Preview

Rebuttal to 'a Proposal I Never Thought Id Consider'

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
794 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rebuttal to 'a Proposal I Never Thought Id Consider'
Brian Rohn
English comp. 2 Amodio
Rebuttal paper ‘A proposal I never thought I 'd consider '
Sabaa Saleem is a Pakistani woman who is about to graduate college and is torn between the modern day American culture she 's grown up in and her cultural background. Sabaa moved to the U.S. after only living in Pakistan her first year of life. Ever since she came to America she has known that one day she 's going to have to live with a person for the rest of her life of her parents choosing. Sabaa has come to terms with this and thinks that although she lives in America and she can do whatever she wants after she is eighteen she feels that respecting her parents wishes is what she has to do. Most of this reasoning is because her dad has had recent health problems and her parents haven 't been as strict as many Pakistani parents can be; letting her do things such as stay out late, letting her attend college away from home, and allowing her to study journalism instead of medicine. She believes that as long as they have been there for her and done many things for her growing up as they have she feels obligated to have an arranged marriage by them. Arranged marriage is a thing of the past. There 's no reason in this day and age for old eastern culture to interfere with every day western culture. Sabaa grew up in the united states with movies and books and magazines and no matter where you go in America you will see these things and a lot of things in the books movies and magazines have to do with freedom of love and true love. The fact that she was brought up in a lackadaisical Pakistani family where her brother refuses to have an arranged marriage and her parents have accepted that fact she should not feel obligated to have to go through with the arranged marriage just because she was born into a family that happens to be from Pakistan. Sabaa says that she has never been intimate with anyone and that every time she senses someone wants to try and ask her out she either

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In societies with reduced mobility, (predominantly non-western cultures) arranged marriages are common as love is expected to grow due to the fact that it is not seen as necessary for marriage. Arranged marriages seem to work well and make good sense as divorce rates are low and Epstein (2002) found that perhaps about half of them report that they have fallen in love with each other.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In chapter thirteen, Susan J. Ferguson talks about arranged marriages and how love come from that. I have mix feeling about arranged marriages because it could either go a bad way or you could find the person of your dreams. One of my best friend is from the middle east and that is somehow acceptable or common in her culture. But from what she has tell me is common but not everyone does it because in her religion you cannot force someone to get marry. However, her family does not have any arranged family between them, it depends on your family traditions. In America, we do not have arranged marriages. We go by who we love,does not matter they passes life, family or financial status. Something that people who believe in arrange marriages see.…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I knew that arranged marriage was prevalent, but not to the extent that the article explains. A particular concept I found interesting was that unarranged marriages created through love, or “love match” have their own name and unique distinction; a very good friend of mine was born in India and frequently expresses the pride he has from his parents being married by love and not by arrangement. This article encouraged me to open my mind and realize how different cultures can be. For example, instead of just expecting food, dress, and language to vary as culture varies, it is important to remind myself that everyday components of the Western culture I know can be very different elsewhere—and that the differences are…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Not So Modest Proposal

    • 1403 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In our society, satire is among the most prevalent of comedic forms. This was not always true, for before the 18th century, satire was not a fully developed form. Satire, however, rose out of necessity; writers and artists needed a way to ambiguously criticize their governments, their churches, and their aristocrats. By the 18th century, satire was hugely popular. Satire as an art form has its roots in the classics, especially in the Roman Horace's Satires. Satire as it was originally proposed was a form of literature using sarcasm, irony, and wit, to bring about a change in society, but in the eighteenth century Voltaire, Jonathan Swift and William Hogarth expanded satire to include politics, as well as art. The political climate of the time was one of tension. Any criticism of government would bring harsh punishments, sometimes exile or death. In order to voice opinions without fear of punishment, malcontented writers turned to Satire. Voltaire's Candide and Swift's Modest Proposal are two examples of this new genre. By creating a fictional world modeled after the world he hated, Voltaire was able to attack scientists, and theologians with impunity. Jonathan Swift created many fictional worlds in his great work, Gulliver's Travels, when he constantly drew parallels to the English government.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" is a satirical article directed toward the people of Ireland and the problem of poverty it was going through at the time. He proposed that the best solution was to take children and sell them off to be made into food and clothing, such as cows for their meat and leather. He claims that not only would this fix the population problems and the case of the unworking youth, but would also fit the palette of many of the wealthy and elite due to their mannerisms and…

    • 93 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arranged marriage is somewhat offensive to feminist America. There is a level of freedom attached to choosing who and when to marry. Hollywood portrays arranged marriage as the evil separator of lovers, the extinguisher of freedom, and the ultimate subjugation of women. Vogue has an article titled “The Arranged Marriage That Ended Happily Ever After: How My Parents Fell In Love, 30 Years Later.” The article highlights the good points of the couple’s marriage which was arranged years earlier in India. Yet, these people had a thirty-year marriage without the “passionate feelings to glaze over your partner’s flaws in…marriage” (Jacob). Marriage looks clinical and dry this way. However, this is the outside view of arranged marriage. Cultural customs…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arranged marriages are common in Asian countries. Some people agree to arranged marriages that are set up by their parents, unlike…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jonathon Swift wrote and published “A Modest Proposal” anonymously in 1729. During this time Swift’s country of Ireland was being controlled by England. Under England’s control Ireland’s conditions were very poor during the 1720’s. Ireland was overpopulated, poor, and heavily dependent on England during this time. “A Modest Proposal” is an argumentative essay that uses both satire and irony to entertain the reader.…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blood Diamon

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the article “I’m Happy with an Arranged Marriage” by Gitangeli Sapra it discusses her view of arranged marriages. Ms. Gitangeli is for arranged marriage, she stated that people who get married for “love” has a 40% rate of divorce. She also states that arranged marriages have a lower rate of divorce for the fact that the couples do not want to start a wrath between their families.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am writing in response to your request of the elimination of Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” from the classrooms, libraries, and the school system as a whole. Let me begin by telling you that I took what you said into deep consideration, but after discussing with the work with some of the English teachers at Martin’s Groves Junior High School and conducting research on my own time, it’s become clear that Swift’s purpose of writing is not to encourage people to eat children, because it is satirical writing. I can reassure you that if Swift was really promoting cannibalism, I would remove it immediately from the curriculum. It is easy to misinterpret the meaning of “A Modest Proposal”, because Swift writes detailed, supported descriptions of his proposal of cannibalism. However, if you give me your time, I would like to explain the irony of the essay and why it upholds morality and decency in its self-mocking irony.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It is natural for everyone to need or have or want a companion to shares their lives with. It is thought normal of young adults to want a spouse and a family of their own. In relationships it is that passion “falling in love” is the dominant aspect of young adults (Berger, 2010, p.412) Intimacy is when two people know each other well enough to share secrets, as well as engage in sexual activity. Commitment is more time consuming and requires work, dedication, shares possessions, in some cases child-rearing responsibilities, and the capacity to forgive. In some international familes arranged marriages commitment is first before intimacy and passion. Domestic violence sometimes occurs but male figures of the bride usually oversees common ground is the husband is too demanding. Arranged marriages hardly ever do divorce, there’s tremendous effort in keeping the family together as well as social and family support is offered.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, it is connected to my sister's life because her marriage was fixed as arranged marriage. Even though it was arranged my parents give her one whole year to think about it and talk to the guy and get to know him and then make the decision. Now she is jubilant about the decision my parents made for her by choosing the guy and letting her know about him before marriage. The primary focus of this paper is to explain different concepts of forced and arranged marriage. Most of the people assume forced and arranged marriage is the same thing. However, in reality, forced marriage is a nightmare for a girl even how hard they try to get out of it is impossible to escape from it. In an arranged marriage, at least, the girl or boy gets the choice to speak out. Arranged marriages are marriages that are arranged by families, specifically parents or other elder members of the family; it is a cultural and traditional norm. Many people assume arranged marriages and forced marriages are similar in fact they are not. It is imperative to clear that forced marriage and arranged marriage are completely two different practices. In South Asia, forced marriages are…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Marraige

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A lot of countries make arranged marriage mandatory, and some people really do agree with it it are apart of some cultures, but others do not. Fatma Uncon was a twenty year old female who was forced into an arranged marriage, which she did not want. Since she was forced she decided to commit suicide by shooting…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why would anyone want to be in an arranged marriage? Sometimes people like to be in arranged marriages because they don’t want the freedom of picking their partner and believe it’s their destiny and some people want to meet their intimate partner on their own. While the author does show a distressing tone, it reveals the author’s attitude through the story of Farima and the customs of marriage and divorce.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In a strict society such as that of Yemen it is easy to see why parents are essential to the choice of a suitable marriage partner. With the exception of relationships within the family, daily life is based on a strict separation of the sexes. A young man has little or no chance of meeting women, particularly those of his own generation. Instead, he has to rely on the advice of his mother of older sisters and aunts. In a Yemeni family there is a bride search, parental agreement, the suitor meeting, two family greeting, exchange of the brides wealth, three day wedding, Laylat az-Zaffa the wedding ceremony,…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics