Preview

Pros And Cons Of Imperialism

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1100 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pros And Cons Of Imperialism
Throughout history, colonization and imperialism have presented themselves as positives to the powerful nations and negatives to the nations being conquered. Even today, bitter feelings linger and issues discussed centuries ago present themselves in modern conversation.
The National Park Service’s guide to Christiansted, St. Croix, does not erase the history of colonization in the Americas, but rather masks it. Despite brief mention of slavery and servitude, Christiansted is painted as a bustling capital of sugar trade - which is was - with only the help of the Danish West India and Guinea Company and the King of Denmark - which it was not. In his letter to King Ferdinand, Christopher Columbus states that he has “discovered a great many islands, inhabited by numberless people,” and that he has taken the islands for Spain. He uses the word “possession” as
…show more content…
“There is no native who does not dream at least once a day of setting himself up in the settler’s place” (page 1107, paragraph 3). This difference in role presents itself consistently throughout history - uprisings and rebellions in colonies have always been an issue. In Shooting an Elephant, George Orwell recognizes the horrors of colonization and imperialism, despite himself being stationed as a British police officer in occupied India. His actions and his morals conflict with each other as he tries to make the right decision - to shoot, or not to shoot? In the end, Orwell’s need for respect, his sense of pride, and his fear of rejection by the natives force him to kill the elephant, though his shame and discomfort at the action lingers. “A white man mustn't be frightened in front of the ‘natives’; and so, in general, he is not frightened.” Though the thought of killing the animal made him ill, his duty was to appear at ease. And so, he

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    On the other hand, the story "Shooting an Elephant” was wrote by George Orwell base on his personal experience in Moulmein, in Lower Burma .He served his country, "British Empire as a colonial administrator. The author described the effects on the oppressed Burmese Indians and theirs oppressor British Empire. The internal conflict of British men, his feelings and convictions linked to his pride from of the angry crowd. Shooting an Elephant is more than a personal experience story, is a reflection of the dilemmas of morals standards in real life and the costs that it represent as a human been and his nature as well .…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Shooting an Elephant” was written by George Orwell, and it describes an incident he experienced during the time he spent in a small town in India, as a police officer serving the British Empire. I found the writing interesting because of Orwell’s use of rhetorical strategies that slowly build up to the conclusion of the story, along with the peak of the action. The story ends in a detailed description of an anecdote Orwell thought of while shooting the elephant that was terrorizing the town he was positioned in. Throughout the writing, we can find different rhetorical strategies that indicate Orwell’s very careful choice of different images to get his message through.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    ,geographers at the royal palace in Brussels (1876). Several years later he hired Henry Morton Stanley to be his right-hand man in Africa. For half a decade, Stanley traveled the Congo setting up posts, building roads, and persuading chiefs─practically all being illiterate─to sign treaties with Leopold. The treaties, some of which doctored to Leopold’s benefit, were then put to use by the Belgian monarch (Britannica). Rubber was booming during that time, and the Congo free estate had one lucrative source of wild rubber, and it was the Landolphia vines in the Central African rainforest.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The incident of shooting the elephant gave rise to a much-talked issue. It also created a tremendous negative impact on Orwell’s mind. Even the opinion of his fellow Europeans differed – the older people supported his act, while the younger ones condemned it and argued that ‘it was a damn shame to shoot an elephant for killing a coolie’. However, deep in his mind Orwell always knew that he had shot the elephant ‘solely to avoid looking a…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    George Orwell describes to us in “Shooting an elephant” the struggle that his character faces when to win the mobs approval and respect when he shoots down an innocent animal and sacrifices what he believes to be right. Orwell is a police officer in Moulmein, during the period of the British occupation of Burma. An escaped elephant gives him the opportunity to prove himself in front of his people and to be able to become a “somebody” on the social scene.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Shooting an Elephant” is an essay written by George Orwell and published in 1936 (Orwell 66). Orwell was born June 25, 1903, as Eric Arthur Blair and passed away January 21, 1950, in India (“George Orwell Biography”). Orwell was known for his journals, novels, and essays published about his own political views (“George Orwell Biography”). Orwell traveled to Burma after not doing good enough in school to earn a scholarship and decided to join the imperial police (Orwell 66). While on duty one day, Orwell received a call that a rampaging elephant was on the loose that had killed a man and destroyed a hut (Orwell 67). Once Orwell found the elephant calm in a field he was faced with a decision of whether to kill the elephant or let it be (Orwell 69). Orwell killed the elephant for the safety of himself and out of pressure from the Burmese standing behind him (Orwell 70). While Orwell contemplated shooting the elephant he knew out of the town he was the only one able to have a weapon to kill the elephant (Orwell 67). The Burmese weren’t allowed to have weapons because the British Empire outlawed them to prevent the Burmese from revolting. The British Empire didn’t want the Burmese to over power them and revolt because they wanted to maintain power imperialism. The British Empire needed to keep the Burmese under their control because they needed the resources from the land. The Burmese were helpless against the rampaging elephant because the British Empire needed to maintain dominance over the Burmese.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Imperialism had it's pros and cons. The pros included improvements to the local transportation and to buildings such as, school and hospitals. However the cons, oppressed the local people. Once European countries gained power in a foreign country, they would completely dominate that country. Even though the Europe countries would gain power in a foreign they, did bring advanced technology to the country. Because of the advanced technology this improved hospitals and vaccines which, improved the health of that population. Not only did people benefit from Imperialist powers medically but, they also provided better road construction which provided better means of transportation to the population as well. With the improvements of schools, hospitals…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1936, author George Orwell wrote an essay titled “Shooting an Elephant”. In the essay Orwell describes a scene of a British police officer who is stuck between having to shoot an elephant. The story takes place in Burma, India where then, they were under British imperialism. Imperialism is a policy of extending a country's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. It humiliates the occupied people, reducing them to an inferior status in their own country. Analyzing Orwell’s work, I realize that Orwell feels Imperialism is not good for both the people subject to and the people of the imperial power. The fact that the main character of the story is an officer of the imperial government, but also in opposition to imperialism…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When not handled carefully, power can destroy freedom. Many tyrannical leaders and countries have bent the rules to their advantage, causing the rights of others as well as themselves to be violated and eventually consumed by their hunger for domination and popularity amongst their followers. Being a follower of an almighty empire, Orwell displays his perplexity in relation to his position and social “responsibilities” as a police officer in a foreign country, in which he must execute the dirty work of the British, in his essay Shooting an Elephant. Through the employment of rhetorical devices and specific word choice, Orwell exposes his conflicting feelings between his hatred of the British Empire’s imperialistic views and the social pressure,…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Shooting an Elephant', George Orwell described the onus of serving with the imperial police in Lower Burma, during a time where the British police were hated by the natives. Orwell expressed his views towards the Burmese, saying “Theoretically—and secretly, of course—I was all for the Burmese and all against their oppressors, the British.” Though he felt that way, they did not feel the same towards him. “As a police officer I was an obvious target and was baited whenever it seemed safe to do so.” He hated his job and felt that the sooner he got out, the better. Imperialism was something that he clearly despised, yet he was caught right in the middle of a cycle of oppression. One day, an event occurred that left Orwell battling with a decision between his own moral beliefs, and gaining the approval of the…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yup This is IT

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages

    George Orwell was “disgusted by the inhumanity of colonial rule that he witnessed while stationed in Burma” (2835 Orwell). Using his writing to confess the inner conflict of an imperial police officer, he wrote an autobiographical essay titled Shooting an Elephant. He notes that the Burmese civilians were not allowed to own guns during his stay – a testament of British control over Burmese resources. Feeling “stuck between his hatred of the empire he served and his rage against the evil-spirited little beasts who tried to make his job impossible” he knew that “the sooner he chucked up the job and got out of it the better” (2844 Orwell). Orwell repressed his emotions because acting out as the only white man would have been foolish. If he betrayed his country, he risked treason. If he sided with the Burmese, he would never fit into their culture. Every white man’s life long struggle in the East was to not be laughed at, so the safest choice for a man like George was to live without action. However, when a sexually aggressive elephant gets loose Orwell is called to take action.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Originally, Columbus was supposed to be on a journey to Asia, due to the journals of the explorer Marco Polo. After a difficult trip that almost required him to go back empty handed, he eventually did reach new land, but not what he intended. He wanted to sail to Asia but instead found himself on an unknown island, which he proceeded to name "La Spanola". It seems that Columbus attempts to make up for his folly of not being able to reach Asia on the route he was so sure of. However rather than to consider this a waste of effort and money, he attempts to present the island as a suitable substitution. His letters back to the country of Spain assert a certain value to the land which is seen through his diction. Columbus says that "In it there are so many harbors on the sea coast, beyond comparison with others which I had known in Christendom, and numerous rivers, good and large, which is marvelous”. Essentially, with so many harbors on…

    • 4303 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Orwell writes of his experience in British-ruled India in the early Twentieth Century. At the time, he was a young, inexperienced soldier stationed there to help protect the Queen 's interests. While he was there, he had to do something that had made some ethical conflicts within him. British Imperialism immerged and killed people’s freedom, hopes, and desires. Shooting an Elephant is an essay written and published in the autumn of 1936. The essay mainly illustrates how a white British imperial police officer in Burma reacted and responded when he ought to encounter a ravaging elephant while he was on duty. The story is set in the British-conquered Burma. The setting of this story provides images and portrayal of imperialism of Britain during their imperial era. The narrator describes the way he feels toward the natives and how the natives respond toward the European throughout his retelling of experiences. The description and portrayal of imperialism in this story shows that being a conqueror does not necessarily means total control—the conquered might as well control the conqueror in a different way, and being in charge of controlling simply means lending out freedom to the occupation.…

    • 2561 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay “Shooting an Elephant” George Orwell argues that imperialism ruins and hurts not just a countries’ economic, cultural and social structure, but has other far reaching consequences; oppression undermines the psychological, emotional and behavioral development of mankind. Orwell served his country, the British Empire, in Burma during the early 20’s as a police officer. The country was colonized by the most powerful economical leader in Europe. The only person who can have an insight look and empathy into what it felt like to be oppressed is Orwell, who lived in Burma for five years. On a daily basis he agonized over three significant issues; entering into a working field where he had insufficient knowledge, felt hatred or bullied by Burmese, and he was disgusted as a human being by recognizing what life meant for a nation that was colonized. History had enough examples of empires violating not just human rights, but intervening forcefully into other countries, robbing their natural resources, and suppressing its people for the sake of their own prosperity. Throughout his essay, Orwell logically illustrates different elements of allegory such as an elephant that symbolizes the British Empire, which was enormous, powerful, and dauntlessly conquered anything that was in his way. The Burmese represent any oppressed nations on the globe that struggles to keep their culture and values alive; moreover, constantly resist against the conqueror even though that withstand was ineffective. The allegory of Indians who were colonized by Brits also symbolize a typical victim who attacks another lower ranked prey, as Albert Memmi in his thesis “Racism and Oppression” asserts that “If the French proletarian wants to feel a little taller, whom is he step on if not on the immigrant worker…”. (Memmi, pp. 183, p. 22). Orwell’s description shows a clear picture of his emotional struggles from hatred, to pressured, to stunned, to…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Purpose: Orwell’s purpose in “Shooting an Elephant” is to persuade his audience that imperialism is harmful to all parties involved. The harms of imperialism are illustrated with Orwell’s words, “I perceived in this moment that when the white man turns tyrant it is his own freedom that he destroys.” This evidences the harms of imperialism by showing that the actor nation or individuals become harmed in turn; specifically, through the deprivation of their freedom. The purpose is further articulated by the narrator’s sentiment regarding his decision to shoot the elephant: “And suddenly I realized…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays