I have chosen Rose’s “I Just Wanna Be Average” to discuss as I have felt this way many times over the years whether it was in school or in the work force.
In "I Just Wanna Be Average" Mike Rose explains how he was placed in the "vocational education" program while he was in high school by error. He and his parents tried to even fix the situation, but it did not work. While in this program he began to learn some dead-end skills from his teachers that were often unprepared, underprepared, or even incompetent. Rose says that those students in the "vocational" track have been written off by the system, but show unrealized potential that no teacher seemed to realize or even want to see.
While in high school, Rose had a friend named Ken who was asked by a teacher for his opinion about parable talents, about achievement, and working hard. Ken simply stated that he just wanted to be average. This stayed with Rose and he explains how he feels the school system is built so the children do not excel. In the "normal" or “college prep” classes the kids are viewed as moving forward and in the “vocational education” the kids are viewed as "slow" or just an "average" student trying to get by with minimal effort.
The vocational education program is supposed to be there to provide the student with basic job-skills necessary for him/her to be "average" in society. The main goal is to provide training to students who are deemed by the school system as not being able to function in society or college, so they are going to train for a “trade”. They provide them with the basic knowledge, information, and facts to get an average job which in turn does not give the kids any reason to go beyond that and so they become “average”.
Rose’s purpose of this article is to educate people of how the “vocational educational” programs are being used in the school system. He wants people to know that the students are really just being pushed through the system without anyone trying to see the potential that these students might have as far as what aspires them to do anything. He is also wanting people to know that if just one teacher reached out to the students that can make a difference in how a student feels out himself/herself and wanting to find something that gives them drive to perform or learn more.
Rose uses examples from his time in high school when he felt left behind and how he saw his friends’ potential for greatness in a particle area that they felt passion for, but no teacher recognized it. He tells of the one teacher that gave him hope and explains how this teacher impacted him to do more with his life. I agree with Rose that the school system does seem to just put kids that have bad grades or behavioral issues into programs that are meant to just pacify them through their high school years and the goal of these programs are to give the students some type of technical/vocational training to get an average job and have an average life. I also feel that some of the “college prep” classes do that to students also. I felt that I just wanted to be average in high school. The “smart” kids got picked on for being smart and the “dumber” kids are got picked on for being “dumb”. I just wanted to be in the middle to keep from being picked on. The only reason I received good grades was my mother. I did the work just to get by for her standards of what she thought I could do. Thinking back, I could have been great in school if I had applied myself since I graduated with a 3.2 and really didn’t do much work. When I was making my decision to continue my education or work for a little while, I started a semester at Kent State, Salem Branch in 1993. Once that semester was over, I knew that going to school right out of high school was not for me. I felt I had just spent 12 years in school and wanted to take a break before I continued my education. Four years after high school, I felt that working in a factor for the rest of my life was not what I wanted, so I looked into a two-year program school that my sister had went to and I was going to just find something to do. I took the admissions test for medical transcription and the advisor at the school indicated that my test grades were well beyond what I was thinking about doing and he suggested maybe I take the legal assisting classes. Taking his advice, I did just that and once I started college I made the decision that I would overachieve and I did just that. I graduated Magna Cum Laude in my 2 year paralegal/legal assisting program. I then tried to overachieve at work also. After 16 years that got me nowhere but the unemployment line for the last two years. During my time working I saw people doing mediocre work or even less than mediocre work get raises and promotions and treated like “rock stars” yet I was not and I always went above and beyond what my regular duties were. I came in early, stayed late and helped others when they needed help once my work was finished. So I again just wanted to be average. I have been on unemployment twice in the last three years. It has been very hard to find a legal assistant position here in Ohio. Employers want someone with a Bachelor’s Degree, but only want to pay $9-$12.00 an hour or they want someone with very little experience to pay them $9-$12.00 an hour. I only have an Associate’s Degree and I have been a legal assistant since 1997 so I have work experience that matches a Bachelor’s Degree education, but that does not seem to matter. I was making $8.00 an hour when I started in 1997 so I am trying really hard to figure out why I should still be making that now. For about a decade, I lived in Kentucky and when I moved back to Ohio in 2010, I was making $16.45 an hour. These events in my life have me thinking that my education does not count. The schools indicate that a person with an Associate’s Degree in certain areas should be making well over what employers want to pay. So I feel that school systems have “lied” to us just to get the tuition. My thoughts and feelings on the subject might be what others think or feel, but I tend to agree with Rose and his opinions on the school system. I honestly do not think that the education in America leads to empowerment, that is a very nice goal, but not obtainable to most people.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A: Vocational school were they learn job skills. The courses that are offered there are wood working, sewing, farming, and electrical work.…
- 298 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In “Why Johnny Can’t Fail”, Jerry Jesness explains what really goes on behind closed doors at many schools. He confesses that he himself, and many others of his ilk, are guilty of passing children who are unprepared to move forward. It is all a matter of the “floating standard”, and it is destroying public education.…
- 521 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
First, when I look at the authors push to get an education I see in Richard Rodriguez’s essay that he was very motivated. He started as a young boy with an accent striving to learn more and attain knowledge whenever he could because he knew of the benefits. In the story Rodriguez says that he shifted away from family life to study more and learn more from his teachers. He wanted school rather than his uneducated family. In contrast, Mike Rose clearly didn’t want to be in school, he wanted an easy way out of things. Rose explains he was put in vocational classes by accident, but decided to stay in the classes with the lower level students. He explains how the teachers could care less about the student’s education which affected Rose because he saw himself and everyone as being average.…
- 733 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Our achievement ideology is based on the idea that the U.S. is full of opportunity and anyone can accomplish success in our society if they work hard enough. Many grow up thinking education is the ladder that will allow for this social mobility and all you have to do is be willing to work hard enough to earn it. But what about children who grow up thinking differently? Why do some strive for high paying careers while others refuse school and are seemingly ok with staying working class? MacLeod challenges the notion that America is the land of opportunity with research he conducted while in college. He uses the research of several reproduction theorists to show that schools not only are not great equalizers, as most think, but actually reinforce social inequality.…
- 9161 Words
- 24 Pages
Powerful Essays -
At Our Lady of Mercy, children were put on a vocational track for their education. The vocational track was merely a “dumping ground for the disaffected” and “a euphemism for the bottom level” (Rose 110, 111). This is a perfect example of students being given a curriculum that teaches them just enough to get by. The basic skills of life, skills you might need to work at your local gas…
- 1192 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In “I Just Wanna Be Average” Mike Rose recalls his years of vocational school. As a matter of fact, the inclination of Mike Rose in this particular class was an accident. However, he decided to keep his enrollment with the students of lower level. Rose, in this particular work, describes the teachers, fellow students…
- 1465 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
After being placed in the Vocational Education class, his interest in his studies faded, and he did the minimum amount of work to pass. To make matters worse, the teachers did not care whether or not the students became more educated. Rose believes that if teachers do not have high expectations for their students, the students will have a decrease in work ethic because there is no one pushing them to succeed. Throughout my years of schooling, I have been lucky enough to have teachers who taught every student on the same level. It is the only fair way for everyone to have an equal chance for…
- 605 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Mike Rose does not describe himself as a nuisance, but as a student who was overlooked. This treatment was very a detriment to his education. "I would hide by slumping down in my seat and page through my reader, carried along by the flow of sentences in a story." (Rose 19) He discusses the teachers ' inability to "engage the imaginations of us kids who were scuttling along at the bottom of the pond." (Rose 26) This strategy combined poorly with the attitudes of other students who did not want to work hard, who just wanted to be average. (Rose 28) Mike Rose describes that mix of students and how it affected his own perception of education:…
- 1260 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The story “I Just Wanna Be Average”, written by Mike Rose offers up a personal account of how a testing mistake early in his high school days could have changed the course of his life for the worse and how these events and those that followed solidified his perception of the educational system as an adult. The author tries to establish credibility by writing in a first-person narrative of his life as a teenager growing up in early 1960s Los Angeles and also with his complex sentence structure and big words as an adult in reflection of his life during that time period. This authority is also emphasized by the intro to the piece about his misfortunes as a teenager and his many accomplishments as an adult as an award-winning author and college professor. By putting such a glowing review about the author in front of the piece, it sets up the belief that what you’re about to read is righteous and true.…
- 1895 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
First of all, the vocational education can teach students some useful skills that can take to their adulthood, even though they won’t become the professionals. Imagine that your car is broken, what will you do? You could pay the repair shop and wait for weeks to get your car back, or you could fix it by yourself if you had the vocational education in high school. Some people say that there is no need to learn the skills like those if you don't want to be a professional. However, life will be more convenient if you can do this stuff. For example, you can fix your car by yourself, for which you can save money and time, or you can cook Chinese food for your family at home instead of going to restaurants. Those things are daily occurrences.…
- 490 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Moving on to their second contention that choosing a vocational school will help the student be taught job specifics for the job they want to do, they wont need to take extra classes to get their training they need as you would have to do at a traditional four year college. But like I stated in my second…
- 643 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Students who are in the predicament noted above are not able to thrive in a strong academic environment because, as Freire states, they don’t know their reality. If they knew their reality, they would be better prepared to adjust to what they need for academic success. My position is that students that will better succeed in vocational or magnet schools. The vocational option is best suited for students that are not college bound and need to learn hands-on job skills to work right out of high school.…
- 970 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The main objective of vocational education is to train the students at +2 level for meeting the demands for the skilled manpower in both organised and unorganised sectors and also to provide an alternative channel for those who aimlessly persue higher education and to prepare them for self reliance. The State Institute of…
- 5584 Words
- 23 Pages
Good Essays -
There are study suggests a lack of vocational training skills for high school graduates affecting workforce. While the unemployment rate fell to its lowest rate in 2011 an old debate has surfaced on the heels of different reports on different groups concerning educations and employments. At its core, the report says that there are not enough alternatives to the traditional four-year education by way of vocational training skills. It is creating issues for “middle-skill” employers.…
- 1467 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Vocational training is somehow similar to technical education. It aims at improving knowledge and skills required to do a specific job. In simple terms, it gives students an opportunity to learn the skills first hand needed for specific jobs. Moreover, it helps them build experience so that they have a competitive edge in the market.…
- 648 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays