Preview

Revisionism In The Cold War

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
433 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Revisionism In The Cold War
The orthodox view of the Cold War’s origins was challenged by antithesis known as “revisionism”. Revisionists proposed new emphases its reasoning by stressing on the importance of American pursuit of its economic survival and that the Soviet Union was not solely to blame for the Cold War.

Revisionists such as William A. Williams explained the emergence of the Cold War in terms of “dollar diplomacy”. Revisionists view the U.S foreign policy as inherently linked to the needs of Capitalism. In his work, The Tragedy of American Diplomacy, William argued that the U.S traditional policy of “Open Door” which has sought to serve the expansion of national economy had precipitated the Cold War.

The Open-Door policy which was intended to globalise a friendly capitalist system in line with U.S economic interest had pushed Washington to press its own hegemony in Eastern Europe on the conviction that it was a vital region for U.S economic expansion.
…show more content…
Substantial differences of interpretation particularly pertaining to Roosevelt’s succession by Truman, the misconception of the U.S towards Stalin’s policies and U.S air raids on Japan. In fact, some Revisionists perceived the Soviets desired for conciliation as opposed to the power-hunger depiction by the Orthodox view. Revisionist hold sympathetic view of Stalin as he is perceived as a trustworthy partner, proved being a reliable ally during the wartime. Moreover, the U.S administration particularly under President Truman had overestimated the Soviet’s postwar capacity. Advocates of the Revisionism suggested the Soviet Union was not a great military threat to the United States as Soviet’s postwar military and economy were severely weakened. Meanwhile radical Revisionists view the nuclear bombing on Japan by the U.S was a direct warn and intimidated the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Ronald Reagan Influence

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During the years of 1947-1991, the World was divided in two, the eastern nations, who believed in Communism and social equality, and those of western nations, who believed in Democracy and free-trade. The world changed a lot during this time, leading from a world divided into a world that was more accepting of foreign ideas. Tensions between the United states and the USSR rose during the Cold War, but feel and disappeared altogether during the end. It was a War fought with espionage and secrecy, instead of combat and bombings. A war with no declaration or actual documentation of conflict, it was the war that lasted 45 years, it was the Cold War.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Was the Cold War Inevitable

    • 2933 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The orthodox view of the Cold War elucidates its inevitability due to the great ideological differences that existed between the Soviet Union and United States. On the other hand, the revisionists argued that it happened due to the actions that Soviets took and the consequential responses made by the United States as a result of their inflexible, single-sided interpretations of Soviet action. Yet, even with the backdrop of the early Bolshevik conflict in 1918 as well as the great ideological gulf between the Soviet Union and United states, the cold war could have been avoided in its initial stages under President Roosevelt. However, what really determined it was the series of events that occurred after Roosevelt was succeeded by Truman. The inevitability of the Cold War, at its roots, was due to Soviet aggression and attitudes felt by the United States which was exacerbated from the post war climate of the time. To be precise, it was a combination of the subsequent events that followed Truman’s accession that sealed the unavoidability of the Cold War. American diplomatic policies were dictated by their fears of communism as well as opportunities that arise from modern warfare which aided in the evolution of American foreign policies. In the end, the Cold War was inevitable as a result of the conflict of interest between nations, whether it be the ideological gulf between communism and capitalism or the determining the political future of Eastern Europe, which was ultimately fuelled by the unstable post World War II environment.…

    • 2933 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    HTST 386 final exam

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It was the clash between capitalism and communism that caused the Cold war in the first place. Looking all the way back to the issue of Germany and its division post-WWII, and leading to the Berlin crisis, evidence is obvious that the United States and Soviet Union’s different polices with respect to governing their portions of Germany led to the ‘plantation of the seeds of mistrust’. In Addition, the fact that European countries had been devastated by the Second World War further fueled this clash of ideals between superpowers, since Soviets were trying to absorb them into their sphere of influence by offering benefits through means of the Warsaw Pact. On the other hand, the U.S. had implemented the Truman Doctrine in order to stop communism from spreading further, most notoriously providing financial aid to Greece and Turkey. As a result, the Cold War was truly put into full gear; the clash of spheres of influence was imminent, it was East Germany vs. West Germany, NATO vs. the Warsaw Pact, Capitalism vs. Communism.…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beer influenced the transition from hunting and gathering to agricultural based societies because it gave people a keen interest in grain storage. Beer was discovered as gruel, a mixture of water and grain, that was heated. It stimulated a dopaminergic release, causing the people that experienced the flavor to yearn for that rewarding sensation more. Standage noted that people could store a pound of grain a year, which caused the transition away from the savage – minded lifestyle even more appealing (13). Beer is a drink used to relax and celebrate, and seeing that the world functions through the ability to communicate, beer was extremely valuable to the people of the time period. In addition, it is possible that a trade-off of some sort was made possible, as some would convert to beer-making and exchange their craft for meat and berries. In the book, it was said that beer “was truly the defining drink of those first great civilizations,” and these various new abilities brought into play through beer makes this understandable (30). All of these positive and attractive new possibilities are ways that beer influenced the switch from the traditional hunt – and – gather mentality to a more society – oriented lifestyle with agriculture.…

    • 1918 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cold War DBQ

    • 1160 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During the time period pertaining to the Cold War, the foreign policies and ideas established by each president remained in effect despite social and political unrest. However, United States’ involvement in the eastern hemisphere, governmental influence in the nation and in the “hot wars”, and presidential diplomacy caused foreign policies and ideas to contain many similarities throughout the duration of the Cold War. Therefore, the United States experienced more continuity in her methods of dealing with the threat of communism.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the time of post-World War II Soviet geopolitical expansion, the political and economic future of European nations were at stake. Truman described the situation as autocratic regimes undermining democratic countries, using political, economic and military means to re-write and disrupt the western European map of geopolitical influence, alliances and independence (Truman 344). Greece and Turkey asked for military and financial aid from the United States as Great Britain, their former benefactor, was no longer able, or in a position to, support the two struggling nations. The two countries would have fallen if not for the immediate financial support from the United States. (Truman, 1) While the Truman Doctrine only gave support to Greece…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Lewis Gaddis is a history professor at Yale University, lecturing an undergraduate class every Monday and Wednesday on the Cold War. He wrote The Cold War: A New History based on questions some of his prior students had on the Cold War, as well as making a shorter, more understanding book for students to read. Gaddis provides a fantastic overview of the Cold War but could have organized the information a lot better. For instance, if he put it in chronological order rather than jumping back and forth between decades, it would have made it a lot easier to understand what caused certain events. Gaddis was born April 2, 1941 in Cotulla, Texas.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Kennan played a major role in the development of the foreign policy of the United States during the Cold War. As a result, I spent a lot of time researching the many aspects on which he left a very visible mark. Not only did Kennan cause the creation and usage of the containment policy, but he also later disagreed with the way the United States government applied the policy. George Kennan provided the United States with much of the Russian and Soviet historical background information that it would know during the Cold War, he suggested solutions to the looming Soviet threat during the Cold War in his “long telegram,” and the government attempted to make decisions based on these solutions. Much of the Soviet and Russian historical background…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1945 and 1946, there were increasing debates within the United States government over how to deal with the Soviet Union. Should the United States now see the Soviets as an "evil empire" that threatened to undermine the peace and freedom of an American-led "free world"? The influential 1946 memo to President Truman said that the Soviets were a global threat to peace. It said that the Soviet Union had a secret plan to conquer the world and spread communism throughout the world. The Soviets refusal to accept American leadership and a global democratic, capitalist community of nations, demonstrated that capitalism and communism could not peacefully co-exist. The Soviet domination of Eastern Europe after World War II and the continuing Soviet military build up was proof that the Soviet Union was threatening global peace and security…

    • 1024 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There is a great disparity amongst historians when discussing the point at which the Cold War began. Many begin their analysis of the Cold War in 1945, when the Allied forces overcame Germany. This is a widely accepted catalyst for the start of the Cold War, and indeed, a very important moment for the Allies. It was not, however, where the tensions between the Soviets and the United States began. This essay will discuss how fundamental ideological differences between the two superpowers existed long before the conclusion of the Second World War.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Truman did not exaggerate the soviet threat When Truman became President, on April 1945, US, Britain and SU were in the same alliance against Germany and Japan. At that time, only SU and Mongolia were official communist countries. The events about soviet treat came fast. After the war, communist governments were installed in Poland, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria and Czechoslovakia, forming the "Soviet Bloc”, under the soviet dominance and control. With the Red Scare in the back history, all the recent communist aggressive movements, all Stalin’s betrayals and his expressed intentions to spread the communism all over the world, personal animosity with Molotov at Potsdam that worsened the Soviet-American relations, President Truman understood that…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Cold War, a non-violent war between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, served as a period of great paranoia for many Americans and the rest of the world. On the brink of nuclear fallout, the world lied in the hands of the communist Soviet Union and the capitalist United States. The two countries emerged from World War II as the strongest nations in the world, but the stark differences in government and economics led to a bitter rivalry. Furthermore, Stalin’s aggressive plans to spread communism throughout the world opposed the U.S.’s values on freedom. The belligerent actions of the Soviet Union to force communism into weak democratic societies caused the United States and some Western European Nations to work to prevent the spread of communism.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harry Truman

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At the end of the Second World War two major issues were brought to attention. The first was dealing with the destruction of the global catastrophe. The second issue involved the shape of the new world and what political alliances were to be made. And although the U.S. and Russia were “allies” during the war the second issue was the foremost cause of the contention between the world’s two political/economic systems, Capitalism and Communism. The Cold War was basically an ideological catch-22 in which the U.S. was caught up in, mostly because of the actions taken by the Federal government and the chief executive, Harry S. Truman. Up until Truman’s speech to Congress in 1947, the most powerful influence on American foreign policy had been the Monroe Doctrine, a policy by President Monroe that proposed America ought to keep out of European affairs. The Truman Doctrine completely overturned the Monroe Doctrine. The Soviet Union viewed the actions taken during Truman’s administration as further threats of American imperialism. Truman’s Foreign Policy reflected an entirely interventionist attitude with the implementation of the Truman Doctrine, the crisis in Berlin, and NATO. Therefore the statement is primarily invalid.…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    My research began for this paper by seeking out those who remembered the Cold War. I talked to many individuals before I came across anyone who did. The first individual I began to interview did not tell me much, what she recalled were the misconceptions broadcasted on television about the war, for instance the protestors. She stated that the television made it look like there were hundreds of protestors when in reality it was only a handful of individuals. One thing she did remembered that I had never heard about before was Bell Helicopter, which was owned by Lady Bird Johnson, she mentioned that there was controversy on the…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Causes Of The Tea Act

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page

    The Tea Act began to help the East India Company obtain business from all of the colonists. Subsequently, tea was not bought from other tea companies without being forced to pay a higher amount of money. Other companies didn't increase their prices, the East Company decreased their price. The colonists believed this to be another form of taxation without representation. They were unhappy by the Sugar Act, Stamp Act, and the Boston Massacre, the Tea Act just upsets the colonists even more. The colonists knew from the prior acts that the only way to stop the act was to protest it peacefully. The protest among the American colonists remained peaceful, they refused to unload the shipments of tea. This act and protest lead to the Boston Tea…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays