Both the English teacher and the school counselor suggested to her to talk to the principal. After reading the paper, the principal told A.M. to leave out the last sentence of the exposition, saying that it sounded too religious. The mother of the student asked if Superintendent Sposato could also review the paper, and once he read it, Sposato agreed with Principal
Howard. He said that the “religious message delivered by A.M. could violate the establishment clause of the First Amendment.”
A.M. presented the speech at the function without the line, but soon afterwards, she sued the school district, declaring that they violated her free-speech rights. She said that she was discriminated because of her religion perspective.