Preview

Red Badge of Courage Film vs. Print

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
567 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Red Badge of Courage Film vs. Print
Matthew Murphy
Mr. Stapp
1st Period Junior English
21 February 2013
Film
Literature constantly glorifies war as a romantic event, where men won honor through acts of heroism and bravery, certainly a classic description. Instead, this story features not only a battle in full blast but of the tormenting fears and emotions of an untried youth in the ranks, in Stephen Crane's "The Red Badge of Courage," which says all that ever need be said about the terror of a man first entering battle, no matter which side he's on or in what war. Crane tells this story from the viewpoint of one ignorant soldier, a new recruit named Henry Fleming. From beginning till the tail-end of the story, the reader witnesses Henry’s maturation.
A classic complaint about movie versions concerns the omission of material that the reader finds important, especially if the material defines a character. If the director must make film that is the proper length for a theatrical release, there is no way to include everything, especially when it comes from a long novel. The film version captured and etched vividly most of the major encounters of the hero that Mr. Crane described—the heart-breaking death of the Tall Soldier, the stunning blow on the head—all but the shocking discovery of the rotting corpse in the woods. This is out of the picture as it is being shown here, probably out of deference for the squeamish.
Crane conveyed the reactions of his hero to war in almost stream-of-consciousness descriptions, which is a technique that works best with words but is brought to life by film. When it is a matter of telling precisely how a young soldier feels at a time, for instance, when awaiting an enemy attack or when wandering behind the lines after lamming, it is easier to do so with words than with a camera but is not as entertaining without the facial expressions and body language.
Audie Murphy, who plays the Young Soldier, does as well as anyone could expect as a virtual photographer's model

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “All Quiet in the Western Front” is a social commentary on how soldiers are effected emotionally and socially throughout the war and are conflicted on how to readjust to their lives after the Great War. Soldiers are conflicted by their character and do not know whether to pick back life up as a youth or as adults who have endured hard circumstances. The book does not focus on battles and it does not focus on a specific time frame, it rather evaluates what goes through the minds of a soldier. These men are literally being bombarded in the war front by explosives and in the home front by misinformed public who want to know the extremity of the war. Bystanders set High expectations for soldiers to be tough and to know how to behave in order to survive, yet those who did not participate in the Great War could only speculate what was going on in the soldier’s minds. The Great War damaged these soldiers physically and mentally, however certain elements gave the survivors the ability to pull through the war. The youth shifted its mentality and lost its innocence in the Great War. Therefore, Remarque did not focus his book on the combat that took place during the Great War, rather he presents social issues, which does not belittle his experience rather it presents a different view of the…

    • 1709 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There was more detail in the film than the book. Most books have a lot of detail. Especially conversations and emotions. They explain how the character feels and explain what the setting is like. In the film, it also had much detail. It shows most of how the character(s) gets place to place. When reading a book, you use your imagination and in a film you can watch in. For instince, in the book, it didn't explain how Rainsford escaped from place to place. In a new chapter, he would be in a different area and it didn't describe what he did to get there. In the film, Rainsford tricked General Zaroff and got back to safety. It…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is certain that as the reader, one is left feeling bereft and truly sorrowful at the close of ‘The Open Boat’. However, it is not with emphasising the self-pity of the seamen, or using particularly emotive language, that Crane achieves this, but rather by subtly manipulating the plot structure, carefully and effectively establishing the characters, and selecting a narrative style that is objective and detached. These techniques culminate in a conclusion that is both unexpected in its resolution, and unexpected in its effect on the reader, who is left to dwell on the fate of the seamen long after the final page is turned.…

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    James M. Cox was an English professor at Dartmouth College in Hanover for 27 years and a visiting professor at Kenyon College, Texas A&M, Princeton University, Emory University, and the University of Virginia. He was also awarded the Jay B. Hubbell medal for his accomplishments in American literature. Based on this information, this source is reliable. This article,” The Red Badge of Courage: The Purity of War” by James Cox, highlighted the key elements of realism portrayed in The Red Badge of Courage. In the article Cox also talks about Cranes other pieces such as Maggie, a Girl of the Streets, The Scarlet Letter, Black Riders, and many more. In this article Cox says, “Crane extends realism down into the society of soldiers. They are invariably…

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Red Badge of Courage is about a young soldier named Henry Fleming,who is drafted during the war. The book traces the thread of emotions and reactions to events that he goes through, in the civil war. Being an an average farmer from New York, Henry wanted to go to war and become a hero like the ones he has read about in his school. The book starts off with a bunch of boys sitting at camp by the river, and while everyone is thinking about what they will do in war and how heroic they would be, Henry was thinking of how he would react when he goes to the battlefields. How would he react if he was severely injured or even died? Though he said that, no matter what happens he will not run from a fight or a battle, he did, during the second war, when he was scared and he saw a few other soldiers scamper due to the smoke. Henry kept telling himself through and through that he was protecting himself, even when the…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Red Badge of Courage requires a less restricted from of reference, for Solomon realizes that Crane was not directing his attention against the Cooke-Cable-George Eggleston celebration of heroism. Instead he found his real subject in the psychology of motivation under stress and anticipated a view of warfare which had become almost universal in our own country.”(web) There is not many books that have been published in the view of a young soldier from the civil war period, and this book gives the reader a glimpse inside of solider mind. “The youth, in his leapings, saw, as through a mist, a picture of four or five men stretched upon the ground or writhing upon their knees with bowed heads as if they had been stricken by bolts from the sky. Tottering among them was the rival color bearer, whom the youth saw had been bitten vitally by the bullets of the last formidable volley. He perceived this man fighting a last struggle, the struggle of one whose legs are grasped by demons. It was a ghastly battle. Over his face was the bleach of death, but set upon it was the dark and hard lines of desperate purpose. With this terrible grin of resolution he hugged his precious flag to him and was stumbling and staggering in his design to go the way that led to safety for it.” (book) Solomon really gives credit to Crane for writing his book in this fashion and credits this book one of Cranes best works. “Solomon has an acute sense for telling word and image, and without straining has revealed the complexity of texture in the best of Crane’s work.” (web) After reading the critics work I believe that Solomon wrote this because he agrees with Cranes prospective on how young boys grew into men in a time of war. They all start out scared and weak, but by the end they are strong and mighty. Solomon…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane tells a story about a youth, Henry Fleming, who is eager to fight in the American Civil War because of the glory of victory. Once he was officially in the military, he realized that war wasn’t all he thought it would be. His regiment mostly just marched from place to place. The lack of fighting made Henry begin to doubt his decision to go against his mother’s wishes and join the war. When his regiment finally went to battle, Henry experienced things that made him mature from a boy to a man in a matter of days.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. One passage that i found in the Red Badge of Courage that had much confusion would have to be in chapter 10. In this chapter, a young man keeps calling Henry the name Tom Jamison. Henry can obviously knows he is suffering from a head wound. These passages can be very different and similar. They are similar in the since of war, but are different in perspective and in detail. General Pleaston's passage makes me feel as if was really experiencing war. I believe this passage makes me feel this way because of the descriptive details the author uses. I also chose this passage because it was from real events. A passage that can offer a blow b blow description of events in battles would probably…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This book embodies all of the facets that go along with love and death, during a volatile time of war. O 'Brien captures the theme of emotional conflict and how strongly it affects soldiers in a brilliant way. By correlating mundane goods with intangibles like feelings and emotion, he successfully points out all of the angles of war that the lay person generally cannot comprehend. He compels the reader to understand not just the daily grind of war, but how the little things can bring important things in life into perspective. He digs under the surface of the tangible items to demonstrate a much greater meaning to these mens lives. In essence, the soldiers are defined by the things they…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Red Badge of Courage

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The main character of this book is Henry Fleming, mostly referred to as The Youth or Youth. The Youth has dark, curly brown hair also; he is a young teenager and is average height when compared to the Tall Soldier. Henry is insecure because he is going through a difficult stage between being a "man" and being a "boy". Henry can't wait to get to war when he signs up but during the book Henry learns that war has a lot of affects on people emotionally and physically. Henry's flaw is that he is afraid of making himself look bad and he is worried that he is going to be a coward and run away from battle. Henry really wants to be a "man" and be courageous. I once heard a swim coach give an extremely good definition of courage. He said "To me courage is not to be unafraid but it is to be afraid but one does it anyways and doesn't worry about being afraid. I think Henry thought of courageous as fearless and that is also part of his flaw.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O’Brien’s novel, The Things They Carried, revolves around the frequent theme of courage however, his perception of courage is ignorant considering the actual meaning of courage. O’Brien uses courage as an antidote to the physical and moral weakness in the soldiers of Vietnam creating character obsession over his interchangeable perception of courage and weakness. Not going to war when drafted is perceived as weak, but O’Brien believes that going to war when one wants to flee is Canada is arguable weakness. O’Brien believes no matter how strong or courageous a solider presumes to be it will never seem to be enough; weakness will always prevail because they are “too frightened to be cowards” (24). In looking at all works of literature from…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen crane shows us Henry Fleming's journey through war. Crane develops Fleming by using animal imagery, patterns of speech, and interactions with other characters.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, the protagonist in the novel, Tim O’Brien, shows bravery in several ways. Before the war O’Brien shows bravery. Entering the war, alone, was an act of bravery that O’Brien performed. In 1968, Tim was “drafted to fight a war [that he] hated (38).” He did not believe in what the war stood for, because he did not understand it. He believed that he was “too smart, too compassionate, too everything (39)” to be in the war. O’Brien hated war, and he did not think he could stand it being on the front lines of it. He “was no soldier. [He] hated Boy Scouts. [He] hated dirt and tents and mosquitoes. The sight of blood made [him] queasy, and [he] couldn’t tolerate authority, and [he] didn’t know a rifle from a slingshot (39-40).” O’Brien had the choice to run away…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The history of war is what many spend time reading about in textbooks. Few, however, experience war and all that it encompasses. David Leckie, a marine during World War II, uses his book, Helmet for My Pillow, to share with readers the truth of what it was like to be a soldier. Rather than skimming the surface of his time on Parris Island and the Pacific Islands, he goes into unmatched, excruciating detail; every trench dug, every shot fired, and every fallen soldier passed was recounted by Leckie. Setting this story apart from any other, the first-hand accounts of combat, unlikely descriptions of the day-to-day actions of the soldiers, and the heart that Leckie intertwines with each part of his story all combine to make this thought-provoking,…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Since the beginning of time there have been wars and there have been stories about those wars. Hollywood has produced wars about the American Revolution to the World Wars. Before the movies, there was oral tradition and written word that told stories about the war. A classic example and one “real” war novel was written by Stephan Crane. In 1895, Crane wrote a post-civil war novel, “The Red.” This novel became the precursor of what a good war story should do, portray a soldier’s personal experience, emotion and the trauma caused by war. Stephan Crane accomplished this by researching firsthand accounts of soldiers, using unique writing styles and wisdom gleaned from prior events of his life. These helped him write “The Red”; the very first “real”…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays