civil remedy for a lawfully recognised wrong. The tort of negligence arises from the common law and is a means by which a person who suffers damage through a negligent act or omission be capable of obtaining compensation from the nurse accountable for that wrong. As a result, when working within the nursing profession it is important for nurses to work within the scope of civil law. The scope of civil law relates to “patient safety; negligent advice; patient consent; patient freedom of movement; and patients’ property.”- (Daly, Speedy, Jackson, 2010, page 158). It is important for nurses to take this into account within their roles and responsibilities and act lawfully as nursing care frequently requires the nurse to be engaged in close physical contact with patients.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Right To Die Case Study

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This paper is being submitted on September 18, 2014, for Ann Never’s M230/HSC2641 Section 08 Medical Law and Ethics course.…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Informed consent

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The court ruled in favor of the doctor, however if this case is judged only on issues of informed consent, there may be a different verdict. “Informed consent which generally contains the elements of disclosure, understanding, voluntariness, competence and permission” (Edge & Groves, 2005) each of these should be addressed when considering if the requirements of informed consent were met.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Balch (n.d.), Jack Kevorkian, the infamous "suicide doctor," said at a court appearance that he considers anyone with a disabling disease who is not depressed "abnormal." But what Kevorkian and others who argue in favor of physician-assisted suicide ignore is that even though the disease itself may be untreatable, the depression is treatable, and it is the depression, not the disease, which makes such persons suicidal” (para. 4).…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays