Preview

René Descartes Third Meditation

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1054 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
René Descartes Third Meditation
René Descartes was a methodical and intelligent thinker, which is to be expected from the man who invented the Cartesian Plane that would eventually lead to the idea of Calculus. It is due to this measured approach that we get his Meditations on First Philosophy, and from his methodology on how to determine what is irrefutably true which Descartes calls a clear and distinct idea. In his first Meditation, Descartes determines that the only way to determine what is true is to first think nothing is true and work from there. Is it possible that the fundamentals of mathematics are false? Can two and three not be equal to five? To Descartes, this must be considered, and he deems that there is a possibility of an all-powerful being that is dedicated …show more content…
How does such a drastic swing in beliefs occur? By Descartes reasoning, this occurs due to a very significant breakthrough in his thought process. This breakthrough is that of the existence of God. While before he admits that it is possible that god does not exist, he personally does not believe that, so he attributes the possibility of a deceiver to the powerful mind. In the third Meditation, he has concluded that God does truly exist. His reasoning is that no idea or substance can contain more intentional reality than its …show more content…
This would mean that any ideas that are positioned within him cannot be from nothing, as he says “There cannot be an infinite regress” thus in order to have an idea of his deficiencies as something that is lacking from the perfect, the perfect idea must be from something which contains the perfect ideals. As he stated earlier, these concepts cannot spring from something that cannot contain them; thus, if he is to have come from his parents, who though loving are flawed creatures as all humans are, the idea must be from something greater. He believes that God left these ideas as a sort of artisanal trademark, thus that is the solution. If all men come from the creation of God, the vague ideas of infinity and perfection come from the source of God. Now that God is proven (by Descartes account), the issue of whether or not he is a deceiver is the key to determine if math is true or not. Descartes believes that if God is infinite and the manifestation of perfection, he cannot be a deceiver, as that would be a deficiency. If god is not a deceiver, the fundamentals of mathematics are not under scrutiny, and are thus held to be valid and true. Everything happens because of things that happen before it. There is something that must start everything and God can be that source. There must be an original action source. The unmoved

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Being derived from one’s own nature means that it is innate, originating in the mind. Before he goes further into it, he states “Now manifest by the natural light that there must be as much in the efficient and total cause as in the effect of that…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The meditator disagrees with the argument that he could believe in a God due to being in denial, and creating the idea in contrast with his own imperfect self. Our own self-doubts, as well as our wishes derive from the idea that we are not adequate and there exists a perfect pious being. "In this first instance of knowledge, there is nothing but a clear and distinct perception of what I affirm. Yet this would hardly be enough to render me certain of the truth of a thing, if it could ever happen that something that I perceived so clearly and distinctly were false. And thus I now seem to be able to posit as a general that everything I clearly and distinctly perceive is true." The meditator also alludes to the idea that he could possibly be on the brink of perfection, and his remaining flaws are slowly vanishing, and he is growing more and more immaculate. However, if he is capable of being perfect, then he is capable of conceiving the idea of God without outside influence. "I am certain that I am a thinking thing. But do I not therefore also know what is required for me to be certain of anything?" (70)The…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to this principle, the reality of the cause must be greater than or equal to the reality of the effect. The idea of God has infinite reality and, by theory, the only cause of this infinite idea can only be God. With all this said, the reality of God is the only plausible cause to the reality of the idea of God. Descartes gives another proof in Meditation Five where he has reasoned that a triangle must have all the properties he assigns to it, because the triangle exists as an idea in his mind and he clearly and distinctly perceives all these properties. He then reasons, by analogy, that God exists as an idea in his mind and he clearly and distinctly perceives all of his qualities. One of these qualities is existence, so it follows from his clear and distinct perception that God must exist. If existence is the essence of God, then God would not be God if he did not exist, just as a triangle would not be a triangle if it were not three-sided. At the very least, then, the existence of God must be as certain as the properties of mathematical and geometrical objects since he can prove them in the same way. Having concluded that God must necessarily exist, Descartes goes further and then asks how he received the idea of God. He could have not invented the idea. Therefore, the idea must be innate which, according to Descartes, means that God must have created him…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Michael Byer’s Work “Monuments to Our Better Nature” he uses subjective descriptions to help us understand how magnificent he saw the National Mall as a child in comparison to his adult view. Both of his perspectives help us understand what experiences he has been through, and the changes they brought. As a child he takes time describing all the fascinating things he saw, and as an adult he feels nostalgic towards them. His title makes me feel that Byers as an adult he feels like, only the good things in history are represented but not the ones that can make us feel shame.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes proves that God exists in his third meditation. He proves that God exists because he wants to be certain about things outside of himself. But, he cannot be certain of these things if he is ignorant about the existence of God. This is because if a supreme God exists, he could cause Descartes to be mistaken in the one avenue to certainty that he has. This avenue is known as clear and distinct perception, and, according to Descartes, it is what is necessary to be certain about a thing. However, a supreme God could easily be deceiving him even when he thinks he is correct as a result of this clear and distinct perception. This is known as the metaphysical doubt. Therefore, to remove this basis for doubt, it is important to Descartes to establish whether this supreme God is capable of deceiving him. But first, he must establish whether this God exists.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In Descartes’ First Meditation, Descartes’ overall intention is to present the idea that our perceptions and sensations are flawed and should not be trusted entirely. His purpose is to create the greatest possible doubt of our senses. To convey this thought, Descartes has three main arguments in the First Meditation: The dream argument, the deceiving God argument, and the evil demon “or evil genius”. Descartes’ dream argument argues that there is no definite transition from a dream to reality, and since dreams are so close to reality, one can never really determine whether they are dreaming or not. To reinforce that argument, Descartes presents the deceiving God argument. He says that since God is all powerful, then he has the power to deceive us about reality or our dreams. But again, Descartes feels this argument is missing something, which is why he concludes with the evil genius argument. The evil genius argument’s purpose is to tie all these arguments together and strengthen Descartes’ entire argument. The evil genius argument goes like this: God is omnipotent and supremely good, which means God cannot be the one who deceives humans, rather, a separate entity -- an "evil genius, [who is] supremely powerful and clever, who has directed his entire effort at deceiving me" (Descartes 492). By deceiving, I mean tricking humans that their sensations and perceptions are real, when they are indeed not real. To overcome this evil genius, Descartes says he will regard all external things as “hoaxes of my dreams, with which he (the evil genius) lays snares for my credulity” (Descartes 492). In this analysis, I will further discuss Descartes’ arguments in the First Meditation, the purpose of the evil genius argument, how Descartes attempts to overcome the power of this great deceiver, and ultimately why his attempt is…

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He states that whether he is awake or asleep, “it remains true that two and three make five, and that a square has but four sides.” From his perspective, these truths are so evident that they could never fall under suspicion.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes Belief in God

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In his groundbreaking work, Meditations on First Philosophy, the French philosopher Rene Descartes lays the groundwork for many philosophical principles by attempting to “establish a bold and lasting knowledge” (171)1. The foundations for knowledge Descartes established would go on to influence a plethora of other philosophers and philosophical works. Descartes argues in his meditations first from the point of view of complete skepticism, using skepticism as a tool in order to discover what is real. Through this method, Descartes explains the existence of man as a “thinking thing,” the capacity for human error, the overall trustworthiness of our senses, the existence of a physical world, the mind and body as separate entities, and the existence of an infinitely perfect God. Descartes uses a variety of premises to help back up his idea of a prefect God. The main idea concluded from these premises is that man alone could not have come up with the idea of infinite perfection, so the idea of God comes from God himself, thus proving his existence. Although his argument for the existence of God is the least strong of his philosophical arguments, I agree with Descartes because humans alone could not grasp the idea of infinity or an infinitely perfect being. I intend examine and defend Descartes’ explanation of the existence of God, propose valid counter-arguments and my own answers to those objections.…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    René Descartes (1596-1650) recognized that this influence of false beliefs could impair his scientific investigations, producing possible false conclusions to his thinking. Therefore, he "realized that it was necessary, once in the course of [my] life, to demolish everything completely and start again right from the foundations if [I] wanted to establish anything at all in the sciences that was stable and likely to last." Descartes began his philosophical career by trying to provide a sound basis for the new scientific method that was being developed, but at the same time he wished to show that this new scientific methodology was consistent with Christianity. It was because of this that Descartes began his Meditations on First Philosophy. Descartes ' overarching goal in the Meditations can be viewed as "a search of a complete system of knowledge, in which [he] would prove the existence of God, understand the nature of the human mind, and establish the principle on which the material universe can be studied."…

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes and Skepticism

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Firstly, he tackles the idea that his own existence and thoughts must have come from somewhere or something. He goes on to explain that the thought he has of God is one of an "eternal, infinite, omniscient, omnipotent, creator of all things" (pg 143). As a result,…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From the beginning of the third meditation, Descartes seeks to establish the existence of God using his initial concept of self awareness. Descartes argued that because he thought, then he lived. Thinking ability at this time was linked to being alive and thought that there must be a god who puts the thoughts in his mind. In his quest for indubitable truth, Descartes came up with the theory of ideas, which classified those things that he considered distinct and clear to be true. Descartes argued that the idea of god should be coming from within him since he cannot experience god himself directly or find any perfection in himself.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes argues that we often have perceptions in life that seem incredibly obvious and unquestionable, things that surely must be real. Yet at times our senses can deceive us. But why would God deceive us if he is the model of perfection? Instilling a fault from a faultless being doesn’t make sense, as doing such would go against him being as impeccable as he is, unless it isn’t god who is behind this curtain of confusion, but instead a deceiver, a cunning demon causing me to question my own judgements.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death of a Salesman

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “The ideals of freedom, equality, and opportunity traditionally held to be available to every American” (Dictionary.com). The American Dream is “a life of personal happiness and material comfort as traditionally sought by individuals in the U.S” (Dictionary.com). The image of America is presented negatively in the novel The Great Gatsby and the play Death of A Salesman because it is depicted as a materialistic lonely place.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In René Descartes Meditations on first Philosophy, he goes through a process of elimination of concepts he has formed up in his mind, to come to conclude whether he is a living thing. Descartes at a point in his meditation comes to say, that he is a living thing due to his ability to think. In his Meditations on first Philosophy, he says that he is precisely nothing but a thinking thing. In this paper I will be explaining how Descartes came to formulate his conclusion of his existence being so, owing to his ability to use his mind.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of Descartes important discoveries is that he considers himself as a thinking thing. He makes this discovery thanks to mathematics and his critical thinking skills. Since he was talented and made a great contribution in mathematics, Descartes was able to come up with own logical theories and techniques. According to Descartes philosophy, ideas are what connect the mind to the world because there are two types of reality contained in them. He calls them objective and formal reality.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays