The great author Margaret Mead once said, “Children must be taught how to think, not what to think.” Americans expect their public system of education to provide a solid curriculum. There is a growing controversy in our country regarding education in private schools versus public schools. Whether or not every child should go to private schools is a decision worth questioning; however, if a child cannot handle the chaos that public schools have to offer, then the decision could be considered. Private schools are valuable and offer programs implementing great educators as well as demonstrating excellent character. In contrast, the United States prides itself on its public education system, making it an acceptable value for many families. The level of each person’s education will have influences on their career endeavors. Most of the people in the United States place their trust in the public school system in which they involuntarily support through property taxes. This trust is contradicting public system of education’s current shape towards a better America. Many of the schools in the United States are either deteriorating, or failing all together. The drawbacks of public education create an unhealthy environment for student learning. Students aren't getting the proper educational tools and with the government ahead of the students’ interest in education, they conduct the standard curriculum of learning for Americans. If public schooling serves the public interest, then it shall serve families and their children the best way it possibly can throughout involvement of teaching certain courses. Therefore, public schooling should be abolished and private schools should take their place because public schools are not working because it limits choice by having zoned school districts, larger classroom sizes, the insufficiency of budgets, and it fails to provide quality education.
If children were allowed to attend the better public schools in their communities without restriction of zoning then they would have greater advantage than other children, because not all public schools are terrible. I do believe the rareness of a city having at least one public school performing higher test scores and higher graduation rates than most, but we need all public schools on board, if that were the case. Parents that cannot afford private schools are obligated to send their child to a district zoned schools, (public schools). The students have no choice, but to attend that school hoping that parent’s child’s learning is of the essence.
Since it is a requirement made by the federal, state, and local government to assign zoned schools for communities, there is no doubt that these schools are not small class atmospheres that allows for a lower student-to-teacher ratio (Burke). In addition, teachers and staff don’t make it a priority to get to know each student better. For instance, if a student in class is acting out the teacher punishes the whole class instead of taking appropriate measures applicable to a particular student which is what private schools practice. Private schools hold each individual accountable for his or her actions so they will learn and understand the right or wrong of what they did.
Researcher Lindsey Burke states in the “Lack of Confidence in Public Schools,” “Americans have always strived for the best. Our public schools are far from it. Across the country, just one-third of children are proficient in reading. In the urban centers, that number is tragically lower. In Chicago—where public school teachers, at the behest of the government unions, are set to strike in order to demand a 30 percent pay raise—just 15 percent of children are proficient in reading” (web). If the government is not involved in public’ school systems then things will be better.
In addition, public schools should be abolished because of the insufficiency of their budgets. Public schools are receiving money from tax payers without telling them how much they are taking. If public schools are supposed to be a choice then parents should be involved in their child’s choice of education of school. Parents who are spending so much money on schools that are not performing up to standards then that shows improper use of property taxes. Though public schools are under government jurisdiction, they are really the voice of the people in these American forced schools. Why should parents have to pay for what the government feels is necessary to learn? If parents are paying for their children’s education, then they should have the ultimate decision, not the government. That is why private schools are a more promising choice. Private schools are funded by organizations such as alumni, charity, and other believers in its purpose. Concerned parents should place them into a private school where they know their child is learning and their money is not being put to waste. Since private schools are not free, students will actually want to be there versus students in public schools who are bored and have no desire to being there. Parents that know their money is being spent on something valuable are the greatest enrichment for their children’s future. Supporters argue that the costs of private schools are way too high and that everyone cannot afford it. While supporters also believe that in certain areas students are receiving the education needed especially in poverty and low-income areas paying more money for public schools will not assist its existence. Instead of the government taking more money from tax payers a solution that eliminates public school attendance mentally is already in effect. Policy Analyst in Empirical Studies Shanae Watkins Ph. D, author of “Are Public or Private Schools doing better?” researched voucher programs and its effective purpose for families that cannot afford private schools, but wish for their child to attend. Voucher programs are government sponsored and privately funded (Watkins).
Nevertheless, public schools fail at focusing on quality education. Not just overall education, yet the divine subject at matter education offers. In my opinion, public schools are guilty of not implementing such values that make a person well rounded in all areas instead they motivate and unmotivated student liking's by forcing what we think we want to know for life, for example private schools have a religious foundation that public schools are permitted from. Becky Norton Dunlop of Berkeley Law School Federalist Society states in her article of “Parental Choice in Education,” “A free society requires an educated society. It requires a conscious and deliberate pursuit of truth, an intuition rightly ordered with reality, and a coherent moral philosophy. So we must work to understand not only what is real and what is possible, but also what is right and wrong”(web).
To be completely human neither public nor private are perfect every child will have his or her weaknesses and strengths in subjects. Since public school classrooms are crowded due to compulsory attendance it is hard for teachers to help each child on an individual basis. In a classroom of public schools, students are separated into age groups, or grades. A child who is not at the same level as other students in the same age group will fall behind and have only age in common with their classmates. In the same sense, students who are academically advanced will eventually become bored and lose the desire to progress in their studies. This is a “lose-lose” situation, but it certainly does not have to be that way. Private schools are considered a privilege not a right. A more challenging curriculum and students of smaller sized classrooms benefit better. Not to mention the values private schools teach that are not only the foundation of academic skills, but the lessons needed in life about spirituality, love, morals, purpose of life, and wonders of creation. Students become more interested in school when they are learning about themselves finding out what one likes most in school. When students are happy and have that urge to learn they perform better and at a greater level such as tests. Competition is inevitable at this point.
The difference between public school teachers and private school teachers is that public school teachers are told to teach according to what the government wants while private school educators follow their school curriculum that suits their students’ needs. Parents concerning the fairness of education among their children should know that their children’s educators are educated with a degree of expertise. Between the quality of teacher education and how educators are separated in terms of degrees are measured by years of schooling and by their level of degree (Richwine). With degrees involved in the different sectors of public and private schools such that public teachers must be certified in that study while private school teachers have a degree in education. Since private schools are not under a union contract, that supports equality among students, they are able to fire and hire who they want to teach without any complications; therefore, with the reassurance that families know what and how their kids are being taught to learn to become a prominent, whole person.
In other words, it is possible to recognize what private schools have to offer as oppose to what public schools have done in America. Graduating from a public school has made me realize the truth about education and it was all a lie. When we stand and recite the pledge allegiance each day we recited our liberty under one nation under God in which we believe in, but the system surprisingly did not offer. Martin Luther King Jr. said it best, “Intelligence plus character-that is the goal of true education.” Think about the future of America and what we as future leaders can do to better our country.
Work Cite
Burke, Lindsey. “Lack of Confidence in Public Schools at an All-Time High”. Heritage Foundation. The Foundry. 21 June 2012. Web. 12 March 2013.
Dunlop, Becky Norton. “Parenntal Chouce in Education and Whether Tax Credits
Serve to Establish a Religion”. Heritage Foundation. 22 November 2010. Web. 3 March 2013. Richwine, Jason, Ph.D. “Assessing the Compensation of Public-School Teachers”. Heritage Foundation. 1 Nov. 2011. Web 3 March 2013. Watkins, Shanea, Ph.D. “Are Public or Private Schools Doing Better? How the NCES Study is Being Misinterpreted”. Heritage Foundation. 1 Sept. 2006. Web. 3 March 2013
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Mark Twain once observed that a cat that jumps on a hot stove, it will learn a valuable lesson and in the future will not jump on hot stoves. Twain wryly points out that the cat will not also jump on cold stoves, either. The lesson it learned - -just as humans learn - - rather than make informed distinctions, it becomes easier to simply avoid the situation altogether. In John Taylor Gatto’s article, “From the Land of Frankenstein,” the former award winning teacher condemns the integrity of the American public education system, asserting it. In actuality, focuses more on training students for obedience rather than attempting to develop each individual’s talents and abilities. The American public education system destroys individual initiative in order for students to become more manageable parts in the overall social order in the country accomplishing this goal by rewarding compliance and discouraging individuality and ensuring dependant and obedient response to authority through curricula enforces students to respond passively to governing entities, and finally punishing those individuals who resist or refuse to assimilate the lessons with escalating levels of negative reinforcement. How much more evidence is necessary? Good schools don’t need more money or a longer year; they need real free-market choices, variety that speaks to every need and runs risks. We don’t need a national curriculum, or national testing either. Both initiatives arise from ignorance of how people learn, or deliberate indifference to it.” Our schools need to teach the values of free speech and individualism. Why do they continue to provide teachings of Dr. Martin Luther King, or Abraham Lincoln who were big on freedom for mankind? But contradict by not allowing our kids express themselves openly. Dr. King once said “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.” Our children need to be taught the values of being able to make right choices and to be an…
- 740 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the story “Against school: How public education cripples our kids, and why” the author, John Taylor Gatto, establishes the idea of how public education can lead to a negative impact on students. School train kids, “[to become] employees and consumers…” (Gatto 231) instead of teaching kids how to deal with certain situations that my come across in life. The story was directed to parents with kids in elementary school.…
- 458 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When such schools exist where funding is nowhere adequate and sufficient enough to prepare a child for college and beyond, we should ask ourselves, “have we given up on public schools?” Have we given up on the kids because we have given up on the future? Benjamin Barber stresses this thought-provoking idea because there is, without a doubt, a need for a change. In a book written by Deborah Tannen called The Argument Culture: Moving from Debate to Dialogue, she expresses the idea that when two parties have a debate over an issue then usually there can only be two sides to a solution; no more no less. The more one side gets into conflict with another, the more it is willing to take outrageous action to not be proven wrong. Could it be that the United States, a nation regarded as the hegemon of the Earth, must now consider reform and learn from the education structure of smaller countries? Maybe this thought process is what prompts America to be stubborn about changing its own educational system and sticks to its own material hoping that one day everything will work itself out. Well, with the number of unemployment rates still relatively high and those will college degrees relatively low compared to other nations, it seems as though we need a…
- 1351 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
John Gatto’s “Against School” is a persuasive essay arguing both the ineffectiveness and negative outcomes of today’s public school system. Not only does Gatto provide credibility with his experience as a teacher, but he also presents historical evidence that suggests that the public school system is an outdated structure, originally meant to dumb down students as well as program them to be obedient pawns in society. Fact and authority alone do not supplement his argument. Gatto also uses emotional appeals, such as fear and doubt, to tear down the reader’s trust in the schooling system. Although it may seem to be so, Gatto’s argument is not one sided. He also offers suggestions to make the educational system more efficient at the hands of positive reinforcement and the employment of more motivated teachers. Through the effective application of ethos, logos, and pathos, John Gatto provides a well-rounded argument against the public school system that would cause any reader to question the goals of modern schooling.…
- 1386 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
American schools have the responsibility to create better human beings, and they are expected to do it consistently over the years for all young people. Currently, anyone can observe the differences between the school system today and 10 years ago. The academic rigor and behavioral expectations of American education have declined. The efforts to make students more competitive worldwide and ready to embrace the demanding workforce have not borne out. The Schools are failing our children because of low standards and poor discipline policies.…
- 95 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Should public, or government, schooling be avoided? In the essay No Home-schooling Vaughn Argues that Homeschooling is the best schooling for children and that government schooling should be avoided. Parents put forth the excuse that they are not smart enough to teach their children. Parents believe that government schooling teaches their children both academics and socialism. “The government schools are not teaching your child Judeo-Christian values; they are going to teach him or her how to survive in a group…” Public schooling in the United States is set up to dumb children down. Homeschooling provides one on one attention to a child, and so they do not have to fight for attention from a teacher in governmental schooling. Public schooling is being used as propaganda changing the way your child may think whereas homeschooling provides your child the opportunity for a parent to teach the values of true freedom and individuality. Children need to be tested for their values instead of their knowledge and this simply cannot be done in government schooling.…
- 646 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Gatto, John T. "Against School: How Public Education Cripples Our Kids and Why." Readings For OSU Writers. 4th ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martins, 2010. Print.…
- 1299 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
“a continuing recession, escalating political polarization, rising racial/ethnic tensions, a growing national debt, and a widening divide between the haves and the have nots portend a future fraught with unprecedented challenges to and clashes over the form and substance of public education in America” (p.1).…
- 4094 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
At the birth of our democratic republic prominent political leaders, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, Benjamin Rush, Noah Webster, and others, recognized that educating the youth of our nation was critical for the future prosperity and security of America. These men, in their writings and oratories, strongly advocated for a publicly supported, non-secularized system of education that would be available to all American children free of charge. However, the newly ratified U.S. Constitution contained no provisions for education and, consequently, the responsibility for providing public education was given unto the individual states. Indeed, of the original thirteen states, seven states included provisions for public education in their constitutions, as would each future state, only in the South was the concept of public education resisted until after the Civil War. Over the next two centuries, public education in America would change and evolve, responding to changes both from within our own society and, increasingly in modern times, from forces that are reshaping the world. This essay shall briefly examine four distinct phases in the development of American public education and some of the individuals who made significant contributions that helped shape our modern system of public education.…
- 1187 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The Educational system in America has been subject to many reforms in the past century, and despite many theories; none have been successful in creating a world-class public school system that America needs to stay on the leading edge of advancement. A mixture of low standards, a transition to equity, and lack of discipline has led to the poor excuse of an educational system we all know today. The costs and consequences of these problems are getting even greater, however, there are examples to be followed and changes that can be made to turn this catastrophe around.…
- 3020 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In America, a child normally goes through at least twelve years of public school to be prepared and knowledgeable for college and the real world. However, a question about the schools is being raised –– are students truly learning in the education system? The system seems to be straying from its purpose. Nowadays, students aren’t enjoying the journey to learn and only goes through the motions of being a student. This takes away from them by not having in-depth learning, making them not as prepared and not as ready to master new challenges as they should be. To allow students to have true, deep learning, schools should grant students time to explore passions, lessen competition between peers, and give opportunities to experiment to find best…
- 1038 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The purpose of public schools has never been to create thinking, analyzing, intellectual citizens, charges John Taylor Gatto, a 30-year New York City public school teacher and New York State Teacher of the Year in 1991. (www.asbj.com) Schools are products of 19th century industrialists, whose purpose was to prepare people to be good employees – docile, productive, and addicted consumers. And if that’s what the public wants, says Gatto, using the Socratic Method to teach children to analyze great works and question the way things are is a hazard to society.…
- 455 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Schooling is seen as a necessary part of life in America for generations, needed to transform the children of the nation into happy and productive individuals. Unfortunately, there seems to be a problem with overall performance. According to the Program for International Student Assessment survey administered by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development in 2012, the United States ranks 27th in math, 17th in reading, and 20th in science. According to the OECD the US spends more on education than most countries with an average of $115,000 per student (PISA, 1). Unfortunately, that level of spending has not equaled an improvement in education. We have tried to improve our schools with more money, better teachers, and legislation such as No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. What if the true problem with schooling is not the components of the system, but the system itself? In the article “Against School” John Taylor Gatto present several causes for the failing of the American public school system. One of the main causes he puts forth is the institution of compulsory schooling in a system designed to repress the working class, keeping the classes…
- 1400 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Educational programs demand effort and dedication to be successful. Barber expresses his concern for the lack of literacy in America. In Barbers essay, he states, “As America’s educational system crumbles, the pundits, instead of looking for solutions, search busily for scapegoats” (Barber, 2014, pp.210). America’s government takes minimal actions toward the educational crisis. The situation resembles a hole in the wall that needs fixed, but instead of fixing it America’s society hangs a picture over the hole. The lack of educational reforms causes the America’s youth to fall behind other countries youth in literacy. The lack of effort from the government, from schools, parents, teachers, and students put a strain on learning. Some American citizens proclaim that they want a change in the school systems, but nothing results from it. Barber states, “With all the goodwill in the world, it is still hard to know how schools can cure the ills that stem from the failure of so many other institutions. Saying we want education to come first won’t put it first” (Barber, 2014, pp.217). Society labels schools as “prisons,” and sadly, some are less safe than actual prisons. The lack of safety forces students to focus on their own safety rather than learning. Not all schools provide safe environments for students; The result of this problem is conflicts and disinterest for learning. The lack of effort put forth by America’s society and government is only one factor in this multitude of…
- 822 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Spring, Joel H.. American education: an introduction to social and political aspects. 5th ed. New…
- 1541 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays