Many cultures have different practices that seem unusual to other cultures. There is a raised debate in modern day Hinduism over the practice of sati, the self-immolation of a widow on her deceased husband’s grave. Many modern Hindu people view that there is no place for such a practice in society today and in the Hindu religion. Others however view that sati should remain in the religion because it has been a sacred historical part of Hinduism. Sati should be continue to be allowed as a strictly religious practice because the performance of this act represents the widow has fulfilled her dharma and devotion to her husband.
Sati should be continued to be allowed as a religious practice in the modern Hindu religion. In the Hindu religion, the roles of genders are produced by a constructed system. The role of women in Hinduism is to serve her husband to the fullest. Upon the death of a woman, she is to either become a nun or continue to her life and never remarry. Women are not deemed fit for independence in the eyes of Hinduism. Through the practice of Sati by a widow, this is one of the only ways a woman can assert their freedom and self-worth in making a decision that they make independently best said by (Burgha 73-77). There may be a self-loathing to show of
Although Sati has been a part of Hinduism since the Philosophical Era around the turn of the century, many view the practice should be outlawed. The world has become a different place than years ago as well as the way society perceives things. In present day, such a practice is deemed politically unacceptable because of the fact is a woman committing suicide regardless of the reason. The religious lenses have been removed as our world becomes a less and less religious oriented stated by (Mani 121-123). Many modern Hindu’s view this practice as immoral and a crime against women seen from the standpoint of society as a whole today.
To perform the act of sati symbolizes the epitome of wifely devotion. A woman’s entire life is devoted to her husband, being an exemplary and model wife. Upon the act of sati demonstrates that she has fulfilled her dharma and has developed the appropriate and admirable behavior of a Hindu woman. Dating to the Vedic period, the act of self-immolation will also help facilitate her husband’s salvation and journey in the next life (Hawley 79-102). Why outlaw a religious practice dating back to the turn of the Century? It is not in the hands of others to decide upon a religious practice especially seeing that does not harm others.
While the practice of Sati may slowly die off in forthcoming years, the debate in modern day Hinduism over the practice will not. The self-immolation of a widow on her deceased husband’s funeral pyre is not caused from insanity but wifely devotion to the fullest. Many modern Hindu people view that there is no place for such a practice in society today and in the Hindu religion itself. Others however view that sati should remain in the religion because it has been a sacred historical part of Hinduism. Sati should be continued to be allowed as a strictly religious practice because the performance of this act represents the widow has fulfilled her dharma and devotion to her husband.
Bibliography
Bhurga, Danesha. "Sati: A type of non-psychiatric suicide."Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention. 26.2 (2005): 73-77. Print.
Hawley, John Stratton. Fundamentalism & Gender. New York, New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. 79-102. Print.
Mani, Lati. "Contentious Traditions: The Debate on Sati in Colonial India." Cultural Critique. 7. (1987): 121-123. Web. 8 Apr. 2013. .
Bibliography: Bhurga, Danesha. "Sati: A type of non-psychiatric suicide."Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention. 26.2 (2005): 73-77. Print. Hawley, John Stratton. Fundamentalism & Gender. New York, New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. 79-102. Print. Mani, Lati. "Contentious Traditions: The Debate on Sati in Colonial India." Cultural Critique. 7. (1987): 121-123. Web. 8 Apr. 2013. .
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The sacred elements of Hinduism are comprised of Hindu religious traditions, and their transcendent connotations. It would be very difficult to completely list all the sacred elements of Hinduism that make up the Hindu religious traditions because of the sheer enormity and depth of the Hindu culture and traditions that have evolved through thousands of years. However, I will deign to describe some of the most notable or prevalent elements.…
- 1537 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The term sati has wide ranges of definition depending on what language is spoken; in Hindu it means a village Mother goddess (satimata) who self-sacrificed her self on her husband’s funeral, the incarnation of goddess Parvati (wife of Shiva) and sati also means a virtuous woman, a woman bonded to her husband who will go where ever her husband goes and death is no exception. In the eyes of westerners, sati (spelled suttee) is a suicidal act where widows are burnt along with the corpse of her husband. But in Hindu, sati does not mean the ritual but the woman itself, a sati is a good woman, a woman who is completely devoted to her husband. Sati is a non-widow woman, and it is a way to avoid widowhood, because in Hindu the husband is considered…
- 942 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In ancient India, tribes from across India had to carry out lots of funerary practices. These practices varied from jumping into fires to hiring professional mourners. These practices were completely different to Western countries. Like in ancient Jewish culture when a family member dies, they can’t watch television for 1 whole year! In ancient India when the widow’s husband died, she would have to jump into the fire with her husband and burn to death. This was called Sati. Another practice was, when a family member died, their family had to cry (a lot).…
- 536 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The women in East Asia had better opportunities than the women in Middle East when it came to the death of their husbands. In East Asia women could not remarry if their husbands divorced them or died, while in the Middle East women performed sati, which is when an elite widow threw herself on her husband’s funeral pyre. East Asia…
- 411 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Whether or not a woman could hold onto their dowry or even control the inheritance of their male counterpart generated similarities between China and the Islamic world after 600 CE. The dowry that women were required to produce was able to be kept in the event of divorce or death. This went against India’s harsher view of women subordination. Women were mandated to commit a form of suicide called sati which involved self-immolation on her husband’s funeral pyre. This was for voluntary religious purposes, but was sometimes forced. In India, religious law was the most powerful law in the land.…
- 587 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Douglas, Kelly B. Review of A Womanist Looks at the Future Direction of Theological Discourse, Anglican Theological Review. 76/2 (1994): 225-231.…
- 3359 Words
- 14 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Today women in India have far greater constitutional rights than before, but are still exploited in the society. A typical Hindu family or society is divided hierarchically, where women are always placed at the bottom. Goddess worship in Hindu society has not necessarily entailed women an equitable position in the society. Even the Hindu epics are evidence of this claim, and are supported by two major incidents.…
- 1740 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The solution to this problem is to become knowledgeable and overcome the illusion and ignorance of materialistic values and recognize the rituals and meditative practice of the Hindu religion practices and to live a life of good Karma. Their main focus, or Dharma, is to create good karma in their lifetime, as it is the cause and effect of actions. Once a person has collected good karma, they are on the right path to liberation. In Hindu household the men of the family usually leaves for an asharamas to finish their last stages of life of manhood. The older male figure usually retires from family and social life to become one with the spiritual world. Here yoga is practiced and a role of a Sannyasin, or a…
- 1193 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Attitude to suicide over the history of humankind has also been rather ambiguous depending on the performer and the circumstances under which the act has been performed. This attitude in different ages and cultures could vary from absolute condemnation…
- 3258 Words
- 8 Pages
Best Essays -
Although many of the countries have their distinct culture, language, traditions, and religions, they also share many common factors, particularly in family traditions, attitudes toward the elderly and women, socio-economic conditions, and problems of overpopulation and low literacy rates. Many of the world’s major religions are represented in the Indian subcontinent including Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhs, and Christianity. All these religions condemn suicide in one form or other. Although suicide is major public health problem globally and the subject is receiving considerable attention in the west, little is being done to address the problem in the countries of the developing countries, where large numbers of suicide take place. Many of the countries of the Indian subcontinent fall into this category.…
- 391 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Hinduism was developed and is now named the major religion of India. It is originally practiced by religious rituals that occur daily at dawn. Most ritual is for prayer that normally would occur after one has bathed himself. It also is revolved around karma and dharma. Karma is one’s action that will be later consequential of either good or bad punishment, while dharma is commendable behavior that is affected by the age, class, gender, and occupation. Meanwhile, most Hinduism practices can be just a way of sorting the reputable deportment of the meritorious.…
- 417 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the united states, suicide is the eighth leading preeminent notion of the death for American which is almost 12 out of every 100,000 people hang to death and also is the third foremost rationale of death for young adults between the ages of 15 to 24 which is about 10 teenagers out of 100,000 decree to erase themselves. Out of the total number of suicides (3971) among teen’s ages 15 to 24 in 2001, 86% were male and 14% were female. The immense aberration between male teen suicide and female teen suicide rates is because males use armament more to effectuate suicide than females (use pills) and avail at suicide more than females. It is quite astonishing that people think killing themselves in the manifest and hasty way to abolish their problems. There are number of emblem and mistaken beliefs that surround the subject of teenage suicide. There have been a numerous leading causes of teenage suicide. Also there are number of things that can cause someone to commit suicide, the one main possible reason is mental illness. Some other leading causes of suicide among teenagers are bullying, anxiety or depression,…
- 831 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Suicide is the act of taking one’s own life whether it is voluntarily or intentionally. According to The Centers for Disease Control, it has shown that each year, more than 34,000 suicides occur in the United States. For Americans, suicide is the eleventh leading cause of death. It resulted in 34,598 lives lost in 2007. The top 3 methods used in suicides included firearm (50%), suffocation (24%), and poisoning (18%). (cdc.gov). Many people try to figure out what is the underlining cause of suicide. According to Steven Gerardi, author of, A brief survey of the sociological imagination, his general conclusion of the underlining cause of suicide varies inversely with the degree of integration of the social groups of which the individual forms a part. He also states that suicide varies inversely with the degree of integration of religious society, domestic society, and political society. (Gerardi, pg.13). As we go further in the studies of suicide, we raise the question as to why do people commit suicide based on these factors and who are the people who commit…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In regards to deviant behaviors it is the general population who determines this behavior. What is evident is that the population gives humanity a sort of peer pressure that in all is even more powerful than religion or even culture itself. However it also depends on the individual. What deviant behavior is, is behavior that is different than what the popular believe is that is acting in a bad way. One of these deviant behaviors is the act of suicide. All though there is a long list of behaviors that are deviant, each deviant act has a lot in common. This essay will look into the deviant behavior of suicide and why it is considered…
- 654 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Sati is a daughter of warriors and her beliefs and attitudes are true to that legacy. She stands alongside Shiva as an equal rather than someone used to move along his story. As a reader, that has immeasurable value to me. Sati is definitely a standout character in several aspects. She is a damsel in distress.…
- 868 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays