December 23, 2011
Did Rizal Really Want Independence?
The newest book about Jose Rizal entitled "Romance and Revolution," written by Luis Liza and Javier de Pedro (University of Asia and the Pacific, 2010) contributes new insights into the much-discussed question of whether or not Jose Rizal wanted the Philippine Islands to be independent of Spain. The authors devoted a whole Annex (IV) to a close scrutiny of Rizal's "Data for my Defense" written in Fort Santiago on December 12, 1896. As we celebrated the 115th Anniversary of this document last December 12, 2011, let me summarize here what the authors of "Romance and Revolution" opine concerning Rizal's convictions on independence. They maintained that a complete understanding of Rizal's political stand requires a thorough study of the "Data for my Defense" document. It can be considered as the final product in the evolution of his thought which had gone through various stages from the time he was a student in Spain to the last days before his execution on December 30, 1896. The first conclusion of the authors is that Rizal wanted independence for the Philippines only as a gradual process, not in one fell swoop. As they wrote: "He denounced those who chose to equate his desire to have freedoms with an intent to have independence, accusing them of either lying or misunderstanding him. He explicitly affirmed: 'I have believed that autonomy was bound to come little by little, and independence after a lapse of years. "Simply put, he felt that independence can be attained only after Spain grants the Filipinos, first, their basic political freedoms and second, autonomy. Although Rizal's early ideas on nationhood remain open to speculation, he later withdrew and refused to give any consideration to the alternative of assimilation with Spain as favored by other Ilustrados. One may agree or disagree with his views and approach, but there is no doubt that he wanted independence: he never desired the Philippines to remain a province of Spain forever. It is to be noted that for many years, he avoided uttering any remark that could be taken as pro-Spanish. This was evident during his last stay in Europe, his short residence in Hong Kong, and his last four years in Dapitan. "The first and last time that he broke his self-imposed silence was in his Defense, and only to affirm that he wanted independence after a lapse of years. He saw self-rule at the end of an unalterable historical development, like the natural process of growth in living organisms. Once this point is understood and accepted, it is easy to explain pro-Spanish sounding statements found in the document." It was also clear in "Data for my Defense" that Rizal never said that he loved Spain with patriotic zeal. Lisa and de Pedro affirm: "One seemingly pro-Spanish passage--'my education, eminently Spanish and as such patriotic'--if properly read, is not directed towards Spain but to the Philippines. When he wrote it, he only wanted to acknowledge that the origin of his Filipino dreams was born and developed during "his early formation years under Spanish educators." This affirmation is fully backed up by Rizal himself when he wrote: "From childhood, I was educated by Spaniards and was nurtured in the great examples of the History of Spain, Greece, and Rome. In later years, all my professors in Spain were great thinkers and great patriots. Everything--books, periodicals, examples, and reason itself--prompted me to love the good of my native land, as the Catolonian loves the good of Catalonia, and Basques, Galicians, Andalusians respectively love Biscay, Galicia, Andalusia etc." Rizal, therefore, admitted learning patriotism from the examples of Spain, Rome and Greece, but he never wished to become a Spanish, Roman, or Greek citizen. On the contrary, he always and unmistakably kept his Filipino identity: "All prompted me to love the good of my native land." Rizal was a pragmatist geo-politically. He was fully aware that his dream for the Philippines could be wrecked by nations with imperialistic ambitions. Lisa and de Pedro comment: "This thinking is especially important to understand why Rizal wanted to remain under Spain for awhile. He lived during trying times when powerful nations were guided by imperialistic motives, making him afraid that the Philippines could not stand on her own without another country defending her. He was worried that empires like England, Germany, and Japan could easily supplant the weakening power of Spain in the Philippines. Some years earlier, he expressed his apprehension in his famous article ‘The Philippines a Century Hence,’ that the United States of America could also be one of these imperialistic nations. Because of this alarming possibility he preferred to remain under the influence of Spain." Because of his emphasis on the gradualist approach, he recommended the intermediate stage of the Philippines first becoming a province of Spain: "Thinking that the Philippines in 1896 was not yet ready for independence, he advocated a progressive granting of liberties at par with Spain's provinces as the path to self-determination and independence. He thought that by advocating the standard liberal program of all progressive European nations, the Philippines would be on the right track toward economic and social progress. Specifically, he wanted press freedom and Parliamentary representation, the exclusion of the friars from active political life, and the secularization of the educational system....He regretted, that even the initial step--freedom of expression of political ideas--was repressed in the Philippines, when the Spaniards had been enjoying it in their own country. Acting as the spokesperson of Filipino aspirations, Rizal hoped that the Spanish government would make the Philippines another province of Spain, so as not be called anymore a colony." The ideas expressed above reveal another aspect of the genius of "The First Filipino" and the "Great Malay." He was no armchair theorist or quixotic ideologue. He had his feet planted firmly on ground. He did his homework in what we now call "SWOT" analysis: an inventory of the strengths and weaknesses of the Filipino nation as well as opportunities and threats she faced towards the end of the nineteenth century. No wonder, he was a very accurate political forecaster. As Josephine Bracken reported after his death, Rizal told her that in no less than ten years after his death, Spain would lose the Philippines as a colony. As an economic forecaster myself, I sure would like to have him today to tell me about the political futures of many countries today where political turmoil is making their economic prospects very uncertain and unsettling the global economic environment. For comments, my email address is bernardo.villegas@uap.asia.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Here are some final thoughts to end this paper. If you were in Rizal's position, would you actually continue to express your thoughts and fight for freedom even if it means risking your own life? Or will you stop expressing your thoughts to your fellow countrymen and save yourself from being killed? Remember, it's easier to say things than to do it, but maybe if you think of it as for the sake of those who are suffering then it wouldn't be so bad to sacrifice ones self isn't it? And perhaps you are that one spark that people need in order to light up an entire nation that would have a great impact on the entire course of our history and of our…
- 682 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
* That the present system of government in the Philippines through corrupt officials, dominated by the friars can lead to the downfall of Spain. This point was stressed by Simoun in the novel, when he said, "What is a man to do when he is denied justice? Take the law into his own hands or wait for Spain to give him rights…" From the foregoing, Rizal was very certain that because of the nature and operation of the government, those who are intelligent, generous, hard-working, courageous and loyal citizens were driven into opposition, crime and…
- 293 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Philippine Salvations during Rizal's Time 1. Instability of colonial administration the government is not stable 2. Corrupt officials 3. No represaentation to the Spanish Cortes 4. Human rights denied to Filipinos 5.…
- 74 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
To buttress his defense of the native’s pride and dignity as people, Rizal wrote three significant essays while abroad: The Philippines a Century hence, the Indolence of the Filipinos and the Letter to the Women of Malolos. These writings were his brilliant responses to the vicious attacks against the Indio and his culture.…
- 330 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
It was during Rizal’s Ateneo life that he developed patriotic feelings and acute quickness of perception (una exquisita sensibilidad). He also developed the quickness of political perception and he even privately concluded that he must dedicate his life to the service of his people. It was also during this time that he realized that the first step in such a life of service is that he must study abroad. I quote the line from the book of Austin Coates, “It is by means of education, he says, that the fatherland acquires it’s glory; and in the poem that follows, fervent with proud and youthful love of country, he says that just as the gentle movement of a breeze causes flowers to show off their colors more vividly, so is education the vital breath which causes a nation to rise to it’s more brilliant heights; that wherever education is implanted there will grow up a youth invigorated and strong, firmly eradicating error and broadening itself on the strength of noble ideas.” In my own opinion, the greatest view that he formulated in his college years in Ateneo is the importance of education. From the line that I quoted, it shows how much Rizal value education. He also had the idea that by altering the basic nature of Philippine society through enlightenment and arms is not necessary. He believes that war/revolution is not necessary to achieve reformation or change and that…
- 530 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Yabes, Leopoldo. “Rizal, Nationalist and Internationalist.” Rizal as an Internationalist. Manila: National Historical Institute, 1980.…
- 1161 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Rizal's 15 December Manifesto,as what Constantino have said, that this manifesto was the definitive proof that Rizal repudiated the Revolution. This was said so because its content was that, Rizal condemned the revolution and he doesn't want to be part of it. What he wants is that the Filipino people will go forth on such education because in education, they will be free from the people who'll colonize and enslave them, they will have the freedom to get to know their own identities and lastly, they will be fit for their liberties. That's why with these reasons, he wanted the people to return to their homes. Another thing, he condemned the revolution because of the belief that the Spaniards will give the Filipinos their freedom sooner or later.…
- 1147 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
“Rizal had a burning desire to know exactly the conditions of the Philippines when the Spaniards came ashore to the islands. His theory was the country was economically self-sufficient and prosperous. Rizal entertained the idea that it had a lively and vigorous community enriched with the collective and sensitive art and culture of the native population. He believed the conquest of the Spaniards contributed in part to the decline of the Philippine's rich tradition and culture.…
- 1149 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The article shares the ideas and opinions in dialogues that usually represent conflicting views about Dr. Jose Rizal. Even though he is our national hero we still feel in need of a continuing dialogue on his ideas, principles and convictions. We know him as a profound thinker and a great doer who love our country and had remarkable patriotism. For that he was called the “First Filipino.”…
- 999 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
3. NOT based on historical FACTS FACTS: (REFORMIST) Province of Spain NOT for INDEPENDENCE Anti-Friar NOT anti-SPANIARD Not for Armed Revolution RIZAL: El Fili and Manifesto to the Filipino People Denounced the Revolution Antonio Luna: x Katipunan…
- 1083 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The Philippines a Century Hence is an essay written by our national hero Jose Rizal and it tells the future of the country within a hundred years. In this essay, published in La Solidaridad, it starts analyzing the various causes of the problems suffered by the Filipino people. One of those problems is the Spain’s implementation of her military policies, because of such laws the poverty here in our country became rampant than ever. And the family as a unit of society was neglected, and overall, in every aspect of life of the Filipino was retarded. Next is the destruction of the Filipino culture, the native Filipino culture, because of this, the Filipinos started losing confidence in their past and their heritage, became doubtful of their present lifestyle, and eventually lost hope in the future and the preservation of their race. The Spanish colonizers are the one with the most powerful forces and they influenced the culture of silence among the natives. Because of the use of force, the Filipinos learned to submit themselves to the will of the foreigners. Eventually, the natives realized that such oppression in their society by foreign colonizers must no longer be tolerated. One question Rizal raises in this essay is whether or not Spain can indeed prevent the progress of the Philippines, keeping the people uneducated and ignorant had failed, Keeping he people impoverished also came to no avail. Spain, therefore, had no means to stop the progress of the country. What needs to do is to change colonial policies so that they are in keeping with the needs of the Philippine society and to the rising nationalism of the people. What Rizal had envisioned in his essay came true. In 1898, the Americans wrestled with Spain to win the Philippines, and eventually took over the country. Theirs was a reign of democracy and liberty. Five decades after Rizal’s death, the Philippines gained her long-awaited independence. This was in fulfillment of what he had written in his…
- 373 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Rizal should not be the national hero of the Philippines. This was Renato Constantino’s thesis in his 1969 work. He reasons out that though Rizal’s greatness is unquestionable, but his nationalistic interests are doubtful. According to Constantino, Rizal’s repudiation of the revolution has been glossed over in the history books and should therefore constitute as unnationationalist behaviour by the national hero. He further points out that Rizal’s elevation to a national hero was a product of the American intervention. During the American Philippine Commission of the 1900’s, the Commission was in search of a Philippine personality who abhors the idea of revolution and instead, someone who embraces governmental reforms in the form of peaceful means. Rizal fits perfectly this description of passiveness and was elevated to his status of prestige and reverence. This measure assured the American colonizers an unmitigated colonization of the archipelago since the Filipinos would emulate Rizal’s passiveness and be focused on bringing down the Spanish colonizers. Aside from being called an American-sponsored hero, Constantino also labelled Rizal a limited hero. He reasons out that Rizal’s elitist and upper class upbringing has inevitably shaped his ideology and limited his grasp of the social reality that the lower classes face. According to Constantino, it was because of this limitation that consequently fashioned Rizal’s aspiration for the Philippines to formally be recognized as a Spanish province rather than a colony. He treated this as another repudiation of the separatist movement that fuelled that Katipunan revolt.…
- 592 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Contrary to the belief of many, Jose Rizal did not ever wanted freedom from our oppressors, this was clearly written in the article. He only sought reform and some amendments which is by far so much different from what the Filipinos want way back then.…
- 506 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Bibliography: Bantug, A. L. (1982). Lolo Jose : An Intimate Portrait of Rizal . Manila: Ministry of Human Settlements, Intramuros Administration.…
- 881 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Veneration Without Understanding is an article written by Renato Constantino who expresses and states what a real hero possess. It is not Dr. Jose Rizal who is the leader of our revolution but Bonifacio who thought of starting the KKK to fight for the real freedom. In no uncertain terms he placed himself against Bonifacio and those Filipinos who were fighting for the country's liberty. The Philippine Revolution has always been overshadowed by the omnipresent figure and the towering reputation of Rizal. Because Rizal took no part in that Revolution and in fact repudiated it, the general regard for our Revolution is not as high as it otherwise would be. On the other hand, because we refuse to analyze the significance of his repudiation, our understanding of Rizal and of his role in our national development remains superficial. This is a disservice to the event, to the man, and to us. Rizal never advocated independence, nor did he advocate armed resistance to the government. He urged reform from within by publicity, by public education, and appeal to the public conscience. Without Rizal there may have been a delay in the maturation of our libertarian struggle, but the economic development of the period would have insured the same result. Rizal maybe accelerated it. Rizal may have given form and articulation and color to the aspirations of the people. But even without him, the nationalist struggle would have ensued. This is likewise true in the case of present-day national liberation movements. The fundamental cause of mass action is not the utterances of a leader; rather, these leaders have been impelled to action by historical forces unleashed by social development. We must therefore not fall into the error of projecting the role of the individual to the extent of denying the play of these forces as well as the creative energies of the people who are the true makers of their own history. Rizal's intellectual excellence paved the way for the winning of the name for…
- 563 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays