Preview

Roderick R. Nash's Island Civilization

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1229 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Roderick R. Nash's Island Civilization
In the presentation, Island Civilization: A Vision for Human Occupancy of Earth in the Fourth Millennium, published on October 16, 2008, Roderick R. Nash presents the idea of four possible courses of which the human race could follow in the future. These paths, termed the wasteland, garden planet, future primitive, and the Island Civilization scenarios all take extreme viewpoints and present controversial hypotheticals, that do not seem very practical. It is with these thoughts in mind that I present another situation, one that Nash fails to acknowledge in his essay— the concept of human expansion into space, or in other words, space colonization.
Before one even dismisses the idea, to quote Nash, “Rarely do humans make plans more than a couple
…show more content…
There are two paths in which we could take, one being, of course, the stereotypical view of a colony on Mars or the Moon, but on the other hand, it is feasible to have humans living in orbit with the advent of new technology. There is a general argument to be made for both, for example, colonization on a planet, although extremely expensive, could have that issue overlooked through alternative means. In Kelsey Tollefson’s, author of Asteroid Prospects II: Between a Rock and a Hard Place, own words, “The United States, for one, has set its sights on the Red Planet. NASA’s Journey to Mars initiative hopes to achieve “Earth Independence” by the year 2030. NASA’s estimated budget for 2017 is set at $19 billion, much of which would go towards developing technology capable of sending humans to Mars” (Tollefson). One may wonder why Mars is the center of attention for many researchers, and the answer to that is quite simple. As Edward McCullough, lead scientist for the Boeing Company, mentions, “Mars is a user-friendly world, rife with many industrially useful minerals for construction and manufacturing purposes. It has a suite of ‘ates,’ ‘ites’ and ‘ides’ of common metals with common non metals. The red planet is also wrapped in abundant carbon dioxide which will be fairly easy to condense” (David). McCullough was also quoted as saying, “There is abundant evidence of past …show more content…
As already said, in terms of research, lots of progress has already been made, and numerous new studies are published yearly regarding the matter. According the Space Settlements: A Design Study, “The focus of the system is a space habitat where 10,000 people work, raise families, and live out normal human lives” (Space Settlements: A Design Study). That is to say, space colonies won’t affect our normal lives in any ways, except for ensuring our survival as a human race. Afterall, it is indisputable that we will eventually run out of space on Earth, and space colonization is just a proviso to the genetic desire to thrive. Unfortunately, the focus of many endearing individuals lies in the wrong path, as “Much like eager prospectors in the early days of the Yukon gold rush, space programs are on the hunt for the best mining locations” (Tollefson). Yet, even then, this can be seen as a positive, as “asteroids would represent a source of capital that could enable the next step in deep space exploration” (Tollefson).
In conclusion, the prospects of space colonization appear to be very promising. Although Nash does address a future in which technology makes humans the master’s of nature, he fails to recognize the possibilities that humans can attain in space. Space is the wild west of the future, that will only bring more riches and expansions

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the article Island Civilization: A vision for human occupancy of Earth, Roderick Frazier Nash describes how the earth that was once a peaceful planet with freedom of living for every specie turned out to be the earth we are living in now. Had human beings more farsighted they wouldn’t have taken wilderness as something that must be controlled. Nash explains how the mankind built fences and roads to control the wild, and soon there came a time when United States Census claimed there was no longer a frontier left that humans haven’t damaged which created a national angst. As Nash says “The notion of wilderness was passing over a tipping point from liability to asset” (Nash 373) This resulted in acts that emphasized the importance of wilderness. Extinction of many other species was observed so acts were taken for the animal protection and various authors started writing books on the negative environmental impact.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Space is the final frontier that we now know so much more about due to NASA’s exploration and research in geology, medicine, engineering, chemistry, physics, and climatology. Exploration in the name of science has only broadened our education and understanding into our world and our universe. This thus far has really only been possible through taxes which make about 0.5% of the $3.4 trillion United States federal budget. Once again, NASA. science is focused on better understanding of the Universe. As Carl Sagan said, too much money is being wasted on unnecessary pursuits, compared to the little amount required by NASA.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1961, the world was changed forever, Soviet cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin entered the spacecraft Vostok 1 and traveled into space. Following him in the same year, was the American astronaut Alan Shepard in Freedom 7. Then in 1969 the crew of the Apollo 11 mission landed on the Moon. This space race in the 1960s helped to light the fire of man’s interest in outer space and has lead mankind to wonder if we could live away from the comfort and safety of planet Earth. Many scientist and explorers have wondered if it would be possible to colonize the Moon or Mars for the purpose of research, resources, and hopefully a secondary home for the human race. However, many people have also doubted the idea of leaving the safety of planet Earth to explore other options of habitable places. Many argue that space exploration is dangerous and some critics argue that it is using too much money that could…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine if you could live on a different planet and have more stuff or space. Well you see having a different lifestyle isn’t always good but it could lead to us having another planet. The planet could give us resources that we can rely on like metals such as platinum, copper, iron, and maybe gold if lucky. These resources could build us better houses or have more protection and resistance to the bad weather conditions. Like on Earth we have had many hurricanes that hit the US. The supplies on the different planet could give us a new way to live. We could make more advance houses than what others have. It could also give us better technology that could make us so advance we don’t need to use the expensive oil or gas we can make them more solar powered by using these metals.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbus Persuasive Speech

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Establishing a colony on mars is not an option, it is a necessity. Clearly, the next logical step for our race is to expand out into the stars, into the unknown. The Human race has to put more effort and resources into space exploration. It is in our deep underlying nature to explore, we are a curious animal that wants to discover all it can, we just need the tools to do so. We need the next Christopher Columbus, we need someone with the drive and will to explore the unknown.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I read about the Apollo missions and the obsession with space exploration. Space exploration has been a human fascination since the early 1960s, probably even before then actually. The first person to be put into space was in was Yuir Gagarin at the age of 27, by the Russian Soviet Union. However, it wasn't until 1969 that NASA successfully landed the first man (men) on the moon, with the Apollo 11space mission. Interestingly enough, NASA hasn't attempted go revisit the moon since. Many speculate humans never made it to the moon, and that all of the "evidence" was entirely fabricated.Regardless, ever since then, humans have been fascinated with the idea of trying to reach other planets and possibly inhabit them. Many attempts to find life on…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article “Island Civilization” provides different scenarios we can take to make mother nature a better place. Nash’s four perspectives are the wasteland, the garden world, the primitive world or the island civilization. I believe the island civilization will be the best option to try to better mother nature. The way we abuse mother nature is unnecessary and the author gives us ideas to try to better it. This could be a beginning to help the wildlife and our world with global warming and all the negative were doing to our planet.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even if we discontinue the funding of NASA we could still have some control over space in some way by setting laws so the states could have some control over the private companies that would fund themselves. If we keep funding NASA or set some control over the private companies we may be able to make some profit off of the space program and besides, would you rather live in space or on another planet, than stay on earth. And in any way the earth is going to inevitably die anyway so basically the only way to survive is to leave this planet and go to an entirely different solar system and find a faster source of space travel like a “Warp Drive” or a “Black Hole Engine” to…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nasa

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Christopher Columbus theorised that the earth was flat. We later found out that the earth was actually spherical, this was due to significant advancement of astronomy. Such important discoveries, wouldn’t be possible without, NASA, space exploration, advances in technology, scientific findings and a more broadened knowledge of the universe. The illusive idea of travelling beyond our clouds has been around before the first moon landing took place. We know that it is relatively important to explore space because some resources on earth will; soon run out and we may have to rely elsewhere for iron, steel, minerals and other such important products, we humans depend on. Despite the fact space travel is expensive, NASA should continue to be funded to learn about the universe and the world we all live in. Also funding NASA means a boost in technology for the economy and perhaps a dramatic change in restoring the environments function by solar panels and natural substances outside our atmosphere.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do the benefits outweigh the cost for funding exploration and expansion into space? From the perspective of a sociologist, whose job it is include the origins, development, organization, networks, and institutions to study social behavior or society, funding NASA would be a wise choice because we could have space colonies creating many benefits for society and people. The article “Food, Leisure, And Social Life In Space Colonies” by Tom Marotta, a diplomat and city planner, made this position clear by presenting the significance of space exploration in today’s world to the future of our world. First, people want to know how to survive on the space colony. Space colonies are settlements in space that can vary in size and contain normal environments such as forests, farms, lakes, and rivers. They are just like a normal community but just in space. There are houses, jobs, and places where people can work on the colonies.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Space Programs

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When everyone says they want America to progress ahead, we need to ask ourselves, what can we do that way America can be at the top of the world? Well, the answer is simple. America can rise above all the nations if they take risks which can motivate citizens the relevance of space programs. A question that has been rising over the years is, is going into space programs worth it? Many can argue that it is a scrupulous field to join and that it’s risky. However, any type of job you do is treated as taking a risk. In today’s society, space programs should be given an opportunity to help those who are interested within the field because one can learn many unique ways to determine the impossibilities.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Space Race Research Paper

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages

    We have always dreamed about reaching the heavens. From ancient civilizations to the modern day world, our obsession of going into space has grown from studying the stars to actual exploration of space. We have come a long way since primitive charts of constellations. From telescopes to satellites, we as a population have progressed greatly in the world of technology. In a mere forty years, we have had more technological advances than the Industrial Revolution. The Space Race has affected our everyday lives; we use the same technology that the astronauts used during their missions for example digital clocks (Dismukes http://spaceflight.nasa.gov). Many industries have benefited, communication companies, industrial manufacturers, and the…

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The under developed nations where people can not enjoy basic commodities such as food, health and sanitation, are completely deprived off the benefits of space technology. This aids in widening the pre-existent gap between the underdeveloped and developed world in terms of advancement. The goal of halving the population of underweight children will be missed by 30 million due to slow progress in Africa and Asia. So does the rat race of acquiring advancements in space technology seem superficial to the intelligent minds of today? Has the sense of universal brotherhood and fraternity been lost upon those living in better conditions? Political disorder has brought the economic condition of countries to a stand still. The tainted picture is further disembodied by the sky high prices of food and oil. Furthermore, the absence of civil liberties in countries such as Burma and Pakistan forms impenetrable ozone of tension and anxiety. People are not only being subjected to the hazards of dictatorship and military rule, but are also forced to learn the art of living amidst an economic standstill. Prosperity can not be attained while there is devoid of job vacancies. Hunger can not be fought if the food prices keep…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Unit E Science 9 Project

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Space exploration is the discovery and exploration of outer space by the means of space technology. This means that useful and resourceful discoveries are being made every time that we send up humans into space. Over the years, space exploration has expanded technology to great heights, helped create new industries, and help create a peaceful relationship between nations. Space Biology is another huge reason why we should keep space exploration. NASA laboratories lead to new technologies that improve astronaut health and monitoring, while making scientific discoveries that benefit life on Earth. Another amazing that thing that space exploration has done for people on Earth is help make huge strides in the continuing development of artificial limbs. These are for people who have lost either an arm or leg and NASA has helped develop artificial muscle for a flexible robotic arm! Now, I am going to discuss three main topics about why we should keep space exploration. They are Economic, Ethical, and Environmental.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “We’ll Never Conquer Space,” Arthur C. Clarke explains his feelings about the idea of man ever entirely conquering space. In doing so, he makes use of connotations and technical terms. In addition, he uses key words to help get his point across.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays