Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Puritan Dilemma Responds to questions: According to Edmund Morgan, what was the "Puritan dilemma?" How did the Puritans and/or Winthrop address this dilemma?

Powerful Essays
1293 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Puritan Dilemma Responds to questions: According to Edmund Morgan, what was the "Puritan dilemma?" How did the Puritans and/or Winthrop address this dilemma?
The Puritan Dilemma by Edmund Morgan

John Winthrop's "Puritan dilemma" arose out of his life long effort to accomplish two goals: to secure a community dedicated to upholding every aspect of God's will and to do this within the context of everyday life. His first challenge dealt with the depravity of the Church of England in the early seventeenth century and how to escape its wickedness without withdrawing from the world. Then, with the founding of the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1630, a decade of domestic problems took center stage as the "separatist impulse" and excessive purity threatened colonial stability. Winthrop's last hurdle occurred in the realm of foreign affairs with the possibility of English intervention in colonial religious practices. On all three occasions, he used moderation and reason combined with the responsible exercise of authority to temper and defeat those forces standing in the way of his ultimate two-fold purpose. As Edmund Morgan's work shows, by his life's end, Winthrop had created in himself a powerful example of how to address the central "Puritan dilemma:" how a righteous man does right in a world that does wrong (182).

According to Puritan belief, every member bore responsibility for the Church of England's behavior, and all would be held accountable to God for its sinfulness (16). For this reason, Winthrop had a personal stake in England's incompetence, and he now confronted "the paradox that required a man to live in the world without being in it" (27) for the first time on a major scale. How could he rectify his moral responsibility to God without neglecting his duty to this world? Among his peers, the opportunity to colonize the New World and create a Puritan "city on a hill" arose as an increasingly attractive solution, but Winthrop was still reluctant: "would it not be deserting the world...to flee into a brave new land?" (36). As popularity for this undertaking grew, he justified it by arguing that it would serve as an example for England to follow. Once she saw its successes, she might reform. In this way, Winthrop could fulfill both obligations, escaping God's fast approaching punishment, while at the same time, correcting and not abandoning England's imperfections. Departing in 1630, he would spend the greater part of the next decade confronting the "separatist impulse" -- the tendency towards excessive purity and withdrawal so hostile to Winthrop's notion of how the Puritan must live.

The necessity of the community in the individual's effort to maintain a requisite level of godliness played a key role in Puritan thinking, for man could not meet these standards on his own. He needed society to keep him in line and correct him when he wavered. For this reason, threats to colonial stability could not be tolerated. John Winthrop understood this, and at the same time he sought to endow the new government with legitimization by extending political rights to the colonists, he preserved for the governorship almost absolute authority which would prove key in keeping dissenters in line. Of these agitators, Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson both promulgated incendiary convictions of religious superiority and exclusiveness incompatible with the fundamental beliefs which provided Winthrop's society with stability.

In the case of Williams, unrealistic expectations of godliness undermined the survival of the community by spreading the "separatist impulse" and by defying authority. When the Boston church failed to repudiate the Church of England, Williams refused to "spoil his new purity" (104) by taking communion and withdrew from it all together. Although Winthrop recognized the futility of this act, Williams, consumed by excessive demands for purity, did not and continued "along the paths of perfectionism" (107), persuading others to adopt his cause. Additionally, he accused the king of blasphemy and questioned the legitimacy of the magistrates' role in religious matters (108). In doing so, Williams had assaulted the colony's government and its stability by encouraging others to break away and form a more perfect order. At first, Winthrop responded with arguments stressing the importance of reform over separating. Only when this approach failed, did he use his authority over the General Court to banish Williams from the colony. This pattern of persuasion and then force was a consistent feature of Winthrop's which he later used to subdue the problem of Anne Hutchinson.

Anne Hutchinson's antimonianism and her theories on justification and sanctification undermined the root purpose of the Massachusetts colony. She claimed that "the Holy Ghost dwells in a justified person" (124) and that "sanctification was no evidence of justification" (123). In effect, she devalued the Puritan demands on the individual to strive for perfection and refuted the state's responsibility to enforce proper behavior. Thus, Hutchinson attacked nothing less than the most basic principles upon which the colony came into being. On top of this, her belief that "justified," or saved, persons could distinguish between damned persons inspired a type of separatism that divided the colony "into two hostile camps" (127). Again, Winthrop responded with letters of persuasion and tried to win over less committed followers. However, as was the case with Williams, he eventually turned to raw authority as the only remaining route and banished Hutchinson from the colony. With the defeat of Williams and Hutchinson, Winthrop turned to a new kind of threat in Robert Child's push for Presbyterianism.

In 1646, Robert Child's request that Parliament impose Presbyterianism in Massachusetts sparked "the greatest challenge [Winthrop's] colony ever faced from foreign intervention" (182). Unlike Congregationalism, Presbyterianism did not place stringent requirements on the individual to prove his purity to gain church admission, and because church membership was a requirement for the right to vote and hold office, it provided an appealing alternative for those disenfranchised under the current system. At the same time, English intervention in this way would hinder "the liberty of Massachusetts to carry out her commission" (182) and thus could not be tolerated. Initially, Winthrop responded by drafting a bill to extend political rights to nonmembers, but events escalated before he could get it passed. Predictably, when his first conciliatory attempt to dissolve the problem failed, "Winthrop fought...by fair means and foul" (181), seizing Child before he could depart for Europe. In the meantime, he made it a point to present Parliament with his version of the facts, and by the time Child was set free, the matter had been settled. Once again, Winthrop had protected his experiment with a godly society by whatever means necessary.

In The Puritan Dilemma, Edmund Morgan delineates John Winthrop's response to the question of what responsibility a man owes to society. Winthrop makes his convictions clear that one must confront worldly temptations and resist the easier path of simply avoiding them. He justified colonization as a means of reforming the Church of England whose standards were too low, only to discover the opposite problem, of aiming too high, in America. In both domestic and foreign affairs, Winthrop addressed threats to the colony's well-being first with moderation, patience, and reasoned argumentation, and only as a last resort, would he utilize his expansive authority to ensure the commission's survival. In many ways, Winthrop's battle with the "Puritan dilemma" parallels later struggles in United States history such as the relationship of the individual's liberty to established authority. Just as the Puritans departed from England to fulfill unmet personal needs, so too the American war for independence represents the triumph of individual freedoms over the restrictions of authority. In the same way that Winthrop overcame the "separatist impulse" of a few zealous persons, the American Civil War illustrates the preeminence of the larger society over divisive strands within it. Thus, in the life of John Winthrop, Morgan presents not only the story of the Massachusetts Bay Puritans, but also the greater American struggle to balance individual liberties with the restrictions of authority.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    John Winthrop 's "City Upon A Hill", described the mission and vision to start a "New England", which became known as the United States of America. John Winthrop believed a perfect society could exist in a perfect city where everyone worshiped and worked together in harmony. He envisioned a community so closely woven together that everyone was equally important to the future of the city. A city where a purer form of Christianity would exist, which would provide a moral and religious show for the rest of the world to see. Quoting the New Testament, (Matthew 5:14) John Winthrop warned the people they would be totally exposed for the entire world to see, as a "city upon a hill."…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    AP US History DBQ

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Constantly, the New England region demonstrated a different motive for colonization, as their main intentions revolved around religious freedom. The New England settlements became a religious refuge for Puritans and Separatists which together formed the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1629 led by John Winthrop. As described in document A, John Winthrop founded the Massachusetts colony in order to obtain religious purity and reform. This idea was called “the city on a hill” which was Winthrop’s idea of a moral society based on godliness, which each region practiced daily.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Winthrop was a Puritan who believed in covenant theology, which means he believed that church and state should work together to govern. He was a leader of the MBC and governor of the colony for 12 terms. He was mainly an authoritarian leader who let his religious beliefs influence much of his governing duties. Roger Williams, on the other hand, believed the polar opposite of Winthrop. He Said, “God requireth not a uniformity of religion to be enacted and enforced in any civil state…” (Doc. F). Williams had believed in separation of church and state and was an important dissenter who found the MBC to be oppressive. He left eventually to create his own settlement of Providence where he allowed more religious freedom and separation of church and state. Both of these men show how Puritan beliefs affected politics in the New England Colonies at the time, and how religion was related to those…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In contrast, New England was founded to escape religious persecution. The “Separatists,” who were later known as the Puritans come only to practice their religion freely. The Puritans had no interest in profit, but only to work together to make their colony triumph. As John Winthrop stated in A Model of Christian Charity, “We must be knit together in this work as one man.” He explains that by working and understanding one another, they may prevail. By working together they’ll become “a city upon a hill” for everyone to look and admire them. They tried to set an example for others to follow. Clearly these two provides a pivotal point of view on the outlook of life.…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Puritans, on the other hand, wanted to change or bring reform to the Anglican church without cutting themselves off from other Englishmen as the Pilgrims did. They came to America to escape religious persecution after Charles I sanctioned anti-Puritan persecution and in 1629, Massachusetts Bay Colony was founded. The Massachusetts Bay Company was formed for the single purpose of founding a colony as a business project and received a charter from King Charles I to establish it. John Winthrop was the first governor of Massachusetts Bay. He believed Puritans had a covenant with God to lead a new religious experiment in the New World. The immigrants to Massachusetts Bay wanted to create a theocracy and adopted the name Congregational…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    English attorney John Winthrop represented the new gentry that had flourished under the Tudor regime, but despite his privileged position Winthrop became increasingly disenchanted with the oppressive and corrupt Stuart monarchy. A time when Charles I, a true believer of the divine right of kings, decided to rule without parliamentary consent, and imprison Puritan parliamentary leaders in 1629. Winthrop penned A Model of Christian Charity in response to his disillusionment on his way to New England on the Arbella in 1630, joining the first large contingent of Puritans who left England in order to establish the godly commonwealth. Leaving behind his lay life as a modest gentleman, ahead lay the wilderness and a vision that English circumstances had frustrated.It can be read, as can so many Puritan statements as "restorationist," that is envisioning a social order in New England that would recapture the serenity of a imagined English past of a well-defined place for all, with clearly understood and easily fulfilled obligations within the social hierarchy. It laid out the model for transition as Winthrop saw it, seeking…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The New World was not without its conflicts as evidenced in the many disputes the Puritans such as Bradford and his Separatists along with Winthrop and his Congregationalists had with other parties who were regarded as dissenters. The causes of such disputes did indeed vary but the inherent reason under all of them was thought to be the Puritan leaders’ defensive nature along with their desire to interpreting history so as to make it compatible with Calvinistic theology. This thus brings varying discrepancies in the early American literature such as those of Thomas Morton and William Bradford who describe similar events but with varying points of view thus reaching different conclusions.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the early colonization of the East coast of North America, many groups of people of Europe came to the New World such as the Puritans and Quakers. Both the Puritans, led by John Winthrop, and the Quakers, led by William Penn, were escaping persecution from England but each they had their own views and goals in religion, politics, and ethnic relations. Being on the native land of the local Indians, both Penn and Winthrop had to face issues and negotiations with the Indians. Penn and Winthrop had their own separate approaches to politics but they both sought a more just system than the one in England. After being persecuted, both Penn and Winthrop wanted their people to be free worship, but Penn and Winthrop each had their own approach to the institution and toleration of religion.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A large number of Puritan merchants obtained a grant of land for Massachusetts and New Hampshire, and acquired a charter form the king to create the Massachusetts Bay Company. This meant that Massachusetts and New Hampshire were part of a Charter Colony—supported by a Company instead of the crown. A large migration of 17 ships and 1,000 people set sail for New England for one reason: to build a Puritan refuge. Their main goal was religious freedom instead of economic gain; the Puritans only wanted freedom from the crown. They elected John Winthrop as governor, and soon established several towns within New England. The Puritans were hard working people. They believed that their work ethic led to material success, which was evidence of God’s favor. Because of this, the Puritan settlers were quick to establish farms and set up communities based on family and hard work. They had a rough beginning, as well, but nowhere near as bad as Jamestown. Their belief in building a “city upon a hill” inspired the community to stay close to God and family. This dominance of families caused a feeling of commitment to the community and a sense of order among settlers. However, Massachusetts Bay was a theocracy- meaning there was no separation between church and state. The Puritans had no more religious freedom than they had in England. This just encouraged them to work even harder for the betterment of the…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even those who are only passingly familiar with the horrific events that occurred during the colonization of the Americas know that the perpetrators betrayed the basic sense of compassion inherent in Christianity. However, many settlers claimed the “new” land in the name of God and asserted that they acted in perfect harmony with biblical ideals. With similar intentions, John Winthrop and his fellow settlers travelled to Massachusetts Bay to establish a colony based on Puritan ideals. While on the way to the new colony, Winthrop delivers a sermon entitled "A Model of Christian Charity" to dictate the ideals his Puritan colony would have to follow to please God. Indeed, Winthrop’s sermon suggests that his guidelines should be considered appropriate…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. The Puritans believe in salvation through Christ’s grace. How did they attempt to bring themselves closer to Christ’s?…

    • 1890 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Winthrop spoke to a crowd of Puritans, saying “...wee must be knitt together...rejoice together, mourne together… The eies of all people are upon us...”, he gets his point across to them that they are a community and they must set an example for the rest of the world to follow (Document A). The point of view of the text is from John Winthrop who was governor of Massachusetts Bay, he was giving a speech to a crowd of Puritans fresh off the boat, inspiring them to stay united through good and bad. This was influential to New England’s social development because it started all the new colonists off in what would become the normal mindset for all of the colonists, comradery. Another example is in Document 3, where it’s shown that the Puritans wanted to advance learning to create educated ministers. Harvard is one example of a college created for the purpose of educating ministers in Massachusetts Bay (OI). These examples both show us how Puritan values influencing social development because the creation of schools creates more educated minds in New England, and better ministers meant more religious influence. With the creation of an education system and a powerful speech from the governor, Puritans had a tremendous impact on the social development of New…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout his oration, Winthrop apostrophizes their “enemies”, who he implies are powered by sin and will engulf the Puritans, should they commit a wrongdoing. By referring to what is effectively the embodiment of sin as a “tangible” enemy, he gives it weight and adds a layer of realness and danger to sin itself. He goes on to describe how breaking away from the community and giving into materialism and greed will cause God to desert them, further deterring them from committing sin, considering how God is the only thing tying them together. Winthrop does all he can to calm the nerves of his fellow shipmates, and ensure that they preserve their common link in…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Winthrop Speech

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Governor Winthrop negotiated for the immigration of the Puritans from New England felt oppressed. Being an attorney he played d a significant role in the development of the Cambridge Agreement. As the governor of the Massachusetts Bay Company, John was very philanthropic and charitable. He donated his money and built houses to the numerous Puritan immigrants. During his tenure as the governor, he encouraged more of the Puritans to settle in Boston (Michael…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Puritan Dilemma

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “The Puritan Dilemma: The Story of John Winthrop” This book talks about the life of one of the most influential puritans John Winthrop. “The Puritan Dilemma was written by Edmund Morgan. Edmund Morgan was a History professor at Yale University from 1955 to 1986. Edmund Morgan wrote many other popular books such as “Birth of a republic, American slavery, American Freedom” and “Inventing The people, the rise of popular sovereignty in England.” This puritan dilemma was written for the intent of future history students reading and learning about John Winthrop and his influence on modern culture and religion.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays