Preview

Res Judicata Case Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
762 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Res Judicata Case Analysis
Storming the Court This true story begins with the overthrow of the first elected president of Haiti and the persecution of his supporters by a military regime. In the early 90’s, thousands of people fled Haiti on boats headed to the United States. The US coast guard intercepted the refugees, INS’s hasty screening process determined they were all economic migrants and returned them to Haiti. A group of Florida lawyers were concerned with INS screening processes and filed the Baker lawsuit. The court issued an order temporarily halting the rushed interviews and preventing the Coast Guard from sending the refugees directly back to Haiti. However, the government did not want to bring the Haitian refugees to the mainland for fear that more would …show more content…
The court in Baker decided that since the government was holding the refugees in an overseas military base that afforded them no protection under American law. The Florida lawyers appealed however the Supreme Court refused to hear the case. Shortly thereafter a group of Yale law students with the help of their professor filed a new lawsuit on behalf of Haitian the refugees. Res judicata played a significant role for the students and professor since the court had already rendered a judgment in the Baker case. Res judicata also known as claim preclusion is a legal principle that states a case may not be relitigated once it has been judged on its merits. Simply, a losing plaintiff cannot re-sue the winning defendant for the same reason they did previously. While this doctrine may not seem just it promotes judicial efficiency, fairness, and consistent adjudication. Res judicata only allows a litigant one chance to litigate an issue and the losing party must rely on an …show more content…
I think that it really doesn’t matter where something is happening if our government is holding refugees those people are entitled to the protections afforded by American law and our constitution. It’s sad to me that the government fought so hard against protecting these people that truly needed our help. The results of this litigation do have an influence on our polices today as it applies to refugees. The Haitian refugee crisis was the first time most of America had ever heard about American laws not applying in certain locations. One of the most touching parts of the book to me was when Judge Johnson said “If the Due Process Clause does not apply to the detainees at Guantanamo the government would have discretion deliberately to starve or beat them to deprive them of medical attention. To return them without process to their persecutors, or to discriminate among them based on the color of their skin.” This litigation paved the way for the protections of the Al Qaeda detainees held on Guantanamo Bay post 9/11. The most interesting part of that for me is the fact that those men were not refugees but rather enemy combatants yet they were still afforded protections and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Case Brief No 1

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Plaintiff and Defendant: The plaintiff/appellant is Harvestons Securities, Inc. The defendant/appellee is Narnia Investments, Ltd.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Exhibit 16.5 is a final pretrial order for the United States District court for the Northern District of Illinois. The case on the pretrial order is Austin Bennaza vs Buddy Smith. The notice states stipulations and statements that deal with the case. It details each parties current state as well as their part in the case. It states what each party owes the other in dealing with the case. It also states how long the trial should take. It allocates specific time to each task associated with the case. The document needs to be prepared and submitted jointly by opposing trial counsel. The pretrial order also needs to be signed by the pretrial judge.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Michael Blair was faced with multiple charges and years in prison for something he did not do. First Blair would be faced with a really long time in prison for capital murder. Wednesday, Blair was charged with capital murder because of the death of Ashley Nicole Estell, who was abducted on Sept. 4 from a crowded park in Plano, Texas (McFarland). This shows what Michael was charged with capital murder against a Texas teen, Ashley Estell, on September 4th from a crowded park. Second, Blair was already a convicted felon and claimed that he was innocent. A convicted sex offender that was 23 years old was charged with capital murder, says that he did not commit the abduction and killing of a Texas girl (McFarland). This goes more into personal detail about the convicted murderer, Michael Blair, and the fact that he is pleading innocent in this capital murder charge. Michael Blair knew that he was not guilty of capital murder against Ashley Estell, but he would have a long fight ahead of him to get exonerated. The investigation would make him seem more guilty, than innocent.…

    • 1741 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The plaintiff a minor alien who survived a tragedy at sea, was rescued and placed in the custody of his great uncle, a temporary legal custodian. His great uncle filed several asylum applications on his behalf against the wishes of the minor's father in Cuba. The Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) rejected the applications as void. The plaintiff appealed to the district court, which was dismissed because the father was the only one that could apply for his asylum case. The plaintiff appealed stating that the INS had violated §1158 of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1996. The issue here was whether a non parental relative could apply or submit an application for asylum on behalf of the plaintiff against parental wishes.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is nothing pleasant about this case, and I thank you for your attention, ladies and gentlemen of the jury. Ms. Milan Jackson did not face any threat from Chris Archer on the night of her death. Ms. Jackson was a troubled young woman who can be confidently determined to have a mental disorder. Dr. Alex Richards claims herself that Ms. Jackson’s eating disorder is a form of “self harm” or “self punishment”. In either instance, it is a self induced disorder caused by the perfection seeking qualities explained by Pat Smith. While in primary school, Milan Jackson was a target for teasing among the other elementary students. Prior to entering college, her perfectionist nature and eating disorder had kept her bullies at bay, as well as any drastic…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first amendment of the United States Constitution guarantees freedoms concerning religion, expression, assembly, and the right to petition. It guarantees freedom of expression by prohibiting Congress from restricting thee press or the rights of individuals to speak freely. Restricting the Monkey Juice billboards have raised an important constitutional issue which our company will use in our effort to challenge the ordinance. Because prohibiting the billboards that advertise alcohol is directly regulating speech, then it is safe to say that is directly violate the right of free speech protected by the First Amendment to the U.S Constitution.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    law case

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The purpose of this arbitration paper is written for arbitration meeting conducted on April 4th 2014 for the incident happened in February 15th.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For a “brutal, cowardly attack” on a 27-year-old man, run over and left for dead, Agustin Caruso pleaded guilty to manslaughter Monday and was sentenced to 8 1/2 years in prison.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Imagine having lived all of your life in a country on a plantation. This is all that you’ve ever known because your family thought that it would be better to leave their home country to go to a place with more opportunity. One day, people come to your home and tell you that you are no longer recognized as a citizen of the country that you have grown up in your whole life. This is the struggle that many Haitian people in the Dominican Republic are going through today, all because of their background. The actions that Sonia Pierre executed throughout her life greatly impacted those of Haitian lineage in the Dominican Republic, which can be traced back through her childhood, the establishment of the Movement for Dominican Women of Haitian Descent (MUDHA), and the fight that she embodied till the end of her life.…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Case Brief

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The parties in this case are Elian Gonzalez with Lazaro Gonzalez and Attorney General Janet Reno. In November 25, 1999 the United States Coast Guard intercepted two fishermen who had rescued five- year- old Elian Gonzalez floating on an inner tube in the Atlantic Ocean off the coast from Florida. Elian’s mother had died during the voyage from Cuba to the United States. The United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (“INS”) granted Plaintiff a temporary deferral of his inspection and placed him in the care of his paternal great uncle, Lazaro Gonzalez, who resides in Miami, Florida.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Does Velta’s friend and her family stay in Latvia? Are Velta and her friend reunited? Is Uncle Maris really kicked out of Velta’s home? Although I would like to know the answers to these questions, I felt that the content that was read was more important than the content that was not read. The issue of immigration in Latvia during Velta’s childhood is very similar to what is happening across the world today. Many immigrants are trying to find a country willing to accept them so they can escape from war-torn homes. How many times have I heard family members or others speak about the Syrian refugees like Uncle Maris spoke about the immigrants coming into Latvia? It is difficult to understand others’ unwillingness to allow asylum seekers into the United States after hearing stories of how much they have suffered already. Velta had heard all about the suffering of the Jewish people, much as we are told about the suffering of the Syrian people. Yet, many Americans refuse to empathize, choosing to hold on to their attitudes of discrimination. Instead of focusing on conspiracy theories about the incoming Syrian refugees, many Americans should read Gina Ochsner book or one like it. Immigration is an emotional journey as well as a physical journey. Those asking for asylum want to feel safe and accepted, not turned away because of racial and religious differences. As Christians, we should help those in need regardless where someone comes from or what they believe in. I believe this small part of Ochsner’s book gave a powerful insight into the struggles of an immigrant family and the effect of just one person’s discrimination can have on a…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    U.S Asylum

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Elian Gonzalez, a six-year-old boy, boarded a boat with his mother to leave Cuba and sail to the United States. During the passage, the boat capsized. Elian’s mother died, along with ten other passengers. Elian’s father was still in Cuba. After being admitted to a local hospital, Elian’s great-uncle Lazaro Gonzalez contacted the Immigration and Naturalization Service (“INS”). A few days later, Lazaro petitioned for asylum on Elian’s behalf. Not long after, another petition for asylum was filed, signed by Elian. A third request for asylum was then filed by Lazaro on Elian’s behalf after he was awarded temporary custody in a state court action. The three petitions were similar, citing that Elian was afraid to return to Cuba alleging persecution and the potential of being used as a propaganda tool for the Cuban government. Elian’s father, Juan Miguel Gonzalez, had sent a letter to Cuban officials requesting that Elian be returned to Cuba. This letter was subsequently forwarded to the INS.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Please accept this letter as a complaint of employment discrimination based on gender by Alice Bennett. Please also accept this letter as an appearance by Marcia Robinson of Auburn University Legal Services on behalf of Mrs. Alice Bennett.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Supreme Court Case Study

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages

    That the Supreme Court exercises a policy making role has been an established fact ever since Maybury vs. Madison defined the Court’s role in judicial review of existing law. By choosing which cases to review and by establishing precedents by way interpretation of a law’s meaning and applicability the Court influences the course of action adopted not only by government but by individuals and businesses who consider the implications of the Court’s actions. In adjudicating disagreements of alternative interpretations of a law the Supreme Court establishes policies which have implications extending beyond the specific case in question and into social policy at large. In choosing which cases to review the Court calls attention to certain issues…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ). The sources of US Law are important because they secure our general wellbeing, and guarantee our rights as natives against misuse by other individuals, by associations, and by the administration itself. We have laws to accommodate our general wellbeing. These exist at the neighborhood, state and national levels, and incorporate things such as laws that originate from the Bill of Rights in the U.S. Constitution, that ensure our fundamental opportunities like the right to speak freely, religion, and the press. Laws that shield us from segregation in light of our race, sex, age, or due to an incapacity. In the United States, the Constitution is a definitive wellspring of the law. Be that as it may, it was never intended to address each particular…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays