Preview

Pros And Cons Of Keeping Killer Whales In Captivity

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
785 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pros And Cons Of Keeping Killer Whales In Captivity
In todays day in age, there are many American issues that seem to be on a never ending vicious circle. A recent American dilemma is the debate about keeping killer whales in captivity. Although retaining these majestic creatures may provide statistics and data for scientists and present entertainment for the public, others have very dissimilar views on this riveting situation. Orcas have been captured and retained in captivity for over fifty years. Whether it be for entertaining the public or allowing scientific studies to be made, many people do not agree with this way of treatment to cetaceans. Killer whales have been withheld in captivity since 1961(WDC,1). This initial whale was captured by Marineland of the Pacific located out of …show more content…
The first killer whale show featured a young, fourteen foot orca, known as Shamu. The show took place at Seaworld San Diego in the mid 1960’s. April 19, 1971 Shamu was retired after a horrifying incident where the orca bit down on the legs and hips of a Seaworld performer. It wasn’t until other workers came to the rescue, prying the jaws open with a pole, that she was released. There has currently been seventeen orca shows from the 1960’s to the present day. The name Shamu was trademarked by Seaworld and has been given to various orcas to perform in the “Shamu Shows”. These shows take place in the Shamu stadiums which seat 5,500 people. Many people enjoy the shows, while others see the cruelty in the confinement of these majestic …show more content…
Although numerous people believe confining orcas is cruel, there has been benefits of the confinement. Multiple scientific discoveries have been made about the species. One main discovery is the discovery of the varieties of different breeds. Three main types consist of the Offshore whale, the Resident whale, and the Transient whale. The dorsal fin and white spot patterns are the main way of identifying the different breeds. In addition to this they recognized the different preys killer whales feed on. Offshore whales mainly feed on Antarctic minke whales, Resident whales mainly eat seals, penguins and some fishes and Transient whales are known to dwell on Antarctic toothfish. Scientist were also able to conduct range tests on whales to understand more clearly how well the hearing of a killer whale is. Scientists then came to conclusion that these majestic creatures had different dialects. There are many repertoires of codas within the killer whale species. Just as in human life, people have different accents, it is the same for these cetaceans. These tend to be very regional. Being that there has been many scientific discoveries, some of these whales don’t compensate from the procedures. Cetaceans spend 80-90% of their time underwater in the wild while they’re surfaced 80% of their time in captivity. In the wild they are naturally very active and playful but in captivity they tend to get bored in the enclosed space.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tilikum Research Paper

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “A killer whale gone very bad” talked about a killer whale at SeaWorld who weighs about 12,000 pounds by the name of Tilikum. He is also the star of the movie called “Blackfish.” SeaWorld made Tilikum out to be a killer, but he is actually a victim of their greed. He was captured in 1983 from the wild at the age of 2 from his mother in Iceland where he was kept in a tank for about a year. Afterwards, he was sent to a park called Sealand of the Pacific. There he spent most of his day in a tank where 2 female whales bullied him. The article also explained how during a performance at Sea Land a performer fell into the water and 3 whales including Tilikum drowned her. While the whales very extremely vicious to her, there were no lawsuits filed…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The documentary entitled Blackfish directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite uses a few rhetorical approaches to reveal the disturbing hardship that orca whales experience in captivity. The film follows the shocking story of a killer whale named Tilikum and the three human deaths that he is responsible for. Cowperthwaite uses interviews with concerned former trainers and whale experts as a device to explore the difference between SeaWorld’s public image and its intense reality. Researchers find that the wild orcas can be described as highly socialized and intelligent creatures; these gentle animals are then compared to the whales pictured in footage from SeaWorld’s marine parks. Whales kept at SeaWorld are mistreated, restrained to dark cages, and live in small concrete pools that cannot be compared to the hundreds of miles that they would routinely swim on a daily basis. To this day, many admire SeaWorld for its broad assortment of marine animals. As a documentary, Blackfish takes on the immense task of trying to alter the audiences’ perceptions of SeaWorld. While Blackfish employs all three forms of rhetoric to accomplish this mission, it predominantly attracts the emotion of its audience using a combination of stock footage and interviews.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The bill also allows for Sea World to rescue and rehabilitate stranded killer whales, as long as they plan to release them back into the ocean, but the federal government determines whether the whale gets released or not. Violators of the bill would face fines up to a hundred thousand dollars. Killer whales have been kept in captivity for many years, especially in Sea World. In the wild, Orcas have an average life expectancy of thirty to fifty years, the estimated maximum lifespan is sixty to seventy years for males and eighty to one hundred years for females. But for killer whales in captivity, their average lifespan is thirteen years, much shorter than the average due to the harsh conditions they are kept in.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although there have been many animal advocates protesting against SeaWorld, there are other people who don’t mind the Orcas being at SeaWorld. “Shamu the show and the marine parks’ collection of orcas have been inextricably linked to SeaWorld since the San Diego park’s origins more than a half century ago” (San Diego Union-Tribune 1). The killer whales have been the face of SeaWorld for many years. The Orcas are one of the main reasons people go to Seaworld. Shamu is the famous name that all the Orcas are known as, because of the captive killer whale that appeared at shows in SeaWorld San Diego in the 1960’s. “She was the fourth orca ever captured, and the second female, after her death, the name Shamu continued to be used in SeaWorld…

    • 203 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Keeping these types of animals in captivity is inhumane and dangerous for the whales and the humans. At the beginning the documentary a family of orcas are shown in a peaceful environment, calmly swimming side by side. This causes the audience to make a warm connection with the orcas…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first story I heard that referred to orcas being held in captivity, was about a young orca named Tilikum. He was ripped from his family when he was only two years old when he was only 13 feet long. After his capture, he was kept in a cement holding tank for close to a year at a marine zoo in Iceland as he waited to be transferred to a marine park in North America. He was held captive against his will, all he could do was swim in small circle and float aimlessly at the surface of the water. Tilikum was very far away from the expansive ocean where he would swim over 100 miles a day alongside his family members. Finally, he was transferred to the rundown…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Seaworld Captivity

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Imagine you are in a boat right off the shores of Greece. You happen to look up and out of the corner of your eye you see something. As your gaze adjusts, you notice it's a killer whale, being torn away from his home. A large net encloses in in, attached to a large ship. Now, imagine you are sitting in the stands at SeaWorld, surrounded by hundreds of people, people waiting so eagerly to lay eyes on this year’s rendition of “Shamu”. When you look into the cement “pool”, you see him. You see the majestic, beautiful, free, wild animal now in captivity. Only, this time, he looks tired, old, neglected, abused, and lifeless. This is exactly what SeaWorld is doing to killer whales. They take these wild animals out of their natural habitat and force them into captivity.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The average age of death of an Orca at SeaWorld is thirteen years.“No Aquarium, no tank in the marine land, however spacious it may be, can begin to duplicate the conditions in the sea.” Jacques-yves Cousteau said in the film, “Blackfish.” Who would want to go to marine parks knowing that the animals captive there are dying more rapidly than those in the wild? In other words, SeaWorld's tanks cannot compare to the ocean, the tanks at SeaWorld are approximately three-hundred and fifty feet long. The average size of an Orca is twenty to thirty feet long, though in the wild an Orca travels more than one-hundred miles a day. A whale would have to swim one thousand two-hundred and eight laps a day in a tank that size to reach the amount of miles an average Orca swims in the wild. “Life in cramped tanks is no prize for Orcas and Dolphins, who want to be free with their families in the ocean,” Bob Barker quoted. The male Orcas in SeaWorld all have collapsed dorsal fins, which is not common in the wild. A collapsed dorsal fin is a sign of a unhealthy or injured Orca. Most of the whales are injured from the other whales that live in the tanks along with them. Living in such confined spaces creates tension among the whales which leads to attacks against each other. In the ocean, there is a vast amount of space for the whales to eventually flee. Although in the tank,…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Blackfish Essay

    • 1976 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Who does not love to see dolphins and whales flipping and doing tricks? Although the animals look happy and unharmed, there is a dark truth behind the captive marine life in amusement parks and zoos. Yes, attending zoos and marine life amusement parks are a part of childhood; but recently researchers have discovered just how cruel the environment is for the marine life in captivity. After studies of comparing the quality of life of marine animals in the wild and in captivity, there are multiple examples shown in Blackfish, PETA, and the Animal Welfare Institute that show that animals prosper and live longer in their natural habitats. Due to the cruelty endured by the captivated Orcas, all the SeaWorld parks should be shut down and the Orca whales should be set free to prevent further demise to their species.…

    • 1976 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the people who took the whales give the whales food they do not give them a lot. Whales are big animals and they are only serving small portions to them. I think whales liked it better in the ocean because they could just have as much food as they want but now that they are in tanks and used as money making tools they don't really care about the animals they just want money off of them, just like the small servings if they cared they would give the whales more food. According to Ingrid Betancourt, “In captivity one loses every way of acting over a small detail.”…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Orcas, also known as killer whales, have been in captivity for over fifty years. The magnificent stunts the animals are trained to do is jaw dropping. Killer whales, on the other hand, do not seem to feel the same positive regard. Infact, they have killed or injured more than one-hundred people during their stay in captivity. Keeping killer whales in captivity not only threatens the whales, but harms humans as well.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The world's greatest and largest apex predator, their extreme intelligence allow them to thrive in any waters from tropics to Antarctica and even sharks are on the menu. Orcinus orca, the Killer Whale, can grow up to thirty-two feet long and weighing in at over twenty thousand pounds. They have been feared for hundreds of years by North American Natives and even mentioned in Greek maritime records. Their name when translated from Greek means "killer from hell" ( n.p. ). Unfortunately the freedom of these mighty sea kings is growing more limited as humans wish to capture them for aquatic mammal parks. The history of captured orcas is a sad one, the first whale captured was by Marineland of the Pacific in Newport Harbor, California 1961.The fully matured female was found sick and disoriented in the bay and easily caught, but after two days in her tank she rammed herself at the tank wall and died. The second capture in 1964 had started as a hunting expedition by Samuel Burich to kill a whale and use it to make a model for the Vancouver Aquarium. When the fifteen foot whale named "Moby Doll" survived being shot the aquarium told Samuel to bring it back alive for the aquarium, but after spending only eighty seven days in the tank Moby died of a skin infection caused by the low salinity levels of the water in his tank.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    to the first captive orcas as, in a sense, serving as ambassadors for wild orcas.4…

    • 11024 Words
    • 45 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Killer Whales

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The whales can survive because the polluted ocean is not as bad as it used to be. The whales that are born in the ocean seem to survive very well. Killer whales have a stronger immune system which helps them with all the oil and trash. In captivity, they are breeding them and so all the whales grow up in a very bad environment. If they would stop breeding them, then the whale population would increase and whales wouldn’t go through premature deaths. Animals would not try and attack them because the whales would be a normal animal that would be in the sea. Although learning about a certain animal could be nice, the animal would not act like they would in the wild. The whales go through lots of stress and getting information from a animal that is going through that can be really bad because the information wouldn’t be correct. Overall, orcas should be in the wild because my claim has more influential reasons.…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Explorer Doughter

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A major part of the passage is an account of a hunt for narwhal whales.…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays